Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's Reviews > Music in the Castle of Heaven: A Portrait of Johann Sebastian Bach

Music in the Castle of Heaven by John Eliot Gardiner
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
70395042
's review

it was amazing

Let's hear it for seriously joyful music!

You know, there is always SO much to love in this vastly entertaining, musically nerdy and very thick book. I think I could lose myself in its beauties indefinitely.

So much good stuff here, and I now have:

Such a wealth of appreciation for the music: music that’s pretty basic in form, but outrageously complex in feeling!

Such a breadth of admiration for this man Bach’s incredible achievements in - to take but one example - single-handedly developing Western music, without any help at all, to a limit necessitating a total discard of other ancient musical modes - still prevalent before his oeuvre became dominant!

Such an amazement at this single composer, who repeated so many subtle tricks with the diatonic scale - becoming an old Isaac Newton to modern music’s iconoclastic Einsteins - that he developed a plug-‘n-play point which today’s young pop composers are still picking up for their own present-day creations... right where he left off!

Such a humble bending of this knee to this one single, ingenious musical polymath whose capacious mind seemed always ready to transmute any random incident into a thundering monolith of pure stentorian sound!

(Say, who was this old guy anyway, who without making much biographical noise in his life, totally KNOCKS THE SOCKS OFF any one of his lucky listeners - luckier still, if we are blessed with enough of the rudiments of tonality and performance to GIVE VOICE to any one of this Olympian’s works?)

Just a quiet, pious, bargain-basement dull-type dude who minded his own business and ONLY DID MUSIC.

Johann Sebastian Bach is sorta like the dull guy in a corner who puzzles for hours over a grossly abstruse mathematical conundrum...

Or the kind of family guy who would rather play the same basic form of frisbee, with fancier and fancier loop-de-loops multiplying as the lazy Sunday afternoon turned to dusk, just himself - with his dogs and his laughing kids and in-laws around a warming barbecue...

Or like a puny choir boy who’s not afraid to sing “thanks be to God� at the top of his voice when his turn finally comes. And really mean it!

This guy was like - really, I mean REALLY, SQUARE.

And how many modern composers are gonna start off in one key - and digressing through endless meanderings, variations and permutations without number - return to the same old ordinary key in the end? And always respect the laws of tonality?

Not many, but if you’re dumb old Bach - practically ALWAYS.

Bach is predictable. But awe-inspiring.

Chromatic. But conservative with regard to never straying far from home (like a well-trained husband)?

Hideously complicated. But delightfully simple-hearted.

World, meet Bach.

A quiet, trustworthy chap who practises what he preaches. A guy you’d trust your grandkids with.

An unassuming nondescript man whose colossal compositions could rock the Pillars of Hercules off their foundations.

A nice, ordinary guy who wrote PHENOMENALLY superhuman music.

You know, John Dryden once said that music will eventually untune the skies.

When that final day ultimately comes, I hope the angels play from a universal soundtrack...

And I think they will choose Bach’s great Art of Fugue after the trumpet of Judgement peals out over humanity.’s lost, errant ways -

For, as the Scrolls containing our individual judgements are unsealed, and we cower in shame in the audience, those 21 sententious notes of Bach’s masterpiece will be ominously repeated -

Until the Blue Cerulean sky cracks wide open, leaving only Percy Byshe Shelley’s “White Radiance of Eternity!�

Forever and Ever.
270 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Music in the Castle of Heaven.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 21, 2018 – Started Reading
July 21, 2018 – Shelved
September 8, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Bev (new)

Bev Walkling great review Fergus!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Bev. I once made a fortress of my room, as a querulous kid, so I could bury my fingers in my piano keys and repetitively churn out those lamenting sounds from the Well Tempered Clavier at which Glenn Gould was so adroit! Well, I tried, anyway...


message 3: by Beata (new)

Beata Fergus, excellent review! I recommend a plsu by Psul Barz about a meeting between Haendel and Bach that actually never took place ..... this book I'm adding😊


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Oh, Beata, I remember that missed opportunity of a Chance meeting! Our music teacher told us the story in Grade Eight... wow. Happy reading!


message 5: by Laysee (new)

Laysee I adore Bach. He wrote ‘phenomenal superhuman music� indeed. Wonderful review, Fergus.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Laysee! My Mom never listened to his music when I was a kid. She played all the other mainstream composers, though, and when I learned to play piano I progressed rapidly. At age 13, my friend David, who became a Physicist, showed me his sheet music collection; I played some Bach and from there on in I was OBSESSED - it was MADE for me!


 Cookie M. My other favorite composer. Whereas, I feel the music of Sibelius, I SEE the patterns in Bach. It is enjoyable for me to watch the elements of his music dance and play. As you can probably guess, I have a mild form of synesthesia.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs I‘ve often envied folks with your gift! Scriabin had it too - in abundance.


 Cookie M. I wouldn't want it in abundance. I had a friend for whom music was nearly intolerable. She could feel it on her skin.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs It’d be so tragic to not be able to enjoy music!


message 11: by Kathi (new)

Kathi Defranc You write beautiful reviews!! I can feel everything when I read them, Thank you for that!!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Kathi! One day last year, while sitting thru memories of the past, I realized that at one time in early childhood my love of music had synesthenic qualities - I could see shapes and colours, for example, while listening to symphonies. It’s probably some of that dreamlike quality that has remained in my writing, cause I’m still a dreamer at heart!


message 13: by Paul (new)

Paul A beautiful review! Will definitely read this soon as Bach is one of my favorite composers.

“Beethoven tells you what it's like to be Beethoven and Mozart tells you what it's like to be human. Bach tells you what it's like to be the universe.� - Douglas Adams


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, guys - and Paul, that quotation is AWESOME!


message 15: by A.E. (new)

A.E. Chandler Thanks, Fergus. Bach can write a song using only quarter notes, and it still makes you want to move while you're singing more than most newer choral compositions. Very talented composer.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Oh, I agree, A.E.. Bach’s musical tension combined with his unflagging sense of direction never fails to keep us moving upward in our struggle to be free of every kinda negative energy!


message 17: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder Excellent review Fergus; a fine appreciation of a great man and one of the most subline of all composers.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Such a nice as well as complimentary comment! Thanks, Gary.


message 19: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder Fergus wrote: "Such a nice as well as complimentary comment! Thanks, Gary."

You're welcome, Fergus. For some time I've believed that people who are searching for God might find their way to Him through Back's music.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs How true that is to me, Gary!


message 21: by Colin (new) - added it

Colin Baldwin Fergus! I was putting off my intended violin practice (part of which is unaccompanied Bach) and thanks to this inspiring review, I’m putting down my book and getting to it! CB


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Funny, I was only just now listening to Pablo Casals, solo in a practice session - only he was practicing for his heavenly recital, before the angels. Think maybe they might LEARN from it?


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs The music, of course, was Bach.


message 24: by Colin (new) - added it

Colin Baldwin Hey Fergus, another great review.
What a moutain of work this guy put out, like Telemann and Haydn, to name but a few.
Is he really 100% predicable! Some of the harmonic clashes in the Bach Double (for 2 violins), if played really slowly, are not what one would not be what one expects. Just sayin'...
INSERT SMILEY FACE

CB


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Well, I think you’re right, good friend. I was thinking plain diatonic scale here, which thanks to him, became our only accepted mode eventually. Oh, we still have our rebels, like Schoenberg (all over the musical map) or even Bill Evans, who played primarily in the Lydian mode. And the new normal is too mickey-mouse for the likes of Bach� but his Diatonic is Straightforward compared to the past!


message 26: by Mbgirl (new) - added it

Mbgirl I love Playing and listening to Bach. His quote about music being for the glory of God is above my piano. Were this not so thick, I would not be so oft deterred
From sticking with it!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Once you get into it, though, it is so accessible, due to Gardiners own easy-going, self-deprecating humour. So often the size of an annoyingily thick tome, too, can be whittled down quite handily with a good audio book version - at least in my own experience!


message 28: by Fred (new)

Fred Jenkins Gardiner is a pretty good conductor, too.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Oh, he's excellent, and I have always especially prized his recording of the Advent Cantatas! Other interpretations are tepid. This one storms - like the Second Coming!


back to top