Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Steven Godin's Reviews > Greed

Greed by Elfriede Jelinek
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26706841
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: austria, fiction


Of the ten previously unread Nobel recipients I had marked down to read this year, something told me to either get Elfriede Jelinek out the way first, or, leave until last so at least if things didn't go so well, the winners that went before made up for it. Well, although I wouldn't class this as a complete train wreak, there is little in the way of positives I can take from my collision course with Jelinek's meandering, tiresome, and weird prose, resulting in one of the most frustrating novels I have ever read. Frustrating because there is a story in there somewhere, through a dense fog, but she mostly puts the reader in a situation of being left on the sidelines, never to stand in the middle of her pitch.

I am lead to believe Elfriede Jelinek has always had a love/hate relationship with her native Austria, and that becomes apparent as the novel moves slowly through some menacing and lighter passages of writing that you feel were written with Jelinek having a laugh in the dark. I can also confirm that with Greed, she has an unhealthy obsession with genitals, with the male form being unfairly used as an aggressive weapon. She was described to me recently as writing from 'somewhere else'. That I can concur with, but being different doesn't always result in a decent book. This is a daredevil, risk-taking novel that may have a minority praising her bold and unflinching look at country life in the mountains and small towns of Austria.

Greed is written with a uniquely sneering tone, and a tireless fury for civilisation. Jelinek has seized the conventional novel by its dirty shoelaces, turned it upside down, continuously shaking and pulling, so that the reader feels nausea settling in. She can be explicit and extremely hostile when in comes to the sex included, and writes with a full-on sordidness for us humans. But there is also a chirpiness throughout the novel, where maybe things are not suppose to be taken that seriously. Some have even called her a comic writer, I wouldn't go as far as that here.

To break it down as simply as possible, there is a cop, Kurt Janisch, married, who mostly goes by the name of 'the Country Policeman', who likes to play around with the woman of his town, until a body turns up in a lake leading to a murder investigation. But all this is kept to a minimum, and Greed is in no way to be classed as a crime/mystery/thriller, if anything it's a dark sexual satire. Jelinek has no interest in plot development, instead, the novel's main function is to flesh it out with the divisions between men and women. They are on completely different wavelengths, the women are in love with the country policeman, whereas he blatantly only does what he does with property in mind. There are other aspects of greed, with that of banks, businesses, and phone companies 'hot for our voices', and also the church.

The Country Policeman was at no point a likeable character, his greed surpasses all. He has his problems financially, and prostitutes himself to every woman in the vicinity and beyond, in the hope that they will hand over their houses to him, or at least leave him something in their wills. He thinks of female genitalia in the same way, 'all these doors permanently flung open for him'. Jelinek circles round him like a wild cat, disgustedly observing his small strengths and big weaknesses. He completely lacks any sort of moral standard. What surprised me, was Jelinek is equally scathing about women, and their repellent eagerness to be loved or screwed. She doesn't exactly paint a pretty picture of her fellow Austrians, and her language used for anything sexual was like a piece of pornography done in bad taste. In fact, there were times when you feel she is trying to break away from the novel just to write some filth.

Brave, adventurous, witty, and antagonistic it may be, but ultimately this is a novel that doesn't really go anywhere. If there were answers, or a deeper meaning to her prose, I just wasn't attached enough to the novel to break it down and dissect it's internal parts. It's also well over a hundred pages too long. I could have bailed out early, and nothing would have been missed.
76 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Greed.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 24, 2018 – Started Reading
July 24, 2018 – Shelved
July 24, 2018 – Shelved as: austria
July 24, 2018 – Shelved as: fiction
August 1, 2018 –
page 159
45.17% "You sweet water you, you are gathered up by the steep forest roads, the inclines, the plastic slopes, the rocks, at first you look enchanting, transparent, glittering, then you turn to mud, become soil, while we, along with you fall into the bottomless limestone pits."
August 5, 2018 –
page 245
69.6%
August 7, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ruben (last edited Aug 07, 2018 09:17AM) (new)

Ruben I lived in Austria for four years, and Jelinek very much splits opinion.
The Piano Teacher is the only one I have read. And will always be the only one.


Steven Godin Rubin wrote: "I lived in Austria for four years, and Jelinek very much splits opinion.
The Piano Teacher is the only one I have read. And will always be the only one."


I thought about reading that. Now, not too sure. I believe Greed was the last book she wrote before winning the Nobel Prize. One can only presume the committee had an off day.


message 3: by Meike (new)

Meike I agree with Rubin: I also found "The Piano Teacher" pretty terrible - there are so many better authors from Austria than Jelinek!


message 4: by Steven (last edited Aug 08, 2018 06:45AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Meike wrote: "I agree with Rubin: I also found "The Piano Teacher" pretty terrible - there are so many better authors from Austria than Jelinek!"

I'd agree, there are plenty of other Austrian writers who put her in the shade. It's baffling how she managed to win the Nobel prize for literature.


message 5: by Lisa (new)

Lisa As I had the somewhat masochistic project to read at least three works by each Nobel Laureate in Literature, I have read three novels by Jelinek. Nothing in the world could make me read a fourth, I believe, so I am relieved you do not recommend this one to me, Steven! Her German prose is eloquent torture.


message 6: by Ilse (new)

Ilse She might have been the first Austrian author I have read, Steven (like Lisa, I read three), and it kept me off Austrian literature for years - I found her style admirable but, like you, also pretty tiresome . Eloquent torture, Lisa nailed it.


message 7: by Steven (last edited Aug 08, 2018 08:47AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Ilse wrote: "She might have been the first Austrian author I have read, Steven (like Lisa, I read three), and it kept me off Austrian literature for years - I found her style admirable but, like you, also prett..."

This was torture alright, and her treatment of women was seriously unpleasant. Only gave it the extra star because at least it was like nothing else I have ever read.


Steven Godin Lisa wrote: "As I had the somewhat masochistic project to read at least three works by each Nobel Laureate in Literature, I have read three novels by Jelinek. Nothing in the world could make me read a fourth, I..."

I will mull over whether to read her again, as would like to find that small shred of evidence to warrant her Nobel success.


message 9: by Julie (new)

Julie G "Meandering." Uh-oh. I might need to take a pass.


message 10: by Steven (last edited Aug 09, 2018 12:33AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Julie wrote: ""Meandering." Uh-oh. I might need to take a pass."

Yes, please pass! (unless mental torture is your thing) pass right on by, carry on walking, take the second left, then the third right, cross over the road (mind the traffic) and you will find a lovely Library with lots of wonderful books! This isn't one of them.


message 11: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Steven wrote: "Lisa wrote: "As I had the somewhat masochistic project to read at least three works by each Nobel Laureate in Literature, I have read three novels by Jelinek. Nothing in the world could make me rea..."

There are so many laureates that just create a big question mark in my head. I have a pet theory on Jelinek. She was chosen by a notoriously misogynist Academy mix of people (the same that are now literally destroying the institution from within as they are unable to reform even at the threat of dissolution). This group was frequently criticised in Swedish media for its blatant bias for male writers, and so they chose the most vitriolic woman on earth out of spite... Mind you, that is just my very unfounded idea, and I am quickly running after Julie down the road and left to the library ... oh ... watch that busssssss....


message 12: by Steven (last edited Aug 09, 2018 12:52AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Lisa wrote: "Steven wrote: "Lisa wrote: "As I had the somewhat masochistic project to read at least three works by each Nobel Laureate in Literature, I have read three novels by Jelinek. Nothing in the world co..."

I wouldn't be surprised if your theory is correct Lisa, Since we entered the 21st century the Academy started losing the plot.
Jelinek, just from one book, comes across as smug, rancorous and perverted. Even worse though was letting musicians get in on the act.


message 13: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Steven wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Steven wrote: "Lisa wrote: "As I had the somewhat masochistic project to read at least three works by each Nobel Laureate in Literature, I have read three novels by Jelinek. Nothing in..."

Yes, the Academy's Jelinek response to accusations of sexist bias would be like a conservative Republican claiming he is inclusive of women because he works with Ann Coulter ;-)

I have tried to like Jelinek, very hard, but it all boiled down to the fact that I can't stand hate porn, no matter what bandwagon the hating person jumps on.


message 14: by Robin (new)

Robin ...an unhealthy obsession with genitals...

Weird. This doesn't sound good, at all.


message 15: by Steven (last edited Aug 09, 2018 10:19AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Robin wrote: "...an unhealthy obsession with genitals...

Weird. This doesn't sound good, at all."


It's one to avoid at all cost for sure.


message 16: by Josh (new)

Josh We've had this on our bookshelf for quite some time. We both really enjoyed 'The Piano Teacher', but I'm starting to wonder if I'll ever try anymore of her books...Good review.


message 17: by Steven (last edited Aug 09, 2018 02:21PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Steven Godin Josh wrote: "We've had this on our bookshelf for quite some time. We both really enjoyed 'The Piano Teacher', but I'm starting to wonder if I'll ever try anymore of her books...Good review."

Thanks Josh, as this is the only one I have read, can't compare to her other books. She is simply just not for me. Maybe you will find something here I didn't, if you ever choose to read this.


message 18: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Despite the two stars...you make this sound both repugnant and interesting ! Nice review Steven !


Steven Godin Jaidee wrote: "Despite the two stars...you make this sound both repugnant and interesting ! Nice review Steven !"

Mildly interesting, highly repugnant!


back to top