Candi's Reviews > The Vegetarian
The Vegetarian
by
by

Candi's review
bookshelves: asia, contemporary-literary, translation, favorites, psychology
Mar 09, 2021
bookshelves: asia, contemporary-literary, translation, favorites, psychology
“It’s your body, you can treat it however you please. The only area where you’re free to do just as you like. And even that doesn’t turn out how you wanted.�
I don’t even know how to begin describing this novel. I’m guessing that in a year’s time or more, it will still hold true that this was one of the most haunting, unsettling and tragic novels I’ve read in a long time. For a slim book, there’s a great deal to mull over and discuss. There are many different ways of looking at this besides what meets the eye. Don’t let the title fool you. This isn’t simply a book about a woman that renounces meat and animal by-products. It’s a story about autonomy over one’s body and one’s life and the repercussions of a lack thereof. It probes the harmful ramifications of patriarchal societies, violence, and victimization. It explores mental illness. I’m not even touching on everything here. This is some heavy stuff!
“Everything starts to feel unfamiliar. As if I’ve come up to the back of something. Shut up behind a door without a handle. Perhaps I’m only now coming face-to-face with the thing that has always been here. It’s dark. Everything is being snuffed out in the pitch-black darkness.�
The subject of this novel is Yeong-hye. She’s not actually given a voice here except for a few very brief passages, as in the quote above, when she recounts the nightmares that led her to turn to vegetarianism. Instead, the book is split into three parts giving the perspectives of her husband, her brother-in-law, and eventually her sister. Not for one second did I ever feel any sympathy for the men. That’s not to say that I wasn’t wholly absorbed by the first two sections, because I surely was. What ultimately made the story for me, however, was the last section when we heard from In-hye, the sister. This was truly poignant and thought provoking. What makes one person suffer from mental illness while another does not? I’ve often considered that the boundary between a diagnosed illness versus a non-diagnosis can be a bit blurred at times. What about responsibility to another � how does that affect us psychologically? How do we protect those we love?
“If it hadn’t been for Ji-woo—if it hadn’t been for the sense of responsibility she felt toward him—perhaps she too might have relinquished her grip on that thread.�
I ended up with more questions by the time I turned the last page. I’ve had experience with a close loved one with a mental illness. As a child it’s scary and disconcerting. For me personally it heavily influenced my development as an adolescent and young adult. It affected many of my choices. I often think about the effects of mental illness on the functioning of a family. Han Kang has made me think about it that much more. What a powerful, beautiful torment of a book this was.
“Life is such a strange thing� Even after certain things have happened to them, no matter how awful the experience, people still go on eating and drinking, going to the toilet and washing themselves - living, in other words. And sometimes they even laugh out loud.�
I don’t even know how to begin describing this novel. I’m guessing that in a year’s time or more, it will still hold true that this was one of the most haunting, unsettling and tragic novels I’ve read in a long time. For a slim book, there’s a great deal to mull over and discuss. There are many different ways of looking at this besides what meets the eye. Don’t let the title fool you. This isn’t simply a book about a woman that renounces meat and animal by-products. It’s a story about autonomy over one’s body and one’s life and the repercussions of a lack thereof. It probes the harmful ramifications of patriarchal societies, violence, and victimization. It explores mental illness. I’m not even touching on everything here. This is some heavy stuff!
“Everything starts to feel unfamiliar. As if I’ve come up to the back of something. Shut up behind a door without a handle. Perhaps I’m only now coming face-to-face with the thing that has always been here. It’s dark. Everything is being snuffed out in the pitch-black darkness.�
The subject of this novel is Yeong-hye. She’s not actually given a voice here except for a few very brief passages, as in the quote above, when she recounts the nightmares that led her to turn to vegetarianism. Instead, the book is split into three parts giving the perspectives of her husband, her brother-in-law, and eventually her sister. Not for one second did I ever feel any sympathy for the men. That’s not to say that I wasn’t wholly absorbed by the first two sections, because I surely was. What ultimately made the story for me, however, was the last section when we heard from In-hye, the sister. This was truly poignant and thought provoking. What makes one person suffer from mental illness while another does not? I’ve often considered that the boundary between a diagnosed illness versus a non-diagnosis can be a bit blurred at times. What about responsibility to another � how does that affect us psychologically? How do we protect those we love?
“If it hadn’t been for Ji-woo—if it hadn’t been for the sense of responsibility she felt toward him—perhaps she too might have relinquished her grip on that thread.�
I ended up with more questions by the time I turned the last page. I’ve had experience with a close loved one with a mental illness. As a child it’s scary and disconcerting. For me personally it heavily influenced my development as an adolescent and young adult. It affected many of my choices. I often think about the effects of mental illness on the functioning of a family. Han Kang has made me think about it that much more. What a powerful, beautiful torment of a book this was.
“Life is such a strange thing� Even after certain things have happened to them, no matter how awful the experience, people still go on eating and drinking, going to the toilet and washing themselves - living, in other words. And sometimes they even laugh out loud.�
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Vegetarian.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 31, 2018
– Shelved
July 31, 2018
– Shelved as:
to-read
July 31, 2018
– Shelved as:
asia
July 31, 2018
– Shelved as:
contemporary-literary
July 31, 2018
– Shelved as:
translation
February 25, 2021
–
Started Reading
March 1, 2021
–
76.0%
""She was no longer able to cope with all that her sister reminded her of. She'd been unable to forgive her for soaring alone over a boundary she herself could never bring herself to cross, unable to forgive that magnificent irresponsibility that had enabled Yeong-hye to shuck off social constraints and leave her behind, still a prisoner.""
March 1, 2021
–
Finished Reading
March 9, 2021
– Shelved as:
favorites
March 9, 2021
– Shelved as:
psychology
Comments Showing 1-50 of 114 (114 new)
message 1:
by
Judith
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Mar 09, 2021 06:03AM

reply
|
flag



I think a lot of people assume the book is merely about a woman who becomes vegetarian, but as you point out, it's so much more than that.







This was a difficult review to write, because the book is not an easy one to read, Judith! There are so many takeaway points from it. Thanks so much!

Thank you very much, Sara. I don't even know who I could recommend this to personally, because of the subject matter. But if you are at all inclined to read it, then I would be so interested in hearing your thoughts on it.

Many thanks, Sue. I've had this book on and off my list for quite some time. I just finally felt like it was the right time to read it. I made the correct choice! Diagnosed vs undiagnosed illness is a subject that we could discuss for days.

I ..."
Thanks so much for your kind comment, Jenna! I wasn't sure how I was going to go about writing this. I could have gotten into the vegetarianism itself and how that is a choice we need to enable others to make. My son made the choice before kindergarten and I've had to struggle with family members who still 'feel sorry' for him because he doesn't eat meat! He's healthier and happier than most of his peers, so it should not make a difference! Anyway, yes, much more than a story about dietary choices though! :D


Thank you very much, Terry. Be prepared for a quick but weighty read! Definitely rewarding if it piques your curiosity :)


Thank you, Barbara! Yes, a lot of 'meat'! (I almost slipped that into my review :D ) I'll be going over this one in my head over and over again for weeks to come. I too love it best when a book has that sort of impact :)

Anne, I hoped that you would have a bit of insight on this topic. I thought genetics and environment would play a role, and it's interesting to see which one has the most influence on later mental health. I can only imagine what you have seen and heard. So many heartbreaking stories, I'm sure. I really appreciate your input as well as your support of the review, as always! :)

I'm glad I've given you a little nudge to pick this one up, moni. It's brilliant, really.

I think many reviews are going to resonate with me in future too, Adina! I know I'm going to read this one again someday. I'm sure that I can gain even more from it. Thanks for your kind comment :)

I've always been curious about this one. Your final paragraph made me want to read it more, and reminded me of my experience of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest as well. I'll never look at mental illness the same way again.

This one certainly has a way to get inside one's head. One thing's for sure, even when I'd forgotten most of the details of the events it still gives me the chills. Having read your review i think you'd be having them too. :)





Thank you, Regina! I totally understand - this won't suit everyone's reading tastes :)

Pedro, so many of those images will stay with me for a long, long time. I'm already thinking about what I can read of Kang's next :)

Thanks so much, Praveen. Yes, this was very unique wasn't it?! I'd have to say it felt surreal to me at times.

I still can feel pain -- in my gut -- from a couple of scenes --
I feel just like Adina - "I still get chills when I read other reviews"....."
Thanks a bunch, Elyse! Yes, there were definitely painful moments in this novel. You are so right about the complexities of mental illness. Thank goodness for a loving family despite the rough patches. I think I would like to read this again someday - but not anytime in the near future! :D I will need a good, long break. XO

Kevin, I so agree! I felt my reading was very narrow before joining ŷ. I can't imagine how I managed without it before :D I think we'll do just fine swapping ideas on fiction and non-fiction books. Thanks very much!

Many thanks, Antoinette! Oh, you would be the perfect reader for this book then! Once you get to it, I have to make sure to know about it so we can chat :)



I've always been curious about this one. Your final paragraph made me want to read it more, and reminded me of my experience of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest as well. I'll never look at me..."
Julie, you so need to read this book someday! You'll likely experience a range of emotions - except joy. There's really nothing happy about this book at all, so just be prepared for that. I am way overdue for a re-read of Kesey's novel. Now that I've read this, I'm really inclined to get to that sooner rather than later.

This one certainly has a way to get inside one's head. One thing's for sure, even when I'd forgotten most of the details of the events it still gives me the chills. Having read your..."
Thank you, Chandrachur. One thing that seems consistent among readers of this book - it's highly memorable. I do believe I will find it to be the same.

Thanks for your kind words, Alismcg. I have read several reviews that really helped me decide that I should pick up this novel. Then again I read a few that made me hesitate! I made the right choice for me personally, and hope that you can decide if it's for you or not :)

Thanks very much, TBV! I'm pleased the quotes caught your attention. This is a quiet yet powerful little novel.

Thank you, Karen! I can't say Kang's work is 'enjoyable', but it sure is rewarding. I'm glad you've added it :)
