Bettie's Reviews > The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined
The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined
by
by

Bettie's review
bookshelves: fraudio, published-2011, nonfiction, philosophy, summer-2012, tbr-busting-2012, abandoned, emperor-s-new-clothes, twats-in-real-life, wrong-so-wrong
Dec 17, 2011
bookshelves: fraudio, published-2011, nonfiction, philosophy, summer-2012, tbr-busting-2012, abandoned, emperor-s-new-clothes, twats-in-real-life, wrong-so-wrong
Audio Books : Educational : MP3/Variable : English

blurb - We've all had the experience of reading about a bloody war or shocking crime and asking, "What is the world coming to?" But we seldom ask, "How bad was the world in the past?" In this startling new book, the best-selling cognitive scientist Steven Pinker shows that the world of the past was much worse. In fact, we may be living in the most peaceable era in our species' existence.
Evidence of a bloody history has always been around us: the genocides in the Old Testament and crucifixions in the New; the gory mutilations in Shakespeare and Grimm; the British monarchs who beheaded their relatives and the American founders who dueled with their rivals; the nonchalant treatment in popular culture of wife-beating, child abuse, and the extermination of native peoples. Now the decline in these brutal practices can be quantified.
With the help of more than a hundred graphs and maps, Pinker presents some astonishing numbers. Tribal warfare was nine times as deadly as war and genocide in the 20th century. The murder rate in medieval Europe was more than thirty times what it is today. Slavery, sadistic punishments, and frivolous executions were unexceptionable features of life for millennia, then suddenly were targeted for abolition. Wars between developed countries have vanished, and even in the developing world, wars kill a fraction of the numbers they did a few decades ago. Rape, battering, hate crimes, deadly riots, child abuse, cruelty to animals - all substantially down.How could this have happened, if human nature has not changed? What led people to stop sacrificing children, stabbing each other at the dinner table, or burning cats and disemboweling criminals as forms of popular entertainment? Was it reading novels, cultivating table manners, fearing the police, or turning their energies to making money? Should the nuclear bomb get the Nobel Peace Prize for preventing World War III? Does rock and roll deserve the blame for the doubling of violence in the 1960s - and abortion deserve credit for the reversal in the 1990s?
Not exactly, Pinker argues. The key to explaining the decline of violence is to understand the inner demons that incline us toward violence (such as revenge, sadism, and tribalism) and the better angels that steer us away. Thanks to the spread of government, literacy, trade, and cosmopolitanism, we increasingly control our impulses, empathize with others, bargain rather than plunder, debunk toxic ideologies, and deploy our powers of reason to reduce the temptations of violence.
With the panache and intellectual zeal that have made his earlier books international best sellers and literary classics, Pinker will force you to rethink your deepest beliefs about progress, modernity, and human nature. This gripping book is sure to be among the most debated of the century so far.
SHEEIT - turned off half way through the introduction, how could I possibly force myself to trudge through nearly 900 pages of earnest wrongness. Look at your newspapers to see that there is little decline in violence.
NEXT!!
9th April 2015 ETA: At last, Pinker's Emperor's New Clothes have been rumbled by someone else:

blurb - We've all had the experience of reading about a bloody war or shocking crime and asking, "What is the world coming to?" But we seldom ask, "How bad was the world in the past?" In this startling new book, the best-selling cognitive scientist Steven Pinker shows that the world of the past was much worse. In fact, we may be living in the most peaceable era in our species' existence.
Evidence of a bloody history has always been around us: the genocides in the Old Testament and crucifixions in the New; the gory mutilations in Shakespeare and Grimm; the British monarchs who beheaded their relatives and the American founders who dueled with their rivals; the nonchalant treatment in popular culture of wife-beating, child abuse, and the extermination of native peoples. Now the decline in these brutal practices can be quantified.
With the help of more than a hundred graphs and maps, Pinker presents some astonishing numbers. Tribal warfare was nine times as deadly as war and genocide in the 20th century. The murder rate in medieval Europe was more than thirty times what it is today. Slavery, sadistic punishments, and frivolous executions were unexceptionable features of life for millennia, then suddenly were targeted for abolition. Wars between developed countries have vanished, and even in the developing world, wars kill a fraction of the numbers they did a few decades ago. Rape, battering, hate crimes, deadly riots, child abuse, cruelty to animals - all substantially down.How could this have happened, if human nature has not changed? What led people to stop sacrificing children, stabbing each other at the dinner table, or burning cats and disemboweling criminals as forms of popular entertainment? Was it reading novels, cultivating table manners, fearing the police, or turning their energies to making money? Should the nuclear bomb get the Nobel Peace Prize for preventing World War III? Does rock and roll deserve the blame for the doubling of violence in the 1960s - and abortion deserve credit for the reversal in the 1990s?
Not exactly, Pinker argues. The key to explaining the decline of violence is to understand the inner demons that incline us toward violence (such as revenge, sadism, and tribalism) and the better angels that steer us away. Thanks to the spread of government, literacy, trade, and cosmopolitanism, we increasingly control our impulses, empathize with others, bargain rather than plunder, debunk toxic ideologies, and deploy our powers of reason to reduce the temptations of violence.
With the panache and intellectual zeal that have made his earlier books international best sellers and literary classics, Pinker will force you to rethink your deepest beliefs about progress, modernity, and human nature. This gripping book is sure to be among the most debated of the century so far.
SHEEIT - turned off half way through the introduction, how could I possibly force myself to trudge through nearly 900 pages of earnest wrongness. Look at your newspapers to see that there is little decline in violence.
NEXT!!
9th April 2015 ETA: At last, Pinker's Emperor's New Clothes have been rumbled by someone else:
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Better Angels of Our Nature.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 17, 2011
–
Started Reading
December 17, 2011
– Shelved
June 19, 2012
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jun 19, 2012 10:06AM
He was better when he was talking about linguistics, et alia... but he was still pretty unbearable. It's a genetic condition, I think.
reply
|
flag


I used to fancy him rotten - shame he opened his non-linguistosity
I used to think he was the cat's PJs too. Why is it that people who are smart in one area think they can be smart all over the place... he'll prolly be running for president of the US next.

Haha! Yeah, thanks to governments for keeping violence down. I guess street crime co..."
*chuckles* - that is exactly how my head was going. Mathematics is not my greatest friend however one feels that 20thC was pretty bloody:
Russian
China
Japan
Armenians
wwI
wwII
All points Africa
etcetera
etcetera
etcetera
shall we dance and leave silly man to his permed locks?


Lady Penelope Creighton-Ward with car-matching trouser suit.
Bettie wrote: "This bit made me gasp:
With the help of more than a hundred graphs and maps..."
Brevity is the soul of wit, after all.
With the help of more than a hundred graphs and maps..."
Brevity is the soul of wit, after all.

Just over half, Daniel. Like I say, a non-subject earnestly rendered. Violence is on the increase, just look around.


go itch forbitch with other earnest non-subject adherents, I think it is pretty clear how I stand on this subject and you are trolling my review because I don't agree with you.


Thanks John - we all tried hard because we knew you and Daniel were out there.
:O)

Your (and John's of course) unsolicited remarks prove how Pinker's book is just so wrong at core reality level.
Rest my case at this point proved moment. YAY

But you know what is fabulous about the peeps like John and Daniel - they make old reviews pop up so I get to see the cool Thunderbird pix which I missed before, because we weren't friends yet. So they're not total plonkers, then...
YAY! ;)

hahaha No of course they can't be total plonkers if their behaviour underscores why this book is just another emperor's new clothes affair. But we shall draw a line under that now and move on.
Glad you liked the Thunderbird piccies, and you have yourself a lovely weekend Miss M, everyone.
:O)


(Thanks for the link, Bettie. A very interesting article).
A critique of Pinker's statistical methods: