Janae's Reviews > Breaking Dawn
Breaking Dawn (The Twilight Saga, #4)
by
by

** spoiler alert **
Where do I begin? I LOVED this book. It was even better than I even imagined. So many surprises! I picked mine up at midnight when it was released and could hardly put it down.
So first off...the wedding was beautiful. The honeymoon was even better. Stephenie Meyer did an amazing job of writing a "tasteful" honeymoon scene. It wasn't dirty at all. It was beautiful. You knew they were able to have sex and that there was a definate strong "intensity" during these moments but she didn't go into too many explicit details which leaves much to the imagination (I loved the quote by Bella, "Why am I covered in feathers?"). It was PG-13. Plus they were married when it happened so that made it even better. I have to admit I was a little shocked she wrote the sex parts. I didn't think she would go there but I am so glad she did because it just made the bond between Edward and Bella even stronger if that was even possible. It was hot and sexy for sure! I am so happy Edward and Bella got their proper wedding & honeymoon and more importantly....that I got to read about it like I was right there! Does that make me a pervert? Oh who cares! It was amazing!
So what I never dreamed of happening was a pregnancy! This is when the story goes from pure happiness to total uncertainty and even sadness for some. Bella is adamant that she would keep the baby even though it was killing her, hoping she could keep her heart beating long enough so she could be turned into a vampire to save her. I have never felt so horrible for Edward. To say he was in agony would be an understatement. Chapter 9 was very hard for me to read because Edward was in so much pain. Pain isn’t even close to describing what he was feeling. Not that I doubted before but it was in this chapter that really solidified that Edward would do ANYTHING for Bella no matter how much pain it caused him. Pain he feels he deserves. I felt awful for him.
Chapter 18...the birth was by far the most intense chapter of all the books in the series for me. I was literally shaking as I read it. It was pretty graphic with Bella’s bones cracking and breaking, her spine shattering, throwing up all the blood she had been drinking to feed her unborn child. She was dying. I was on the edge of my seat wondering if they would be able to save the baby and at the same time save her. I always hoped Bella would become a vampire but I always had this feeling that Stephenie wouldn’t let that happen. I am so happy I was wrong. One of my favorite parts from the chapter was when Jacob was giving Bella CPR after the baby was born�.
“Move your hands, Jacob,�
I looked up from Bella’s white eyes, still pumping her heart for her. Edward had a syringe in his hand-all silver, like it was made from steel.
“What’s that?�
His stone hand knocked mine out of the way. There was a tiny crunch as his blow broke my little finger. In the same second, he shoved the needle straight into her heart.
“My venom,� he answered as he pushed the plunger down.
You could feel that at this moment Edward was very somber. He was turning the woman he loved into a vampire. Something he had fought against for a long time because he didn't want her to have to give up any human experiences and eventually regret becoming a vampire. Now he did it to save her. There was no other way. I wish I could have been in his head at this time though it would have been very depressing I'm sure. Jacob too had to give in to letting her become a vampire to save her.
So now not only was Bella changed into a vampire, but she
was a mother and a wife. So many changes so fast. This all shocked me but nothing shocked me more than when Jacob imprints on Bella & Edward’s baby...Renesmee(not fond of the name...but thank goodness it wasn't an Edward Jacob! That name irritated me even more). I have to admit though it kinda freaked me out at first. I don't blame Bella for wanting to tear him apart. Like me I don't think she could have ever imagined this happening. This event was so significant. It released all the pain Jacob had to endure by being in love with Bella but knowing she would never be his. At the same time it tied him to her permanently. He still loved her but in the way it should have always been. He loved her as a friend and nothing more. Also with her change into a vampire & birth of Renesmee brought a release from the pull she felt to have Jacob as part of her life, though he would still be because of the whole imprinting thing but it would never complicate things between her and Edward’s relationship again which I was very grateful for. She loved him as a brother like she always wanted. Everything was as it should be.
So in the end the challenge was the Volturi. They were coming to kill all of them because they believed Edward & Bella had created a youngling. Changed a child into a vampire when really Renesmee was the biological child of Edward and Bella. I cried (the ugly kind, I was hysterical) at a point when Edward and Bella said their quiet goodbyes to their daughter and Jacob when they thought they were about to die. It was heart wrenching. It was so touching when Edward said to Jacob, "Goodbye Jacob, my brother.....my son." What a wonderful gesture from Edward to Jacob. Luckily in the end they were able to conquer because of Bella and her amazing gift to shield everyone she loved from the "special" gifts of the Volturi. I thought it was wonderful to see Bella so powerful and strong. That for once she was able to be the protector instead of the one being protected. She got to be the savior. This too made the unbreakable bond between her and Edward stronger. Because of her they were able to beat the Volturi and save their daughter that they loved more than anything. Their family was intact.
One of my absolute favorite parts (there are so many I have to say) was at the end when Bella removes her "shield" so Edward can read her thoughts. Edward was NOT expecting this. Not being able to all this time has driven him mad at times. Especially when it came to Jacob. He always wondered if Bella made the right decision. Now he knows without a doubt that she always loved him and that nothing can or ever will change that. Edward got to experience all the feelings she had for him as far back as she could remember. He can know now without a doubt that they truly belong together. What a wonderful gift to give Edward. Oh I just LOVE Edward! That Bella is one lucky vampire.
I was so glad this book had the Happily Ever After ending. Especially after all the horrible things that have occured in the past. Everything came together beautifully. I loved it. I liked Jacob a lot more in this book in fact I laughed out loud several times at him. I also liked Bella a lot more when she became a vampire. She wasn't as selfish and winey. I wanted to strangle her at times in the other books because of the way she treated Edward and even Jacob. The pain she caused both of them in the past because of her own selfish desires. Everything for the characters is balanced or in line how it should be in their relationships. I feel closer with the story now which I needed badly. These books totally consumed me to say the least. This was my favorite of the series by far. It was filled with love, suspense, true friendship, loyalty, sorrow, happiness and so much more. I look forward to reading it again! I don't think I will ever be able to find a series again that has affected me like this. These books are my favorites above all others!
So first off...the wedding was beautiful. The honeymoon was even better. Stephenie Meyer did an amazing job of writing a "tasteful" honeymoon scene. It wasn't dirty at all. It was beautiful. You knew they were able to have sex and that there was a definate strong "intensity" during these moments but she didn't go into too many explicit details which leaves much to the imagination (I loved the quote by Bella, "Why am I covered in feathers?"). It was PG-13. Plus they were married when it happened so that made it even better. I have to admit I was a little shocked she wrote the sex parts. I didn't think she would go there but I am so glad she did because it just made the bond between Edward and Bella even stronger if that was even possible. It was hot and sexy for sure! I am so happy Edward and Bella got their proper wedding & honeymoon and more importantly....that I got to read about it like I was right there! Does that make me a pervert? Oh who cares! It was amazing!
So what I never dreamed of happening was a pregnancy! This is when the story goes from pure happiness to total uncertainty and even sadness for some. Bella is adamant that she would keep the baby even though it was killing her, hoping she could keep her heart beating long enough so she could be turned into a vampire to save her. I have never felt so horrible for Edward. To say he was in agony would be an understatement. Chapter 9 was very hard for me to read because Edward was in so much pain. Pain isn’t even close to describing what he was feeling. Not that I doubted before but it was in this chapter that really solidified that Edward would do ANYTHING for Bella no matter how much pain it caused him. Pain he feels he deserves. I felt awful for him.
Chapter 18...the birth was by far the most intense chapter of all the books in the series for me. I was literally shaking as I read it. It was pretty graphic with Bella’s bones cracking and breaking, her spine shattering, throwing up all the blood she had been drinking to feed her unborn child. She was dying. I was on the edge of my seat wondering if they would be able to save the baby and at the same time save her. I always hoped Bella would become a vampire but I always had this feeling that Stephenie wouldn’t let that happen. I am so happy I was wrong. One of my favorite parts from the chapter was when Jacob was giving Bella CPR after the baby was born�.
“Move your hands, Jacob,�
I looked up from Bella’s white eyes, still pumping her heart for her. Edward had a syringe in his hand-all silver, like it was made from steel.
“What’s that?�
His stone hand knocked mine out of the way. There was a tiny crunch as his blow broke my little finger. In the same second, he shoved the needle straight into her heart.
“My venom,� he answered as he pushed the plunger down.
You could feel that at this moment Edward was very somber. He was turning the woman he loved into a vampire. Something he had fought against for a long time because he didn't want her to have to give up any human experiences and eventually regret becoming a vampire. Now he did it to save her. There was no other way. I wish I could have been in his head at this time though it would have been very depressing I'm sure. Jacob too had to give in to letting her become a vampire to save her.
So now not only was Bella changed into a vampire, but she
was a mother and a wife. So many changes so fast. This all shocked me but nothing shocked me more than when Jacob imprints on Bella & Edward’s baby...Renesmee(not fond of the name...but thank goodness it wasn't an Edward Jacob! That name irritated me even more). I have to admit though it kinda freaked me out at first. I don't blame Bella for wanting to tear him apart. Like me I don't think she could have ever imagined this happening. This event was so significant. It released all the pain Jacob had to endure by being in love with Bella but knowing she would never be his. At the same time it tied him to her permanently. He still loved her but in the way it should have always been. He loved her as a friend and nothing more. Also with her change into a vampire & birth of Renesmee brought a release from the pull she felt to have Jacob as part of her life, though he would still be because of the whole imprinting thing but it would never complicate things between her and Edward’s relationship again which I was very grateful for. She loved him as a brother like she always wanted. Everything was as it should be.
So in the end the challenge was the Volturi. They were coming to kill all of them because they believed Edward & Bella had created a youngling. Changed a child into a vampire when really Renesmee was the biological child of Edward and Bella. I cried (the ugly kind, I was hysterical) at a point when Edward and Bella said their quiet goodbyes to their daughter and Jacob when they thought they were about to die. It was heart wrenching. It was so touching when Edward said to Jacob, "Goodbye Jacob, my brother.....my son." What a wonderful gesture from Edward to Jacob. Luckily in the end they were able to conquer because of Bella and her amazing gift to shield everyone she loved from the "special" gifts of the Volturi. I thought it was wonderful to see Bella so powerful and strong. That for once she was able to be the protector instead of the one being protected. She got to be the savior. This too made the unbreakable bond between her and Edward stronger. Because of her they were able to beat the Volturi and save their daughter that they loved more than anything. Their family was intact.
One of my absolute favorite parts (there are so many I have to say) was at the end when Bella removes her "shield" so Edward can read her thoughts. Edward was NOT expecting this. Not being able to all this time has driven him mad at times. Especially when it came to Jacob. He always wondered if Bella made the right decision. Now he knows without a doubt that she always loved him and that nothing can or ever will change that. Edward got to experience all the feelings she had for him as far back as she could remember. He can know now without a doubt that they truly belong together. What a wonderful gift to give Edward. Oh I just LOVE Edward! That Bella is one lucky vampire.
I was so glad this book had the Happily Ever After ending. Especially after all the horrible things that have occured in the past. Everything came together beautifully. I loved it. I liked Jacob a lot more in this book in fact I laughed out loud several times at him. I also liked Bella a lot more when she became a vampire. She wasn't as selfish and winey. I wanted to strangle her at times in the other books because of the way she treated Edward and even Jacob. The pain she caused both of them in the past because of her own selfish desires. Everything for the characters is balanced or in line how it should be in their relationships. I feel closer with the story now which I needed badly. These books totally consumed me to say the least. This was my favorite of the series by far. It was filled with love, suspense, true friendship, loyalty, sorrow, happiness and so much more. I look forward to reading it again! I don't think I will ever be able to find a series again that has affected me like this. These books are my favorites above all others!
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Breaking Dawn.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
June 18, 2008
– Shelved
Started Reading
August 3, 2008
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 70 (70 new)
message 1:
by
Bill
(new)
Aug 03, 2008 07:50PM

reply
|
flag


And I too am happy that Jacob finally found someone to love so soon and that he felt nothing more than a strong friendship with Bella. And thank goodness when Bella became a vampire that she had nothing but friendship with Jacob as well and she was 1 million percent true to Edward...
Ok, sorry for rambling!


I know exactly what you mean! I loved when she lifted that shield off her, so Edward could read her mind. It was so sweet. I loved the book. I can't get over how good it was.


I was feeling frustrated about being called an idiot from so many for liking this book, and the series. You made my day - thank you!




heeehehehee, I think my husband and daughters are ready to burn my books! He's worried for me that the movie will not meet my expectations. I've already seen a couple trailers and complained. He's sworn off going to the movie with me - heeheheheee he KNOWS I'm going with one of my best friends.
I don't know why ANYONE would read an entire series of books if they didn't like it. I also think that there was so much anticipation and build up for this book, that no matter what she would have written it wouldn't have been received well. Everyone had their own theories ect. I was truly freaked when she got pregnant and annoyed, but I knew if I was patient, it would all turn out just right. I thought it was a perfect series.
Thank you again - I'm glad that I stumbled across your great review.

Me 2. It makes the book so much better. There are things she needs to hide from him at times. And thoughts she wishes him not to know. But that was just so sweet.

The way other people criticize SM's writings it's as if it's so easy to write a book, or in her case, a whole series. Sure editing needs to be done, but really, just go with the flow. I mean, I got reallly annoyed with some grammatical errors as well, and sometimes i even had to reread a paragraph because of it, but so what? Really, it's not that big a deal. It's a big book (and I'm guessing she wanted the story to be that long) and she can't pinpoint every single mistake she's made in the book because she's the one writing it.
and yes, she has an editor for that, but again, it's not like it's so easy editing something that much while trying to stick to the plot she has in mind right? And no one has perfect grammar and punctuation.
Some people are waaayyy too insightful that it kills everyone's fun. XD
Anyway, i totally agree with everything you said and i'll back you up no matter what.



I was so excited at volleyball to be one of the first people to be done with the book and everytime someone messed up I told them I would tell them something about the book. We played really hard. It was a fun book and I am glad that I got into the series. I read your spoiler before I read the book so it made it easier to read cause I knew that all would be well. I liked that cause I could read with ease. I still like Jacob but I am warming up to Edward.

P.S. I BAWLED when they said goodbye to Nessie! BAWLED like a baby! I'm glad I wasn't alone! LOL

I'm sick of reading the bad reviews as well. I think it was wonderful, all of the books. I think some take them a bit too seriously, instead of enjoying them. I wonder what they would have rather happened.




I absolutly loved to book and I was tired of seeing all of these horrible reviews on it and all..
And Bella's birthing scene and her being changed was one of my favorite parts of the book
Plus I have started re-reading it for like the 3rd time!!!!



i loved the book and i am sick of reading bad reviews haha
" oh totally, i hate all these haters!...wait, does that make me a hater too?....oh well! lol


I read that a couple times and was so happy that I had moments like that in my life too..

Give yourself a treat and listen to the audio versions. The reader is AMAZING!
I agree with you. I loved the last one most. I got over worrying about why I shouldn't like it or any of that and just enjoyed it!
Good for you!
oh my goodness it's as if i wrote that review myself! you've mirrored my thought exactly on this book. i love love loveeeeee this review!
i have no comments for you, kathryn.

Breaking Dawn was horrible. It would have been better if she tied up all the little problems in seperate books, not trying to finish them and get them all hastily tied together in one book. Don't get me wrong, she's a fairly good writer and the series is sort-of good. But it's still lacking. The characters.. they don't have anything in common. Bella just thinks Edward's uberly hot and Edward's just fascinated by the scent of her blood and the fact he can't read her mind. Okay, anything else? I don't think so. The side characters are more fleshed out than the main characters, which I find kind of sad. All in all, this is just some sick, twisted fantasy. And for you who're going to ask me why I read it, all I have to say is that I heard such high praise for the book that I decided to read it. I was sorely disapointed.
But, again. This is my opinion on the series. Debate if you like. c: Debating is always fun.~
i disagree. no hard feelings, though. i get your point, i mean, she could've written two books from that.

I love the saga sooo much and i agree with you, there is no series of books that has ever affected me so much and i don't think there ever will be. There is barely a day that goes by without me thinking about it. it was utterly addictive when i was reading it and i'm so sad i've finnished all the books. Also, it took me a long time to pick up any other book after reading the saga. It might sound really dumb, but i felt like reading anything else would betray Stephanie and the characters of Twilight. Maybe i'm just crazy, but I'm sure the books have changed me as a person.

And if you're serious about this book affecting you so much and betraying SMeyer, then, frankly, you have a mental problem. They've "changed" you? Just because you think their love is all happy-happy and is how love is "supposed to be"? You think Edward stalking her is "unbearably sweet", am I right? Gods, you people disgust me. It's a freaking /book/ for crying outloud. Go pick up something /good/ to read, and then come talk to me. (x
Bahah, I luff all you Twilight fangirls. You make me laugh.
Are you telling me you'd be okay with some creep you barely know stalking you? Following you where you go so you don't get hurt?
Because, I for one, would steer clear of them, no matter how "hot" they may be.
Edward's too perfect. He can do this, he can do that. God, he can even sparkle in the sun. O.o
Is there anything this ugly guy /can't/ do? Because that list would be much shorter, something I'm not happy with.
Bella and Edward's relationship is too... blechh. "Ohemgee. Edward's not here, I'm going to /die./"
"God. Edward's gone. I'm depressed. While I wallow in my pools of despair, I'll go hang out with Jacob because he loves me and he'll let me complain to him without arguing."
Now, I have near to nothing to dislike about Jacob, except that he's mostly some desperate guy wanting Bella to love him. I mean, there are better girls out there.
Reallynao, She's too clingy. It's like her life depends on the sole being of Edward's existence. Doesn't she have something better to do than fantasize about being a vampire and staying with Edward forever? I mean, she's 17. Or however the heck old she is.
Shouldn't she focus on school and such before having sex? Isn't that something adults like SMeyer should be enforcing? I mean, I know 2nd graders that read this series, and she's basically telling them it's okay to have sex and have a child before college/getting married/etc.
She's polluting children's minds with crap.
Not to mention she's extremely beautiful now that she's a vampire, and whatever those other qualities she has now.
Now for her daughter. Renesmee.
Are you serious? It's a horrid name for a child.
Would /you/ want to parade around with a mix of your grandmother's names? I sure as heck wouldn't. I like the name Carlie, though. I'd prefer that.
Renesmee also has vampire-istic qualities, something about being able to.. do something with your thoughts? I don't remember - as I've only read it once. For a reason I'm sure you know by now.
They're all too perfect. The whole lot of them.
You know what SMeyer needs to do?
get some creativity.
Give them flaws.
Make Edward and Bella's relationship... not as happy-happy.
Yes, I realize this is long, thanks. But maybe it will brighten your day. Or rain on your parade. Whichever type of fan you are. Or maybe it won't affect you at all. Maybe you couldn't care less. But you know what? I like pointing out flaws to die-hard Twilight fans who think this sappy, stupid, cliche, wanna-be love story is the most amazing book ever. It just makes me feel a lot better, like a weight's been lifted off my shoulders.
So on a final note: Go pick up a better book. There are plenty of them out there that don't pollute little children's minds. Then get back to me.
"It might sound really dumb, but i felt like reading anything else would betray Stephanie and the characters of Twilight."
Are you for real? Are you sure you don't belong in an insane asylum? Because I can get you a room. ASAP.
You seriously have problems. You think that reading something else would make SMeyer upset or something? Or the characters? Mygod, the characters. They aren't even /real/ and you think you're betraying them? Go read something better, please. And get back to me then. Maybe you'll see that Twilight isn't all you think it is. There are far better writers out there that put SMeyer's books way down on the charts.
You people disgust me.
I mean, Edward and Bella have pretty much nothing in common.
Nothing.
Bella's clumsy.
Edward's perfect.
Bella's this.
Edward's that.
They're completely different.
Are you telling me you'd be okay with some creep you barely know stalking you? Following you where you go so you don't get hurt?
Because, I for one, would steer clear of them, no matter how "hot" they may be.
Edward's too perfect. He can do this, he can do that. God, he can even sparkle in the sun. O.o
Is there anything this ugly guy /can't/ do? Because that list would be much shorter, something I'm not happy with.
Bella and Edward's relationship is too... blechh. "Ohemgee. Edward's not here, I'm going to /die./"
"God. Edward's gone. I'm depressed. While I wallow in my pools of despair, I'll go hang out with Jacob because he loves me and he'll let me complain to him without arguing."
Now, I have near to nothing to dislike about Jacob, except that he's mostly some desperate guy wanting Bella to love him. I mean, there are better girls out there.
Reallynao, She's too clingy. It's like her life depends on the sole being of Edward's existence. Doesn't she have something better to do than fantasize about being a vampire and staying with Edward forever? I mean, she's 17. Or however the heck old she is.
Shouldn't she focus on school and such before having sex? Isn't that something adults like SMeyer should be enforcing? I mean, I know 2nd graders that read this series, and she's basically telling them it's okay to have sex and have a child before college/getting married/etc.
She's polluting children's minds with crap.
Not to mention she's extremely beautiful now that she's a vampire, and whatever those other qualities she has now.
Now for her daughter. Renesmee.
Are you serious? It's a horrid name for a child.
Would /you/ want to parade around with a mix of your grandmother's names? I sure as heck wouldn't. I like the name Carlie, though. I'd prefer that.
Renesmee also has vampire-istic qualities, something about being able to.. do something with your thoughts? I don't remember - as I've only read it once. For a reason I'm sure you know by now.
They're all too perfect. The whole lot of them.
You know what SMeyer needs to do?
get some creativity.
Give them flaws.
Make Edward and Bella's relationship... not as happy-happy.
Yes, I realize this is long, thanks. But maybe it will brighten your day. Or rain on your parade. Whichever type of fan you are. Or maybe it won't affect you at all. Maybe you couldn't care less. But you know what? I like pointing out flaws to die-hard Twilight fans who think this sappy, stupid, cliche, wanna-be love story is the most amazing book ever. It just makes me feel a lot better, like a weight's been lifted off my shoulders.
So on a final note: Go pick up a better book. There are plenty of them out there that don't pollute little children's minds. Then get back to me.
"It might sound really dumb, but i felt like reading anything else would betray Stephanie and the characters of Twilight."
Are you for real? Are you sure you don't belong in an insane asylum? Because I can get you a room. ASAP.
You seriously have problems. You think that reading something else would make SMeyer upset or something? Or the characters? Mygod, the characters. They aren't even /real/ and you think you're betraying them? Go read something better, please. And get back to me then. Maybe you'll see that Twilight isn't all you think it is. There are far better writers out there that put SMeyer's books way down on the charts.
You people disgust me.
I mean, Edward and Bella have pretty much nothing in common.
Nothing.
Bella's clumsy.
Edward's perfect.
Bella's this.
Edward's that.
They're completely different.

But yes. I agree with you 100%, Blizz.

Can hardly wait to see NEW MOON at the movies, 14 days to go YEAH!!!!


Breaking dawn definatly is the best book out of the series, and i can´t wait to see if they will make it justice in the film.
I enjoyed sooo much the series.
Hey have you heard of Nidnight Sun that stephanie Meyer wrote it is Twilight however it is from Edwards point of view.
Some one leaked it into the internet and now stephanie doesn´t want to finish it. I feel sorry for her because it was something personal to her and they leak a raf draft, but even so she place it in her website to show her fans that she is upset and wants us to understand that it wasn´t ready, but she still place it on her website so we can read the little bit.
I truly hope she finish it because even the bit she wrote i love it.
so if anyone wants to read it. It´s on her website.
Stephanie Meyer rules:P!!!


"One of my absolute favorite parts (there are so many I have to say) was at the end when Bella removes her "shield" so Edward can read her thoughts. Edward was NOT expecting this. Not being able to all this time has driven him mad at times. Especially when it came to Jacob. He always wondered if Bella made the right decision. Now he knows without a doubt that she always loved him and that nothing can or ever will change that. Edward got to experience all the feelings she had for him as far back as she could remember. He can know now without a doubt that they truly belong together. What a wonderful gift to give Edward. Oh I just LOVE Edward! That Bella is one lucky vampire. "
So, is it a gesture of true love to give your loved one EVERY intimite part of yourself so that they can objectively be certain that you love them? There should be no trust between partners? Does one need to PROVE anything in a relationship?
I'm sorry, I just find that to be bull. It's not love, it's control. When there's no real trust, based on feeling and knowing the person for who they are, I sincerely think that a relationship is doomed to fail.