ŷ

Luffy Sempai's Reviews > Norwegian Wood

Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7407364
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 5-star, literary, page-turner, popular, romance, superb-characterization

I don't have many meaningful things to say about Norwegian Wood. First, a disclaimer. This is, by no means, a romance book - no offence meant. I cannot suffer to attach such a tacky word on this book. Oh, what do I know, it IS a romance book. But it is laterally more than that.

Like Dickens, Murakami fuels his potboiler with death of the innocent. Each one is offing herself. That's right. What really matters is the subtext. In all superficial opinion, Watanabe is having a normal college life. But though the actions of his peers unravel with robotic neatness, in the background there's chaos going on.

Watanabe's best bud, Nagasawa, plays the devil's advocate. Showing himself as an evil guy, which he partially is, he prompts and tempts and gauges. He teases with Watanabe's rhythm of orderliness.But stuff was happening before they met. The one humanitarian thing that Watanabe does, in the hospital, attending upon Midori's dad, is hefty in its purity. That's what lacks in classical literature, ambivalent people who have their own set of morals. People who still are heroes.

There is the question of death lingering throughout the book. Near the end I was fed up with these upheavals. But then the hero himself put him in purgatorial madness. The sex in the book doesn't appear obscene at all. It feels natural. The people who don't feel real, such as Midori, are still full of a palette of colours. She is a healthy caricature. And she does her job of making me laugh. In a way Midori is the most generous girl of the bunch.

Murakami had always been a closed door for me. But if his other work is like this one, then I need a second crack at one of his other books. I tried hard not to let spoilers show, but man has Murakami got the talent to keep churning interesting words. The best thing is that few people notice that beneath this seamless flow of words, lie a lot of twists. Twists are what make art great. And this was great art. It contains lots of films, literature, the Beatles' music, Bach, Mozart. And in the end, the love you take, is equal to the love you make.

Thanks to my cyber friend, Manju, to recommend this book to me.
240 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Norwegian Wood.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 11, 2018 – Started Reading
August 11, 2018 – Shelved
August 18, 2018 – Finished Reading
August 11, 2020 – Shelved as: 5-star
June 9, 2021 – Shelved as: literary
June 9, 2021 – Shelved as: page-turner
June 9, 2021 – Shelved as: popular
June 9, 2021 – Shelved as: romance
June 9, 2021 – Shelved as: superb-characterization

Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)


message 1: by Diane S � (new)

Diane S ☔ Terrific review, Luffy.


Sharyl Nice review😊 I've read a couple novels by this author and know what you mean by how he churns out interesting words. Glad to see you liked this so much--I will make sure to read it sometime.


message 3: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron I keep meaning to get to this one. Really enjoyed your review, Luffy.


Phrynne Great review Luffy.


message 5: by Paula (new)

Paula K Excellent review, Luffy!


Em Lost In Books Am so happy that you read it and loved it.😊

Fantastic review.


Luffy Sempai Diane S � wrote: "Terrific review, Luffy."

Thanks a lot, Diane!


Luffy Sempai Sharyl wrote: "Nice review😊 I've read a couple novels by this author and know what you mean by how he churns out interesting words. Glad to see you liked this so much--I will make sure to read it sometime."

Thanks, Sharyl! It took me a few paragraphs until I took a liking to the book, I won't lie. But after that, it was plain sailing.


Luffy Sempai Zoeytron wrote: "I keep meaning to get to this one. Really enjoyed your review, Luffy."

Thank you, Zoeytron! I'd been meaning to read this a long time ago too.


Luffy Sempai Phrynne wrote: "Great review Luffy."

Thank you, Phrynne!

Paula wrote: "Excellent review, Luffy!"

Thanks, Paula!


Luffy Sempai Manju wrote: "Am so happy that you read it and loved it.😊

Fantastic review."


If you have more recommendations like that, do share. Thanks for the compliment!


Luffy Sempai Adina wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it."

I did. And it's still on my e-reader. I dared not delete it.


message 14: by Marialyce (new) - added it

Marialyce This one has been on my list for awhile. Glad to see that it is a good one.


Luffy Sempai Marialyce wrote: "This one has been on my list for awhile. Glad to see that it is a good one."

You would surely like it. It's very relatable.


message 16: by Liz (new)

Liz A friend was just telling me about Murakami's book of short stories yesterday. I need to check him out. Great review.


Luffy Sempai Liz wrote: "A friend was just telling me about Murakami's book of short stories yesterday. I need to check him out. Great review."

Thanks, Liz! Keeping fingers crossed for you.


message 18: by Ms. Smartarse (last edited Aug 21, 2018 05:50AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ms. Smartarse "The people who don't feel real, such as Midori, are still full of a palette of colours. She is a healthy caricature."

That's interesting! I've always felt that Naoko was the "unreal" one... at least from Watanabe's point of view. To me she seemed like those perfect goals one tries to achieve, but always falls just a bit short. Admittedly, my high-school self was always confused by her philosophical meanderings... which was when I first read the book.

Midori, on the other hand, with her more pragmatic interests, seemed much more grounded in reality. I could relate to her, despite personally having zero interest in cooking, and lucky enough to have healthy parents. Sure, she is whimsical, but I've always viewed that as an adorably clumsy character trait. Especially in the way she tries to flirt with Watanabe so bluntly. :)

"Murakami had always been a closed door for me. But if his other work is like this one, then I need a second crack at one of his other books."

The only other book similar to Norwegian Wood that comes to mind is South of the Border, West of the Sun. Most of his other work is closer to fantasy in genre, IMO. Not that I've read each and every one of his writing. This is especially true of his short stories, that tend to feel unfinished to me.
Incidentally, I'm enough of a snob to shelve them as 'magical-reality' rather than outright 'fantasy'. :P My personal favorite book of his, is Kafka on the Shore.

Oh, and just in case I went overboard with the nitpicking, please rest assured that I love your take on the book. ;)


Luffy Sempai Ms. Smartarse wrote: ""The people who don't feel real, such as Midori, are still full of a palette of colours. She is a healthy caricature."

That's interesting! I've always felt that Naoko was the "unreal" one... at le..."


That was a well thought out reply. To be honest whenever Midori opened her mouth to say something, I felt reinforced in my opinion of her. Who speaks like that? Naoko seemed angelic because she was a plot device, more so than most characters. Thanks for the compliment, Ms. Smartarse.


message 20: by Sarah (new)

Sarah I need to check out his stuff. I really want to read 1Q84 but the size intimidates me.


Luffy Sempai Sarah wrote: "I need to check out his stuff. I really want to read 1Q84 but the size intimidates me."

If you're ready to buddy read it with me, send me a PM. Otherwise, if you want to stay private, read it at your own pace. It's worth it.


message 22: by Ms. Smartarse (last edited Aug 21, 2018 06:28AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ms. Smartarse Luffy wrote: " Who speaks like that?"

I always figured that she was a socially awkward, yet incredibly courageous person. Something I wish I could have pulled off when I was her age. :P

Sarah wrote:"I really want to read 1Q84 but the size intimidates me."

Hah, you're not the only one. I'm a die-hard Murakami fan, and I'm also intimidated by it. Granted, my reticence stems from the reviews that claim the book gets worse as it progresses (excellent 1st volumne, OK 2nd volume, and mediocre 3rd volume).


Luffy Sempai Ms. Smartarse wrote: "(excellent 1st volumne, OK 2nd volume, and mediocre 3rd volume)...."

Yikes! I'll circle around his other work then. I respect popular opinion regarding chunky books.


message 24: by Em Lost In Books (last edited Aug 21, 2018 06:21AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Em Lost In Books Ms. Smartarse wrote: ""Midori, on the other hand, with her more pragmatic interests, seemed much more grounded in reality. I could relate to her, despite personally having zero interest in cooking, and lucky enough to have healthy parents. Sure, she is whimsical, but I've always viewed that as an adorably clumsy character trait. Especially in the way she tries to flirt with Watanabe so bluntly. :)..."

I concur. Naoko was just too gloomy, drowning in her own sorrow and not giving life a chance.

Am reading Kafka next month. (^.^)


message 25: by Ms. Smartarse (last edited Aug 21, 2018 06:31AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ms. Smartarse Luffy wrote: "Yikes! I'll circle around his other work then. I respect popular opinion regarding chunky books."

And now I feel guilty: turning you off, despite not having read it yet. >_< For the record, I do actually own 1Q84 in physical format, and intend to read it eventually.

Manju wrote: "Am reading Kafka next month. (^.^) "

Yay! *waves pompoms*


Luffy Sempai Ms. Smartarse wrote: "And now I feel guilty: turning you off, despite not having read it yet. >_< For the record, I do actually own 1Q84 in physical format, and intend to read it eventually...."

No, please don't feel guilty. I'll be enjoying reading anyway, regardless of the choices. It's okay to influence someone's reading. Really.


Em Lost In Books I have read 1Q84. it was good but nowhere near the brilliance of NW. lower down your expectations.


Luffy Sempai Manju wrote: "I have read 1Q84. it was good but nowhere near the brilliance of NW. lower down your expectations."

Yes ma'am. I've been trying to read a couple of 1000 paged books that I've not registered yet on GR. I'll think of 1Q84, after them.


message 29: by Olivia (new)

Olivia I have to try that soon, thank you.


Luffy Sempai Olivia wrote: "I have to try that soon, thank you."

I live to serve.


Em Lost In Books Luffy wrote: "Yes ma'am. I've been trying to read a couple of 1000 paged books that I've not reg..."

am not a strict teacher. :P


Luffy Sempai Manju wrote: "Luffy wrote: "Yes ma'am. I've been trying to read a couple of 1000 paged books that I've not reg..."

am not a strict teacher. :P"


XDD


Dominika I have mixed feelings about Murakami, but this was genuinely one of my favorites of his and the characters feel very grounded. I enjoyed this is a coming of age story, and while several people were annoyed at the upbruptness of the ending, I feel that it's reflective of life.


Luffy Sempai Dominika wrote: "I have mixed feelings about Murakami, but this was genuinely one of my favorites of his and the characters feel very grounded. I enjoyed this is a coming of age story, and while several people were..."

Well said Dominika. I liked this book for the exact same reasons as you portrayed.


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Luffy wrote: "Adina wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it."

I did. And it's still on my e-reader. I dared not delete it."
I keep all my read books on Kindle. Or i did, until I managed to block it and had to reset it to factory settings :((


Luffy Sempai Adina wrote: "Luffy wrote: "Adina wrote: "Glad you enjoyed it."

I did. And it's still on my e-reader. I dared not delete it." I keep all my read books on Kindle. Or i did, until I managed to block it and had to..."


That's a bummer. Hope you don't need more resetting.


AudioBookLover Great review! I just got the audiobook after reading this.


Kat Wonderful perspective and insights on this. You're absolutely right that he has a gift for "churning interesting words". There is often real poetic beauty to them. I'm glad your experience with the book was a more positive one than mine!


Luffy Sempai Kat wrote: "Wonderful perspective and insights on this. You're absolutely right that he has a gift for "churning interesting words". There is often real poetic beauty to them. I'm glad your experience with the..."

Thank you! The book was simply incompatible with your sensibilities as a reader. There's something about Murakami that's remote. That's why, despite liking this book, I didn't venture more into his other books. Though it's only a question of time and the right mood.


message 40: by Jessaka (new)

Jessaka Excellent review


Luffy Sempai Jessaka wrote: "Excellent review"

Thank you, Jessaka. The language here is pretentious, but I was in earnest naivity.


message 42: by Meghhnaa (new)

Meghhnaa  (On a Review-Writing Break!) Comparing Murakami's style to Dicken's! OMG, fantastic, to-the-point review, Luffy!


Luffy Sempai Meghna wrote: "Comparing Murakami's style to Dicken's! OMG, fantastic, to-the-point review, Luffy!"

I have some idea of NW, but I need to reread it. Thank you for the praise. It is well appreciated, believe me 🤍


message 44: by Franky (new)

Franky I'm a big fan of Murakami but this one I have yet to read. Thanks for the thoughtful review. The only one that was a miss in my opinion was 1Q84.


Luffy Sempai Franky wrote: "I'm a big fan of Murakami but this one I have yet to read. Thanks for the thoughtful review. The only one that was a miss in my opinion was 1Q84."

Thank you, Frank. I am saving his other books for later. I'd like to read them next year in festive moments, birthdays, New Year, etc etc. Murakami's books (even the bleakest ones) are sometimes Christmassy in their tone. Odd, I know.


message 46: by Franky (new)

Franky Luffy wrote: "Franky wrote: "I'm a big fan of Murakami but this one I have yet to read. Thanks for the thoughtful review. The only one that was a miss in my opinion was 1Q84."

Thank you, Frank. I am saving his ..."


No, that's funny you mention that. I was plowing through 1Q84 towards the end of December 2022 and right through New Year's Eve. I agree. There are books that are summer reads, fall reads, spring reasds, and there are books that are winter reads.


Luffy Sempai Franky wrote: "Luffy wrote: "Franky wrote: "I'm a big fan of Murakami but this one I have yet to read. Thanks for the thoughtful review. The only one that was a miss in my opinion was 1Q84."

Thank you, Frank. I ..."


:)


message 48: by Christina (new) - added it

Christina Splendid review, Luffy!


Barbara Beautiful review Luffy!


Lance Mellon Luffy great review dude. I loved the book (best of the 3 I've ready (Kafka, Wind up Bird) such a lyrical talented readable writer!


« previous 1
back to top