Petrik's Reviews > A Storm Of Swords
A Storm Of Swords (A Song of Ice and Fire, #3)
by
by

I have a Booktube channel now! Subscribe here:
An absolutely merciless and brilliant masterwork.
This was unbelievably amazing. A Storm of Swords could actually be the height of George R. R. Martin’s writing career. I know I haven’t read A Feast for Crows, A Dance with Dragons, or the extra books of the series yet. But realistically speaking, it would be bloody difficult for Martin to top what he has achieved in this book.
Picture: A Storm of Swords by Marc Simonetti

I’ll try to make this review shorter than usual, and I won’t be talking about the story at all to avoid spoilers. Seriously, you have to experience this for yourself. If you miraculously haven’t watched the TV series yet, A Storm of Swords encompassed seasons 3 and 4 of the TV series. I have known the main twists and turns of this volume due to watching the TV show first, but somehow this incredible novel was still able to fully capture my attention. It brings me to this point once again: I can’t even imagine how much I’ll love this traumatizing book IF I’ve read it without having watched the TV series adaptation.
This, of course, doesn’t mean that you should skip the TV series. Up to season 4, the TV series adaptation remains mostly loyal to the original material. Sure it’s not like the scene by scene adaptation portrayed in the first season anymore, but I do honestly think that there were some moments that the TV series did even better than the book, and vice versa. I totally loved what I’ve read so far in A Song of Ice and Fire; this novel, in particular, is currently my favorite within the series, and that’s saying a lot. From my experience reading the series, Martin’s prose during his battle scenes were great, but I personally feel there are other grimdark fantasy authors—like Joe Abercrombie, Jeff Salyards, and Steven Erikson—that writes superior battle scenes compared to Martin’s. The battle scenes were one factor where the TV show excelled. Also, I will never stop praising Peter Dinklage’s acting performance as Tyrion Lannister. I found that the acting exhibited by Peter Dinklage and many other actors/actresses in the TV show did sufficient justice to the superb characterizations that Martin gave to the characters of the series.
The main reasons why I loved reading the series is not because of the battle scenes, but for the terrific characterizations, intricate world-building, how Martin deftly set up each scene, and most of all, the immense strength in the unpredictability of the storyline; all proven clearly within this book. The myriad pivotal events that occurred in this single installment were simply insane and unforgettable. The Red Wedding, for example, is one of the most traumatizing events to ever transpired in a fantasy novel for me; it has pretty much become a standard of comparison for believable brutality and shocking scale in speculative fiction. “It wasn’t as crazy as The Red Wedding,� or “It was more traumatizing than The Red Wedding.� You probably have read or heard these phrases on reviews or on social media often—lately more so due to the super exposure caused by the TV shows; let me assure you that they’re there for many valid reasons.
At 424k words—it took me about 23 hours to read—in total, A Storm of Swords has become the third biggest novel I’ve read so far after The Stand by Stephen King and Oathbringer by Brandon Sanderson. It’s truly astounding that there were close to zero dull moments in a novel this massive; I didn’t really enjoy Bran’s storyline, but his appearances here were relatively small. Excluding Bran’s story, I was completely immersed, and I was in love with every page I read. Martin sang a song of violence, grief, and treachery with spellbinding impacts; the writing was thoroughly engaging, filled with a plethora of memorable passages, and the phrases were cleverly structured to be evocative.
Excluding the fame he gets from the TV series adaptation, if you’re ever in need of evident proofs on why George R. R. Martin has become one of the most legendary fantasy authors of our time, A Storm of Swords is the answer. The series indeed remains unfinished to this day, and there’s a chance it might not ever be finished, but I utterly believe that the series is worth your time despite that. The first three books—especially this one—in A Song of Ice and Fire provided an exceptional reading experience that epic fantasy readers should gain. I unquestionably loved A Storm of Swords. I'm giving this tome a full 5 stars rating, and I'm extremely confident it would've earned one of those ultra-rare 6 out of 5 stars rating from me if I'd read it without watching the TV series adaptation first. I expect I will end up loving A Storm of Swords more on future subsequent reread. This is truly a phenomenal magnum opus. Do yourself a favor. Read it, simple as that.
You can order the book from:
You can find and the rest of my reviews at
Special thanks to my Patrons on for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Alya, Annabeth, Blaise, Devin, Diana, Edward, Hamad, Helen, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Lufi, Michelle, Mike, Miracle, Nicholas, Zoe.
An absolutely merciless and brilliant masterwork.
This was unbelievably amazing. A Storm of Swords could actually be the height of George R. R. Martin’s writing career. I know I haven’t read A Feast for Crows, A Dance with Dragons, or the extra books of the series yet. But realistically speaking, it would be bloody difficult for Martin to top what he has achieved in this book.
Picture: A Storm of Swords by Marc Simonetti

I’ll try to make this review shorter than usual, and I won’t be talking about the story at all to avoid spoilers. Seriously, you have to experience this for yourself. If you miraculously haven’t watched the TV series yet, A Storm of Swords encompassed seasons 3 and 4 of the TV series. I have known the main twists and turns of this volume due to watching the TV show first, but somehow this incredible novel was still able to fully capture my attention. It brings me to this point once again: I can’t even imagine how much I’ll love this traumatizing book IF I’ve read it without having watched the TV series adaptation.
“Old stories are like old friends, she used to say. You have to visit them from time to time.�
This, of course, doesn’t mean that you should skip the TV series. Up to season 4, the TV series adaptation remains mostly loyal to the original material. Sure it’s not like the scene by scene adaptation portrayed in the first season anymore, but I do honestly think that there were some moments that the TV series did even better than the book, and vice versa. I totally loved what I’ve read so far in A Song of Ice and Fire; this novel, in particular, is currently my favorite within the series, and that’s saying a lot. From my experience reading the series, Martin’s prose during his battle scenes were great, but I personally feel there are other grimdark fantasy authors—like Joe Abercrombie, Jeff Salyards, and Steven Erikson—that writes superior battle scenes compared to Martin’s. The battle scenes were one factor where the TV show excelled. Also, I will never stop praising Peter Dinklage’s acting performance as Tyrion Lannister. I found that the acting exhibited by Peter Dinklage and many other actors/actresses in the TV show did sufficient justice to the superb characterizations that Martin gave to the characters of the series.
“Rhaegar fought valiantly, Rhaegar fought nobly, Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaegar died.�
The main reasons why I loved reading the series is not because of the battle scenes, but for the terrific characterizations, intricate world-building, how Martin deftly set up each scene, and most of all, the immense strength in the unpredictability of the storyline; all proven clearly within this book. The myriad pivotal events that occurred in this single installment were simply insane and unforgettable. The Red Wedding, for example, is one of the most traumatizing events to ever transpired in a fantasy novel for me; it has pretty much become a standard of comparison for believable brutality and shocking scale in speculative fiction. “It wasn’t as crazy as The Red Wedding,� or “It was more traumatizing than The Red Wedding.� You probably have read or heard these phrases on reviews or on social media often—lately more so due to the super exposure caused by the TV shows; let me assure you that they’re there for many valid reasons.
“It all goes back and back," Tyrion thought, "to our mothers and fathers and theirs before them. We are puppets dancing on the strings of those who came before us, and one day our own children will take up our strings and dance in our steads.�
At 424k words—it took me about 23 hours to read—in total, A Storm of Swords has become the third biggest novel I’ve read so far after The Stand by Stephen King and Oathbringer by Brandon Sanderson. It’s truly astounding that there were close to zero dull moments in a novel this massive; I didn’t really enjoy Bran’s storyline, but his appearances here were relatively small. Excluding Bran’s story, I was completely immersed, and I was in love with every page I read. Martin sang a song of violence, grief, and treachery with spellbinding impacts; the writing was thoroughly engaging, filled with a plethora of memorable passages, and the phrases were cleverly structured to be evocative.
“The greatest fools are ofttimes more clever than the men who laugh at them.�
Excluding the fame he gets from the TV series adaptation, if you’re ever in need of evident proofs on why George R. R. Martin has become one of the most legendary fantasy authors of our time, A Storm of Swords is the answer. The series indeed remains unfinished to this day, and there’s a chance it might not ever be finished, but I utterly believe that the series is worth your time despite that. The first three books—especially this one—in A Song of Ice and Fire provided an exceptional reading experience that epic fantasy readers should gain. I unquestionably loved A Storm of Swords. I'm giving this tome a full 5 stars rating, and I'm extremely confident it would've earned one of those ultra-rare 6 out of 5 stars rating from me if I'd read it without watching the TV series adaptation first. I expect I will end up loving A Storm of Swords more on future subsequent reread. This is truly a phenomenal magnum opus. Do yourself a favor. Read it, simple as that.
You can order the book from:
You can find and the rest of my reviews at
Special thanks to my Patrons on for giving me extra support towards my passion for reading and reviewing!
My Patrons: Alfred, Alya, Annabeth, Blaise, Devin, Diana, Edward, Hamad, Helen, Jimmy Nutts, Joie, Lufi, Michelle, Mike, Miracle, Nicholas, Zoe.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
A Storm Of Swords.
Sign In »
Quotes Petrik Liked

“Old stories are like old friends, she used to say. You have to visit them from time to time.”
― A Storm of Swords
― A Storm of Swords

“Rhaegar fought valiantly, Rhaegar fought nobly, Rhaegar fought honorably. And Rhaegar died.”
― A Storm of Swords
― A Storm of Swords

“It all goes back and back," Tyrion thought, "to our mothers and fathers and theirs before them. We are puppets dancing on the strings of those who came before us, and one day our own children will take up our strings and dance in our steads.”
― A Storm of Swords
― A Storm of Swords
Reading Progress
August 13, 2018
– Shelved
January 24, 2019
–
Started Reading
January 29, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)
message 1:
by
Trent
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 29, 2019 04:26AM

reply
|
flag

It was just insanely good, Trent. Add the fact that this book was released almost 20 years ago amazed me even more. I will read the next two as well, but I'm taking a break from the main series for a while right now. This was massive and as much as I loved it, I'm in need for a shorter read for a while. xD

Just curious- what books have received this magical 6/5 rating?


Just curious- what books have received this magical 6/5 rating?"
Thank you, Michael. I strongly urge you to continue to this installment! :)
I have ten books so far that I'll rate 6/5 stars:
-The Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson (all 3 books available so far)
-Wrath by John Gwynne
-The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss
-Blood Song by Anthony Ryan
-Assassin's Fate by Robin Hobb
-Memories of Ice, The Bonehunters, The Crippled God by Steven Erikson.
and I'm sure this book IF I didn't watch the TV show first.

Thank you, Alex! It definitely has become one of my favorite of all time too! Could've been even more I think if I haven't watched the TV series before I read this one. I will read the next two books too, but I think I'll read A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms first. Need to take a break from the main series for now :)

But fab review Petrik. Your reviews are definitely one of the deciding factors when i'm looking to purchase a book.
Well done!!!


Thank you, Sade! Hey, finding out the differences between the TV series and the original material, along with refreshing my memory in preparation for the final season of the TV show, are actually my reason for finally reading this series. I think it's worth it though, you should give it a go! ASoS have some differences with the TV adaptation, but still tolerable. It seems like book 4 and 5 is where the TV show starts to deviates a lot. :D

Thank you, Mark! After researching and talking to some friends upon finishing this book, it seems like a lot of the fans also agreed that ASoS is Martin's best work. I heard a lot of mixed things about the fourth book, but I will still continue; just not anytime soon! :)


That's an interesting take, Ahmed. I hope I'll feel the same about the fourth and fifth book like you! Haha the excitement over The Winds of Winter has been unreal for several years now isn't it? Let's hope Martin can write a book that lives up to the immense expectation! :D



Not surprised! It kinda made me wish I haven't watched the TV show so I can experience this book in its full glory. To be fair though, the TV show did a phenomenal job on adapting this book imo; even though there were changes done. (view spoiler)

I agree! Btw, "Might...?" You HAVE to reread the whole series when The Winds of Winter comes out, Iryan! 7 years is a long time hahaha. I mean, let's say The Winds of Winter comes out in 2021, I seriously might reread the series again.

I totally understand that, Umairah. Having known the main plot from the TV series did some of the intensity that could've been heightened if we didn't know about the story; this makes the book feels longer than it should be imo; even when they're actually really massive xD

wait, 2021? It used to be 2020 a couple of months ago. Oh, brother!

I'll definitely keep it in mind. Good to know the book more than holds up.


2021 is just my assumption. Isn't it cool, 10 years after the release A Dance with Dragons? xD

I'll definitely keep it in mind. Good to know the book more than holds up."
Awesome! :)

Yeah, right now it's my favorite in the series and seems like it will stay that way! :)

Thank you, Gavin! I agree with you. I found myself completely amazed by what Martin has created with the series (up to the third book) really. Hahaha as long that he doesn't pull the infamous Queen of Fire (which I'm still not brave enough to read) I should be okay with it! :D

From my experience until book 3, yes! To be honest though, I don't have a problem with author taking years to finish a book. It may be incomplete right now, it may never be completed, but as long that I know they're working on it, I really don't mind reading an incomplete series. ASOIAF is a special case, it's incomplete and has sparked a lot of new readers into reading or accepting fantasy, I think that's something much more important. Of course a completed series is much more preferable, but if I follow that kind of thinking, I won't be reading The Stormlight Archive for 25 more years and that's just insane... xD


I totally understand that! I love binge reading a series; I get so much more out of the series that way. For an incomplete series, I usually reread the series from start again when the last book comes out. It takes time, but oh well... what can be done? xD


Thank you, Lynn! Haha I don't know when I'll continue to A Feast for Crows! Four years is crazy though xD I hope I don't end up in the same predicament as you. I did however hear a lot of mixed things about the fourth book! I'm curious to find out how I'll feel about it myself! :D


Thanks, Nick! Same here. I'm glad you loved it too! :)

Thank you so much, Colleen! Yes, I highly enjoyed this series so far! I heard mixed things about book 4 and 5 so we'll see how I feel about it later; dunno when I'll get to it though. The actors and actresses really did a phenomenal job on the TV show imo, but Peter Dinklage is hands down the best one of them all :D


Thank you, my friend! Hahah I can totally see why now. Well, I hope that Feast will enjoyable to dine for me! xD


Right!? Haha thank you, Lynn! I hope so too! That's what I heard from everyone really. I guess knowing the structure of the story allows me to be prepared when I get to it! :)
I hope you can finish AFfC so you can get to Dance with Dragons soon. Good luck!

Thanks! I've been mentally prepping myself to jump back in soon. Fingers crossed I can make it lol


Yeah... I've read all of the books in ASoIaF, and Martin never reached what he achieved here again. Unfortunate, really. 😅

thanks, Griffin! It's such an incredible book. I actually want to reread it again! 🤩