Muphyn's Reviews > March
March
by
by

Well.. I finished the audiobook last night and I must say that I really did enjoy listening to the narrator's voice - it was really nice and warm. But the book itself..
I think Brooks' writing style is fabulous, I really enjoyed that. The beginning of the book was relatively gripping, but I got increasingly irritated with the main character March. For one he remained the very naive yet proud dreamer throughout the entire book, and while I found it endearing at first, he did not develop as a character and remained stuck in his role as a naive abolitionist of slavery.
I found the last few chapters particularly exasperating, March feeling excessively guilty over what happened during the war. He just seemed pathetic to me - I so wanted him to grow and be a man.. I found the end disappointing, almost as if Brooks couldn't be bothered to find a way to redeem March (though perhaps that was never her intention - it's just that I would have liked to see March's pride broken one way or another).
Some other reviewers have commented how Brooks seemed to have completely missed Marmee's character - I couldn't agree more. I found Brooks' Marmee totally out of character as originally created by Alcott, and cannot say I liked her at all.
If you didn't know Alcott's "Little Women", perhaps it wouldn't matter too much and be quite enjoyable. All in all it was just OK for me.
I think Brooks' writing style is fabulous, I really enjoyed that. The beginning of the book was relatively gripping, but I got increasingly irritated with the main character March. For one he remained the very naive yet proud dreamer throughout the entire book, and while I found it endearing at first, he did not develop as a character and remained stuck in his role as a naive abolitionist of slavery.
I found the last few chapters particularly exasperating, March feeling excessively guilty over what happened during the war. He just seemed pathetic to me - I so wanted him to grow and be a man.. I found the end disappointing, almost as if Brooks couldn't be bothered to find a way to redeem March (though perhaps that was never her intention - it's just that I would have liked to see March's pride broken one way or another).
Some other reviewers have commented how Brooks seemed to have completely missed Marmee's character - I couldn't agree more. I found Brooks' Marmee totally out of character as originally created by Alcott, and cannot say I liked her at all.
If you didn't know Alcott's "Little Women", perhaps it wouldn't matter too much and be quite enjoyable. All in all it was just OK for me.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
March.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 19, 2008
– Shelved
July 9, 2008
– Shelved as:
audiobook
Started Reading
July 10, 2008
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
July 10, 2008
–
Finished Reading
October 13, 2008
– Shelved as:
fiction
April 6, 2012
– Shelved as:
usa
Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Miss Bookiverse
(new)
Jul 05, 2008 07:28AM

reply
|
flag

March ist der Vater von Little Women. sozusagen sein teil der geschichte.

das ist ja kein spin-off - nicht so wirklich sein teil der geschichte, dann aber wieder doch.. eigentlich auch wirklich ganz interessant (jedenfalls als audiobook, weiss nich ob ich beim lesen durchstehen wuerde), wenn der mensch nur nich soooo anstrengend and teilweise nervtoetend waere.. :( so geschichtsmaessig find ich's echt interessant (amerikanischer buergerkrieg und sklavenabschaffung usw.) aber der march-mensch...