Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

William2's Reviews > The Confessions

The Confessions by Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4684009
's review

bookshelves: 18-ce, autobiography, france, translation, to-read

I would never have read The Confessions had it not been for the admiration W.G. Sebald expresses for the man and his works in his A Place in the Country. The writing here is lucid, often floridly emotional, but it’s the density of Rousseau’s memory that astonishes. His focus on a single incident or individual is uncanny; his retrospective interpretations can go on for pages. And this was a man with substantial social deficits. In Book Three, it becomes clear that the author suffered from something like autism, for he had limited social capacities, and admits that he was little more than a fool in social settings. It was only in retrospect that he could review his knowledge and come to conclusions—and write.

The piety becomes annoying, all the discussion of great fathers of the Church who, let’s face it, were just as pederastic then as they are today. Human nature hasn’t changed. Rousseau even has a story about a priest picking him up for sex one night during a bout of homelessness in his late teens. The view one gets of society at this time, too, is a contrast of extremes. Pre-industrial revolution, there’s the unspoiled landscape which at this remove seems almost unimaginable. Contrast that though with the primitive medicine—not much more than herbs for illnesses, the brevity of life, the impenetrable Ignorance of the people, the extractive business practices, zero public education. It would not be a stretch to read The Confessions purely as an historical dystopia.

Despite his aforementioned social incapacities, Rousseau was paradoxically highly social, or would “high functioning� be the more accurate term? Since he knows Italian he undertakes the position of secretary to the French ambassador in Venice; this during the War of the Austrian Succession as Prince Lobkowitz is marching on Naples. His devotion to his duty is impeccable, while the ambassador himself concerns himself primarily with whoring. The Venice chapter is a classic story of working under incompetent leadership all too familiar to those who have experience working in either military or corporate settings. One’s heart goes out to Rousseau when he recounts how he was so basely insulted by his superior.

I must finish...
85 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Confessions.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 15, 2018 – Shelved
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: 18-ce
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: translation
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: france
August 15, 2018 – Shelved as: autobiography
August 21, 2018 –
page 123
20.23%
September 8, 2018 –
page 303
49.84%
September 9, 2018 –
page 309
50.82%
March 13, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ryan (new)

Ryan That's well said! You really hit the mark with 'social deficits'. That reminds me of a quote from "The Red and the Black", whose protagonist—irony and plot context notwithstanding—shoots a delightful barb his way: "But even as [Rousseau] argues for a republic, and the overthrow of monarchical ranks and
stations, this upstart is absolutely drunk with joy if a duke condescends to alter his afterdinner walk so he can accompany one of his friends."


message 2: by P.E. (new)

P.E. Happy with these first thoughts on a thinker that divisive in Europe!


message 3: by William2 (new) - added it

William2 Yes, Ryan, and he’s completely ruthless about his stupidities, too. He knew himself rather well, but I wonder if he thought of himself as pathological.


message 4: by William2 (new) - added it

William2 A new can of worms for me, P.E. :-)


message 5: by Majdouline (new)

Majdouline Hi William, first of all I have to say that I am delighted to see an American reading so much French authors.Your point about Rousseau being an authist surprised me as I never come across such a description of him and made me tried to recall what I ve read from him. As his mother lost her life while giving birth to him, he is been known to have a big survivor guild complex. Hes has been controversed mainly because of his book " Emile" where he gives guidance on how to educate a child, knowing that he puts his children in an orphanage. In France he is more known as a philosophe, great inspiration for the Revolution with " Le contrat social" and his view on property being a sin. I have not read " Les Confessions" which is not considered as one of his major piece but was mainly just viewed as one of the first autobiography written ( at least in Europe) and published after his death. At least this is what our teacher told us in high school back in the days.. Anyway you really intrigued me with your analyse and I feel like picking up this book this year. Thank you :)


message 6: by William2 (new) - added it

William2 Thank you, Majdouline. Very thoughtful.


Simen Strand-Pedersen Great review of The Confessions! Its very interesting to see 17th century France as a Dystopia lacking Education and basic Freedom, but at the same time having more considerate social manners and profoundly more natural beauty than in our own Industrial Era. I do have to disagree with the argument made for Jean-Jacques Autism though. Is it only in Book 3 or is it consistent throughout all the books? He is, as you said, highly functional in social and societal settings, but also tend to be introspective and clumsy at times. He also have long periods, where he goes deeply into his own interest for weeks and months at a time; the writing of Plays and the study of Botanics. This could make an argument for autistic tendencies in Jean Jacques as you suggest. I think you should have to conclude with the fact that he is too functional and too much aware of his inconsistencies as a social being (even in retrospect) to be showing traits of Aspberger or any other form of Authism. Just because someone is akward and bewildered in conversation does`nt make them abnormal or having mental illnesses. You can however make the argument that its natural to be showing partly "autistic" traits in some difficult interaction or setting? It`s an interesting idea to consider Jean-Jacques as a slightly autistic person, that he is a 17th Century; Greta Thunberg, who actualy have Aspberger, and is sort of a Reformer in Govermental Policy as Rousseau. I need more evidence to support the argument, even in a GR review. Love to hear your thoughts on this.


message 8: by William2 (new) - added it

William2 These are terrific comments, Simen. Thank you for sharing them. Sorry it took me a year to acknowledge you. Many thanks. Be well.


back to top