ŷ

Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's Reviews > Crime and Punishment

Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
70395042
's review

it was amazing
Read 2 times. Last read July 1, 1968 to August 15, 1968.

If you’ve ever committed an unjust act, as Raskolnikov does, you know now it would have been better right at the outset to confess your injustice and seek the absolution of clemency.

For if you neglected to come clean you were probably racked with ruin within, and “delivered to the bondsman� of tortuous guilt. It happened to Raskolnikov, and it happened to me.

Each one of us is a Raskolnikov, you know.

No, not like you’re thinking - not a shabbily-dressed, impoverished murderer. But we all share his nature. To a T.

That, in essence, is the key to understanding Dostoevsky’s tortuous, convoluted, anxious prose - it’s the one message that Fyodor Dostoevsky takes anguished pains to drum into our insulated and isolated little heads!

Not that, hey, Raskolnikov’s not such a bad guy after all... no - it’s that he is inwardly bad and so are we, potentially at every moment, bad inside - and that that that will never change.

We don’t change our inner lives; but we CAN constantly be making amends for our mistakes - and starting our life anew in others� eyes at each moment, though never perhaps to our own complete inner satisfaction.

For our selves aren’t static and we all invariably tend towards moral entropy.

There are no easy answers in Dostoevsky!

I remember so well the time I finally quit smoking - cold turkey, 22 years ago. I was lucky I did it, I guess; but to face the indefinitely long rest of my life - stretching out before me like a vast restless desert - without smokes, seemed unbearable back then!

It was just like the Zen Master says - reaching the top of a thousand-foot pole, and then, CONTINUING TO CLIMB. In empty air. Yikes!

Panic City! The flames of utter hopeless anxiety threatened to engulf me entirely.

So I started to pray. Nonstop. Like a dog chewing a meatless bone! It must have worked... so saith the Preacher.

And I escaped from that Inferno by the very Skin of my Teeth.

So likewise, there are few pat answers in Faith, no matter what we’ve seen or heard: “Ours is only the trying,� Eliot said. Trying to make the best of a mess!

And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if C.S. Lewis is right, and there remain plenty of challenges in Heaven.

So, there is no finality in this life, Dostoevsky is saying. We can’t rest on our laurels.

Or our guilt, either, for that matter!

The best way I can sum up my thoughts on this Everest of a novel is by quoting W.H. Auden:

“Faith, while it condemns no temperament as incapable of salvation, flatters none as being less in peril than any other... Christianity is a way, not a state, and a Christian is never something one IS, only something we can pray to BECOME.�

And if Raskolnikov is not a Christian, neither are we.

But we must never give up the trying, just like Raskolnikov...

And for us, too, in time there may come Redemption.

And a Peace that passes all understanding, after the intolerable Shirt of Flame is extinguished, in

A condition of complete simplicity
Costing not less than EVERYTHING.
777 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Crime and Punishment.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
July 1, 1968 – Started Reading
August 15, 1968 – Finished Reading
October 13, 2018 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-50 of 94 (94 new)


Jill Hutchinson Interesting review, Fergus.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Jill. A bit strongly worded, perhaps, for a secular time like ours, but so many great writers think that such indeed was Dostoevsky’s real intention.


Alan I may have told you I read Dostoevsky's erly letters in Russian, and in his military HS or "college" he received worse grades in Russian or composition than in Military Science (maybe math and artillery, as it was for Napoleon, who excelled at it in Sardinia I think).


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs I guess like so many of us he chose to go his own stubborn way early in life, and continually swam against the tide! But that’s the price we pay to become human - in contradistinction to this modern robotic world of yes-men. And authentic humans always have trouble with the rudiments that are so easily drummed into compliant kids� heads!


Caterina Interesting take on one of my favorite novels, Fergus! I’m not sure I agree that we don’t change our lives, but definitely agree we don’t get to escape our natures. In light of your review, didn’t you love the relationship between R and his sister Dunya? She seemed like R with the addition of maturity and good sense... almost a perfect person. But wait � she, too, had her temptations and failings ...


P.E. Thanks for this keen review, Fergus.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Caterina and PE! Yeah, obviously I should have said INNER nature! I’ll read it through again and see if it makes more sense that way. In light of that, we really can’t KNOW Dunya’s - or even anyone else’s inner nature, however obvious it may appear to us that that Dunya, or someone we know, has indeed changed her or his life.


message 8: by Laura (new)

Laura That's so true. We never really know for sure anyone's true nature.


ALLEN Powerful review, Fergus!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Laura, and thanks, Allen old friend. This past weekend I was awakened VERY early in the morning and couldn’t fall asleep again. I read a bit, then put this review together on a whim, never guessing it would strike a chord in others!


ALLEN Once in a while I write such an "insomniac's delight" and it takes off. Can't count on that happening all the time, but isn't it fun?


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs You betcha! Thanks again.


message 13: by ALLEN (last edited Oct 15, 2018 04:19PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

ALLEN Fergus wrote: "You betcha! Thanks again."

Oh, man, I owe thanks to you for the joy of such a well-written review.
I am so happy we're GR friends.


message 15: by Nat (new)

Nat K Fab review Fergus! What I found tortuous about this story is that each character seemed to have numerous "pet" names. I simply couldn't keep up.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs And, you’re right, that’s a real obstacle to getting to the kernel of so awesome a literary landmark! But that at least accentuates its inherent inner tension for us non-Russians.


message 17: by ALLEN (last edited Oct 16, 2018 11:09AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

ALLEN Some editions of the longest and best-known Russian classics will post a genealogy chart in the book. Some that are even more obliging will give pet names, explaining how Katarina Terenkova Maximovich (my fictional name) might be Madame Maximovich in society, "Tessie" to her husband, Katya to school chums and Kitty to her sisters and immediate family.

Patient rummaging around the Internet is likely to yield such information for free regarding the REALLY big big Russian novels, like this one. I do not know about worthies like THE IDIOT, but it's always worth a try.

Remember that we do it in a way: C. Wright Mills was "Chuck" to friends.

"Her name was McGill, and she called herself Lil, but everyone knew her as Nancy."
- The Beatles, "Rocky Raccoon."


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Allen! You, like me, can probably remember the early translations of such classics by Constance Garnett - they seemed to always include such reading aids.


message 19: by Nat (new)

Nat K ALLEN wrote: "Some editions of the longest and best-known Russian classics will post a genealogy chart in the book. Some that are even more obliging will give pet names, explaining how Katarina Terenkova Maximov..."

Alas Allen, my book didn't have a genealogy tree with the "pet" names. It would have been so helpful! That's where this book fell down for me, I couldn't keep up. Otherwise, it would have been brilliant. Fab reference to Rocky Raccoon, I haven't thought of that song in years 😍


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Yeah, I meant to say that - when the White Album came out, I couldn’t stop thinking how funny Rocky Raccoon was! Great to be reminded.


Karina Can't wait to read this one!!! Dostoyevsky is a favorite of mine. Brothers Karamazov (misspelled?) did it for me.. he is amazing!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Love your enthusiasm, Karina! There is certainly a lot that is challenging in his writing, but it’s endlessly rewarding. Good luck!


message 23: by da (new) - rated it 5 stars

da AL absolutely wonderfully said, Fergus -- bravo!! -- indeed, the best yet most difficult books to write & read are those with nuanced characters, the ones who teach us that we're all capable of great evil as well as good. I found Lolita to be such a book, especially the audio version read by Jeremy Irons -- I've never entertained such thoughts, yet Nabokov (& his under-appreciated wife for her contributions to his writing) made me understand at least in part...


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, da! Nabokov always seemed a bit too much for me - but doesn’t Dostoyevsky venture into deep waters as well? Yes, I see the parallel! Thanks.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader One of the best of the classics and a worthy review, Fergus!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thank you so much, Jennifer!


message 27: by Kay (new) - added it

Kay Wonderful review, Fergus. You're churning out excellent reviews like a pro!


message 28: by Cynthia (new)

Cynthia  Scott Inspiring review. Thank you


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, ladies! And Jen, I write my reviews as a sorta tribute to my late Mom, a librarian. Every night she used to read reviews to prepare for the next day as the Chief Librarian!


message 30: by da (new) - rated it 5 stars

da AL thoughtful & well done


message 31: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Much food for thought in your review, Fergus. Great point about not resting on our laurels or on our guilt. Hence, like Iris Murdoch said, “The way is always forward, never back.� I’m also reminded of Tennyson’s lines: “More things are wrought by prayer than this world dreams of.� Thank you, Fergus, for sharing this thoughtful review.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much to both of you! And Laysee, Iris Murdoch’s adage needs to be inscribed in our hearts! Wow.


Henry Wonderful review of one of the greatest of all novels.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Henry! My parents drove me 150 miles to register for university, 51 years ago... I was so taken by this book during the trip that most of the talking during the journey was done by them. Inexcusable, of course - but it nevertheless shows the novel’s compelling power!


message 35: by Tg (new)

Tg Nice Review----"If a man constantly aspires, is he not elevated ? '" Thoreau

"From exertion come Wisdom and Purity, the petty fears, and the petty pleasures are but the shadow of reality" Thoreau


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Those are such remarkable quotes, Tg. So amazing to have two giants like Thoreau and Emerson, not only living in the same time and town, but once good friends. And the one so practical, the other so elevated!


message 37: by Erin (new)

Erin Clemence Fergus, good on you, mate! Taking this on is quite a challenge, as rewarding as it may be. I am still too intimidated to give this one a shot. :S


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Erin, it’s not long, and it will buoy you effortlessly but anxiously to the denouement we ALL hope for! I read it in an afternoon (albeit back in my teen years when my eyes were OK!)... try it.


message 39: by Zoeb (new) - added it

Zoeb Thoughtful review...compels us to question our basic nature. Suitable for a meditative novel as this.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Zoeb, I remember a story from long ago about a princess upon a thick mattress. She couldn’t sleep, as a tiny uncooked pea was hidden in the centre, underneath. We do like her and pile layer upon
Layer of mattresses until our irritation stops. Well, Dostoevsky says that irritation is primordial guilt! ...much to think about indeed.


Josephine Briggs I read this book when I was a teenager. Impressive book. I have read another of his books about the same time. I did smoke when I was a teenager, but had to quit. It is a bad habit, also expensive.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Dostoevsky is impressive indeed, and shows us the sharply introspective insight an anxious mind is capable of under duress!


Josephine Briggs This is an exceptional book. I read it when I was quite young and have never forgotten about it. It stays with you. Good reading Fergus. Makes readers think.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Josephine! I think we’re ALL little oysters working out grains of sand - and sometimes turning them into Pearls. Raskolnikov’s crime is Dostoevsky’s raw material, and another grain of sand we all must deal with as we look for that Pearl!


Josephine Briggs These books remind me so much of high school and college reading. "Crime and Punishment" is such strong reading, it is unforgettable. I'm happy to see that is still popular among people who want to read it, not just made to. It is a wonderful read.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs It really hits you, doesn’t it? Maybe it’s because, being grown up, answers no longer come so easily. That’s how I feel inside!


message 47: by Laura (new)

Laura There are no easy answers Fergus. I agree.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs So true, Laura - but simple love can still work miracles! It shows us to look for no other answer beyond it. But our minds just chatter on and we get lost again...


message 49: by Laura (new)

Laura Love is the answer to all questions as is living any way you can. Incessant mind chatter is a recurring theme for me too.


message 50: by Zoeb (new) - added it

Zoeb I have to say it, my friend, that this review touched and stirred me in a way that I cannot explain. 'Crime And Punishment' now stands awaiting my avid interest and attention at the earliest notice and I intend to buy one of those old, bulky, yellowing copies to weigh the wood of my bookshelf properly. And all those wonderful and eye-opening things you said about faith and trying to atone for our sins, they are all true to the word.


« previous 1
back to top