Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's Reviews > Crime and Punishment
Crime and Punishment
by
by

Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's review
Oct 13, 2018
Read 2 times. Last read July 1, 1968 to August 15, 1968.
If you’ve ever committed an unjust act, as Raskolnikov does, you know now it would have been better right at the outset to confess your injustice and seek the absolution of clemency.
For if you neglected to come clean you were probably racked with ruin within, and “delivered to the bondsman� of tortuous guilt. It happened to Raskolnikov, and it happened to me.
Each one of us is a Raskolnikov, you know.
No, not like you’re thinking - not a shabbily-dressed, impoverished murderer. But we all share his nature. To a T.
That, in essence, is the key to understanding Dostoevsky’s tortuous, convoluted, anxious prose - it’s the one message that Fyodor Dostoevsky takes anguished pains to drum into our insulated and isolated little heads!
Not that, hey, Raskolnikov’s not such a bad guy after all... no - it’s that he is inwardly bad and so are we, potentially at every moment, bad inside - and that that that will never change.
We don’t change our inner lives; but we CAN constantly be making amends for our mistakes - and starting our life anew in others� eyes at each moment, though never perhaps to our own complete inner satisfaction.
For our selves aren’t static and we all invariably tend towards moral entropy.
There are no easy answers in Dostoevsky!
I remember so well the time I finally quit smoking - cold turkey, 22 years ago. I was lucky I did it, I guess; but to face the indefinitely long rest of my life - stretching out before me like a vast restless desert - without smokes, seemed unbearable back then!
It was just like the Zen Master says - reaching the top of a thousand-foot pole, and then, CONTINUING TO CLIMB. In empty air. Yikes!
Panic City! The flames of utter hopeless anxiety threatened to engulf me entirely.
So I started to pray. Nonstop. Like a dog chewing a meatless bone! It must have worked... so saith the Preacher.
And I escaped from that Inferno by the very Skin of my Teeth.
So likewise, there are few pat answers in Faith, no matter what we’ve seen or heard: “Ours is only the trying,� Eliot said. Trying to make the best of a mess!
And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if C.S. Lewis is right, and there remain plenty of challenges in Heaven.
So, there is no finality in this life, Dostoevsky is saying. We can’t rest on our laurels.
Or our guilt, either, for that matter!
The best way I can sum up my thoughts on this Everest of a novel is by quoting W.H. Auden:
“Faith, while it condemns no temperament as incapable of salvation, flatters none as being less in peril than any other... Christianity is a way, not a state, and a Christian is never something one IS, only something we can pray to BECOME.�
And if Raskolnikov is not a Christian, neither are we.
But we must never give up the trying, just like Raskolnikov...
And for us, too, in time there may come Redemption.
And a Peace that passes all understanding, after the intolerable Shirt of Flame is extinguished, in
A condition of complete simplicity
Costing not less than EVERYTHING.
For if you neglected to come clean you were probably racked with ruin within, and “delivered to the bondsman� of tortuous guilt. It happened to Raskolnikov, and it happened to me.
Each one of us is a Raskolnikov, you know.
No, not like you’re thinking - not a shabbily-dressed, impoverished murderer. But we all share his nature. To a T.
That, in essence, is the key to understanding Dostoevsky’s tortuous, convoluted, anxious prose - it’s the one message that Fyodor Dostoevsky takes anguished pains to drum into our insulated and isolated little heads!
Not that, hey, Raskolnikov’s not such a bad guy after all... no - it’s that he is inwardly bad and so are we, potentially at every moment, bad inside - and that that that will never change.
We don’t change our inner lives; but we CAN constantly be making amends for our mistakes - and starting our life anew in others� eyes at each moment, though never perhaps to our own complete inner satisfaction.
For our selves aren’t static and we all invariably tend towards moral entropy.
There are no easy answers in Dostoevsky!
I remember so well the time I finally quit smoking - cold turkey, 22 years ago. I was lucky I did it, I guess; but to face the indefinitely long rest of my life - stretching out before me like a vast restless desert - without smokes, seemed unbearable back then!
It was just like the Zen Master says - reaching the top of a thousand-foot pole, and then, CONTINUING TO CLIMB. In empty air. Yikes!
Panic City! The flames of utter hopeless anxiety threatened to engulf me entirely.
So I started to pray. Nonstop. Like a dog chewing a meatless bone! It must have worked... so saith the Preacher.
And I escaped from that Inferno by the very Skin of my Teeth.
So likewise, there are few pat answers in Faith, no matter what we’ve seen or heard: “Ours is only the trying,� Eliot said. Trying to make the best of a mess!
And I wouldn’t be at all surprised if C.S. Lewis is right, and there remain plenty of challenges in Heaven.
So, there is no finality in this life, Dostoevsky is saying. We can’t rest on our laurels.
Or our guilt, either, for that matter!
The best way I can sum up my thoughts on this Everest of a novel is by quoting W.H. Auden:
“Faith, while it condemns no temperament as incapable of salvation, flatters none as being less in peril than any other... Christianity is a way, not a state, and a Christian is never something one IS, only something we can pray to BECOME.�
And if Raskolnikov is not a Christian, neither are we.
But we must never give up the trying, just like Raskolnikov...
And for us, too, in time there may come Redemption.
And a Peace that passes all understanding, after the intolerable Shirt of Flame is extinguished, in
A condition of complete simplicity
Costing not less than EVERYTHING.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Crime and Punishment.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
July 1, 1968
–
Started Reading
August 15, 1968
–
Finished Reading
October 13, 2018
– Shelved
Comments Showing 1-50 of 94 (94 new)
message 1:
by
Jill
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Oct 13, 2018 07:22AM

reply
|
flag








Oh, man, I owe thanks to you for the joy of such a well-written review.
I am so happy we're GR friends.



Patient rummaging around the Internet is likely to yield such information for free regarding the REALLY big big Russian novels, like this one. I do not know about worthies like THE IDIOT, but it's always worth a try.
Remember that we do it in a way: C. Wright Mills was "Chuck" to friends.
"Her name was McGill, and she called herself Lil, but everyone knew her as Nancy."
- The Beatles, "Rocky Raccoon."


Alas Allen, my book didn't have a genealogy tree with the "pet" names. It would have been so helpful! That's where this book fell down for me, I couldn't keep up. Otherwise, it would have been brilliant. Fab reference to Rocky Raccoon, I haven't thought of that song in years 😍










"From exertion come Wisdom and Purity, the petty fears, and the petty pleasures are but the shadow of reality" Thoreau





Layer of mattresses until our irritation stops. Well, Dostoevsky says that irritation is primordial guilt! ...much to think about indeed.








