Yun's Reviews > The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle
The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle
by
by

I'm always up for a good, mind-bending story, something unique and complex I can just sink my teeth into. But even though I enjoyed The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle, I actually found it a bit too complicated, which is something I never thought I'd say.
Evelyn Hardcastle will die at 11pm. Aiden Bishop has eight chances to relive the same day, inhabiting a different body each time, to discover who kills her. Only then will he be set free. He has many enemies working against him and also some who claim to be his allies, but who can he really trust? Such is the premise of this story, and it is an intriguing one.
There was so much I liked about this book. The plot is unique, fresh, and interesting. The writing is believable and riveting, and you can tell the author went to great lengths to keep track of everything so that he can correctly weave it all together. And the mystery itself is multi-layered; the more we discover, the more we realize is still hidden beneath the surface.
Yet, this is a case where the story's complexity is a bit too much and works against itself. It was really hard to keep track of everyone and to understand all that is going on. You really have to pay a lot of attention while reading not to feel lost. This was especially so in the first half of the book while we are getting to know all the characters.
The complexity also made revealing the solution in the end confusing, since it wasn't straightforward. Rather, more and more are added to the mystery while bits of it are solved. Even now that I have finished the book, I'm still not sure I understand everything.
I also found the implications of a sequential but also simultaneous timeline to be hard to grasp. Aiden lived sequential days in different bodies while the different bodies (with Aiden in each of them) interacted with each other simultaneously. It raises the interesting question of whether Aiden has control over his actions or is he predestined to do them because he has already observed himself doing so (from a different body). Too bad the story never satisfactorily explores this fascinating dilemma.
Still, even though the book had a few things that fell short for me, I found it entertaining nonetheless. This looks to be Turton's first book, so I look forward to seeing what he comes up with in the future.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
See also, my thoughts on:
The Last Murder at the End of the World
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
Evelyn Hardcastle will die at 11pm. Aiden Bishop has eight chances to relive the same day, inhabiting a different body each time, to discover who kills her. Only then will he be set free. He has many enemies working against him and also some who claim to be his allies, but who can he really trust? Such is the premise of this story, and it is an intriguing one.
There was so much I liked about this book. The plot is unique, fresh, and interesting. The writing is believable and riveting, and you can tell the author went to great lengths to keep track of everything so that he can correctly weave it all together. And the mystery itself is multi-layered; the more we discover, the more we realize is still hidden beneath the surface.
Yet, this is a case where the story's complexity is a bit too much and works against itself. It was really hard to keep track of everyone and to understand all that is going on. You really have to pay a lot of attention while reading not to feel lost. This was especially so in the first half of the book while we are getting to know all the characters.
The complexity also made revealing the solution in the end confusing, since it wasn't straightforward. Rather, more and more are added to the mystery while bits of it are solved. Even now that I have finished the book, I'm still not sure I understand everything.
I also found the implications of a sequential but also simultaneous timeline to be hard to grasp. Aiden lived sequential days in different bodies while the different bodies (with Aiden in each of them) interacted with each other simultaneously. It raises the interesting question of whether Aiden has control over his actions or is he predestined to do them because he has already observed himself doing so (from a different body). Too bad the story never satisfactorily explores this fascinating dilemma.
Still, even though the book had a few things that fell short for me, I found it entertaining nonetheless. This looks to be Turton's first book, so I look forward to seeing what he comes up with in the future.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
See also, my thoughts on:
The Last Murder at the End of the World
~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
October 13, 2018
– Shelved
Comments Showing 1-50 of 116 (116 new)
message 1:
by
Holly
(new)
Oct 23, 2018 06:07PM

reply
|
flag

Oh interesting, I have Life after Life on my to-read list, but I didn't realize it covered some of the same concepts. Yes, definitely not light reading. :)


Thanks, Joanna! I definitely liked it enough, but it's awesome that you totally loved it! Woohoo! :)

I did! Thanks, Maureen! 💖


Thanks, Aaron! Haha they came out around the same time, and I remember being confused. Like what are the odds two books would both have "7" and "Evelyn" in their titles? I think with the right mindset going in, this could still be a fascinating read! I hope you enjoy it when you get to it! :)

Thanks, Minna! Time-loops are tricky and I've rarely seen it done well. It usually makes the whole thing confusing.

Thanks, Emily! Ha, it did go on a bit, didn't it? I think so too! :)

Thanks, Jayme! Figures! I'm glad it worked better for you! 🤗


Thanks, Debbie! This was definitely interesting, but light read it isn't. I agree that reading it will be better than listening. If you ever get to it, I will be super curious to see your thoughts! But I understand your taking your time lol! :)


Thanks, Baba! I usually don't mind using my thinking cap, but this one befuddled me a bit, I don't mind admitting lol! :)

Thanks, Kay! Haha, that's pretty spot-on! 😅


Thanks, Chantel! A mixed bag, but overall an entertaining read nonetheless! :)

Thanks, Lori! Yep, I can totally understand that! :)



Thanks, Jasmine! Sounds like we're pretty much in agreement on this one! :)

Thanks, Terrie! If you do read it, I hope you very much enjoy it! Will be super curious to see your thoughts on it! :)

Thanks, Marilyn! Haha, not sure how two books came out around the same time, both with "7" and "Evelyn" in their title. What are the odds? I usually don't mind thinking books, but this one got me muddled a bit lol! 😅

Thanks, Lisa! Maybe I just wasn't concentrating hard enough when reading this lol! 😅


Thanks, Tina! I totally understand that lol! :)


Thanks, Paula! Maybe I just wasn't thinking hard enough lol and you may not run into the same issues? Otherwise, it was an interesting and unique read. :)


Thanks, Beata! Maybe I just wasn't concentrating hard enough when I read this lol. I'm so glad you thoroughly enjoyed! His new one is on my tbr, and I'm definitely looking forward to it! :)
