ŷ

Yun's Reviews > The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle

The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
30181442
's review

liked it

I'm always up for a good, mind-bending story, something unique and complex I can just sink my teeth into. But even though I enjoyed The 7½ Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle, I actually found it a bit too complicated, which is something I never thought I'd say.

Evelyn Hardcastle will die at 11pm. Aiden Bishop has eight chances to relive the same day, inhabiting a different body each time, to discover who kills her. Only then will he be set free. He has many enemies working against him and also some who claim to be his allies, but who can he really trust? Such is the premise of this story, and it is an intriguing one.

There was so much I liked about this book. The plot is unique, fresh, and interesting. The writing is believable and riveting, and you can tell the author went to great lengths to keep track of everything so that he can correctly weave it all together. And the mystery itself is multi-layered; the more we discover, the more we realize is still hidden beneath the surface.

Yet, this is a case where the story's complexity is a bit too much and works against itself. It was really hard to keep track of everyone and to understand all that is going on. You really have to pay a lot of attention while reading not to feel lost. This was especially so in the first half of the book while we are getting to know all the characters.

The complexity also made revealing the solution in the end confusing, since it wasn't straightforward. Rather, more and more are added to the mystery while bits of it are solved. Even now that I have finished the book, I'm still not sure I understand everything.

I also found the implications of a sequential but also simultaneous timeline to be hard to grasp. Aiden lived sequential days in different bodies while the different bodies (with Aiden in each of them) interacted with each other simultaneously. It raises the interesting question of whether Aiden has control over his actions or is he predestined to do them because he has already observed himself doing so (from a different body). Too bad the story never satisfactorily explores this fascinating dilemma.

Still, even though the book had a few things that fell short for me, I found it entertaining nonetheless. This looks to be Turton's first book, so I look forward to seeing what he comes up with in the future.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
See also, my thoughts on:
The Last Murder at the End of the World
~~~~~~~~~~~~

Connect with me
673 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
October 13, 2018 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-50 of 116 (116 new)


message 1: by Holly (new)

Holly Sounds a little bit like Life After Life, which also uses the concept of living the same event over and over but making different choices - some of which lead to the same outcome no matter what which begs the question of destiny vs free-choice. Interesting concept, but hard to read casually.


message 2: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Holly wrote: "Sounds a little bit like Life After Life, which also uses the concept of living the same event over and over but making different choices - some of which lead to the same outcome no..."
Oh interesting, I have Life after Life on my to-read list, but I didn't realize it covered some of the same concepts. Yes, definitely not light reading. :)


Joanna Chu (The ChuseyReader) Bummer this one didn't work out for you. But I definitely understand how it gets very confusing, there was a lot of jumping and having multiple timelines confusing too. But I loved it haha.


message 4: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Joanna Chu (The ChuseyReader) wrote: "Bummer this one didn't work out for you. But I definitely understand how it gets very confusing, there was a lot of jumping and having multiple timelines confusing too. But I loved it haha."
Thanks, Joanna! I definitely liked it enough, but it's awesome that you totally loved it! Woohoo! :)


Maureen Sounds like you enjoyed it Yun despite some issues, great review ♥️


message 6: by Julie (new)

Julie Very nice review, Yun!! 💖


message 7: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Maureen wrote: "Sounds like you enjoyed it Yun despite some issues, great review ♥️"
I did! Thanks, Maureen! 💖


message 8: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Julie wrote: "Very nice review, Yun!! 💖"
Thanks, Julie! 💖


message 9: by aaron (new)

aaron i remember i bought this book confusing it for the seven husbands of evelyn hugo, i don't really have much to contribute but i still think about that mistake from time to time lol. anyway, great review as always yun! i might add this to my fall tbr even though it does sound a bit confusing


message 10: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun aaron wrote: "i remember i bought this book confusing it for the seven husbands of evelyn hugo, i don't really have much to contribute but i still think about that mistake from time to time lol. anyway, great re..."
Thanks, Aaron! Haha they came out around the same time, and I remember being confused. Like what are the odds two books would both have "7" and "Evelyn" in their titles? I think with the right mindset going in, this could still be a fascinating read! I hope you enjoy it when you get to it! :)


Jayme Fantastic review! This one did not work for me, either!


message 12: by Minna (new)

Minna Thanks for the review, Yun. I’ve been noticing several authors have been using time-loops recently.


Emily Carter-Dunn Great review! I had similar thoughts about this book and thought it also rambled on a bit!


JaymeO Great review! I loved this for all of the reasons it didn’t work for you 😂


message 15: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Jayme wrote: "Fantastic review! This one did not work for me, either!"
Thanks, Jayme! :)


message 16: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Minna wrote: "Thanks for the review, Yun. I’ve been noticing several authors have been using time-loops recently."
Thanks, Minna! Time-loops are tricky and I've rarely seen it done well. It usually makes the whole thing confusing.


message 17: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Emily wrote: "Great review! I had similar thoughts about this book and thought it also rambled on a bit!"
Thanks, Emily! Ha, it did go on a bit, didn't it? I think so too! :)


message 18: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun JaymeO wrote: "Great review! I loved this for all of the reasons it didn’t work for you 😂"
Thanks, Jayme! Figures! I'm glad it worked better for you! 🤗


message 19: by Debbie (new)

Debbie W. What an interesting premise! Based on your review, Yun, I think reading it rather than listening to this story may work better for me as I would probably be constantly rewinding it! Even reading it might make me reread parts of it! Either way, I appreciate your informative review and won’t be adding this one to my WTR list anytime soon!


message 20: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Great review, Yun ;)


message 21: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Debbie wrote: "What an interesting premise! Based on your review, Yun, I think reading it rather than listening to this story may work better for me as I would probably be constantly rewinding it! Even reading it..."
Thanks, Debbie! This was definitely interesting, but light read it isn't. I agree that reading it will be better than listening. If you ever get to it, I will be super curious to see your thoughts! But I understand your taking your time lol! :)


message 22: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Diane wrote: "Great review, Yun ;)"
Thanks, Diane! :)


message 23: by Baba (new)

Baba Thanks for your view Yun! This book's concept sounds really interesting, but I would also concur that making it so complex will go against its accessibility and the opportunity for readers to truly engage with and enjoy it as much as they could.


message 24: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Baba wrote: "Thanks for your view Yun! This book's concept sounds really interesting, but I would also concur that making it so complex will go against its accessibility and the opportunity for readers to truly..."
Thanks, Baba! I usually don't mind using my thinking cap, but this one befuddled me a bit, I don't mind admitting lol! :)


message 25: by Kay (new)

Kay Great review Yun, glad it was entertaining in a confusing way! 😁


message 26: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Kay wrote: "Great review Yun, glad it was entertaining in a confusing way! 😁"
Thanks, Kay! Haha, that's pretty spot-on! 😅


message 27: by Chantel (new)

Chantel Great review, Yun! Glad that, though you encountered some less than favourable parts, the book was an overall entertaining read for you :)


message 28: by Barbara (new)

Barbara A revealing and fair review, Yun.


message 29: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Chantel wrote: "Great review, Yun! Glad that, though you encountered some less than favourable parts, the book was an overall entertaining read for you :)"
Thanks, Chantel! A mixed bag, but overall an entertaining read nonetheless! :)


message 30: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Barbara wrote: "A revealing and fair review, Yun."
Thanks, Barbara! :)


message 31: by Lori (new)

Lori Insightful review, Yun! I DNF'd this before I knew DNF was a Thing. Glad I did :)


message 32: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Lori wrote: "Insightful review, Yun! I DNF'd this before I knew DNF was a Thing. Glad I did :)"
Thanks, Lori! Yep, I can totally understand that! :)


Jasmine Great review, Yun! I remember enjoying this and also getting things muddled, so I’m with you there!


message 34: by Terrie (new) - added it

Terrie  Robinson I get the impression from your notes this is a speculative review, Yun. Based on that I will give it a read/listen on my own, as well!


message 35: by MarilynW (new) - added it

MarilynW I have never read either book but like others, I get this book and The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo mixed up in my head so much that I then can't remember what either of them are supposed to be about. 😂 I'm pretty sure I'd be frustrated by this book because I think too much anyway and this one requires a lot of thinking 😬😵🤯 Great review, Yun!


message 36: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Jasmine wrote: "Great review, Yun! I remember enjoying this and also getting things muddled, so I’m with you there!"
Thanks, Jasmine! Sounds like we're pretty much in agreement on this one! :)


message 37: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Terrie wrote: "I get the impression from your notes this is a speculative review, Yun. Based on that I will give it a read/listen on my own, as well!"
Thanks, Terrie! If you do read it, I hope you very much enjoy it! Will be super curious to see your thoughts on it! :)


message 38: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun MarilynW wrote: "I have never read either book but like others, I get this book and The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo mixed up in my head so much that I then can't remember what either of them are supposed to be ab..."
Thanks, Marilyn! Haha, not sure how two books came out around the same time, both with "7" and "Evelyn" in their title. What are the odds? I usually don't mind thinking books, but this one got me muddled a bit lol! 😅


message 39: by Lisa (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lisa Fantastic review Yun, glad you enjoyed this for the most part but sorry it was too complicated. 😎


message 40: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Lisa wrote: "Fantastic review Yun, glad you enjoyed this for the most part but sorry it was too complicated. 😎"
Thanks, Lisa! Maybe I just wasn't concentrating hard enough when reading this lol! 😅


message 41: by Tina (new)

Tina I've been staying away from this one as I fear I would feel the same way. Thanks for the honest and true opinion!


message 42: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Tina wrote: "I've been staying away from this one as I fear I would feel the same way. Thanks for the honest and true opinion!"
Thanks, Tina! I totally understand that lol! :)


message 43: by Paula (new)

Paula K Glad to see your point of view, Yun…excellent review! On my TBR, but now not certain if it is one I will read�


message 44: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Paula wrote: "Glad to see your point of view, Yun…excellent review! On my TBR, but now not certain if it is one I will read�"
Thanks, Paula! Maybe I just wasn't thinking hard enough lol and you may not run into the same issues? Otherwise, it was an interesting and unique read. :)


Beata Terrific review, Yun! :)) I loved this novel precisely for the reasons you mention: not everything is easy to grasp lol :) Probably the timing for such a read was perfect for me :) His latest book is also good, really recommend it! :)


message 46: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Beata wrote: "Terrific review, Yun! :)) I loved this novel precisely for the reasons you mention: not everything is easy to grasp lol :) Probably the timing for such a read was perfect for me :) His latest book ..."
Thanks, Beata! Maybe I just wasn't concentrating hard enough when I read this lol. I'm so glad you thoroughly enjoyed! His new one is on my tbr, and I'm definitely looking forward to it! :)


message 47: by Marta (new) - added it

Marta I actually gave up on this book and I never do that!


message 48: by Yun (new) - rated it 3 stars

Yun Marta wrote: "I actually gave up on this book and I never do that!"
Marta, I totally understand! :)


Laurie I got to around 70% before I threw in the towel on this one. Like you, I found it too complicated. It was also too repetitive. Terrific review, Yun!


message 50: by JanB (new)

JanB This one never interested me enough to add it, and now I'm glad. Sorry it was a miss, but terrific review, as always, Yun!


« previous 1 3
back to top