ŷ

Glenn Russell's Reviews > Monday Starts on Saturday

Monday Starts on Saturday by Arkady Strugatsky
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
23385697
's review

bookshelves: favorite-books




Many people outside Russia are familiar with Stalker, Andrei Tarkovsky's 1979 film loosely based on the novel Roadside Picnic by Boris and Arkady Strugatsky. But, let me tell you comrades, the brothers Strugatsky's Monday Starts on Saturday is one of the most imaginative, off-the-wall hilarious SF novels ever written, a work that should be better known than it is.

Science fiction held a special place within the Soviet Union back in 1964 when this novel was first published, with issues revolving around censorship and maintaining the party line. If writers wanted to express their personal creativity or share independent ideas rather than serve the cause of communism and the state, they stood a better chance of having their books published if they wrote about future, distant worlds and impossible happenings and events - in other words, if they wrote science fiction.

And we find just such a distant, impossible world in Monday Starts on Saturday. It all begins when young computer programmer Alexander Ivanovich Privalov from Leningrad headed north to meet up with some friends, picks up two hitchhikers who convince him to drive to their destination to spend the night. As Alexander Ivanovich quickly discovers upon arrival where there's a sign reading: "N I T W I T - The Log Hut on Chicken Legs," he has crossed over into a universe where magic, myth and mayhem intersect with science and technology, a universe where, among many other extraordinary occurrences, a talking pike pops out of the water and the mirror in his room refuses to reflect his image. Alexander Ivanovich must admit, all of what he encounters "seemed to me even more interesting than modelling a reflex arc." Thus our computer programmer stays on for much longer than one night.

Working within such a preposterous literary canvas, the Strugatsky brothers throw every conceivable objects and animal and plant, not to mention gentlemanly ghost, mad researcher and buffoonish bureaucrat at programmer Alexander and, indirectly, at the reader. Powerful images and ideas are all tangled together - I can imagine Soviet men and women pouring over this novel in private gatherings, relishing every glorious sentence, coming up with associations galore taken from history and current events as well as their own knowledge of fairy tales, myths and legions.

To share a taste of the treats a reader is in store for, I've included my own comments linked to a mere handful of the hundreds of bizarre happenings generously served up in the novel's 240 pages:

Modern Soviet State's Fairy Tale Grandma: Alexander is greeted by old Nina Kievna, the prototypical ancient granny from fairy tales and folk legions; she's well over 100-years-old and wears not only the predictable black shawl knotted under her chin but "her head was covered by a cheerful nylon scarf with brightly colored pictures of the Atomium and an inscription in several languages: 'Brussels International Exhibition'."

What a scream, comrades! The traditional forms of magic usually associated with the fairy tale grandma, such things as magic pebbles or golden apples, are replaced by a symbol of the "rational" magic of physics and chemistry -as tall as a 33-story building, the Atomium (pictured below) is built of stainless steel in the shape of a unit cell of an iron crystal magnified 165 billion times - and not only does each sphere contain an exhibition hall connected by escalators but there's a restaurant on the top sphere. Whoa! An undeniable feat of engineering and scientific know-how amounting to nothing less than the magic of the modern world.

The crossover between sorcery, wizardry and magic on the one hand and modern science, technology and engineering on the other is a key theme running throughout the entire tale. In many important ways, particularly in the general public's eye, scientists and technicians have taken the place of wizards.

Computer Programmer's Dreamscape: Alexander's very first night at N I T W I T proves memorable: he moves his pillow and sheets from the floor to a couch (a magical couch, as it turns out) and is woken out of his sleep in the middle of the night by voices. He tries to go back to sleep but realizes he's hungry not sleepy. The programmer gets up and picks up a book from the windowsill - Alexei Tolstoy's Overcast Morning. He flips to a random page and reads of a character opening cans of pineapple. Then a pungent smell of food fills the room - granny Nina Kievna enters and serves him a plateful of delicious hot potatoes smeared with butter.

Thereafter Alexander lies down once again and this time hears a quiet voice speak of an elephant in scientific terms then references to Carl Jung and the Upanishads. This is followed by Vasily the cat under the oak tree outside walking like university professor Dubino-Knyazhitsky giving a lecture, referencing, among other topics, a vile monster and a snow-white swan. Meanwhile, the book by Alexei Tolstoy transforms into other works by other authors. When Alexander peers out the window again he observes a wet, silver-green shark's tail hanging from the lowest branch of the oak tree. Equally astonishing (perhaps the influence of the couch?), our computer programmer takes it all in stride.

Law and Order: The following day Alexander is in the town square and is surprised to find the five kopecks in his pocket mysteriously reappearing after he hands over his coins to a merchant. According to a young lieutenant on duty at the time such behavior is completely unacceptable. The programmer is interrogated and the lieutenant informs him that he will have to draw up a report.

Alexander reflects: "What is the essential point here? The essential thing is whether or not a person thinks of himself as guilty." Readers back when Russia was the Soviet Union must have hooted when reading this brothers Straugatsky scene. During those Soviet years, millions of honest men and women were sent off to forced labor camps for trifles. To judge oneself as guilty was nothing short of laughable.

Wizards Go Bonkers: Turns out, N I T W I T stands for National Institute for the Technology of Witchcraft and Thaumaturgy. Alexander enters the main building and is put to work in a laboratory where he comes in contact with a string of remarkable departments and offices - to list several: Department of Linear Happiness, Department of the Meaning of Life, Department of Predictions and Prophecies, Children's Laughter Distillation Unit, Department of Defensive Magic, Department of Absolute Knowledge.

As I'm sure any reader will appreciate, with such a list the tale's social and cultural satire kicks into even higher gear. What are the consequences when technicians attempt to calculate society's highest happiness using mathematical formulas? How effective and efficient can such departments become? Are research projects and experiments being conducted here at all practical or useful?

Such questions fan out to even larger questions: What value is there in academic and scientific institutes around the world when subjects addressed have nearly zero relevance to the general population? What if researchers become so specialized they lose sight of what is beyond their specialty? In this way, the novel speaks to our modern world well beyond 1960s Soviet Russia.

There is even consideration at the institute of the ways to use vampires and magic carpets in modern warfare. And how will future research be done when such important components are added to the equation? I've just touched the surface here. Many more astonishing discoveries and ideas and memorable scenes await a reader opening the pages of Monday Starts on Saturday.



One can only wonder if old Nina Kievna has to travel to Moscow and stand in line on a mile-long queue to receive her Atomium scarf made from that modern synthetic fabric - nylon. Incidentally, the Soviet Union participated in the Brussels International Exhibition with its major contribution: a replica of Sputnik.


Authors Boris and Arkady Strugatsky

"I was woken by the flapping of wings and an unpleasant screeching. The room was filled with a strange, bluish half-light. The vulture on the stove was rustling its feathers, screaming repulsively and ganging its wings against the ceiling. I sat up and looked around. Floating in the air at the centre of the room was a big tough-looking bozo in tracksuit trousers and a striped Hawaiian shirt." - Arkady and Boris Strugatsky, Monday Starts on Saturday
233 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Monday Starts on Saturday.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 15, 2018 – Started Reading
October 15, 2018 – Shelved
October 21, 2018 – Shelved as: favorite-books
October 21, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cheri (new)

Cheri I'm looking forward to reading your thoughts on this one, Glenn!


message 2: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Cheri wrote: "I'm looking forward to reading your thoughts on this one, Glenn!"

Thanks, Cheri! I should have my review of this terrific novel up by the weekend. Love to hear what you think - surely a wild ride, like Alexandre in Soviet-Wonderland!


message 3: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell *Note - I am no longer using the star system


message 4: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King A beautilly crafted review Glenn but after my reading experience with Return From the Stars, I realize there is no comparison of course, I'm very nervous about undertaking an unknown quantity.

Nevertheless, I must say it does sound a splendid books and I particularly liked:

"There is even consideration at the institute of the ways to use vampires and magic carpets in modern warfare." - Intriguing concept!

And,

"The crossover between sorcery, wizardry and magic on the one hand and modern science, technology and engineering on the other is a key theme running throughout the entire tale. In many important ways, particularly in eye of the public, scientists and technicians have taken the place of wizards." Also rather fascinating!

I've added it but...


message 5: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Lynne wrote: "A beautilly crafted review Glenn but after my reading experience with Return From the Stars, I realize there is no comparison of course, I'm very nervous about undertaking an unknown ..."

Thanks, Lynne! I can appreciate how following your distasteful experience with that Lem novel, you might be hesitate before reading another science fiction novel reviewed by Glenn Russell!!


message 6: by Lynne (new) - added it

Lynne King Nothing personal Glenn! I always admire your reviews.


message 7: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Lynne wrote: "Nothing personal Glenn! I always admire your reviews."

Thanks, Lynne! Most appreciated.

I certainly recognize my tastes are entirely eccentric.


message 8: by Glenn (last edited Oct 24, 2018 07:54AM) (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Book Wyrm wrote: "Great review of a great book, Glen. I didn't see your symbolism of the magic kopeck and the nature of guilt the first time reading, but it makes sense."

Thanks, Book! I can certainly see why this novel is among your favorites - every single page is filled with insights and memorable images. The old granny with her Atomium scarf was one I'll never forget. Monday would make an excellent read for a book club.


message 9: by P.E. (new) - added it

P.E. Hi, Glenn. From the Strugatsky Brothers, I have already read a French translation of Stalker and another of The Troika. Both were filled to the brim with a pandemonium of freaks and miracles and dubious technological troves crammed up together.

In your review, I found back this blend of Dostoevsky (the wild thoughts in The Dream of a Ridiculous Man, the defiance about Progress in Notes from the Underground), Stanisław Lem (Cyberiad) and Philip K. Dick (Martian Time-Slip, The Simulacra, The Penultimate Truth, Now Wait For Last Year...) with all manner of lowlives and fowls and fish and apparatus jabbering together about metaphysics. I found back this blend I crossed paths with in Stalker and Troika.

'As I'm sure any reader will appreciate, with such a list the tale's social and cultural satire kicks into even higher gear. What are the consequences when technicians attempt to calculate society's highest happiness using mathematical formulas? How effective and efficient can such departments become? Are research projects and experiments being conducted here at all practical or useful?

Such questions fan out to even larger questions: What value is there in academic and scientific institutes around the world when subjects addressed have nearly zero relevance to the general population? What if researchers become so specialized they lose sight of what is beyond their specialty? In this way, the novel speaks to our modern world well beyond 1960s Soviet Russia.'


The same questions are throbbing in the backstage in Stalker and Troika. In the end, what is at stake is the meaningfulness of meaning, the worth of the worthies, the unbearable lightness of being.


message 10: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell P.E. wrote: "Hi, Glenn. From the Strugatsky Brothers, I have already read a French translation of Stalker and another of The Troika. Both were filled to the brim with a pandemonium of freaks and miracles and du..."

Ha! Thanks so much - I enjoyed all of your insights and comparisons. It also reminded me at points of Lem and PKD. One thing that isn't emphasized so much in Monday is "feel good" drugs. Probably a good thing - there's so much other mindbending going on.


message 11: by Denis (new)

Denis you can make a book 1 day and so many people will like your books and you will be famous 1 day so people like my review and support Glenn Russell.
He might mension your name on that book.

Thank you for seeing my comment thx


message 12: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Denis wrote: "you can make a book 1 day and so many people will like your books and you will be famous 1 day so people like my review and support Glenn Russell.
He might mension your name on that book.

Thank yo..."


You are welcome!


message 13: by Michael (new) - added it

Michael Another wonderful review, Glenn! I don't know how you keep unearthing these wonderful, weird gems, but I continue to be amazed at (and appreciative of) this treasure trove of literature that I never knew existed!


message 14: by Glenn (last edited Oct 24, 2018 03:23PM) (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Michael wrote: "Another wonderful review, Glenn! I don't know how you keep unearthing these wonderful, weird gems, but I continue to be amazed at (and appreciative of) this treasure trove of literature that I neve..."

Thanks very much, Michael! I found this novel since it is part of the SF Masteworks, a series I decided to read through this fall. This truly is a one-of-a-kind story. As I understand, Arkady Strugatsky and brother Boris Strugatsky worked through every single sentence together. Remarkable collaboration.


message 15: by Alvokun (new)

Alvokun Marvelous review for a seemingly unconventional book, Glenn. Thanks!

I have found some of the reflections you mention from the novel about academia, science and technology very interesting. I actually remembered a slightly related quote: "If you show a caveman technology, he'll think it's magic; but if you show a modern man magic, he'll think it's technology."

I get the impression that the work is a potpourri of elements in a very specific historical context, as you explained. The fact that they are two brothers writing the novel is already meaningful enough! I'll bear the book in mind.


message 16: by Glenn (last edited Oct 24, 2018 06:01PM) (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Alvokun wrote: "Marvelous review for a seemingly unconventional book, Glenn. Thanks!

I have found some of the reflections you mention from the novel about academia, science and technology very interesting. I actu..."


Ha! I enjoy that quote - very accurate.

And thanks for your kinds words on my review - writing about such a mix of craziness is a bit of a challenge. And you are spot-on: although there is a universal quality to the subject, the book is undoubtedly rooted in the Soviet society with all its rational-scientific planning.

Such a unique way to write a novel - two brothers composing every single sentence together.


Richa I had never before heard of Strugatsky Brothers. Nor had I ever heard of Rusian Sci-Fi books. I am definitely reading this one, all owing to this review, Glenn. Your review speaks of the fun you had reading this book.


message 18: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Richa wrote: "I had never before heard of Strugatsky Brothers. Nor had I ever heard of Rusian Sci-Fi books. I am definitely reading this one, all owing to this review, Glenn. Your review speaks of the fun you ha..."

Thanks so much, Richa! Apologies for late "thank you" for your comment - I just did see. And, yes, yes - I certainly had oodles of fun doing this write-up.


message 19: by Իé (new) - added it

Իé I look forward to read the book.
Amazing review!


message 20: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Իé wrote: "I look forward to read the book.
Amazing review!"


Thanks, Իé. Fantastic SF - enjoy!!


message 21: by ã (new) - added it

ã Reis Great review, Glenn.


message 22: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell ã wrote: "Great review, Glenn."

Hey, thanks, ã. Both Roadside Picnic and Monday Begins on Saturday are on the list for the most imaginative SF novels ever written. Hands down, this novel is my favorite from the Brothers S.


Алексей Китаев Great review. Sorry if I missed but have you read Snail on the slope by Strugatskies?


message 24: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Алексей wrote: "Great review. Sorry if I missed but have you read Snail on the slope by Strugatskies?"

Thanks millions, A! Coming from a reader living in the great city of
Saint Petersburg I'm especially heartened. I've not read that novel but it on my huge TBR stacks. The only other review I've posted for the authors is Roadside Picnic. Link: /review/show...


Алексей Китаев To my mind Slope.. very much depends on translation. Hard book to deliver in a foreign language. But certainly its one of best by Strugatskies, if not the best one. And probably should be on the same shelf as Gogol, Kafka, Bradbary, Orwell. in other words on the shelf Masterpieces.


message 26: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell Алексей wrote: "To my mind Slope.. very much depends on translation. Hard book to deliver in a foreign language. But certainly its one of best by Strugatskies, if not the best one. And probably should be on the sa..."

Enjoyed your reflections here, A. I'll have to keep what you note in mind when I get to Slope.


message 27: by Anurag Dutta (new)

Anurag Dutta ur name is mixed with glenn maxwell and andre russell right??????


message 28: by Glenn (new) - added it

Glenn Russell RUSSELL Anurag #KKRFOREVER wrote: "ur name is mixed with glenn maxwell and andre russell right??????"

In name only! No relation to either at all. And I've never played cricket.


message 29: by Anurag Dutta (new)

Anurag Dutta good to be my frnd


back to top