ŷ

Andrew Smith's Reviews > The Lost Man

The Lost Man by Jane Harper
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5885760
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: netgalley, aussie-writers

I loved both of Jane Harper’s previous books but I think this one might just be the best yet. Set in the Australian outback it’s a tale of a three brothers: Nathan, Cameron (Cam) and Bub. As the book opens Nathan and Bub have met at old gravestone on family land. The grave represents the final resting point of a man known as the stockman, the tale of whose demise takes many forms. In the shadow of the gravestone lies a body, it’s that of Cam.

The family farm is vast and quite why Cam was at this spot, miles from anywhere with no vehicle in sight is a mystery. It seems that he was due to meet up with Bub to carry out a repair some distance from this point, but he didn’t show up. The heat is so extreme in these parts that to be separated from your vehicle and from water for even a short period can be fatal. Out here everyone know that you live on your wits and take no chances � which makes Cam’s fate all the harder to understand. Though it seems that Cam had been somewhat stressed lately, could it be that he deliberately found his way to the stockman’s grave knowing what his fate would be?

From this small view of the three brothers gathered together under such tragic circumstances we start to learn their story. Actually, it’s the story of a mother and father and their three boys and also of the broader family, as the boys grow into men and add grandchildren into the mix. It’s also an account of what it’s like to live in such a place, a farm a thousand kilometres from Adelaide and fifteen hundred from Brisbane, with a journey by road to the latter taking some 18 hours! There’s a small town some hours away but really nothing much else in the vicinity.

From such an intimate beginning the picture gradually grows, but it grows slowly. There was a point early on where I thought for an instant that the pace might be too slow but almost immediately thereafter I found myself totally captivated by this book. Without warning I realised that I just had to know everything about these people, their lives in this place and � maybe � what caused Cam to die in such a way. The characters are largely gruff, hardened by the life and the landscape, but to an extent that’s just surface noise. As I learned more and more about the upbringing the boys had had and about their more recent lives a clearer view started to emerge: actually life was even tougher than I’d thought! And I felt for all of these people who had jointly suffered this loss and were desperately trying to absorb it and to understand it.

There's sadness here and tension and a mystery to be solved too. The writing is first class, the pacing (despite my early reservation) is perfect and the way in which Harper describes life in this harshly beautiful place is extraordinary. If I read a better book this year, I’ll be a happy man � this one is already guaranteed to be in my top 5!

My sincere thanks to Little, Brown Book Group UK and to NetGalley for supplying a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
118 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Lost Man.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 11, 2019 – Started Reading
January 11, 2019 – Shelved
January 11, 2019 – Shelved as: netgalley
January 15, 2019 – Finished Reading
January 9, 2023 – Shelved as: aussie-writers

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Emma (last edited Jan 18, 2019 12:37AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Emma I loved it too. Clever and really well developed characters. Her second book wasn't quite as effective and I wondered whether she'd be able to hit the heights of The Dry again....this answered that question with a big, definite YES.


Andrew Smith Emma wrote: "I loved it too. Clever and really well developed characters. Her second book wasn't quite as effective and I wondered whether she'd be able to hit the heights of The Dry again....this answered that..."

Thanks, Emma - and to a degree I had the same thought. I'd enjoyed the Aaron Falk books but this one was a departure. But what a story, and so well told.

I understand that JH was born in Manchester, England - maybe it's time to claim her before she gains world wide renown as a brilliant Aussie writer :))


Emma Andrew wrote: "Emma wrote: "I loved it too. Clever and really well developed characters. Her second book wasn't quite as effective and I wondered whether she'd be able to hit the heights of The Dry again....this ..."

Was she???!! Yep, we're stealing her....


Andrew Smith Emma wrote: "Andrew wrote: "Emma wrote: "I loved it too. Clever and really well developed characters. Her second book wasn't quite as effective and I wondered whether she'd be able to hit the heights of The Dry..."

It seems so :))


Kathleen Lovely review!


Andrew Smith Kathleen - many thanks 🙏


message 7: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Terrific review, Andrew.


Andrew Smith Angela M wrote: "Terrific review, Andrew."

So kind, Angela - thank you!


Karen Fantastic book, fantastic review Andrew!


Andrew Smith Karen wrote: "Fantastic book, fantastic review Andrew!"

Many thanks, Karen. I think Jane Harper is here to stay - three books and I've loved 'em all. But I think this one surpasses the others simply for the atmosphere and sheer tension she creates. Brilliant!


Karen Andrew wrote: "Karen wrote: "Fantastic book, fantastic review Andrew!"

Many thanks, Karen. I think Jane Harper is here to stay - three books and I've loved 'em all. But I think this one surpasses the others simp..."

I’ve read all three of her books too, she doesn’t disappoint!😊


message 12: by Jaline (new) - added it

Jaline Excellent review, Andrew! :)


Andrew Smith Thank you, Jaline 😊


Tammy I agree, Andrew. Her best yet. Great review


Andrew Smith Tammy wrote: "I agree, Andrew. Her best yet. Great review"

Thank you, Tammy. I really hope this book is a major success, it deserves to be.


Karen I just finished 'The Dry' and 'Force of Nature'......can't wait to read this one as well!


Andrew Smith Karen - I really liked those two books. I think JH has a great writing ‘voice� and it’s equally evident in this one. I’m determined to read everything she writes!


message 18: by Katerina (new) - added it

Katerina Thank you for the tip, I think I’ll have to read this one. Although I’m a bit disappointed to find it a stand-alone, not an Aaron Falk novel, I sort of got to like him :)


Andrew Smith Katerina wrote: "Thank you for the tip, I think I’ll have to read this one. Although I’m a bit disappointed to find it a stand-alone, not an Aaron Falk novel, I sort of got to like him :)"

You're welcome! I've really enjoyed the Aaron Falk books too, Katerina, but I have a feeling this one might float you're boat too.


Gloria ~ mzglorybe I’ve been looking forward to this one, Andrew. I may have to move it on up the list :) Great review!


Andrew Smith Gloria ~ wrote: "I’ve been looking forward to this one, Andrew. I may have to move it on up the list :) Great review!"

Thank you, Gloria :))

I really loved this book - I hope you do too!


message 22: by Susu (new) - rated it 4 stars

Susu I’m currently reading this and I agree (thus far anyway) I think this is the best.
I’ve enjoyed her other books as well. Her descriptions definitely transport you to the harsh, desolate lands!


Andrew Smith Susu - I think it’s the descriptions of life in the Outback that first drew me into the story. As you say, it makes you feel that you’re there with them. I liked how she develops things too and makes the characters people you can believe in. Loved it!

I’d love to hear what your thoughts are when you’ve finished it too.


Jaidee Glad this was such a winner for you Andrew !


Andrew Smith Jaidee wrote: "Glad this was such a winner for you Andrew !"

Thank you. Loved this one Jaidee :))


message 26: by JanB (new) - rated it 5 stars

JanB I’m reading this one now, happy to see your 5 stars!:)


Andrew Smith Jan - I really hope you enjoy it as much as I did. I look forward to your thoughts :)


Richard (on hiatus) I’m reading this soon so it was great to see your 5 stars ....... nice review Andrew!


Andrew Smith Many thanks, Richard. I think this is her best book to date - hope you enjoy it too.


message 30: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue I’m adding this one, Andrew, and may get the kindle copy on special today. That way it won’t get lost in the shuffle. Thanks for your great review.


Tracy Greer- Hansen This was my best one too! Great review!


Andrew Smith Tracy wrote: "This was my best one too! Great review!"

Yes, I loved this one, Tracy. I’m always excited when I spot that JH has a book coming out. She’ll do well to top this one, though.


Tracy Greer- Hansen Andrew: I agree. I have faith that it will be a great read no matter what.


back to top