Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Leonard Gaya's Reviews > Metamorphoses

Metamorphoses by Ovid
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
27098959
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites

The Metamorphoses are °¿±¹¾±»å’s masterpiece and one of the literary monuments of Antiquity, alongside the Bible, Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey and Virgil’s Aeneid. As the title suggests, °¿±¹¾±»å’s book is about change, transformation, mutation. Its scope is exceptionally ambitious, encyclopaedic even. It covers the whole of ancient mythology, from the creation of the world and the flood to the epic of Phaëton, from Jupiter’s rape of various nymphs to the abduction of Europa, from Narcissus in love with his own reflection to Perseus and Medusa, from the rape of Proserpina to Medea and Jason, from Theseus and the Minotaur to the fall of Icarus, from Meleäger and the Calydonian Boar to Byblisâ€� and Myrrha’s incestuous passions, from the works of Hercules to the doomed love of Orpheus and Eurydice in the underworld, from the desire of Venus for Adonis to King Midas turning everything into gold, from the shipwreck of Cëyx to the battle of the Centaurs and to the Trojan War, from the sufferings of Hecuba to the wanderings of Aeneas, from Ulysses in Polyphemusâ€� cave to Circe’s witchcraft, and last but not least, from Romulus down to Julius Caesar. In short, Ovid has it all figured out!

°¿±¹¾±»å’s Metamorphoses, like Virgil’s Aeneid, was written under the reign of Augustus and both works are, in their way, a glorification of the Roman Empire. All prior tribulations of gods and men aim towards this apex of history, this ideal order of civilisation. But Virgil’s and °¿±¹¾±»å’s ways are very different. While Virgil unfolds the story of Aeneas in a single grand narrative, taking inspiration from the Odyssey, Ovid seems to be jumping randomly from one legend to the next, sometimes arranged into a Russian doll structure, thus covering a vast body of material (several hundreds of tales borrowed mostly from Greek literature). Within this colourful poem, there is one obsessive idea: the metamorphose (other recurring themes are romantic passion and sexual obsession). In a way, Virgil and Ovid could be compared to the myth of Arachne, exposed in book 6: Virgil being the Minervean, elevated, distinguished bard and Ovid the Arachnean, careless, disorganised poet.

At first, it seems he has gathered together every legend where some magical transformation is involved (Jupiter turning himself into a white bull, Actaeon changed by Diana into a stag, and so on). But by the end of the epic, primarily through Pythagoras� speech in book 15 (my fave section), we come to understand that Ovid has a sort of profound ontological idea in mind. His book illustrates some kind of Heraclitean world view, whereby everything is in constant transmutation and flux. In a way, while Virgil is putting forward a historical statement about the origins of Rome, placing everything in a genealogical line, Ovid suggests something much more unstable and uncertain. If Augustus� Empire is the pinnacle of human history, the poem makes room for further transformations and alterations down the line � a non-dogmatic, almost modern vision of history. Ovid knows that the Augustinian Empire, like everything else under the moon, is condemned to decay and death. (Did this contribute to his later banishment to the Black Sea � see the fantastic Poems of Exile?) The only thing that will remain through time is, according to the Epilogue (15, 870 sqq.), the poem itself, a poem about growth, transformation, and degeneration.

Another surprising fact about the Metamorphoses, also in line with °¿±¹¾±»å’s metaphysical view of an all changing universe, is the justification of vegetarianism in book 15: “What a heinous crime is committed when guts disappear inside a fellow-creature’s intestinesâ€� (15, 86-87). Indeed, if gods and men can mutate into animals, a meat-eating individual is in some way a barbaric cannibal or a sacrilegious god-eater. Note the similarities between °¿±¹¾±»å’s pagan doctrine on this issue and modern religious practices based on the belief on reincarnation (Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism). In a broader sense, this very much resonates with our contemporary concerns about animal suffering and climate change. (One last thing that resonates with me in that same book 15, during this present time of coronavirus global pandemic, is the mention of Aesculapius, the saviour of Rome during the plague.)

Ovid is always a delight to read, chiefly because his descriptions are still readable and to the point, often playful or emotional, and never shy away from graphic details, visceral or sexual. See, for instance, the gory wedding banquets at the beginning of book 5 and book 12 (possible influence to the “Red Wedding� in ). Also see the erotic and gruesome story of Tereus and Philomela (book 6) � incidentally a blueprint for Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus (which is, in turn, a recipe for the episode of the “Frey Pies�, again in Game of Thrones!). Furthermore (considering that the little Latin I have ever known is gone forever), David Raeburn’s recent translation into English hexameters is extraordinarily readable and never draws the reader’s attention to itself.

The Metamorphoses have had an enormous influence on Western culture, not just on other Roman writers, such as Apuleius with his spicy Golden Ass. It has made a particular impression on numerous artists since the Renaissance. Think of , of course. Think of ’s Poesie, ordered by King Felipe II of Spain. Think of Brueghel’s (from book 8). Think of the Pre-Raphaelites (see below the exquisite Echo and Narcissus by Waterhouse � from book 3). Think of countless references made by Dante, Montaigne, Cervantes or Shakespeare in their works. Case in point: Pyramus and Thisbe (book 4) is inserted within A Midsummer Night's Dream and is the inspiration of Romeo and Juliet; the affliction of Hecuba (book 13) is slotted into Hamlet; Prospero’s late speech in The Tempest is inspired by Medea’s speech (book 7). Think too of all the plays based on the myth of Pygmalion (e.g. the Broadway musical and the film version of ). Think of the popular sword-and-sandal movies such as . And think nowadays of all the bestsellers that borrow from Greco-Roman myths � most of which are to be found chiefly in the Metamorphoses � indirectly, J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series, or more directly, Madeline Miller or Stephen Fry’s latest books.

In short, °¿±¹¾±»å’s Metamorphoses is to Greco-Roman mythology more or less what Snorri Sturluson is to Norse myths. While Snorri is essential to understanding the culture of the Vikings, without some knowledge of °¿±¹¾±»å’s book, it would be practically impossible to comprehend Mediterranean Antiquity and, indeed, Western culture.

John William Waterhouse - Echo and Narcissus
117 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Metamorphoses.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 15, 2019 – Shelved
January 15, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
March 5, 2020 – Started Reading
May 18, 2020 – Finished Reading
July 4, 2020 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Krista (new)

Krista Wonderfully astute and helpful analysis, Leonard.


Leonard Gaya Thank you very much indeed, Krista!


message 3: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala Very useful review, Leonard. You're right of course, this book is a keystone of western culture, and I know I should finish it. I started reading it during MeToo season, and found the double whammy of coercion and rape in the media and in Ovid too much.
I put the book on my 'ongoing' shelf rather than my 'abandoned' shelf so I will pick it up again sometime—I suspect you've put it on your 'ongoing' shelf for a different reason.


message 4: by Leonard (last edited May 22, 2020 04:56AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leonard Gaya Thanks, Fionnuala. I actually didn’t make the connection between this book and the MeToo movement. In my mind, these are very different things: in the one hand this book, a massive compendium of myths with, granted, some sexual content, but ultimately a work of imagination; on the other hand some very real and truly disgusting acts of sexual assault by powerful and depraved individuals on defenceless men and women (mostly women).

I for one read the Metamorphoses on this occasion after doing some research on Titian. Again, lots of nude ladies in Western painting, but one thing is to “sublimate� one’s basic instincts into an art or literary form, another thing entirely is to “take action� like criminals such as Harvey Weinstein, Jeffrey Epstein or other scoundrels of the same kind.


message 5: by Fionnuala (new) - added it

Fionnuala I understand your point about works of imagination versus reality, Leonard.


Leonard Gaya And I understand your qualm nonetheless! ;)


TBV (on hiatus) Excellent review, Leonard. I’m bookmarking it for future reference.


Leonard Gaya Of course! Thank you so much, TBV.


back to top