ŷ

Sunny's Reviews > The Queen of Nothing

The Queen of Nothing by Holly Black
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32222897
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: 2019-reads, diversity, fantasy, magic, ya-fantasy, young-adult, 2024-reads
Read 2 times. Last read September 22, 2024.

** spoiler alert ** After thoroughly evaluating my feelings about this book, I've decided to settle at 2.5 stars.

Please be aware of major spoilers ahead.

My disappointment started in Chapter 4 when Locke was declared dead. Don't get me wrong...I hated this boi with every bone in my body, but I always believed him to be an intelligent manipulator. Not someone who would be stupid enough to die an easy simple death at the hands of Taryn of all people. He's the kind of character you love to hate. His thirst to be a part of a dramatic story was so profound that he was willing to do terrible acts just to set things in motion. So naturally, I expected him to play a much larger role in this installment. He could've had the potential to be the Petyr Baelish of YA fantasy. His deserved a death to be on page. What a waste...

My disappointment then increased during Cradan's reasoning for sending Jude into exile. Really? I expected something more than just a misunderstanding.

Let's not even get started with Lady Asha. Someone, please explain to me the purpose of her character. Why was she even introduced if her character wasn't going to play a poignant role in the story? The Wicked King was filled with plot twist after plot twist. The revelation of Asha being Cardan's mother was such a huge shock factor that it makes absolutely no sense when she didn't even manage to make a tiny dent in the overall plot.

But the biggest disappointment of all...Cardan and Jude's relationship. Here is a pen and paper...someone draw me a map from point A (where Cardan love-hates Jude so much ), to point B (where Cardan loves Jude so much he wants to play the dotting husband). This relationship was supposed to build very slowly. So slow that the chemistry was constantly off the charts. And one of Cardan's best qualities was that he never lost his personality despite falling for a girl. I loved that he never got cheesy and mushy like most male characters do when a girl enters the picture. He managed to remain a sassy person while being a nicer being at the same time...and I LOVED it. But he did a complete 180 in this book. It wasn't even a slow and gradual process. He's this nice wonderful person right off the bat.

The ending was way too easy. One of the reasons I adored the first two books was because of Jude's thirst for vengeance. The Wicked King ended with an implication that Jude was going to reappear in Elfhame with fire in her eyes. She was made out to be this girl with a revenge-driven persona for being exiled. But that wasn't really the case here. I didn't expect a perfectly crafted novel. But I also didn't think everything would this easy. Remember in The Cruel Prince when Madoc went batshit crazy and killed everyone? Well, I wanted jaw-dropping scenes like that. Not necessarily a mass murder spree, but scenes that would have my eyes bulge out in surprise like they did when reading the first two books. Cardan turning into a snake was not something I could take seriously.

I know this sounds more like a 1-star review. But despite all my disappointments, I still read this book like an addict. And well...Cardan's tilted crown and weird tail managed to make me smile. Overall, this series still remains to be one of my favorites. But I wish Holly Black put more time and effort into this final installment. I felt there was still a lot left unsaid. Specifically revolving around Locke and Cardan's mother.
223 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Queen of Nothing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 19, 2019 – Shelved
January 19, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
November 18, 2019 – Started Reading
November 18, 2019 – Shelved as: 2019-reads
November 19, 2019 –
56.0%
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: diversity
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: fantasy
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: magic
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: ya-fantasy
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: young-adult
November 20, 2019 – Finished Reading
September 22, 2024 – Started Reading
September 22, 2024 – Finished Reading
September 23, 2024 – Shelved as: 2024-reads

Comments Showing 1-48 of 48 (48 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Sunny Tom wrote: "I finished reading it. How was it?"

I'm only on chapter 5. But so far it is really addicting. How much did you love it?


✨Kayla of The Court Of Dreams✨ How do people already have this it doesn't release till tomorrow 😥


Sunny Kaylanii of The Court of Dreams wrote: "How do people already have this it doesn't release till tomorrow 😥"

I found a copy at Barnes and Nobles. Sometimes they have hidden copies a few days early. Not sure if it is purpose or accident lol.


Sunny Tom wrote: "I liked a lot but the climax was a little anti climactic. Lots of Jurdan scenes."

After finishing, I agree with you. Unfortunately for me, it was a little bit of a letdown.


Kacey I haven’t finished yet, but the Locke situation was a huge letdown


message 6: by Reynita (new)

Reynita ★ The Night Reader ★ Sorry to hear that the book let you down :(


Julia (bookish.jka) Am totally agreeing with the letdown comments 😢


Sunny Kacey wrote: "I haven’t finished yet, but the Locke situation was a huge letdown"

Really...like it was way too easy.


Sunny Reynita wrote: "Sorry to hear that the book let you down :("

I just wish it was longer and more complex.


Sunny Julia wrote: "Am totally agreeing with the letdown comments 😢"

Good to know I am not alone. My GR page is filled with raving reviews.


Kacey Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Kacey wrote: "I haven’t finished yet, but the Locke situation was a huge letdown"

Really...like it was way too easy."


Yes! I needed so much more than just that. (view spoiler)


Roshio So disappointing


Paula (She Sniffs Books) Not alone, girl! It was a major disappointment.


Victoria Patton Agreed!


Kylie Blackwell I think I made my review a vent session but yes, couldn’t agree more. So many let downs. She went with safe and easy and stuck to bullet points.


Miranda My thoughts EXACTLY, especially the 180 on Cardan. It was still a fun read but had the first book been written like the last, I wouldn’t have continued on with the series. 🤷‍♀�


MischaS_ Ehm, I could sign under your review...
Basically everything you said.


Sunny Kacey wrote: "Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Kacey wrote: "I haven’t finished yet, but the Locke situation was a huge letdown"

Really...like it was way too easy."

Yes! I needed so much more than just that. [spo..."


Right?! (view spoiler)


Sunny Victoria wrote: "Agreed!"

Paula wrote: "Not alone, girl! It was a major disappointment."

Roshio wrote: "So disappointing"

I thought maybe I was being too hard on this book. But I’m now realizing a lot of people had issues. Good to know I wasn’t going crazy.


Sunny Kylie wrote: "I think I made my review a vent session but yes, couldn’t agree more. So many let downs. She went with safe and easy and stuck to bullet points."

I agree with you. I didn’t think Holly Black of all people would pull punches. There wasn’t enough betrayal and backstabbing in this one like the first two books had. She went too easy with Locke and Taryn especially. Both character arcs went in a completely different direction than I was hoping. They got off too easy.


Sunny Wilde wrote: "I'm seeing a lot of people complaining about how everything seems to be rushed/too short."

It was too short in my opinion. Don’t get me wrong, I dislike books that are unnecessarily long. But there was so much left out.


Sunny Miranda wrote: "My thoughts EXACTLY, especially the 180 on Cardan. It was still a fun read but had the first book been written like the last, I wouldn’t have continued on with the series. 🤷‍♀�"

Exactly. The romance was the most disappointing of all. And it was Cardan’s 180 that made it less fun. I wish she didn’t release it early and took more time to edit and revise it.


Sunny Wilde wrote: "Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Wilde wrote: "I'm seeing a lot of people complaining about how everything seems to be rushed/too short."

It was too short in my opinion. Don’t get me wrong, I dislike..."


Yeah and I was so excited when she moved the publication date up. But now I wish she took more time to write it lol.


Sunny MischaS_ wrote: "Ehm, I could sign under your review...
Basically everything you said."


Makes me happy I’m not alone 😅


MischaS_ You're definitely not the only one! I felt so lonely when I posted my disappointed review cause my feed was flooded by the 5* rating! But I was really surprised by the amount of people who wrote under my review that they agree with me.


Ѳ✨ I actually agree with everything and hadn't thought of a few things you mentioned. Now I'm a bit more disappointed now than before haha


Sunny MischaS_ wrote: "You're definitely not the only one! I felt so lonely when I posted my disappointed review cause my feed was flooded by the 5* rating! But I was really surprised by the amount of people who wrote un..."

Yeah I’m realizing now that many people were disappointed. But as a I scrolled through my feed, I saw literally nothing by four and five stars. So so I thought I was being too hard. I now wish she didn’t release it early. I would’ve gladly waited longer for a better version of this.


Sunny Maria wrote: "I actually agree with everything and hadn't thought of a few things you mentioned. Now I'm a bit more disappointed now than before haha"

Haha oops. There was actually a lot I left out of my review so all my disappointments were not listed lol.


message 29: by Aida (new) - rated it 2 stars

Aida I waited SO DAMN long for this book. I'm so fucking mad Holly didn't put any effort in this. She has proven that she can write kaw dropping plot twists and crazy interesting characters. She was just being lazy with this one and it makes me furious.
You basically said everything on my mind in this review by the way.


Sunny Aida wrote: "I waited SO DAMN long for this book. I'm so fucking mad Holly didn't put any effort in this. She has proven that she can write kaw dropping plot twists and crazy interesting characters. She was jus..."

I feel you. I’ve seen many authors get lazy with their last books lately and I’m not sure why this is. It’s like they already gain success with the first two so why try... All these main characters had so much potential. And every single one of them fell flat.


MischaS_ Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Aida wrote: "I waited SO DAMN long for this book. I'm so fucking mad Holly didn't put any effort in this. She has proven that she can write kaw dropping plot twists and crazy interesting characters..."

Yeah, it used to be the curse of the second book in the series... but lately, to me, it seems like the finales are failing more often than not. And I wonder why's that... maybe the pressure? Of what your fans want and the author suddenly starts to doubt what they planned?
Or maybe they had a great idea for a book, for a series but are unsure how to finish it?


Aishah Ali So damn on point.

Knew it was going to be lacklustre the moment (view spoiler)

So many unanswered things and super anticlimactic. Really shocking how book 1 is like a bloodbath with twists and comparing that to this, this is like a kiddy ride.

I just think either Holly did not know how to end it or wanted to move on to other projects. Which is sad because she definitely could've brought to the table with the same book 1 and 2 quality with this book.


Sunny Aishah wrote: "So damn on point.

Knew it was going to be lacklustre the moment [spoilers removed]

So many unanswered things and super anticlimactic. Really shocking how book 1 is like a bloodbath with twists an..."


For sure! Book 1 was amazing because of all the bloodshed and backstabbing. Book 2 was amazing because of Jude and Cardan’s push and pull as well as the word building and politics. Book 3 didn’t really have anything special. It fell short in all aspects. Madoc was this ruthless and savage person. I don’t like how easily he backed off. You’d think he’d have more backbone than that. Just UGHH. Every character was weakened.


Aishah Ali Sunny ✨wordslikefury� wrote: "Aishah wrote: "So damn on point.

Knew it was going to be lacklustre the moment [spoilers removed]

So many unanswered things and super anticlimactic. Really shocking how book 1 is like a bloodbath..."


Right? It's crazy. Feels like different author and characters. YES! He would never surrender. He wouldve fought till his last breath. Not only him, Queen Orlagh too. Like where she go? I thought theyd have a bigger role. SIGHHHH

Cardan became a plot device. And Jude just lost her spark. A lot of telling and not showing, here too.


Andrea I 100% agree, cardan and Judes relationship was so different in this book and it made me a bit mad also there was a lot of pointless stuff put into this book and the plot was super rushed all in all it disappointed me


Crystal well said!


Summer I'm so happy I didn't pay full price.


Gaby Agree


Divine MY THOUGHTS EXACTLY.


Natalie Same it honestly didn't fell like the last book in the series.


Aoife - Bookish_Babbling 100% same page for all that you said!


Kulsum Finally a 3 star review if this book that I can agree with! I read other 2-3 star review and it was clear it was a hate read for them,like they opened this book knowing they'll hate it because "ugh YA" y'know? which not why I was disappointed and this review put all my feelings in words Thank you!


Sunny Kulsum wrote: "Finally a 3 star review if this book that I can agree with! I read other 2-3 star review and it was clear it was a hate read for them,like they opened this book knowing they'll hate it because "ugh..."

To be honest, I have hate-read some book before. And I do feel kind of iffy with YA books. But I genuinely loved this series. First two book were amazing. And they made me realize that not all of YA is typical and predictable. But the third installment was a major letdown. I still consider this series one of my favorites in YA despite how I felt about this installment.


message 44: by Luna (new) - rated it 2 stars

Luna I was obsessed with Cardan’s and jude’s relationship. It was one of my favorite things about this series. But then THIS???? Wtf, where is the toxic love/hate relationship I came for 😭😭


Sunny Luna wrote: "I was obsessed with Cardan’s and jude’s relationship. It was one of my favorite things about this series. But then THIS???? Wtf, where is the toxic love/hate relationship I came for 😭😭"

Right? Like I didn't need them to act like they did with each other in book 1. But there wasn't even bickering in this book. They were too lovey-dovey for my taste.


Sunny Jess wrote: "Couldn’t agree more about the ending. It was SO cookie cutter? Laughing about being in the human world and learning how to use the self checkout felt totally antithetical to the high stakes (and bl..."

Haha right? And I'm sorry but I couldn't take (view spoiler)


Anouk Schoute I pretend I do not see


Sunny Anouk wrote: "I pretend I do not see"

IM SORRY :omg:


back to top