ŷ

Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs's Reviews > The Idiot

The Idiot by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
70395042
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: currently-reading
Reading for the 2nd time. Most recently started January 9, 2025.

Prince Lev Nicolayevich Myschkin discovered relativity in 1886.

Well, actually the scientific theory of relativity wasn’t discovered until 30 years later, by Albert Einstein, but I don’t think that discovery would have been possible without the relativistic ferment that had started sweeping through Europe in the mid-19th century, with its ultimate CHRISTIAN formulation in The Idiot, in 1886.

Moral chaos is so cataclysmic to conservative spectators. So much so to Prince Myschkin, in fact, that he suffers an enormous three-year nervous collapse. But he comes out of it Reborn.

“Reborn!?� you may say. “Isn’t he just... a little ODD?�

Well listen, if as an intelligent kid you were submitting - along with the rest of intelligent Europe - to the Willy-nilly Transvaluation of all Values, wouldn’t you want to somehow return to your Moral Roots?

And if you didn’t Pooh-Pooh change in any form, like so many mature people do, wouldn’t you try to reason through this enormous alteration in values?

Prince Myschkin does both. He REASONS THROUGH THE CLIMACTERIC OF RADICAL RE-ORIENTATION - from a CHRISTIAN POV.

Something we all should be doing today if we’re believers.

Sure, the sophisticated St Petersburg in-set decides mainly to lead him on - apparent imbecile that he is - into traps of their own devising, but isn’t that what most normal people do today with an oddball: feed him enough rope to hang himself with?

But these worldly sophisticates have a “don’t go there� mindset to new ideas. Unless they’re new FUN ideas. They are intellectually and morally stuck. And so the nutty prince is like a breath of fresh air to them, in a funny sort of way!

Bigotry wasn’t born yesterday. It was born when someone decided to take a small, SAFE pathway through the perils of life. And so many have - alas! - followed him.

But Prince Myschkin has just emerged, barely breathing, from a total moral collapse in a world of ethical relativism. More power to him, I say - at least he’s not scared of the world’s shadows anymore.

For he’s now emerged with a triumphant Christian Faith from the dark chambers of Dis. Into a New, Wide-Awake World.

Myschkin, you see, refuses to JUDGE OTHERS. All his crazy antics are just a logical offshoot of that logically primitive decision.

The basic building block of his, and all true ethical behaviour.

And that’s what makes this book Great.

For this is the portrait of an unlikely modern saint - but it is written with a double-edged pen!

It’s ironical - and it’s not.

Sort of reminds you of the Gospel, doesn’t it?

And, somehow, you know - I think that’s what Dostoevsky intended.
497 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Idiot.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 7, 2019 – Started Reading
February 7, 2019 – Shelved
February 7, 2019 –
5.0% "This Naxos audiobook is excellent!"
May 5, 2019 –
13.0% "Will Prince Myshkin EVER learn that society can open its arms to you - for all the wrong reasons?"
September 6, 2019 – Finished Reading
January 9, 2025 – Started Reading

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by C.S. (new) - added it

C.S. Wachter This has been one of my favorite books from the time I was in high school. I haven't read it in years but after reading your review I long to experience the story again. Thanks.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much! Myschkin has suffered a disconnect with the ordinary world. It’s as if the crisis of epilepsy has broken the outer shell of his psyche, revealing a purity which is consistently misconstrued by his interlocutors.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Please take it S-L-O-W-L-Y! Myschkin suffers quite unawares through hard sophisticated drubbing after drubbing, and the effect is discombobulating for the reader - if we don’t double over in embarrassed sympathy for the well-meaning and harmless man! But man oh man, he SHINES through it all - truly an Old Soul.


message 4: by Shainlock (new)

Shainlock I really enjoyed reading your thoughts Fergus. I read them and the book became clear. Pretty cool. 🙏🏻 thanks.


message 5: by Electra (new)

Electra I love this book !


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs TYSM, ladies! I think also of William Barrett, speaking of early Existentialists in Irrational Man: these guys had to swallow the Fact of their Deaths whole, and in so doing liberated their souls to face the Beyond without frills. Myschkin’s illness does this for him, and Liberates his Spirit! He becomes a Pure Anomaly.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, LK.! Myschkin by turns fascinates, then bores, then angers his listeners. Why can’t this guy be NORMAL? they ask. Because his illness has exposed his raw nerve endings, is why!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs I only hope you do - its effect is HUGE! Enjoy, LK.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Nicola! Prince Myschkin speaks from the Heart. It’s really too bad, though, because it’s a language everyone else has Forgotten! Either that, or ever so politely demurs to remember - because it causes them too much grief. Hence, by some abstruse and affectively-charged logic, he’s simply an idiot...
This is a masterpiece!


message 10: by Karina (new)

Karina I wish I could write like you. You are so amazing at it! You could sell me whatever you're selling. Sure, Fergus, how much? Lol.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs All I’ve done is lay my heart on the line in what I write. I could do that only because I truly believe these things are worth saying out loud!


message 12: by Karina (new)

Karina ❤❤❤👍🏻👍🏻👍�


message 13: by Ned (new) - added it

Ned You really really make me want to get it off the shelf and read it, that’s the flattery you get from me. Thanks for the free brilliance, it could only come from the heart...


message 14: by Ned (new) - added it

Ned NNTR, I’m quite certain (?) that’s not what you seek


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Ned, whenever I see a note pop up of a comment from you, I look forward to reading it! Your comments are singularly wonderful. TYSM.


Sharon Barrow Wilfong Wonderful review!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks so much, Sharon! So many of us find so often that we’re totally misunderstood. But the Prince has found safe haven in faith.


message 18: by Madeleine (new)

Madeleine Myers Dostoevsky is so amazing--he is so subtle in his Christian themes, but so deeply penetrates what Faulkner calls "the old verities"--love and pity and pride and compassion and sacrifice. He knows the human heart so well, and like most of our greatest literature, art, and music, can be revisited over and again and each time some new insights are revealed. I read The Idiot over 50 years ago. Myshkin had my deep sympathies then because I suffered from migraines. Time to revisit and learn new things. Another great review, Fergus!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs That’s extremely kind of you, Madeleine - and I so relish the effusive enthusiasm of your replies! And your parallel with Faulkner is so well taken.


message 20: by Josephine (new)

Josephine Briggs I haven't read this book, but I have read others by Dostoevsky. His books are excellent. I might have to try this one.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs It’s quite long, and can be a real tough slog, what with Myshkin’s interminable madcap meanderings. I found the best format - and happiest medium - was in the premium audiobook I picked up with an Audible credit!


message 22: by Balu (new) - rated it 5 stars

Balu Amazing review as always Fergus! The Idiot is my all times favorite novel.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs It says so much: Dostoevsky reaches us at such an unfamiliar level here. Thanks so much, Alan, for your enthusiasm & your complimentary words!


message 24: by Balu (new) - rated it 5 stars

Balu Just wondering, Fergus, how did you like The Resurrection by Tolstoy if you've read it?


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs That one’s on my to-read list! With a great club like GR, it seems impossible to get to them all...


message 26: by Tg (new)

Tg Thanks Fergus, You are executing the Admiral Stockdale Reading Curriculum to perfection--These are the type of readings he had for Up and coming Mid-Career officers at the Naval War College.
I actually attended the Strategy and Policy course there in 2007.
I really think these existential readings about Morality and Religion should be given to beginning Officers.
We are all works in progress, thanks for fanning the flames of human potential....


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs So great of you to leave such wonderful comments, Tg! I had no clue you attended Stockdale’s alma mater. You amaze me!


message 28: by Tg (new)

Tg Thanks Fergus......


Warren Fournier You managed to put things into perspective on perhaps my most-studied and favorite book of all time. Great thoughts on a great book!


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, Warren. It’s all due to my identification to the poor prince. Alas, I could relate, being an ingenuous Aspie - and for that reason cringed and winced throughout the book!


Sanjana I didn't like this book at all. But I like your review :D


Iluvatar . I believe this one to be superior to Crime & P


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Thanks, folks! Dostoevsky disjoints and discomfits us all with his gem - your credentials are questioned whether you're a Myshkin - or you're one of the woke flies in his ointment! I think what the writer is telling us is that there's no Rest for either the wicked or the wacky in this world...


back to top