ŷ

karen's Reviews > Malorie

Malorie by Josh Malerman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
45618
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: from-publisher-or-author, live-through-this

oooh, goodreads choice awards finalist for best horror 2020! what will happen?

possible oblique spoilers for Bird Box.

i wouldn't have thought that Bird Box needed a sequel six years later (and 2 years after the disappointing—YEAH, I SAID IT—netflix adaptation), but here we are and here it is and honestly? i thought it was great. when i first read Bird Box, the premise blew me away; answering the question, "what if lovecraft was actually scary?" by centering a horror novel around an unfaaathomable beastie, or species of beastie, that broke the mind, driving anyone who looked even indirectly at one into an uncontrollable homicidal and suicidal frenzy, causing...everything that happened in Bird Box.

this picks up seventeen years later, where survivors are still living behind closed eyes so they don't see any creatures, always at risk of being berserker-murdered by someone else's having seen a creature.

what breaks MY mind to think about it is that, in a situation like this, the threat could have passed and you would have NO WAY OF KNOWING. there you’d be, long after all the creatures had died or moved on, blindfolded and stumbling through what remained of the world making life harder for yourself for no reason. ‘course, you could also be here in this sequel, more than a decade after the creatures appeared and think “surely i am safe by now,� and risk a peek and OH NOOOOO!

i would not last very long at all, with my poor sense of time, fear of the dark and dislike of vulnerability. it would be the biggest fomo of all; i’d be convinced that i was the only person still blindfolded whilst everyone else in the world was frolicking around unencumbered, either laughing silently at me behind their hands while they looted all the good shit or creeping up behind me creeping up behind me creeping up behind me NO, BLINDFOLD OFF NOW!

ANYWAY, BACK TO BOOK

people more stalwart and patient than i am have adapted to living alongside these monsters—whose presence can be sensed if not seen—but all things evolve, and since the creatures have been thriving and increasing in number all these years, it's a bit concerning.

and no one is more concerned about the creatures than malorie.

after fleeing the place they ended up at the end of Bird Box under spectacularly unpleasant circumstances, malorie and her children have spent the past ten years living quietly and simply in an isolated farmhouse, where she has become the very incarnation of the concept of surviving without living, or in her words—having become a living blindfold; her days entirely consumed by establishing routines and rules to protect herself and the children, her safety measures increasing rather than relaxing over the years.

olympia and tom are now teenagers, and they've never lived in a world that was safe enough to actually see. olympia's understanding of human behavior and how the world used to be has come from novels, while tom is more interested in the future, restless with longing to be somewhere else, somewhere people are making scientific advancements and finding ways to live in—and even look at—this monsterfilled world. he's a teenager, so he knows everything, and he's a rebellious little scamp, impatient with his mother's overcautious paranoia and her strangling apronstrings.

fortunately, something occurs that gives them all the opportunity to meet new people and experience new things. unfortunately, THE WORLD IS FILLED WITH MONSTERS.

it's a smart and shivery horror novel, and re-reading it now in mid-pandemic isolation has added an extra level of horror onto the situation for me, the experience of watching a global health crisis unfold and fundamentally change the way people live; keeping them apart, limiting their movements, sacrificing their freedom—swap out a blindfold for a surgical mask and we're all malorie; threatened by some new monster we don't know how to stop (yet), not knowing how long it will last, how much damage it will do, when its next wave will hit and what fresh hells that will bring. and out there, there're the same range of precautions and reactions—some people aren't even wearing gloves while others are out walking their dogs in full-on gas masks with layers of plastic trash bags over the rest of them and some people have gone mad and are yelling with anachronistic fury at actors on the teevee screen, "STOP TOUCHING YOUR FACE! STOP TOUCHING EACH OTHER! DON'T GO OUTSIDE, YOU FOOL!" where a and c are me.

but here's the thing—josh malerman created the hellscape of Bird Box and ended it on a positive cautiously optimistic note. and this sequel balances the monster-horror with themes of family and future and progress and hope and *spoiler alert* it does not end in complete soul-crushing despair.

so maybe we'll get through this.
stay cautiously optimistic with me.

**

well, look at this!

wait, no—i mean DON'T look at this. AAAAAAAAHHHHH COVER YOUR DAMN EYES!!!




356 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Malorie.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 22, 2019 – Shelved
March 7, 2020 – Started Reading
March 9, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea Humphrey Instead of Beyoncé telling her ladies to get into formation, she’s going to tell everyone to blindfolds up-but make it fashion!


Bradley DAMN IT! I just looked! ; ;


karen beyoncé will save us all!


message 4: by Rae (new) - added it

Rae Yassss!! I totally read the title as a creature whispering... M A L O R I E

Also if Netflix does another movie, I *need* one of the kids, any kid, to do a crazy, creepy version of
"mom, are you looking?!"


Hilary "Fox" I have no idea how a sequel would work but I 100% will read it...


karen i want it to be from the monsters' point of view. and they're all "why are you hitting yourself??? why are you hitting yourself???" and laughing like bullies.


Hilary "Fox" karen wrote: "i want it to be from the monsters' point of view. and they're all "why are you hitting yourself??? why are you hitting yourself???" and laughing like bullies."

...I'd read that so much.


message 8: by Erin (new)

Erin Shut. Up. I had no idea there’d be a sequel but I’m here for it!!


karen i know! this came outta nowhere!!


message 10: by Christine (new)

Christine Hahaha!


message 11: by Linda (new) - added it

Linda Byers Hahaha. What to make of this Karen?


karen WHAT INDEED?


James Omg karen


message 14: by Kara (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kara Can't wait to read this!


message 15: by Ellen Gail (new) - added it

Ellen Gail I will also say it - the Netflix adaptation was a huge letdown! It felt like Sandy was giving it her all, but the whole thing just fell flat.

Glad to hear the sequel is good! Also, this: "swap out a blindfold for a surgical mask and we're all malorie." That's just a fucking good sentence, and I felt the need to point that out.


karen i was so excited for it - john malkovich AND b.d. wong? YES PLEASE! and it was good for a while, but once it started going downhill, it was terrible and that whole river scene...wow and no and wow.

i hope this thing still comes out when it's scheduled to - all of publishing is breaking down so who even knows anymore. but fingers crossed and thank you very much and stay safe! �


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ I fell asleep halfway through the Netflix movie and never bothered to finish it.
And Bird Box was one of the easiest 5 stars I’ve ever given ever.


message 18: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen  Saciuk The book was so much better!


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ I preordered this one and should come today. I am so excited. I just re-read Bird Box and I have to agree with you, reading that novel during quarantine and a pandemic was really really weird. Because our world was mirroring their world at the beginning of Bird Box. The way Malerman predicted how a worldwide pandemic of sorts would happen was actually very very accurate. And I kept thinking while reading that if you swapped out blindfolds for face masks, this is our world. Crazy!


karen ooof, yes. between this, Survivor Song, and The Down Days, i made some EXCELLENT reading choices during pandemictimes. too many people predicting too many things i ended up experiencing.


message 21: by Theresa (new) - added it

Theresa "the disappointing—YEAH, I SAID IT—netflix adaptation"
YES THANK YOU!! I thought I was the only one who felt this way!


karen nope!! this thread is a safe place for that kind of thinking! there are several of us!


message 23: by Tara (new) - added it

Tara Great review. I loved Bird Box and never saw the film though looks like it might be a good thing! In any case, do want to read this, especially after your review. Amazing he's a musician yet has the visual as well.


karen i've never sought out his music, but i've read everything i could get my hands on. still mad about that expensive pig book. ):


message 25: by Tara (new) - added it

Tara karen wrote: "i've never sought out his music, but i've read everything i could get my hands on. still mad about that expensive pig book. ):"

:-0!


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ karen wrote: "i've never sought out his music, but i've read everything i could get my hands on. still mad about that expensive pig book. ):"

His music is really kinda cool weirdish indie sound and reminds me of kinda a Fratellis meets The Flaming Lips. If you've ever seen the show Shameless, his band plays the theme song called The Luck You Got. I looked up his band right after I read Bird Box and still listen to his music! Talented guy!


karen well, there's something for my to-do list, thanks!


message 28: by Diana (new) - added it

Diana Brown I loved the film but yes, the book was better


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ Just finished it and GAH! The emotions, the feels, the thoughts!!!

Reading it amidst an actual pandemic is very weird. Because it becomes almost like an exaggerated allegory for what we are living in right now. But (view spoiler)


karen watch for that in 'our' world in a month or so.


Jess ❈Harbinger of Blood-Soaked Rainbows❈ It’s already happening where I live.


karen OHNO


Betty Lopez I saw the movie but hadn't read the book yet but I will might as well. I found Malorie by chance at the library, I was looking for a book to read and it was available so I'll read it and then read the Bird Box lol yes I'm backwards.


karen haahah yeah, you're gonna be so discombobulated!


Betty Lopez I finished the book. Not too bad.


message 36: by Linda (new) - added it

Linda Byers Great review. I was holding back but I'll read it now.


ErinFlight Thanks for the review. I just recently read, and was a bit disappointed by Malerman's other recent-ish book "Black Mad Wheel". And I was wondering if maybe this book was released because of the movie, ant not necessarily because Malerman had more he wanted to do with the world. But your review makes it sound like it's definitely worth a try! I always love it when books show us horror over a longer scale, its hard to do well but great when someone really pulls it off.


message 38: by Jen (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jen Brilliant and spot-on review!


Michelle D Yes! I finally read the first book during intial lockdown and it was terrifying the comparisons my mind made. I loved the first book and it got me back into reading more. I watched the Netflix adaptation a month or so later, never one to be caught up in fads when it was first popular, and complained the whole time. What a waste of a talented cast on that garbage. How did it ever gain popularity? I just finished and loved the Malorie sequel as well but wasn't sure I liked the neatly tied up ending. Don't get me wrong I'm glad it wasn't a cliff hanger haha. But I do love your analogy and comparison to it giving us some hope back after such a brutal blow and life for these characters. And yes right now it feels like "we are all Malorie" or some other character on this spectrum. Thank you!


Betty Lopez I read both and was actually hoping they make a movie out of Malorie


message 41: by Tara (new) - added it

Tara I watched the movie with my husband and son this Christmas. If you see the bad reviews and don't have expectations nor read the book, I think the movie is actually really good. Maybe why it did so well. Anyway, hoping to get to this sequel in paperback and see a sequel movie. I love Sandra Bullock in just about anything.


karen i think the movie started off strong, but by the end even sandy couldn't save the day for me. but i acknowledge that it's a hard book to adapt, so hats off for the parts that were done well.


message 43: by Tara (new) - added it

Tara karen wrote: "i think the movie started off strong, but by the end even sandy couldn't save the day for me. but i acknowledge that it's a hard book to adapt, so hats off for the parts that were done well."

Yeah, wasn't thrilled with ending and didn't like that they beefed up romance. But that is Hollywood...loved the kids.


message 44: by Ethan (new)

Ethan This book GREAT.It made me scared of being alone thinking the aliens in the book would just appear and look me in the eye than make me go mad!


message 45: by AquaMoon (new)

AquaMoon Sounds like someone needs to open a Monster Rescue, possibly one with a Trap-Fix-Release option for those that are so feral they cannot be rehomed.


karen they always find their way back


Hilary "Fox" Holy shit, I finally got around to reading this and I really enjoyed it


karen yeah yeah yeah!!! pretty good, right?


Hilary "Fox" karen wrote: "yeah yeah yeah!!! pretty good, right?"

Read it in a single day and nearly a single sitting. Definitely a few creepy scenes that chilled me. At one point I literally said "oh no" outloud while reading it... Gotta love THAT.


karen oh, that's the BEST. i love it when books give me vocal reactions.


back to top