Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Smokey's Reviews > Gates of Fire

Gates of Fire by Steven Pressfield
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
540802
's review

it was amazing

Soldiers are philosophers by trade, as opposed to nature. Whether they are gifted logicians or readers or not, their profession demands a close association with death and life, fear and courage, love and hate, joy and sorrow. A soldier gets acquainted with these, not as abstract ideas, but as intimate realities which are a part of the day-to-day environment.

When faced with such larger-than-life concepts, though, words often fail, no matter how important or meaningful a place they hold in every day life. I've tried once or twice to put some of this/these into words myself, because I felt a need to share with people outside my line of work just what it is that goes through our heads. We service-folk aren't mythical or demonic, we aren't legendary or infamous, we are neither "The Greatest Generation," nor the worst. But having tried to communicate something of what I've seen and felt, I realize now just why so many who served so honorably chose to remain so silent as to their experiences.

This book, Gates of Fire, says all of those things I couldn't say.

As you may guess, the book centers upon the Battle of Thermopylae, the same subject as the movie 300. As you read through the book, you will see why that movie treated it the way it did. The heroism on display at that time in that place makes any comic book superhero look silly by comparison; it's only natural that Leonidas & Co. should have their own line of action figures. Seriously.

But the book goes further than just the names, dates, and places; it is not "history" in the strictest sense, though it strives for such accuracy as historical records can offer. More so Gates of Fire delves into the why and the wherefore: why did these men go, knowing they would die? how were they able to stand and fight knowing that eventually they would be butchered where they stood? what could possibly have motivated the greatest "Alamo" the world has ever known? The book excels in this effort, bringing the concepts of the heroic into terms that the average reader can immediately grasp, or at least imagine.

The book also shows quite graphically the scenes of warfare. As one seasoned veteran asks a shaken youngster "What did you expect? What sort of wounds did you suppose the sword and spear would cause?" But it also shows in painful detail the moments of poignancy: the moments spent at home with loved ones, carved indelibly into the soldiers' hearts; the moments after the battle when soldiers realize they have survived the carnage to live once again; the unbelievable courage of the families they leave behind.

I have never marched in a phalanx with spear and shield. I have never truly closed with the enemy, or grappled with him in anger. But if you want to know what a soldier thinks, lives, and feels, read this book. The times and technologies have changed, but the principles have really not. Thank you, Mr. Pressfield for writing this.
31 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Gates of Fire.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
July 1, 2008 – Finished Reading
July 20, 2008 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by E_Collins :) (new)

E_Collins :) yup. pretty strong language. i dont care. great summary of the battle.


Smokey Strong language seems to be endemic to a soldier's existence, today anyway. Less crudity would have lead to a less illustrative story, harsh as it gets sometimes.

Thanks for the props!


Lady of the Lake Your review is excellent. It shows the timesless aspect of this story, this book. I am the wife of a veteran, a soldier, and your words hold such truth.


Smokey It's not a pure "history" book, and that will turn some purists away, but the realities presented are valid nonetheless. Also, one can realistically make the argument that those men fought for us today, as much as for their own homes and lands and masters. Without their sacrifice, history takes a MUCH different turn.

Thank you, Ma'am, for your service, and for his. *salutes*


Lady of the Lake Oh, I am sorry I realize now that my post doesn't read well, I am not a soldier, just the proud wife of one! Nevertheless, I thank you on his behalf, just the same.
I also believe, that with any work of Historical Fiction that there are people who don't get the word FICTION in it...It is possible to take the facts, use them accurately as well as add fictionalized personalities to it and be able to tell a good story. Obviously, any personal exchange in a HF work, is the result of a good authors mind. Why someone would read HF and then go on to complain that it isn't pure non-fiction, as I see often, is beyond me.


Smokey Those who serve at home, serve nonetheless. (Another portion of the book that I thought was absolutely accurate, and at times, heart-breaking.) So my comment stands. :D


message 7: by Brittany B. (new)

Brittany B. Wow! Insightful and Eloquent review!! :)


message 8: by Smokey (last edited Mar 05, 2013 10:05PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Smokey Thank you very much. :)

Sometimes you just stumble across something that should be required reading, not only for its historical context, but also because it's just a good, thought-provoking story. I would, in all seriousness, put this one right next to The Red Badge of Courage without blinking.


Randy We'll said, sir.


Jeffrey Whitney Awe-inspiring synopsis!


back to top