Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Katia N's Reviews > Ali and Nino

Ali and Nino by Kurban Said
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7381993
's review

really liked it

Ali and Nino would be a quite convential written love story apart from a few facts. Firstly, the book is set in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan, oil-reach trans-Caucasian country which many people would not be able place on the map. The time frame is the turbulent beginning of the last century, the first oil boom, the Russian revolution, the Young Turks and the fall of Osman empire are just a few cataclysms affecting the region. Secondly, the author of the book is unknown. The book is written from the perspective of Ali, the young and rich Muslim Prince. But the most likely author is a Jewish exile in Europe Lev Nisselbaum who has converted into Islam during his time in Germany and was known there as Essad-Bey. And lastly, the book was first published in 1937 in Germany - very unusual place and time for such a novel.

I would recommend to read this book if you are interested in the atmosphere and the history of the place. The book is brilliant in describing the Caucasian region at the beginning of the last century. I could not stop but feeling that the destiny of Caucasus falling under the Soviet rule was not inevitable at all. Instead it was the one of the cruel cards served to the region in geopolitical games between the big powers. Obviously a bit idealised, but Baku is described as a cosmopolitan vibrant rich city where Muslims, Christians and foreigners live together in a relative piece. It was the fringe of the Russian Empire before the revolution. However, strong case for the independence of the region really existed when the Empire has started to crumble. Apart from Azerbaijan the main characters take us to Iran, Georgia and Dagestan. The sense of place is always vivid: Georgian hospitality, Persian sleepiness at the time, the simple life with the elements in a mountain village in Dagestan. One can learn a lot of history in this slim novel. There is also a powerful insight into a Muslim’s male mind. The main character is in love with the Georgian girl who is obviously Christian, cosmopolitan and does not want to compromise her identity beyond a certain measure. She, for example refuses, to cover her face. He, on the other hand, is trying to understand better where are the limits of his faith.

This is very ancient enigmatic region. Armenia and Georgia existed well before any concept of Europe. There predated the Byzantine Empire as well and were the ones of the first places in the world adopting Christianity. Azerbaijan was the part of Persia, I believe. That is why they are Shiite Muslims. The book and the stories within it have resonated with me on personal level. It reminded me the well forgotten trip of my youth. The one of my first ever trips in fact. When I was 16, the group from my school, has travelled on the train from Kiev to Baku. The train journey took 70 hours one way. When we arrived in Baku I felt that the ground literally moved under my feet for a day after that train’s vibration. But before we arrived, we experienced a lot of cultural shocks. The group contained around 6 girls. On the last day of our journey, two things happened. First, we have seen the desert and proper caravan of camels travelling behind the windows of the train. I had an impression the caravan was going quicker than we. Secondly, our group leader, the young man of around 25 was approached by the group of Azerbaijani looking men with the business offer to sell us (6 girls) for a good price. Fortunately, we did not know what the men were talking about. But they look very amiable and smiling. Again, fortunately for us, our group leader has rejected their proposition saying he needs us for other things. The simple word of our leader seemed to be more powerful than the legal aspect of the suggested proceedings. So we were left alone, at least for a time being. The city, when we arrived seemed empty, the powerful winds were blown alone the streets. So when Baku was mentioned as a city of winds in the novel, it brought back a vivid memory. We’ve seen the Maiden tower - beautiful medieval construction which is as well mentioned in the book. We did not venture far enough without our sympathetic young local guide. But he took us into very weird places like an illegal leather shop. It was the time when the shelves of the proper shops were totally empty anywhere in the disintegrating Soviet Union. So he probably wanted to please us. But we did not have money anyway. We’ve also visited a Chikhana - the place where men only were having tea from very small cups while biting sugar stones. What was also striking how friendly the people were towards each other. One might stop a trolleybus anywhere by just raising a hand. It was the end pf 1989 I believe. We left and in a few months Baku has become a centre of the bloody events . I could not believe the news. The last time something similar took place was the time of Ali and Nino.

Ok, back to the book. The life story of its alleged writer, Lev Nisselbaum was so dramatic that it was become the subject of the book itself The Orientalist: Solving the Mystery of a Strange and Dangerous Life. The american journalist Tom Reiss has followed the traces of Lev from Baku to Berlin and later to Italy were Lev died prematurely in 1942. Someone called "Ali and Nino� Azerbaijan’s “Doctor Zhivago�. There are certainly a lot of similarities. However, the Pasternak’s book is much stronger work of literature. “Ali and Nino� is a profound document to the time and place, very moving, but the storytelling is relatively straightforward and a bit of overdramatising sometimes. However, it contains a lot of interesting details about the cataclysms in the region and a moving love story. I personally was also grateful for the opportunity of re-living some moments of my 16-year old self which the book has dogged out from my memory.
15 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Ali and Nino.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 11, 2019 – Started Reading
April 11, 2019 – Shelved
April 17, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Antonomasia (new)

Antonomasia Fascinating. Thank you for including the anecdote about the trip to Baku.


Katia N Thank you for reading such s long review. Yes. It was very memorable experience of my teens. It is a pity I have not been back there. It would be interesting to compare. But the book is quite worthy on its own. I liked especially the part set out in Iran when nino is not allowed out of harem and has got a eunuch assigned to look after her and check her teeth. For me it was beyond my limited imagination.


message 3: by Antonomasia (last edited May 03, 2019 01:43AM) (new)

Antonomasia Not that long! I have a lot of reviews to catch up on from the last couple of months, hence all the likes in one go just now.


message 4: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse When I noticed your rating of this book a few days ago and read the blurb, I had added this book to the list tbr even before you posted your splendid review, Katia - how interesting what you write on its alleged writer, and on the region it is set having such a fascinating history. Wonderful how this book transported you back in time and place, I enjoyed reading your travel memories a lot and sigh with relief you weren't sold there :-)! Svetlana Alexievich's Secondhand Time had a haunting testimony of one of the victims of the Baku pogrom, thank you for that enlightening link.


Katia N Antonomasia wrote: "Not that long! I have a lot of reviews to catch up on from the last couple of months, hence all the likes in one go just now."

Oh thank you for paying attention. I think Stone upon Stone might be of interest to you - fantastic book and such a unique perspective. Btw, I've finished the Remainder following your nudge and enjoyed it. But still have not be able to finish the review as it has sent me into the tour of the Latin American literature which I cannot stop. I've read a lot from that Continent before but not for a few years. And it is so enjoyable reading all this books with the writers not caring about the plot, story arc, fiction/non-fiction etc, - feeling like coming home.


message 6: by Antonomasia (new)

Antonomasia Yes, I've had a copy of Stone Upon Stone for a few years now. I first learnt of it because it won the BTBA the year before I started using the old Mookse and Gripes forum, and it was very highly regarded on there.

Glad you are enjoying the Latin American literature. I am hoping to read more of it, and Spanish lit, this year. The Latin American and Arabic books on the MBI longlist proved a good springboard and made me want to do this, when it had previously been more of a "should".


Katia N Ilse wrote: "When I noticed your rating of this book a few days ago and read the blurb, I had added this book to the list tbr even before you posted your splendid review, Katia - how interesting what you write ..."

Thank you, dear Ilse. Yes it is really good little novel. I hope you will enjoy it. It certainly transports the reader into a very different reality and it is told by the person who has been there (at least as far as anyone could know). The related non-fiction book The Orientalist: Solving the Mystery of a Strange and Dangerous Life I've also read is very detailed and panoramic in its scope covering pre-revolutionary Russia, Weimar republic and many other fascinating subject. Lev seemed to be a very charismatic if a little eccentric man and his destiny is almost unbelievable. He was a refugee from Bolshevik Russia to Germany, a Jew converted to Islam and managed to die in Fascist Italy from a disease, not persecution at the age of 42 after writing around 30 books.


Katia N Antonomasia wrote: "Yes, I've had a copy of Stone Upon Stone for a few years now. I first learnt of it because it won the BTBA the year before I started using the old Mookse and Gripes forum, and it was very highly re..."

Well, I hope you would have a chance to pick it up one day. The translation is a bit american, but wonderful nevertheless. And the book is very different from anything Ive read by the Poles before (well, not a lot, I have to admit unfortunately).

Good luck with the your reading quest whenever it would take you. Hopefully you would enjoy the Latin Americans. The Arabs is very interesting area too. I've bought "Celestial bodies" and it looks good. I still want to read the collection of short stories by Hassan Blasim. I will look forward to your reviews as you always have this wonderfully unique personal take in them.


message 9: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala This would have been an interesting review even if it had remained a conventional one, Katia, but your account of your trip to Baku lifted it way beyond the conventional. So good!
I've been fascinated by Baku ever since a friend told me stories of her great-grandparent's lives there. And she recommended this book too, so now, with the added incentive of your review, I'll definitely read it.
And having read the excellent comment thread, I feel I'll have to add the story of the book's author too....


Katia N Fionnuala wrote: "This would have been an interesting review even if it had remained a conventional one, Katia, but your account of your trip to Baku lifted it way beyond the conventional. So good!
I've been fascin..."


Thank you, dear Fionnuala. We've just cross-posted. It is a very fascinating story indeed. Another thing, i am not sure i mentioned above is that it is appeared first in German and the german woman who kept the manuscript said she has written it herself. So the authorship is still not confirmed 100%.


message 11: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala The doubt about the author kind of adds to the fascination for me, Katia.


Katia N Fionnuala wrote: "The doubt about the author kind of adds to the fascination for me, Katia."

Lets see what you think when it comes to it. There is certainly a lot of atmosphere there and quite a bit of a backstory.


message 13: by Quo (new) - rated it 4 stars

Quo Baku is a fascinating place on the Caspian Sea & so different from Georgia, Armenia or Iran, all of which I visited about 5 years ago. Off to the distance of the old section of Baku are amazing new towers, including one the evokes a flame. Big money is definitely afoot in Azerbaijan but it retains an old-world feel in spite of that.

Ali & Nino is a charming little novel & the story of its parentage is almost as mysterious as the love between the Romeo & Juliet couple who are the focus of the book. Also there is a woman who edits the Azerbaijan journal & who I suspect knows more about the novel than anyone, Mr. Reiss included. If interested, I will send her email contact. Both Tbilisi in Georgia & especially Baku seem to have taken the book to heart. Bill


Katia N Quo wrote: "Baku is a fascinating place on the Caspian Sea & so different from Georgia, Armenia or Iran, all of which I visited about 5 years ago. Off to the distance of the old section of Baku are amazing new..."

Thank you very much for sharing your thoughts and impressions, Bill. I am sure Baku has changed dramatically since I've been there in 1989. This book was quite unique as it brought the sweet memories of my teens:-) I am glad you've met lovely people there. It was my experience as well. I will get in touch if I would decide to know more about this book. It is fascinating that the identity of the author is still not totally proven.


back to top