Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

William2's Reviews > 10:04

10 by Ben Lerner
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4684009
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 21-ce, fiction, us, new-york

The narrator is a millennial, a successful writer, a valetudinarian. There’s no plot. The novel’s character and verbiage driven. He likes multisyllabic words but don’t we all? He drives around Brooklyn and Manhattan. He takes the subway. He walks to a bar in DUMBO to see vaguely realized friends. He lends an activist the use of his shower and cooks a meal for him. He fucks a woman who immediately rejects him. He has heart problems. He sees the need for reform of capitalism, and praises the Park Slope Food Coop. There are a few unfortunate sentences:

“Is that why you’ve exchanged a modernist valorization of difficulty as a mode of resistance to the market for the fantasy of coeval readership?� (p. 93)

Another show-stopper: “Only an urban experience of the sublime was available to me because only then was the greatness beyond calculation the intuition of community.� (p. 108)

These are what I think of as dream killers if, indeed, as John Gardner said, the narrative is the dream. But ultimately in a text so brilliant they’re momentary untowardnesses. Like a growling stomach at a wedding. What I especially like is Lerner’s ability to take relatively recent news events—like the New York Times’s story that Park Avenue Co-op members were sending their nannies to do their monthly labor (2011)—and fearlessly incorporate them into the story. And I thought Ali Smith was rushing things.

“It was the kind of exchange, although exchange isn’t really the word, with which I‘d grown familiar, a new bio-political vocabulary for expressing racial and class anxiety: instead of claiming brown and black people were biologically inferior, you claimed they were � for reasons you sympathized with, reasons that weren’t really their fault � compromised by the food and drink they ingested; all those artificial dyes had darkened them on the inside. Your child, who had never so much as sipped a high fructose carbonated beverage containing phosphoric acid and E150d, was a more sensitive instrument: purer, smarter, free of violence. This way of thinking allowed one to deploy the vocabularies of sixties radicalism � ecological awareness, anticorporate agitation, etc. � in order to justify the reproduction of social inequality. It allowed you to redescribe the caring for your own genetic material � feeding Lucas the latest in coagulated soy juice � as altruism: it’s not just good for Lucas, it’s good for the planet. But from those who out of ignorance or desperation have allowed their children’s digestive tracts to know deep-fried, chemically processed chicken, those who happen to be, in Brooklyn, disproportionately black and Latino, Lucas must be protected at whatever cost.� (p. 98)

There’s much more here I’m not touching on. Climate Change—Hurricane Sandy; to become or not to become a father; a writer’s residency in Marfa, etc. It’s highly autobiographical. There’s too much post modernist hoodoo but the satire is brilliant. I think it an excellent novel of New York literary life. Others that spring to mind include Sigrid Nunez’s recent The Friend and Edmund White’s harrowing The Farewell Symphony.
61 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read 10.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 15, 2019 – Shelved
April 15, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
April 15, 2019 – Shelved as: 21-ce
April 15, 2019 – Shelved as: us
April 15, 2019 – Shelved as: fiction
May 27, 2019 – Started Reading
July 1, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
January 22, 2020 – Finished Reading
January 26, 2020 – Shelved as: new-york

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Andrew Guthrie This is by Ben Lerner, who was a poet previous to 2 novels. This is his second, which is far superior to the first, which shares what you call "no plot", but with far more self-deprecating humor. I became interested in Lerner through his non-fiction "The Hatred of Poetry" of which I wrote a review (if you care to read it)


William2 Thank you for your comment Andrew


message 3: by Romaissa (new)

Romaissa Bellaoui A personnal question please..
How many book u read by a week?


William2 One per week, Romaissa.


message 5: by Romaissa (new)

Romaissa Bellaoui Good.. i need more than 7 days on week to catch u.. bonne continuation


William2 I accept the challenge with honor. :-)


message 7: by Susan (new) - added it

Susan I may just give up reading to read your reviews! Love your word choices and perspective.


William2 Thank you, Susan. Quite a compliment!


message 9: by Emmett (new)

Emmett Grogan "These are what I think of as dream killers if, indeed, as John Gardner said, the narrative is the dream. But ultimately in a text so brilliant they’re momentary untowardnesses. Like a growling stomach at a wedding." That is both the sharpest critique AND best rebuttal of an aforementioned critique I have ever read -- in the SAME PARAGRAPH. Bravo! (I especially like the use of a wedding as the event being unceremoniously interrupted by a growling stomach. Spot on! So vivid! Haven't we all been there, at one time?)


William2 Thanks, Emmett.


back to top