Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Steven Godin's Reviews > The Passion According to G.H.

The Passion According to G.H. by Clarice Lispector
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
26706841
's review

liked it
bookshelves: fiction, latin-america


After recently being blown away by Lispector's The Hour of the Star I was hoping for more of the same with this, but ended up finding it a far more difficult nut to crack. She takes the most banal of situations involving a woman alone in a room with a cockroach and turns it into a sort of philosophical exploration. There is some Camus in there, Sartre too, and yes even Kafka.
The setting maybe a single room but it is as much taking place within the human soul. Through G.H. the first-person narrator, Lispector jousts with language playfully, but forcefully examining the ambiguous nature of words resulted in a range that went from the disturbing to the profound to the pretentious. The existential crisis theme is blended with an experimental edge that I found just went too far. It's plotless narrative will likely mean it's one for those with erudite tastes rather than the wider masses. Lispector further expands the reach of her text with networks of metaphor, and makes language the medium of both imprisonment and liberation. It has the feel of a manual for meditation, a set of spiritual exercises leading to new plane of being, a more authentic relation with the world, one self, and others. She certainly does everything with a European touch, and roots her French imports deep into the Brazilian soil. The result was a provocative hybrid of both fascination and bewilderment. It will likely leave those who have a fear of confined spaces and blattodea insects with clammy hands.
90 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Passion According to G.H..
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 28, 2019 – Started Reading
April 28, 2019 – Shelved
May 2, 2019 –
page 39
18.75% "My heart turned white like hairs turn white, up against the face I had thrust
through the opening, right next to my eyes, in the semidarkness, the heavy cockroach moved. My scream was so muffled that it was only by the contrast with the silence that I realised I hadn't screamed. The scream had stayed inside my chest."
May 6, 2019 –
page 66
31.73% "I opened my mouth in fright: to ask for help. Why? because I did not want to become impure like the cockroach? what ideal held me to the sensing of an idea? why should I not make myself impure, exactly as I was revealing my whole self? What was I afraid of? being impure with what?"
May 9, 2019 –
page 183
87.98% "What I am now feeling is a happiness. Through the live cockroach I am coming to understand that I too am that which lives. To live is a very high stage, it is something I have just now attained. It is so high an unstable equilibrium that I know I won't be able to stay aware of it for long - the grace of passion is short."
May 9, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Fatima (new) - added it

Fatima This was extremely difficult book to get through


Sunny Camus Sartre Kafka!!! I literally wrote the same in my last review of one of her books !


Magdelanye Fabulous review of fabulous book. After an initial disorientation I actually found it almost unbearingly exciting, never pretentious.
I am totally jealous that you were able to access The hour of the Star


±·¾±³¦³Ùé Reyes Thanks foto the review! I'm looking for my 2nd Lispector encounter!, I read near to the wild heart, and found it breath taking (I don't know if it's really that good, or if it's just because i'm a woman that Iiked it that much).


±·¾±³¦³Ùé Reyes *for the review


Steven Godin Fatima wrote: "This was extremely difficult book to get through"

Yep, that's a valid point Fatima.


Steven Godin ±·¾±³¦³Ùé wrote: "Thanks foto the review! I'm looking for my 2nd Lispector encounter!, I read near to the wild heart, and found it breath taking (I don't know if it's really that good, or if it's just because i'm a ..."

I haven't read that one yet ±·¾±³¦³Ùé, but look forward to it. I'd read Hour of the Star over this if I were you.


Steven Godin Magdelanye wrote: "Fabulous review of fabulous book. After an initial disorientation I actually found it almost unbearingly exciting, never pretentious.
I am totally jealous that you were able to access The hour of t..."


I found Hour of the star easier to read that this, but both were certainly eye-catching.


Steven Godin Sunny wrote: "Camus Sartre Kafka!!! I literally wrote the same in my last review of one of her books !"

Apparently she is very popular in France. Going by this one it's easy to see why.


message 10: by Janete (new)

Janete on hiatus due health issues Steven, I hate this Clarice Lispector's book.


Steven Godin Janete wrote: "Steven, I hate this Clarice Lispector's book."

That's understandable Janete, it's not one to please all. I didn't hate it, but didn't think it was that great either.


message 12: by Robin (new) - rated it 1 star

Robin Steven I just saw your review now. I found the book obnoxious. A test of endurance. But your review, the opposite. Your description makes me wish I saw more in this novel.


back to top