欧宝娱乐

Thomas's Reviews > Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, Her Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone by Lori Gottlieb
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2018505
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: nonfiction, biography-or-memoir, psychology

A warm, engaging, and funny book about a therapist who sees a therapist after her boyfriend breaks up with her. I so appreciate Maybe You Should Talk to Someone for further destigmatizing therapy. I read somewhere that my generation is the 鈥渢herapy generation鈥� and yet so much stigma and misinformation surrounding therapy persists. Gottlieb describes her experience in therapy for herself and the therapy she provides to a few different patients with compassion and humor. Her writing style is conversational and demystifies therapy, both the process and the emotion involved, and her deep care for her patients and her own therapist is wonderful to read. I always wanted to know what would happen next, and Gottlieb鈥檚 insights always resonated on an emotional level without restoring to clich茅. Just a few ideas that stood out to me and/or felt relevant to my own life: 1) that we often turn to anger when we feel hurt, that we lash out at others or ourselves in periods of intense emotional distress, 2) all relationships will involve some level of being hurt, either you being hurt or you hurting someone else, it鈥檚 a matter of repairing that rupture after the conflict occurs and setting boundaries surrounding how much you鈥檙e willing to put up with, and 3) I鈥檓 not alone in having Facebook and internet-stalked my therapist (thank you Lori Gottlieb for normalizing my own behavior there lol!)

I do rate this book four stars very intentionally, because Gottlieb does not acknowledge the importance of race, privilege, power, oppression, intersectionality, or culture, at all in this book. I felt shocked that as such a competent therapist, she wouldn鈥檛 mention the importance of taking into account how societal oppression affects patients and the therapy process and dyad (I think she mentioned men being socialized to withhold emotional expression, but aside from that, nothing). It鈥檚 so important that therapists educate themselves on how to be culturally competent, and after reading this I鈥檓 honestly unsure if Gottlieb would be the type of therapist who might commit a microaggression against a client or not acknowledge her privilege or power in the therapy dyad. For people of color, queer people, and those at the intersections of marginalized identities, I鈥檇 recommend this article () to help you navigate how to find a therapist who鈥檚 with it and will understand important concepts and lived experiences related to oppression and intersectionality. I also feel like this book would have benefited from Gottlieb acknowledging her own privileges, in particular her whiteness, especially in terms of the smoothness of her career development trajectory despite multiple transitions.

Overall, would recommend to those who want an engaging reading experience and are curious about or passionate about therapy. As a therapist who鈥檚 into writing I鈥檓 appreciative that Gottlieb has expanded the canon of books about therapy, especially from a more modern perspective. I think we should all talk to someone, ideally a therapist, at some point in our lives, if we have the resources to.
270 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Maybe You Should Talk to Someone.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

May 23, 2019 – Shelved
August 23, 2019 – Started Reading
August 28, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-21 of 21 (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rami (new) - added it

Rami I've been wanting to read this book, but after i read your review (which was well written) It's a definite thing.

I've been looking for answers about anger and hurt in relationships, and it's relieving to know she is discussing them in this book.

Thanks, Thomas :)


Shauna I always appreciate your reviews!


Antigone I'm pleased you found this worth the read, Thomas! And those sticking points are well worth noting - possibly the product of a practice that is, due to the very privilege you mention, under-populated by the marginalized? I imagine the author would have a tough time speaking about a client base she's not frequently possessed of.


Thomas Rami wrote: "I've been wanting to read this book, but after i read your review (which was well written) It's a definite thing.

I've been looking for answers about anger and hurt in relationships, and it's rel..."


Hope you enjoy it Rami, looking forward to reading what your thoughts/feelings on the book are! Yes, she touches on a bunch of relevant topics related to relationships. :)

Shauna wrote: "I always appreciate your reviews!"

That means a lot to me, thank you Shauna!

Michael wrote: "Insightful review! I'd been wondering how this was, and I'm sorry to hear it's limited in scope. I've encountered the one-size-fits-all model of therapy before, as have some of my friends, where th..."

Thank you Michael, for your kind comment and your intelligent reviews! Yeah I completely agree with you, and I'm sorry you and people you know have encountered that form of therapy. It sucks when people with marginalized identities are exposed to that form of therapy, especially because therapy is such a vulnerable space and it takes so much courage to go, and it's awful if someone is demotivated from trying because of a therapist who's complicit in oppression. I'm glad we're talking about it, even if just within this 欧宝娱乐 comment thread.

Antigone wrote: "I'm pleased you found this worth the read, Thomas! And those sticking points are well worth noting - possibly the product of a practice that is, due to the very privilege you mention, under-populat..."

Aw thank you, and thank you for your review that led motivated me to pick up this book even more. I think you raise a good point that perhaps Gottlieb doesn't have much exposure to clients of color or other marginalized clients, however, I find it hard to believe that literally every single client she sees is white, cisgender, heterosexual, middle to upper middle class, etc. And even if that were the case, in her training she should have been educated (and again, should continue to educate herself) on topics related to culture, race, power, privilege, etc. This isn't an ad hominem in that I acknowledge it's possible Gottlieb is well-versed on these topics, yet, I wish they received more attention in this book.


InfirmBookwyrm Thomas, thank you for another great review! I, too, always appreciate and look forward to reading them. I get especially excited when you review a book I have read myself, as is the case here with Gottlieb鈥檚 book. I鈥檓 ashamed to admit that when I read it, none of the more negative points you brought up even registered with me, but now after reading your review, I completely agree. Being a white, heterosexual, cis-gender female, (with only health and financial struggles to worry over) it鈥檚 so easy to forget my own privilege鈥攁s difficult as that is to admit. But I NEVER want to be seen as anything other than an ally, or at the very least鈥攁lways aware. So I鈥檓 grateful to you for speaking up and reminding the rest of us. Even in a book review, which may not seem like much to some, with the following you鈥檝e earned here, the awareness that you spread is priceless. Thank you!


message 6: by Mridula (new)

Mridula Incredible review. Thank you for the thoughtful insights and consistent attention to intersectionality. Context, as one writer put it, is everything.


 Sarah Lumos I thought the same thing when I read this book! Although it was a well-written, enjoyable read, I felt like it was lacking because the author lacked self-awareness of her privilege and also never acknowledged intersectionality (helping disabled, low-income, queer, POC, and so forth clients).


Thomas Emily wrote: "Thomas, thank you for another great review! I, too, always appreciate and look forward to reading them. I get especially excited when you review a book I have read myself, as is the case here with ..."

Awwww Emily reading this comment warmed my heart, thank you so much for taking the time to write it out and share your thoughts. You're not alone in your journey to acknowledge your own privilege - there are definitely books I've read in the past where I look back now and think "omg, that was actually pretty problematic" (e.g., Gone with the Wind, The Help) but I didn't realize it at the time, so I think we are all on our own journey. I think what is important is our openness to acknowledging our privilege and shortcomings and taking active steps to address those things, which it sounds is like what you're doing. Appreciate your attention to my reviews and hope you're doing well.

Mridula wrote: "Incredible review. Thank you for the thoughtful insights and consistent attention to intersectionality. Context, as one writer put it, is everything."

Thank you so much for your kind words Mridula! Friends like you motivate me to continue paying attention to important topics like intersectionality. :)

Sarah wrote: "I thought the same thing when I read this book! Although it was a well-written, enjoyable read, I felt like it was lacking because the author lacked self-awareness of her privilege and also never a..."

Yep, we're on the same page here Sarah! Glad you were thinking along similar lines when reading this. While I so appreciate Gottlieb for normalizing therapy I think she could have done more to address her privilege and how privilege in general affects the therapy process.


message 9: by Susan (new)

Susan Your hyperlink on "this article" I'm your OP doesn't work. Do you mind posting that link or URL again? I'm interested, thanks!


Thomas Hi Susan, thanks for pointing that out! Tried to fix the hyperlink but it didn't work, so I included the full link in the review and here: Hope you find this helpful.


message 11: by Cat (new) - added it

Cat This review is from ages ago for you but I just finished this and I feel so relieved that I wasn鈥檛 the only who felt that Lori Gottlieb was Really White! I really enjoyed the book and related to a lot of its content, but it definitely felt a little distant in the privilege she was able to have/does have, and especially her whiteness. Also this makes me feel really proud of you for doing your thing in the therapy world as the person you are!!!


Thomas Haha I love that a review from two years ago is considered ages ago. :) Yes I'm glad that you also noted how Gottlieb's whiteness affected the book. It is a step forward in representation for therapy though I do think more work needs to be done in all fronts for destigmatizing therapy and making it more accessible/effective for people of color, as I definitely know clinicians of color who are excellent and hope more will join our ranks too. Thank you for your kind words!


message 13: by LaTeisha (new) - added it

LaTeisha Cl茅ment This was a very thorough review and I agree with the concern of wanting the author to acknowledge her privilege. That lack of privilege is definitely a barrier to marginalized communities, especially POC鈥檚 long history of health and medical discrimination, amongst a plethora of other types of micro aggressions... I鈥檇 definitely recommend this book to clients seeking help, through the gaze of being objective to the author鈥檚 experience.


Thomas Thanks so much for your thoughtful comment LaTeisha! Yes, love the notion of both using this book to destigmatize mental health treatment while also acknowledging the author's privileges.


Nancy I have the good fortune of reading your review three and a half years later. As a retired therapist, I picked this up at a book sale and ignored it because I anticipated it would be too dry. But you're right, she did a great job of making therapy more accessible. Her understanding of the issues you mentioned is very important. I also felt she was a little "under informed" about chemical dependency. I admire your reading + reviewing speed. I still can't believe you can do that and grad school. Congrats.


Thomas I appreciate this thoughtful comment Nancy, glad you also perceived the book as quite readable and I appreciate your note too about the author's potential "under informed"-ness about chemical dependency. Thank you too for your kind words haha yeah reading is one of my primary hobbies and I try to organize my time well. Hope your 2023 is off to a great start in regard to reading and all else!


message 17: by J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J. Moyer Great review. While all therapists are human and have their shortcomings, I think your observation that she is coming from a privileged perspective without acknowledging that is spot on. I still gave her the benefit of the doubt. My issue was that she says this isn鈥檛 a book about getting people to go to therapy but that鈥檚 what happens in the book. She doesn鈥檛 acknowledge other ways of coping with the challenges of being human at all. A disappointment for a therapist to omit.


Kristen I rated it 5 stars and was deeply intrigued and touched by all the client鈥檚 stories. However, it was a tad annoying how the author has 3-4 extremely prestigious careers and still harps on about whether a 鈥渄ual鈥� career as a therapist and journalist is really right for her. First world problems.


Thomas John wrote: "Great review. While all therapists are human and have their shortcomings, I think your observation that she is coming from a privileged perspective without acknowledging that is spot on. I still ga..."

Thank you John for this thoughtful comment! I agree about how there are other ways to cope with life's problems other than therapy, even though I am a therapy enthusiast.

Kristen wrote: "I rated it 5 stars and was deeply intrigued and touched by all the client鈥檚 stories. However, it was a tad annoying how the author has 3-4 extremely prestigious careers and still harps on about whe..."

Glad you enjoyed it Kristen, and I can totally see where you're coming from with this critique!


message 20: by Lynn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lynn Burgess Thomas,
I completely overlooked what you so astutely mention in your review. Perhaps because I too come from a place of privilege? Oh, how I hope that is not the reason! I do come from that place and it is most likely a telltale sign that I read Lori鈥檚 book without seeing what was missing. I am someone who is very aware of my own privilege, the unfairness of my family鈥檚 safety as compared to brown skinned friends. Almost every time I rant about the one percent, those who can afford fancy houses, who do not worry whether insurance (if they have any) will cover surgery, chronic illness or even childbirth, etc. etc. I am usually hit with the realization of my own elite richness, i.e. the ability to buy the food I want, not just need. My heterosexual children do not worry about their own safety. I could go on and on.
I agree with Kristen鈥檚 assessment completely. The client stories and even the author鈥檚 vulnerability touched me in the same way. I wish Gottlieb had acknowledged her first world concerns as just that. I point my fingers back at myself!

Thank you Thomas, for always getting me to delve a bit deeper. I still love the book. Julie and John will stay with me for a long time.

Oh! I found myself wishing the author would have allowed herself a bit more freedom in her role as Julie鈥檚 therapist, especially later in their time together. Lori, Julie and Julie鈥檚 husband could have figured something out. Lori could have transitioned into a simpler role more easily shared with others.


Thomas Glad the book touched you Lynn and I think it's great for each of us to own our privileges and try to use them to eradicate the circumstances that create societal inequities in the first place. Hope you have a read in the future that you enjoy as much as you did this one! :)


back to top