ŷ

*TUDOR^QUEEN* 's Reviews > The Bookish Life of Nina Hill

The Bookish Life of Nina Hill by Abbi Waxman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
25976435
's review

liked it

The subject matter of this book seemed like a perfect fit to my tastes, seeing as how I identify so closely with the main character, Nina Hill. Just like Nina, I would much rather sit in a comfy chair with a beloved pet nearby curled up with a book and some coffee, than doing most anything else. I would much rather be in these same circumstances than have to make small talk with people. Like Nina, the bubble of my home is my happiness, with my kindles and thousands of book files (in her case, actual physical books on bookcases) at my fingertips. We also know a lot of facts and relate to our pet like they are a real person. However, even though "Bookish Nina Hill" and I are kindred spirits, I did not enjoy this book quite as much as I had hoped.

For a brief overview of this story, Nina lives by herself in a little guesthouse with bookshelves, a comfy chair in the corner, and her cat Phil. She happily works in a bookstore called Knight's Books. She occasionally suffers from panic attacks, and finds comfort in routines, schedules and making daily lists. These cute, handwritten daily lists precede each chapter. Nina is a geek that participates in trivia quiz competitions. There also are several book groups that hold meetings at the store in the evenings. Needless to say, Nina's life is full, and she seems to be quite content with it. Her mother is a successful travelling photographer, but Nina was raised by a loving nanny named Louise. In many ways, Louise seems more like her mother than her biological one. In addition, Nina never knew her father because her birth was the result of an affair. NIna's Mom had an agreement with Nina's father that he would never contact her. However, when Nina's father dies, a lawyer contacts her with the news and that she has an extended family. Nina's life is suddenly stirred up with unexpected people to meet and deal with, with the possibility of an inhertitance.

I thought I was in for a delightful ride as I first delved into the book and periodically found myself breaking into laughter. Now that I think about it, I enjoyed the story of Nina's life by herself more than when she discovered her new family members. That's the part when I began to lose interest. I didn't connect with these other characters, and there were too many of them to follow with any recognition. They became a distraction to the story I was enjoying about Nina's insular life. I also was bored reading about the trivia quiz competitions Nina participated in.

I was initially intrigued by her burgeoning relationship with Tom, an attractive, worthy opponent on the other trivia quiz team. However, I was turned off by Nina's sexual encounter on their second date, when they barely knew each other. In addition, on a later outing when Nina ran into some common friends and was asked about Tom, she couldn't bring herself to label Tom her boyfriend...this after having slept with him. Call me a prude, but I found it bizarre behavior, especially for a "bookish" type that I had been identifying with.

A book that started out so promising for me with unexpected bursts of laughter gradually ran out of steam for me. I know I am an outlier on this, but by the book's end I was ready to read something else.

Thank you to Berkley / Penguin Publishing Group who provided an advance reader copy via Edelweiss.
224 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Bookish Life of Nina Hill.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 22, 2019 – Shelved
June 22, 2019 – Shelved as: to-read
July 13, 2019 – Started Reading
July 14, 2019 –
10.0%
July 15, 2019 –
20.0%
July 16, 2019 –
30.0%
July 17, 2019 –
50.0%
July 17, 2019 –
60.0%
July 18, 2019 –
70.0%
July 19, 2019 –
85.0%
July 19, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 82 (82 new)


Paromjit Sorry to hear that this doesn’t work out as well as you had hoped, TQ.......but so glad you enjoyed elements of it....wonderful review! 😎😎


Toni Great review, TQ! I also had my doubts about the way Nina and Tom's dates went. I tried to explain it by Nina's (self-professed) lack of understanding of how social and romantic relationships develop. You're definitely not alone in thinking it was a strange behaviour (and not very respectful).
Hope your next book is something you can enjoy all way through!


Marialyce Sorry that this much hyped book was such a disappointment, TQ. There are millions more books waiting for you. Hoping your next one merits five stars.


Ceecee Excellent review TQ. I find it often happens when books are hyped up. Hope next one is good


Nadia Brilliant write-up TQ, the best review I read on this! Sorry the second part of the book was disappointing.


message 7: by Liz (new) - rated it 5 stars

Liz Sorry you didn’t love this one as much as I did. Hope your next book is five star worthy.


message 8: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Good review, Tudor! honest insight also


Angela M Sorry it didn’t work for you, TQ. Onwards! I will be giving this a try soon, so we’ll see !


Brandice Great review, TQ! Sorry you didn’t love it as much as you hoped to! I’m looking forward to this one because of the premise but will keep my expectations in check - Other People’s Houses (also by Waxman) ended up being just an ok read for me though I remember seeing mostly high reviews for it. Hope you love your next read! :)


Holly  B (slower pace!) I had some issues with this one too TQ! Great review.


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Paromjit wrote: "Sorry to hear that this doesn’t work out as well as you had hoped, TQ.......but so glad you enjoyed elements of it....wonderful review! 😎😎"

Thank you so much, Paromjit! :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Toni wrote: "Great review, TQ! I also had my doubts about the way Nina and Tom's dates went. I tried to explain it by Nina's (self-professed) lack of understanding of how social and romantic relationships devel..."

Thank you so much, Toni! I really appreciate your take on the relationship aspect. Thanks again! :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Marialyce wrote: "Sorry that this much hyped book was such a disappointment, TQ. There are millions more books waiting for you. Hoping your next one merits five stars."

Thank you very much, Marialyce! I find myself really overloaded with NG and Edelweiss books for this month. For the first time I've fallen behind with publication dates. Scandalous! Maybe I'll get lucky with my next...:-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Ceecee wrote: "Excellent review TQ. I find it often happens when books are hyped up. Hope next one is good"

Thank you so much, Ceecee! Yes, I've fallen victim to the hype quite often, lately. And now I'm paying the price with having fallen behind with arcs being tardy past publication dates. I've got to curb my NetGalley and Edelweiss addictions :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Nadia wrote: "Brilliant write-up TQ, the best review I read on this! Sorry the second part of the book was disappointing."

Wow...thank you so much, Nadia! I really appreciate it! XOXO


*TUDOR^QUEEN* sue wrote: "Great review."

Thank you very much, Sue :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Liz wrote: "Sorry you didn’t love this one as much as I did. Hope your next book is five star worthy."

Thanks very much, Liz! I enjoyed your review :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Diane wrote: "Good review, Tudor! honest insight also"

Thank you so much, Diane! :-) XOXO


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Angela M wrote: "Sorry it didn’t work for you, TQ. Onwards! I will be giving this a try soon, so we’ll see !"

Thank you, Angela! I'll be looking out for your review with interest :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Brandice wrote: "Great review, TQ! Sorry you didn’t love it as much as you hoped to! I’m looking forward to this one because of the premise but will keep my expectations in check - Other People’s Houses (also by Wa..."

Thanks a lot, Brandice! I hope you enjoy it more than I did (most seemed to) and I look forward to reading your review! :-)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Holly wrote: "I had some issues with this one too TQ! Great review."

Thanks so much, Holly! I just went back and took a look at your review, and really enjoyed it and agreed with your points :-)


message 23: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Wonderful review, Tudor! I think many of us on here can relate to Nina's chosen path in life.


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Michelle wrote: "Wonderful review, Tudor! I think many of us on here can relate to Nina's chosen path in life."

Thank you, Michelle! You are so right :-)


message 25: by Kylie (new)

Kylie D Great review Tudor Queen :)


message 26: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Excellent review, TQ!! :)


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Kylie wrote: "Great review Tudor Queen :)"

Thanks so much, Kylie! 😀💕🔰


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Deanna wrote: "Excellent review, TQ!! :)"

Thank you very much, Deanna! 😉🌹🔰


message 29: by JanB (new) - rated it 4 stars

JanB TQ, I loved this review! I’ve seen so many glowing reviews that I appreciate an alternate opinion. I have this on my EW shelf so will be reading it soon and will adjust my expectations. Thanks!


*TUDOR^QUEEN* JanB wrote: "TQ, I loved this review! I’ve seen so many glowing reviews that I appreciate an alternate opinion. I have this on my EW shelf so will be reading it soon and will adjust my expectations. Thanks!"

Why, thank you so much, Jan! You have made my day! 😀💖👸


message 31: by Judy (new)

Judy A thoughtful review Ms. Queen! Sorry this one wasn't as good as you expected, but glad you enjoyed part of it.


message 32: by Felicia (new)

Felicia Great review, TQ 💖 interesting views on sex and dating 😁


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Felicia wrote: "Great review, TQ 💖 interesting views on sex and dating 😁"

Thank you, Felicia! 👸💖😱


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Judy wrote: "A thoughtful review Ms. Queen! Sorry this one wasn't as good as you expected, but glad you enjoyed part of it."

Thank you so much, Judy! 👸💖


message 35: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Fab review, T.Q! �


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Mary Beth *Traveling Sister* wrote: "Fab review, T.Q! �"

Thank you so much, Mary Beth! 💗🌹👸


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Nicola wrote: "Fantastic review TQ! 💕"

Thanks very much, Nicola! 💖👸🔰


Richard (on hiatus) A very well considered review TQ ........ shame the early promise faded a bit.


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Richard wrote: "A very well considered review TQ ........ shame the early promise faded a bit."

Thanks so much, Richard 🔰👸🌞


message 40: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Great review TQ, very fair and honest 🤗


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Maureen- Thank you very much! ♡♡�


message 42: by Paula (new)

Paula K Terrific critique, TQ!


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Paula wrote: "Terrific critique, TQ!"

Thanks so much, Paula! 😉💓🔰


Julie Excellent review, TQ! Sorry this one fizzled out in the end. 💕🤗


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Julie- Thank you so very much!! ♡♡�


message 46: by Holly R W (new)

Holly R W I started this book, but did not finish it. I could not connect with it. I guess I'm an outlier too!


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Holly R W wrote: "I started this book, but did not finish it. I could not connect with it. I guess I'm an outlier too!"

There are a lot of books that if I were not reading/reviewing it for a publisher who granted it to me in exchange for an honest review, I would probably move on to something else. If it's so bad that I'm actually dreading reading it that it would fall to a 1 or 2 star, then I'd just DNF it. Life is too short and there are too many books to read! :-)


Jenner I couldn't have said it better!


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Jenner- Wow, thank you very much! :-)


Kayla I had a similar experience reading this novel! It started out so well and seemed so promising but it quickly lost my interest. I think it was at the family plot like you said. I honestly would have been happy simply reading a book about Nina and her book clubs.


« previous 1
back to top