欧宝娱乐

Tatiana's Reviews > White Nights

White Nights by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
180908
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: classics

This story, really a novella, is the one I use to introduce people to Dostoyevsky. If you like White Nights you will like Fyodor Mikailovich, I think, and if you don't you won't. In it we're introduced to a charming intelligent young man who lives on the edges of St. Petersburg life, a shy dreamer who spends almost all his time alone. The life of his observations and imagination is very full, however. He daydreams in 3d with vivid colors passionate intricate tales that engross him completely, to the point that an actual friend knocking on his door to say hello flusters him totally, leaving him nonplussed for the entire short awkward visit. Dostoyevsky, in his brilliant way makes me care deeply about our hero, and feel a total sense of identification with him.

One day, our protagonist meets an actual real-life girl, one whose temperment and situation in life are something like his. They become great friends immediately, something that has never happened to him before. The story takes off at this point, piling up so much light and darkness that I'm gasping for breath all the way through until the magnificent ending.

It's extraordinary the way Dostoyevsky can make all of us feel so much identification with his characters. I feel each time I read this story that he's plumbed the secret depths of my soul that not even I had any idea of. He slices me apart and puts me back together so that I'm somebody totally new after he's done. I feel as though he's writing about me and only me, through a century and a half of time travel and a thorough reading of my subconscious mind, and I do feel exposed by it.

My son's aunt who studied Russian literature in Russia says Dostoyevsky is evil, because he cuts us open and has a poke round our deepest selves with such complete and utter honesty. It's true he does see the whole of humanity, from our basest depravity to our highest divinity. But for me his truth is purifying, like a sacred flame, like the caress of a being who's both angel and demon at the same time. I do think Dostoyevsky is the greatest novelist of all in the whole history of western civilization.
1764 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read White Nights.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 1, 1980 – Finished Reading
July 9, 2007 – Shelved
July 11, 2007 – Shelved as: classics

Comments Showing 1-50 of 59 (59 new)


Karen Chung Lovely review!


Tatiana Thanks, Karen!


Eduardo Camargo What a great review! Couldn't describe better what I felt reading White Nights.


Tatiana Thank you, Eduardo!


Caterina I agree!


Tatiana Thanks!


Yusef Gaiter A wonderful critique! Thank you!


Tatiana Thanks, Yusef!


Tatiana I'm so glad you liked it, Maria! Thanks!


Mirela Wonderful! Its like he explains my feelings to me...


Tatiana Isn't he amazing? He's the best writer ever! Thanks for your comment.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Lovely review Tatiana! I will have to read this book.


message 13: by Prashant (new) - added it

Prashant white nights one of my favorite short story


Poggar Thanks, a lovely review!


Oscar Fernando Moreno Alonso Hermoso comentario. Te seguir茅 para continuar ley茅ndote.


message 16: by Anil (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anil Wonderful review!


message 17: by honey (new) - rated it 1 star

honey Wow. This wonderful review has made me more excited to begin the book, soon. I can't wait as of this moment.


message 18: by William (new)

William He is very good. That's for sure. I'll have to add this to my list. I'm interested after having read all the major works to find the old lonely obscure one's and parse out what gives about this guy? This description reminds me of when I'm busy writing and someone comes into the room...totally knocks me off. Hear tell F had epilepsy, so...it would really send him out I'm sure.


Tatiana Honey wrote: "Wow. This wonderful review has made me more excited to begin the book, soon. I can't wait as of this moment."

I hope you enjoy it as much as I have!


Tatiana Anil wrote: "Wonderful review!" Thank you, Anil!


Tatiana Poggar wrote: "Thanks, a lovely review!" Thanks!


Tatiana Oscar Fernando wrote: "Hermoso comentario. Te seguir茅 para continuar ley茅ndote." 隆Gracias, Oscar!


Tatiana Prashant wrote: "white nights one of my favorite short story" Mine too!


Tatiana Oriana wrote: "Lovely review Tatiana! I will have to read this book." Oh, do! And let me know how you like it.


message 25: by Brad (new) - rated it 4 stars

Brad Balderson Brilliant review, thankyou.


Tatiana Brad wrote: "Brilliant review, thankyou." Thanks for the nice comment, Brad!


message 27: by Matt (new) - added it

Matt Well, with that sort of endorsement, I guess I have to read it.


Tatiana Matt wrote: "Well, with that sort of endorsement, I guess I have to read it."

Let me know what you think. It's not very long.


message 29: by Matt (new) - added it

Matt Tatiana wrote: "Matt wrote: "Well, with that sort of endorsement, I guess I have to read it."

Let me know what you think. It's not very long."


Sadly, I found the whole thing rather twee and tedious, which I found rather incongruous to its attempt to stab you in the stomach and leave you bleeding at the end.

I guess I'm not a modernist. I've never had any use at all for any of the existentialists, and it turns out at that a devout Christian existentialist doesn't in fact make an exception to that rule. I've no interest in a writer that is trying to achieve an effect. I've got no interest in the questions that they agonize over. In as much as I now realize every modern writer since then is just trying to imitate Dostoyevsky, I am impressed with his talent. In as much as I now hold him responsible for all these fields of soupy stinking manure and bad literature that have resulted from it, I consider it a poor project.


Tatiana So sad you didn't like it! It's always a surprise to me how different people get such different things out of the same story. I hope my review didn't ruin it for you by somehow overhyping. Dostoyevsky just resonates with my spirit like nobody else.


message 31: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth I've recently added Crime and Punishment to my tbr list this year. Never heard of this one before, but your review makes me really want to check this one out!!


message 32: by Gail (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gail Cuts right deep into the heart Tatiana!


Misael Araya Excuse me, im currently ready brothers karamazhov and i already read the player and crime and punisment. Which other book besides The Idiot can i read from dostoyesvky and which other author?


message 34: by Matias (new)

Matias Your comment was the push I needed to dive into it, thanks!


message 35: by Tyba (new)

Tyba Alfatih Such an amazing review, l appreciate that


Michalis I have not started yet with Dostoyevsky but my first book will probably be "Notes From The Underground". After reading this comment however, I am curious. Would "White Nights" be a better choice? In the end I will read both, so there's probably not a big difference.


Tatiana Michalis wrote: "I have not started yet with Dostoyevsky but my first book will probably be "Notes From The Underground". After reading this comment however, I am curious. Would "White Nights" be a better choice? I..."

I would definitely go with this one first, before Notes from the Underground. But tell me which you chose, when you do choose, and how it went.


Michalis Tatiana, I recently finished "White Nights" and "The Meek One/A Gentle Creature" and wrote their reviews here. Those were probably the most difficult-to-write reviews for me, as I tried to be fair, as always, and separate the good from the bad elements of the stories. My final impression leaves me a little disappointed by Dostoyevsky, maybe because I had too high expectations all along or because I compare his works to other works from writers that I really liked.

Thank you for your recommendation, I will soon start reading "Notes From The Underground" and will let you know about it as well


message 39: by Emma-Luna (new) - added it

Emma-Luna Wooow! I am enamoured by your review so I guess I鈥檒l have to read White Nights now!!


Julianna Torres Your review makes me wanna finish reading White Nights right away, the beginning of the book was pretty fast for me and after he met the girl I got bored for awhile and stopped reading. I鈥檒l give it a chance!


message 41: by Mia (new) - rated it 3 stars

Mia Preach it sister


Mirae Adrienne A wonderful critique!


Carla Castillo Think exactly the same鈥� masterpiece


Vijay Very well said, the way he writes its like as if we are not reading it rather we actually are in the scene鈥�


message 45: by Soukies (new) - added it

Soukies The best review for this book, can not say more about it. Thank you!


Alexandre Lemay White nights is the perfect novel to introduce you to Dostoe茂vsky writing style! It's a simple, short well put togetherstory! As you go trough each nights, you start to understand why he is so popular! He dig right through your feelings in such an direct way that it almost feels like you are a part of the story, as if you were here, watching them exchanging thoughts! Truly loved this one!


message 47: by Hajerah (new) - added it

Hajerah Umar A review worth Dostoevsky! Loved the descriptions of how he touches you, I feel the same!!


Sabra Kadabra Yes yes yes!! I feel this to the core


message 49: by Vivienne (new)

Vivienne Dolder Ok, now I have to read this book!


Sophie Peschanel i鈥檇 like to give your review 5 stars because WOW


芦 previous 1
back to top