Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Petra nearly in Melbourne's Reviews > A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings

A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings by Gabriel García Márquez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1237196
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2019-read, 2019-100-reviews, fiction, reviewed, travel-adventure-countries

You can read it free or to it. At first the story reminded me of the children in those medical documentaries where the child has a birth defect and doctors in the US, UK or Australia fly them over from India to fix them. Invariably these children are from very poor and backward villages and the child, with six limbs, an extra head or other appalling defect is worshipped as a god. People come to give them offerings and beg for miracles. Their minds cannot conceive of anything out of the ordinary that isn't to do with religion. And so it is with these poor Colombian folk on finding an old man with wings in their chicken coop.

They don't understand him and he makes no effort to involve himself with them, just choosing to live quietly until spring, the time of renewal, when his feathers will grow again and he can fly and be free once more.

Meanwhile his 'keepers' do whatever the Indians do too, they charge for viewings and grow rich on the proceeds. So whether or not the miracles of the teeth, the sunflowers and - my favourite - 'almost winning the lottery' are true or not, their rags to riches story certainly is.

People find it hard to accept that which is different from them, they invent reasons, they praise them, worship them, ridicule them, isolate and exclude them, but they just can't accept them and go about their daily business. You don't need wings or a deformity, you just need to be different enough that the tribe will say you are 'other'.

That's what happens with race, with immigrants, with people of different religions, even those that move to a neighbourhood that is distinctly unlike their own background. Our common humanity is ignored for the sake of tribal-bonding and the feelings of superiority it gives its members.
__________

Meaning? I have been thinking on the meaning of the story and think I have a clue. The peasants think he is a foreigner from far off lands and he sings himself sea shanties in Norwegian. He is an angel, or at least a being from another sphere or dimension, maybe he was one of the original ones maybe even a Magrethean like who got left behind before the mice settled on using humans. The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Just joking.
262 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 10, 2019 – Started Reading
July 10, 2019 – Shelved
July 10, 2019 – Shelved as: 2019-100-reviews
July 10, 2019 – Shelved as: 2019-read
July 10, 2019 – Shelved as: fiction
July 10, 2019 – Shelved as: reviewed
July 10, 2019 – Shelved as: travel-adventure-countries
July 11, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Interesting and off to check out the link right away


message 2: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Couldn’t get link to work unfortunately


message 3: by Petra nearly in Melbourne (last edited Jul 11, 2019 04:33PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Petra nearly in Melbourne Sharon wrote: "Couldn’t get link to work unfortunately"

The free pdf will work, but I fixed it in the review as well. Sorry about that.


message 4: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Great review!


Petra nearly in Melbourne Carmen wrote: "Great review!"

Thank you. The story is just a 10 minute read, it's worth it! (The audio is 14 mins long. The narrator reads more slowly than me).


message 6: by Carmen (new) - added it

Carmen Thanks! I always read faster than the audio goes.


Daren Nice find Petra


Petra nearly in Melbourne Daren wrote: "Nice find Petra"

It really was. Just a little gem. I was so pleased to have found something by Gabriel Garcia Marquez I hadn't read.


message 9: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray I must have read this, as I read Leaf Storm many years ago, but it does not register. Thanks for the reminder


message 10: by Sharon (new)

Sharon Thanks Petra. I found it and listened to it last night. Lovely story but still mulling over its meaning x


message 11: by Hanneke (new)

Hanneke Beautiful review, Petra. And thanks for the link to the pdf!


Petra nearly in Melbourne Ray wrote: "I must have read this, as I read Leaf Storm many years ago, but it does not register. Thanks for the reminder"

I don't remember it in Leaf Storm either. Maybe it wasn't in all editions?


message 13: by Petra nearly in Melbourne (last edited Jul 12, 2019 06:56AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Petra nearly in Melbourne Hanneke wrote: "Beautiful review, Petra. And thanks for the link to the pdf!"

Thank you. I hope you enjoy it and will write a review. I would like to know what you made of it too.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Sharon wrote: "still mulling over its meaning x"

I have added the "meaning" in a spoiler.


message 15: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Better Eggs wrote: "Ray wrote: "I must have read this, as I read Leaf Storm many years ago, but it does not register. Thanks for the reminder"

I don't remember it in Leaf Storm either. Maybe it wasn't in..."


Mysterious. I will have a look this evening. Reading the PDF - I hope I would have remembered this line

"Against the judgement of the wise neighbour woman, for whom angels in those times were the fugitive survivors of a spiritual conspiracy, they did not have the heart to club him to death"

There were a few little old ladies like that in the village I grew up in


Petra nearly in Melbourne Ray wrote: "they did not have the heart to club him to death"
There were a few little old ladies like that in the village I grew up in ..."


Lord have mercy! Where did you grow up???


message 17: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Better Eggs wrote: "Ray wrote: "they did not have the heart to club him to death"
There were a few little old ladies like that in the village I grew up in ..."

Lord have mercy! Where did you grow up???"


Rural Suffolk. There were some mean old ladies out there, nice as pie to your face, but backstabbing biddies once you were out of sight.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Ray wrote: "There were some mean old ladies out there, nice as pie to your face, but backstabbing biddies once you were out of sight ..."

They are a ubiquitous breed, male and female they are all over the world and all ages. It has different names, gossip, diplomacy, journalism.... Men say sweet nothings to women's faces and then slag them off to their friends.


message 19: by Chris (new)

Chris Excellent review. I love how so many of the Hispanic authors use magical realism or allegorical writing in their novels.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Chris wrote: "Excellent review. I love how so many of the Hispanic authors use magical realism or allegorical writing in their novels."

Thank you. I think my favourite magical realism book of all time (because of the MR) is Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands where the widowed Dona Flor remarries a man who is not good in bed and so is delighted when her late husband turns up to spice things up in that department.


Stacey B Excellent review my friend.


message 22: by Dmitri (new)

Dmitri Fascinating review and story Petra! I’ve got to look this up and read GGM. It reminds me of the now discredited tale of Cortes landing in Mexico, being mistaken as Quetzalcoatl by Moctezuma due to his strange appearance in shining armor. Thanks for the link.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Stacey B wrote: "Excellent review my friend."

Thank you Stacey. :-)


Stacey B Petra X a kind word is like a spring day wrote: "Stacey B wrote: "Excellent review my friend."

Thank you Stacey. :-)"

You are so welcome :)


Cecily I love your final paragraph! The rest isn't bad, either !!

I just read this story, probably more than a decade since I last read GGM, and then it was novels. This seemed more mythic than I remembered him and potentially a children's story. I then saw it has been adapted for stage and page, aimed at children.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Dmitri wrote: "Fascinating review and story Petra! I’ve got to look this up and read GGM. It reminds me of the now discredited tale of Cortes landing in Mexico, being mistaken as Quetzalcoatl by Moctezuma due to ..."

I think you are a great deal more educated than I am. I didn't know about the tale, but now I've looked it up, I see the reference :-) thank you. But even the uneducated among us (me) recognise the name as in Montezuma's Revenge which is what you get when you go on holiday to Spain.


message 27: by Dmitri (last edited Apr 12, 2023 04:14PM) (new)

Dmitri Petra X a kind wrote: I think you are a great deal more educated than I am. I didn't know about the tale, but now I've looked it up, I see the reference :-) thank you...."

I think you are being way too kind dear! I know that you are much more widely read and world wise, but thank you. I get the revenge when I eat Mexican, and not only in Mexico.


Petra nearly in Melbourne Dmitri wrote: "I get the revenge when I eat Mexican, and not only in Mexico..."

Ironic really to be immortalised as revolting sickness rather than as the king who expanded Aztec lands. I suppose since he effed up, he deserves it though. I get revenged on with Margaritaville nachos, every time. I wonder what they put in them?


message 29: by Jessaka (new)

Jessaka Wonderful review Petra


Petra nearly in Melbourne Jessaka wrote: "Wonderful review Petra"

Thank you Jessaka. It was a wonderful story, much deeper than it seemed on the surface, typical Gabriel Garcia Marquez.


back to top