ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > The Vegetarian

The Vegetarian by Han Kang
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: man-booker, nobels

I read The Vegetarian during a day-long trip on buses, trains and planes, starting at about 8 o'clock in the morning, finishing when the plane touched down an hour late at my final destination.

Readers, be warned: this experiment should not necessarily be repeated, it may cause utter distress and embarrassment.

8 o'clock, inner city bus in a major German city:

"Before my wife turned vegetarian, I'd always thought of her as completely unremarkable in every way."

I laugh out loud, and gather some surprised looks in the "pre-morning-coffee" crowd on the bus. My reaction is somewhat inappropriate, both with regards to my setting and to the fact that this book takes a turn that is NO LAUGHING MATTER! Before buying a coffee-to-go on my first train ride of the day, I already choke on my own laughter, realising that the first of the different narrators is one of the most selfish, uncaring, brutal male prototypes imaginable, and the story is developed from his point of view, which is a magnificent stylistic feature.

10 o'clock, crammed local train moving into the conservative countryside:

While I read about an atrocious case of physical abuse in the name of patriarchal power, leading to mental breakdown as well as family dissolution, shivering at the passive fictional bystanders watching the violence in voyeuristic fascination, the train prepares for its final station and a group of Asian tourists are lining up in the corridor to leave the train. An elderly Bavarian man tells his wife and grandchild that there is no use getting off their seats as long as (enter derogatory word for Japanese in German which I still am too angry to repeat) are clogging the train. Fuelled by the effect of patriarchal superiority complex I read about just a second earlier, and by the fact that the Asian setting of the novel makes it somehow closer to the situation I am experiencing in real life, I literally see red and turn to the old man, just a casual racist as there are legion everywhere, and ask him if he is aware that all people have the same right to this train? He mumbles something, trying to explain that it is a fact though. They are standing there. Yes, it is a fact that people are standing in the train, trying to leave. Only a racist makes a derogatory remark on their origin (which, by the way, doesn't have to be Japanese at all, just because he thinks so). That is how patriarchy and racism work, and I was shaking when I left the train, as much because of the conflict I had had myself, as because of the enhancing effect of the brutal novel on my fragile equilibrium.

12 o'clock in a local village, without cash:

While the story evolves into a case of mental disease and a rare form of anorexia nervosa, I start to feel like I am starving myself. Where do you find anything to eat in a village that doesn't accept credit cards, and that thinks vegetarianism means taking the meat off the regular plate?

14 o'clock in a local train, other direction, still no food, hallucinating over a chocolate bar:

While the train stops for a police action (the story doesn't provide any further information on that matter, unfortunately), and I see minutes pass, worrying I might miss my plane, I look outside and see beautiful landscapes with trees and flowers in abundance, while reading about violent sex acts carried out in a most disturbing way, by protagonists with flower patterns painted all over their bodies. I feel slightly uncomfortable to read the book in a public space now, hoping not to draw any attention to myself. It is intense reading. No quotes.

17 o'clock at an airport, waiting, I have food and water and a spot to myself, locked away in the security area:

And that is a good thing, because now the story moves between dream and reality, between now and childhood trauma, between guilt and shame. How can you possibly be a woman in a world dominated by male rules and male violence? In a hospital for mental health, the vegetarian tries to change into a plant in order to escape the carnal pain that has defined her life from the beginning. And in her sister, she plants a seed of doubt. What if she is not the strong one, after all? Just the one hiding behind a polished surface, having demured, but not lived?

20 o'clock, on a plane, constant background noise as a mother struggles to keep her two toddlers quiet (without success) while the plane has been delayed twice before finally heading to the North:

The screams that fill the claustrophobic aircraft cabin resonate in the silent pain of the main character trying to erase the traces of humanity in herself. The story is hardly bearable on a regular day, but after 12 hours of exposure to public transportation, it hits you in the stomach and makes you feel nauseous.

22 o'clock, touchdown, last lines.

"The look in her eyes is dark and insistent."
182 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Vegetarian.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
August 2, 2019 – Shelved
August 2, 2019 – Shelved as: man-booker
August 2, 2019 – Finished Reading
October 10, 2024 – Shelved as: nobels

Comments Showing 1-34 of 34 (34 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jan-Maat (new)

Jan-Maat thank you Lisa for a fantastic review, very interesting feeling your travelling interacting with your reading, but really is there 'a pre-coffee' crowd on public transport in Germany, I find this hard to imagine ;)


Lisa Jan-Maat wrote: "thank you Lisa for a fantastic review, very interesting feeling your travelling interacting with your reading, but really is there 'a pre-coffee' crowd on public transport in Germany, I find this h..."

Haha, you are of course right, Jan-Maat. I guess it should accurately be: my perception of the crowd through my "pre-coffee-eyes" (barely open, that is), as I bought my (first) coffee at the train station.


message 3: by Jan-Maat (new)

Jan-Maat Lisa wrote: "Jan-Maat wrote: "thank you Lisa for a fantastic review, very interesting feeling your travelling interacting with your reading, but really is there 'a pre-coffee' crowd on public transport in Germa..."

goodness Lisa you ventured forth into bright day without so much as a mouthful of coffee?!


Lisa Jan-Maat wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Jan-Maat wrote: "thank you Lisa for a fantastic review, very interesting feeling your travelling interacting with your reading, but really is there 'a pre-coffee' crowd on public trans..."

Yep. That's probably why it took such quixotic turns...


Anika Fantastic review!!!


Alison Hardtmann Rural Bavaria is the place where "vegetarian" means "only a little meat in it."

Wonderful review.


Lisa Alison wrote: "Rural Bavaria is the place where "vegetarian" means "only a little meat in it."

Wonderful review."


True, Alison! And one serving of meat is probably equivalent to the weekly consumption of a typical carnivore in other places...


Lisa Sadie wrote: "Fantastic review!!!"

Thanks, Sadie!


message 9: by Dimitri (new) - added it

Dimitri The reader location forms part of the experience. Yours is one of the most memorable I've read hereabouts


message 10: by TBV (on hiatus) (new)

TBV (on hiatus) Whew, that sounds exhausting. Very nicely written, Lisa.


message 11: by Julie (new)

Julie TBV took the words right out of my mouth, Lisa. I needed to go take a nap after I read this. My one surprise was that the old (German) man only mumbled to you. In my experience, they've only become more aggressive and ugly when confronted because they are ashamed of having been overheard. But as to the book ... I think I would need nerves of steel to read this one, so perhaps I'll move it to the bottom of the waiting list.


message 12: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Julie wrote: "TBV took the words right out of my mouth, Lisa. I needed to go take a nap after I read this. My one surprise was that the old (German) man only mumbled to you. In my experience, they've only become..."

He had his grandchild next to him, and I think he could see in my eyes that I would challenge his line of thought and not back down at that moment - I was furious. Racists are usually quite cowardly when confronted in an unexpected way. I didn't match his idea of a proper opponent. Had I been a darkskinned young man, he would probably have gone bonkers on me. But most old conservative men can't possibly imagine themselves yelling in dialect at a welldressed middle-aged blonde woman with an educated accent. Social code is all they can read. So he did what a misogynist does when he can't argue his case with a woman: pretending it's not a big deal, almost non-existent ;-/


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa TBV wrote: "Whew, that sounds exhausting. Very nicely written, Lisa."

Oh it was, TBV! I needed a whole day to recover!


message 14: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Dimitri wrote: "The reader location forms part of the experience. Yours is one of the most memorable I've read hereabouts"

Thanks, Dimitri!


message 15: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala So good, Lisa, your journey mirroring your reading, so that we get a double impression of what this book is like. I'm reeling � I think I'll have a second coffee.


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "So good, Lisa, your journey mirroring your reading, so that we get a double impression of what this book is like. I'm reeling � I think I'll have a second coffee."

Thanks, Fionnuala! I think it is actually your strength to connect your reading to your life - and your sharing stimulates all of us!


message 17: by dianne b. (new) - added it

dianne b. Wonderful, palpable review.


message 18: by Jaline (new)

Jaline Excellent review, Lisa!


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Jaline wrote: "Excellent review, Lisa!"

Thanks, Jaline!


message 20: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa dianne wrote: "Wonderful, palpable review."

Thanks, Dianne!


message 21: by Kevin (new)

Kevin That was fantastic, I feel like I traveled there beside you, taking it all in as you read your book and moved across the landscape. 💕


message 22: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Kevin wrote: "That was fantastic, I feel like I traveled there beside you, taking it all in as you read your book and moved across the landscape. 💕"

Thank you so much, Kevin! Happy you tagged along for the ride :-)


Alexandra Great! The experience of your journey connected to the feelings with the book 👍🏻


message 24: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Alexandra wrote: "Great! The experience of your journey connected to the feelings with the book 👍🏻"

Yes, it really did!


message 25: by Ray (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ray Wonderful personal review of what sounds a great, if searing, book.

Good for you on calling out an elderly racist. If only the rest of us were like this then the world would be a better place. I write this as people in el paso are facing the consequences of incitement to hate from an elderly racist


message 26: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Ray wrote: "Wonderful personal review of what sounds a great, if searing, book.

Good for you on calling out an elderly racist. If only the rest of us were like this then the world would be a better place. I w..."


Thanks, Ray! And I agree. The racists that used to keep at least a bit of a low profile earlier feel emboldened by the elected haters. What infuriated me most about the situation was that he thought he'd find approval for his remarks - thinking my looks put me in "his" tribe. Nauseating...


Annie wonderful review of a wonderful book! made me wish to re-read it instantly.


message 28: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Dyrgripen wrote: "wonderful review of a wonderful book! made me wish to re-read it instantly."

Thank you so much, Dyrgripen!


message 29: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Wonderful review. This sounds a very intense reading experience, Lisa.


message 30: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Ilse wrote: "Wonderful review. This sounds a very intense reading experience, Lisa."

Yes, I can't remember any other of that kind - it was like the double journey intensified throughout the day too...


message 31: by Cecily (last edited Jul 07, 2020 09:42AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cecily I did enjoy sharing your reading journey, both literal and metaphorical.

Well done for calling out the racist comment on the train - and a small hooray for this startling book.

(In the before times, when one could travel, I would read in transit. On the rare occasions I reacted visibly, I was never aware of anyone even looking curious.)


message 32: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Cecily wrote: "I did enjoy sharing your reading journey, both literal and metaphorical.

Well done for calling out the racist comment on the train - and a small hooray for this startling book.

(In the before ti..."


I think you are better at composing yourself when you read and therefore manage not to draw too much negative attention to yourself while reading in public, Cecily! I tend to live a bit too much in my head, and express that a bit too openly, much to the mean joy of my students who listen to me expressing anger or surprise while sitting alone at my library desk marking papers in full passionate craziness... Guess I am just about to confess my insanity here, so I break off.


message 33: by Clio (new) - rated it 4 stars

Clio One of your best reviews!


message 34: by Jack (new) - added it

Jack I love this review. Well done!


back to top