ŷ

Trace's Reviews > To Sir Phillip, With Love

To Sir Phillip, With Love by Julia Quinn
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5079926
's review

did not like it

Fuck off, Sir Philip, fuck off fuck off fuck off.
1939 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read To Sir Phillip, With Love.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 12, 2012 – Started Reading
March 12, 2012 – Shelved
March 12, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lauren I felt this to my core while reading it, hard agree. Anger issues is not what most people would call "sexy," and certainly doesn't constitute as a redeeming quality worth sticking around to "fix" 🙄


Ellie "Marriage is great! My wife takes care of everything, including my kids, while I fuck off doing my own thing, until I wanna have relations. Wait, you don't agree? I don't get it."

So annoying. So bad. So frustrating. Fuck off indeed.


Leena Aluru I so agree with you. My review was so much milder- I'm regretting it.


Mudibu  Rita Nsumbu Okay yeah I’m so glad I’m not the only one who didn’t think Phillip was a stand up guy. Dude needs therapy and anger management like real bad. Not the match I would have wanted for Eloise or anyone really


Alia McHugh A fuckin men


message 6: by Shruti (new)

Shruti (Hiatus) I dont even know what this book is about but I really enjoyed this review 😂


Leena Aluru Don't bother even for curiosity sake.


mandinmandin A TRUE POS


Rose  Faour Oh my! Such strong language for a character in a fiction book! Really?


message 10: by Fem (new) - rated it 1 star

Fem loonieslibrary Literally DESPISE him


Jenny Ullrich that was my thought during reading. he is just an idiot.


message 12: by megan (new) - rated it 1 star

megan Your review matches my thoughts exactly!

When I read comments on twitter about how great a match Eloise and Phillip make I was really looking forward to reading the book - setting aside my expectations of the second season of Bridgerton the tv show and also setting aside my hopes of Eloise and Theo finding a way to eachother. But after reading this book I really hope that the romance between Phillip and Eloise will not be part of the show or that at least drastic changes will be made since I find him a rather unpleasant fellow and unsuitable for such a free spirited woman such as Eloise.


Larissa Roussille Read this review before reading the book and thought "can't be that bad"... but this review is spot on.


message 14: by մdzá (new)

մdzá Flórez Dilo


message 15: by Yana (new) - added it

Yana One of the best reviews on goodreads


Mikayla Absolutely, yes, I agree.


Gabrielle Sums up my feelings perfectly, thank you


Sarah My thoughts exactly. Did Eloise dirty on this book.


firebreathingbq I came to read spoiler free reviews, and I started laughing when I yours


message 20: by Lilo (new) - added it

Lilo I couldn't have written a better review myself.


Sofia ✨ so relatable


Crystal Walsh I actually don’t understand the hate of Philip. He
Comes from a highly abusive childhood where he actually has scars on his back from being horse whipped. Not exactly sure how everyone expects him to act lol where is the hate on that damn nurse who was beating his children with a book? I was expecting there to be a more in depth love story with Eloise that I will agree upon instead of runs away to his home without telling anyone and is married 2 weeks later. I’m hoping when they do the show there will be more back and forth and more of her feisty spirit in the show.


Jayleen Philip must have invented the red flag


message 24: by Rhea (new) - rated it 2 stars

Rhea Absolutely agreed. Such an infuriating person. Didn't understand how Eloise could fall for him. Didn't understand how anyone could. And the whole "women are like this and that" labeling drove me absolutely crazy.


message 25: by Jus (new) - rated it 1 star

Jus Just about to read the book. Love your review!


Cindy Williams This is the best review! Lol


message 27: by arina (new) - rated it 1 star

arina @Crystal (spoiler - quote) ‘He’d married Eloise in part, well, more than in part, almost in whole, in truth, because he’d wanted her to take charge, to take all the annoying little tasks in his life, to free him up for the things that really mattered. The fact that he was growing to care for her, had been an unexpected bonus� sums it up tbh


ĐܰᲹ Stanimirović Thank you for this awesome review. Could not have said it better


back to top