Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind
Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind
by
by

”Despite the astonishing things that humans are capable of doing, we remain unsure of our goals and we seem to be as discontented as ever. We have advanced from canoes to galleys to steamships to space shuttles � but nobody knows where we’re going. We are more powerful than ever before, but have very little idea what to do with all that power. Worse still, humans seem to be more irresponsible than ever. Self-made gods with only the laws of physics to keep us company, we are accountable to no one. We are consequently wreaking havoc on our fellow animals and on the surrounding ecosystem, seeking little more than our own comfort and amusement, yet never finding satisfaction.�
Cave of the Hands. Cueva de las manos in Argentina. The art in this cave dates from 13,000 to 9,000 years ago. I find this photograph to be very emotional to think about because this band of Humans are saying...we were here.
The pursuit of happiness is one of the many big themes that Yuval Noah Harari covers in this remarkable book about the history of Homo Sapiens. He brings us from the beginning of our known history to the present and offers his interpretations and evaluations of our conduct along the way. There are many points in the book where he crystallized my thinking about a subject, and there are several other points where he encouraged me to think about what I know in different ways. Since taking myself out of the rat race, I’ve had a lot of time to ponder exactly what I was trying to accomplish for the 30+ years I pursued money and career advancement. Now, I want to make sure with what time I have left to spend it pursuing something much more meaningful and satisfying than the pursuit of more and more money.
This book will make you uncomfortable. You may disagree with some of his conclusions, but do not use that as an excuse to not read the book. He will also enlighten you on other points that very well may help shape your personal philosophy. I have been thinking about reading the book for some time, but what convinced me was all the one star reviews for the book on Amazon. It was quickly apparent to me that most of those reviews were written by religious people who never read the book but were told they should be offended by it because of his opinions on religion. He doesn’t just believe that Christianity is a fabricated construct, but also thinks that nationalism and a whole host of other -isms are as well.
”How do you cause people to believe in an imagined order such as Christianity, democracy or capitalism?�
Or how about this one?
”It may well be that we’d all be better off if Christianity and Islam had been forgotten or defeated.�
Why did Constantine the Great pick Christianity as the religion of the empire? We really don’t know. It was far from a dominant religion at the time. Harari compares it to a POTUS waking up one morning and deciding that the Hare Krishnas are the national religion. It is hard to fathom that it was a moment of altruism. He was an intelligent man and must have felt that Christianity offered the best way to better control his people and unite them under one concept, instead of the host of gods that polytheism offered.
I come away from this book realizing how deeply brainwashed I’ve been about a whole host of issues, and I have been remiss in not questioning more of the foundations of thought or intent behind most of my long held beliefs.
The big revelatory moment for me was when he talked about individualism.
”The state and the market approached people with an offer that could not be refused. ‘Become individuals,� they said. ‘Marry whomever you desire, without asking permission from your parents. Take up whatever job suits you, even if community elders frown. Live wherever you wish, even if you cannot make it every week to the family dinner. You are no longer dependent on your family or your community. We, the state and the market, will take care of you instead. We will provide food, shelter, education, health, welfare and employment. We will provide pensions, insurance and protection.� Romantic literature often presents the individual as somebody caught in a struggle against the state and the market. Nothing could be further from the truth. The state and the market are the mother and father of the individual, and the individual can survive only thanks to them.�
How often do we hear the term “stand on your own two feet?� Or “pull yourself up by your own bootstraps?� Looking for help from others in current culture is seen as a sign of weakness. Standing as individuals has made us weaker, not stronger. We are accused of a form of co-dependency if we are too attached to our extended family or our friends. I’d never really thought about how being individualistic was actually helping the powers-that-be to exert more control us. We are experiencing a great divide in politics, and many of my friends have already decided they won’t be going home for the holidays. We used to be able to set disagreements aside and focus on what we do agree on, like...baseball or reading books or the weather, but now politics has become such a defining part of our lives that we feel like those who disagree with us are actually immoral.
Have all these technological advances made us happier? To a degree yes, but also very unhappy in other aspects. The demands on our attention are more immediate and all consuming. Even when we relax, we are not really relaxed. Faster and more efficient doesn’t necessarily equate to making anyone, but the people making the enormous amounts of money at the top, any happier.
”Nothing in the comfortable lives of the urban middle class can approach the wild excitement and sheer joy experienced by a forager band on a successful mammoth hunt. Every new invention just puts another mile between us and the Garden of Eden.�
I made 62 highlights reading this book, which is an all-time record for me. I could have had even more! Harari gave me so much to ponder and consider that I’ve already decided that in a few years I’m going to reread the book. I borrowed the book from the library, but I already know I will need to own this one because a book like this needs to be readily available to help me better explain my own thoughts. I could have written a review as long as the book itself because there are so many assertions in this book that cause the mind to expand and make new connections across a myriad of subject matters. It is the most important book I’ve read in a long time. I hope it will be for many of you as well.
We are gods on this planet, and we need to change our view of how we see ourselves in the context of the planet and the future.
”Is there anything more dangerous than dissatisfied and irresponsible gods who don’t know what they want?�
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
Cave of the Hands. Cueva de las manos in Argentina. The art in this cave dates from 13,000 to 9,000 years ago. I find this photograph to be very emotional to think about because this band of Humans are saying...we were here.
The pursuit of happiness is one of the many big themes that Yuval Noah Harari covers in this remarkable book about the history of Homo Sapiens. He brings us from the beginning of our known history to the present and offers his interpretations and evaluations of our conduct along the way. There are many points in the book where he crystallized my thinking about a subject, and there are several other points where he encouraged me to think about what I know in different ways. Since taking myself out of the rat race, I’ve had a lot of time to ponder exactly what I was trying to accomplish for the 30+ years I pursued money and career advancement. Now, I want to make sure with what time I have left to spend it pursuing something much more meaningful and satisfying than the pursuit of more and more money.
This book will make you uncomfortable. You may disagree with some of his conclusions, but do not use that as an excuse to not read the book. He will also enlighten you on other points that very well may help shape your personal philosophy. I have been thinking about reading the book for some time, but what convinced me was all the one star reviews for the book on Amazon. It was quickly apparent to me that most of those reviews were written by religious people who never read the book but were told they should be offended by it because of his opinions on religion. He doesn’t just believe that Christianity is a fabricated construct, but also thinks that nationalism and a whole host of other -isms are as well.
”How do you cause people to believe in an imagined order such as Christianity, democracy or capitalism?�
Or how about this one?
”It may well be that we’d all be better off if Christianity and Islam had been forgotten or defeated.�
Why did Constantine the Great pick Christianity as the religion of the empire? We really don’t know. It was far from a dominant religion at the time. Harari compares it to a POTUS waking up one morning and deciding that the Hare Krishnas are the national religion. It is hard to fathom that it was a moment of altruism. He was an intelligent man and must have felt that Christianity offered the best way to better control his people and unite them under one concept, instead of the host of gods that polytheism offered.
I come away from this book realizing how deeply brainwashed I’ve been about a whole host of issues, and I have been remiss in not questioning more of the foundations of thought or intent behind most of my long held beliefs.
The big revelatory moment for me was when he talked about individualism.
”The state and the market approached people with an offer that could not be refused. ‘Become individuals,� they said. ‘Marry whomever you desire, without asking permission from your parents. Take up whatever job suits you, even if community elders frown. Live wherever you wish, even if you cannot make it every week to the family dinner. You are no longer dependent on your family or your community. We, the state and the market, will take care of you instead. We will provide food, shelter, education, health, welfare and employment. We will provide pensions, insurance and protection.� Romantic literature often presents the individual as somebody caught in a struggle against the state and the market. Nothing could be further from the truth. The state and the market are the mother and father of the individual, and the individual can survive only thanks to them.�
How often do we hear the term “stand on your own two feet?� Or “pull yourself up by your own bootstraps?� Looking for help from others in current culture is seen as a sign of weakness. Standing as individuals has made us weaker, not stronger. We are accused of a form of co-dependency if we are too attached to our extended family or our friends. I’d never really thought about how being individualistic was actually helping the powers-that-be to exert more control us. We are experiencing a great divide in politics, and many of my friends have already decided they won’t be going home for the holidays. We used to be able to set disagreements aside and focus on what we do agree on, like...baseball or reading books or the weather, but now politics has become such a defining part of our lives that we feel like those who disagree with us are actually immoral.
Have all these technological advances made us happier? To a degree yes, but also very unhappy in other aspects. The demands on our attention are more immediate and all consuming. Even when we relax, we are not really relaxed. Faster and more efficient doesn’t necessarily equate to making anyone, but the people making the enormous amounts of money at the top, any happier.
”Nothing in the comfortable lives of the urban middle class can approach the wild excitement and sheer joy experienced by a forager band on a successful mammoth hunt. Every new invention just puts another mile between us and the Garden of Eden.�
I made 62 highlights reading this book, which is an all-time record for me. I could have had even more! Harari gave me so much to ponder and consider that I’ve already decided that in a few years I’m going to reread the book. I borrowed the book from the library, but I already know I will need to own this one because a book like this needs to be readily available to help me better explain my own thoughts. I could have written a review as long as the book itself because there are so many assertions in this book that cause the mind to expand and make new connections across a myriad of subject matters. It is the most important book I’ve read in a long time. I hope it will be for many of you as well.
We are gods on this planet, and we need to change our view of how we see ourselves in the context of the planet and the future.
”Is there anything more dangerous than dissatisfied and irresponsible gods who don’t know what they want?�
If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Sapiens.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
September 26, 2019
–
Started Reading
September 26, 2019
– Shelved
September 26, 2019
– Shelved as:
science
September 26, 2019
– Shelved as:
nonfiction
October 3, 2019
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)
date
newest »


Most of my younger friends have no interest in marriage and most of my older friends say never again. We have become too individualistic for marriage or even pairing up. Any relationship requires compromise and my friends don't seem interested in having to do so even if the benefits of companionship outweigh what are perceived as negatives. Suicide rates will continue to climb as people become more and more isolated. The pursuit of money and individualism and the isolationism from family and real friends will lead most of the next generation into leading lives of lonely desperation tapping away at one keyboard or another in search of entertainment that doesn't require friends.


In this case Alex I borrowed a digital copy of the book so I made the highlights on my Kindle, but in the case of 98% of my reading I read a "real" book and I make notes as I go. I keep those notes with the book so that I can quickly reference a passage if I need my memory refreshed. When I buy a copy of this book I will transfer my Kindle highlights to old fashioned pencil and paper. Thanks Alex! I hope you are always keeping notes of everything you read because decades in the future you will find it invaluable.

Thanks Lisa! You won't regret bumping it up. You will find much to ponder between the covers of this book.

This is definitely a book with such large, arching themes that a reader can reread this book periodically and discover new thoughts or revisit old thoughts with fresh eyes. You are welcome Sharmili. I hope you continue to find new wisdom with each reading.


Absolutely, in our quest to be productive and dominate we have almost abandoned our priority of finding happiness. It is only when we get older that we realize that we spent most of our lives chasing the wrong things. We have been such a menace to everything on this planet and yet we still can't be content. Thanks Bharath! This book created so many great discussions in my household. I've changed my focus in the past few years and Harari confirmed for me that I'm finally on the right track.

”How do you cause people to believe in an imagined order such as Christianity, democracy or capitalism?�
Perhaps you got this quote wrong, but it seems that Classical Greece is known (from surviving Classical literature) to have had a form of "democracy." And circa 1789 the U.S. wrote down the "right kind" of democracy - designed in part to avoid Mob Rule (the Founders, mostly familiar with the Classics, no doubt knew that "a democracy killed Socrates")
Perhaps I'm too literally interpreting a provocation? What does he say is "imaginary" about the form of governance that most respectable societies currently offer?
Likewise, what is "imaginary" about Capitalism - the economic system that most respectable societies currently practice?
(the ones that don't are "poor" by many objective measures, for instance in how loud one's stomach rumbles at what we call breakfast-, lunch-, and dinner-times)
The idea that we are co-dependent is so ingrained, that evolutionary psychologists theorize that co-dependent behavior is largely innate - whatever "they" may say. It's part of the "air we breathe" (to use a not-literal metaphor).
I'll stop and let the rest of the "romance" go unchallenged and close by saying thanks for "taking one for, if not 'the team' ", then "taking one for me".
(or perhaps you can cite some other, less trivial, "connections"?)

/review/show..."
Jim if you suggest one more review to me I will block you. Everyone interprets or chooses to talk about certain aspects of a book. I chose some things that would be more controversial to readers because I wanted people to be intrigued by the book. You choose to be offended. I'm sorry you are offended.

”How do you cause people to believe in an imagined order such as Christianity, democracy or capitalism?�
Perhaps you got this quote wrong, but it seems that Classical Greece is know..."
Using terms like "romance" and "trivial" shows that you are intentionally being insulting to me for some reason. Maybe you need to read the book and then maybe you will understand what I am suggesting.
We have to believe in capitalism and christianity so that it works. If we don't believe in a lot of imaginary aspects of it for example how money that doesn't physically exist move through the system or how chrisitianity beliefs does not jive with known science. They are constructs that we either choose to believe in or not. It was a new path of thinking for me and I wanted to share that with my followers. I was trying to expand the thought of why we believe what we do and is it really working as well as we think it does.

”How do you cause people to believe in an imagined order such as Christianity, democracy or capitalism?�
Perhaps you got this quote wrong, but it seems that Classical Greece is know..."
If I had answered all of your irriations the review would be longer than what I can post. Reviews, by their intention, are meant to be short and show a window into the book. They are suppose to tease the reader into wanting to know more or for the reader to discover that they are too mired in their own view of the world to even entertain the idea of having their beliefs challenged. That would be you Jim.

OK, our posts crossed - I will delete mine - please don't block me, as you are by far my favorite reviewer - really!!

I honestly never intend to insult you. I'm very sorry to have crossed the line.
Keep up your excellent work.


Jim's frustration with me stems from the fact that when I write something in a review that challenges his core beliefs he wants me to support my comments in my reviews with a long list of sources beyond just the book I read. Obviously, I can't do that in the review. As he did here he searched around for reviews that in his mind refuted my review even though those reviewers just chose to focus on different aspects of the book. This book is full of concepts and there are plenty for any reviewer to focus on. I chose to talk about the ones that were most interesting to me. I had 62 highlights so I had many to choose from. I consider it rude to post reviews by other reviewers on my thread (those that didn't choose to challenge Jim's particular view of how things are supposed to work) especially when the person, in this case Jim, has not read the book. Jim and I generally work things out but I certainly seem particularly adept at pushing his buttons. That, of course, is not my intention unless of course I get him to consider things from a different viewpoint. Then, it is certainly worth shaking him up.



Well said Michael! You are right on the mark.

I am still processing all the changes this book has inspired in my world perspective. Counterintuitive is the perfect word to use with many of Harari's assertions. Our brains are wired so early to believe so many things without question. As I continue to discover how misguided many of my core beliefs are I almost feel like I'm becoming a different person, hopefully a wiser person. I do understand the wish for moments of naivete. The more we learn about how the world really works the more scary and unwieldy it seems. Thanks for the great comment Ron! I may have to reread this book sooner than later.

You are most welcome Diane. Do make time for this one. You won't regret it.

Thanks James! This definitely gave me much to ponder. I think most people would be surprised by how much he challenges what we presume to be self-evident.


Thanks Michael! I'm a huge Richard Powers fan and also intend to read The Hidden Trees as well. I'll have to dig out my copy of Overstory from the TBR mountains.


Thanks Bookophiliac! I hope you are finding plenty of books to keep your philiac fulfilled.

Yes, his mother was probably a factor for him decided to make this momentous change, but I feel always a little leary of blaming a woman for a man's decisions about religion. It sort of opens up the whole Eve concept and Christianity's tendencies to blame women for all of man's faults. Of course that is my atheist view, the Christians gave her the ultimate reward of sainthood. Thanks K! Very good point.

But there is also the fact that the reason for this joy is the insecurity and pain they go through before reaching their goal. We aren’t amazingly happy every time we get a meal, because we are used to it. We find joy someplace else. To me happiness isn’t so much about what you have or what you do, but the feeling you invest in it. To me the happiest people are those finding joy in small things, like a great book, a tree, a sunset, a familiar face smiling at you. You know how much I love languages and I have asked myself if I would have been that excited if there weren’t any foreing languages to learn. I believe I would have been. It isn’t the languages that make me happy, it is the desire to learn. There will always be something to learn and to improve. I think people’s needs and desires have not changed that much since the dawn of time. We still want the same things, but some of us can’t make the difference between goal and means. Some of us, maybe including myself sometimes, tend to forget that money and technology aren’t end game in itself. They are here to improve our lives, but we are the only ones who can give them a true meaning. Thank you, Jeffrey. As always, you give a lot of food for thought. May I say that I LOVE books and movies about ancient humans? I will list this.

I think we are now at a crossroads; we have to figure out a new way of running the world if it is to survive. One of the problems is that people who don't give a shit about anything often have the power to mess things up, and do. I just hope we fail to colonise other planets so that we have to sink or swim on this one � we don't deserve a second chance.

Wise words, Vessey. I find it so sad that so many people never read a book. If they did, they would improve their lives, I'm sure.

His quote on individualism above is spot-on. What capitalism wants is Economic Man who will consume without limits, only to find himself empty, broke, and alone.
A third of adults in the U.S. now live alone. I know people who have no friends. They go to movies and eat out alone. The WSJ, a vested interest, just ran an article about the virtues of eating alone. The reader comments were rather sad: "yes, I prefer that, so I don't have to worry about the tastes of others."
We are social creatures not meant to be isolated, as you say, by the state or an economic system. We celebrate individuals who seem to have reached the peak only to be shocked when they opt for suicide. They had everything, didn't they?