K.D. Absolutely's Reviews > Silence
Silence
by
by

K.D. Absolutely's review
bookshelves: 1001-core, japanese, religion, historical-fiction
Mar 31, 2012
bookshelves: 1001-core, japanese, religion, historical-fiction
Mind-blowing. It tells about the 17th century Japan when the Tokugawa shogunate was in power. During this time, practicing Catholics were called Kakure Kirishitan ("Hidden Christians") because they had to do their religious rituals underground. This was also the time of "fumie" a metal plate bearing the images of Jesus and Mary. The religious police asked the families suspected to be Catholics to trample this fumie to prove that they had not converted from Buddism.
It was also during this time when Portuguese missionaries arrived in Japan to further propagate the Catholic faith. This book, Silence tells the story of the Jesuit priest, Sebastian Rodriguez who has to come to Japan via Macao to find the truth about his mentor Cristobal Ferreira who is reported to have apostatized, i.e., have defected from the Catholic faith.
The first few chapters of the book are told in a chronicle-like narration. Fr. Rodriguez records his day-to-day experience during his journey to Japan. Once in the country, the narration shifts to third party narrator. The shift is like journeying together with the narrator and then later looking at the whole scene as a third person. The effect is fresh and invigorating despite the too sad and serious theme of sacrificing life and bearing all the tortures just to keep one's faith in God. Its impact to me was that I should not take my belief in God for granted because missionaries (now saints and blessed ones) gave up their lives to spread the Catholic faith all over the world. Although I am living in the Philippines and Catholicism spread in the country almost with no resistance, still what some missionaries in other parts of the world played the roles of martyrs and their examples should always be remembered.
The title of the book came from their question of why during this era in Japan, God had remained silent. That during the torture of the missionaries when they were asked to stay inside a small well until they were dead, God did not do anything. The question was answered at the end of the novel and it was I think an appropriate ending.
I recommend this book to all religious scholars who want to know more about that era in Japan. I also recommend this to all fans of Japanese novels in English. It is just mind-blowing and bewildering in this beauty: prose, theme and content.
My second Endo and he is still to disappoint. Whew!
It was also during this time when Portuguese missionaries arrived in Japan to further propagate the Catholic faith. This book, Silence tells the story of the Jesuit priest, Sebastian Rodriguez who has to come to Japan via Macao to find the truth about his mentor Cristobal Ferreira who is reported to have apostatized, i.e., have defected from the Catholic faith.
The first few chapters of the book are told in a chronicle-like narration. Fr. Rodriguez records his day-to-day experience during his journey to Japan. Once in the country, the narration shifts to third party narrator. The shift is like journeying together with the narrator and then later looking at the whole scene as a third person. The effect is fresh and invigorating despite the too sad and serious theme of sacrificing life and bearing all the tortures just to keep one's faith in God. Its impact to me was that I should not take my belief in God for granted because missionaries (now saints and blessed ones) gave up their lives to spread the Catholic faith all over the world. Although I am living in the Philippines and Catholicism spread in the country almost with no resistance, still what some missionaries in other parts of the world played the roles of martyrs and their examples should always be remembered.
The title of the book came from their question of why during this era in Japan, God had remained silent. That during the torture of the missionaries when they were asked to stay inside a small well until they were dead, God did not do anything. The question was answered at the end of the novel and it was I think an appropriate ending.
I recommend this book to all religious scholars who want to know more about that era in Japan. I also recommend this to all fans of Japanese novels in English. It is just mind-blowing and bewildering in this beauty: prose, theme and content.
My second Endo and he is still to disappoint. Whew!
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Silence.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 31, 2012
– Shelved
August 17, 2013
–
Started Reading
August 17, 2013
– Shelved as:
1001-core
August 17, 2013
– Shelved as:
japanese
August 17, 2013
– Shelved as:
religion
August 17, 2013
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
August 17, 2013
–
7.31%
"The Portuguese missionaries trying to spread Catholicism in Japan. This book is running for 5 stars!"
page
16
August 19, 2013
–
21.46%
"I'm about to begin Ch. 4. So far, each chapter is an account (letter) of the Catholic missionary Sebastian Rodrigues to his superiors in Portugal. The letters are horrifying and very informative about the life of Catholic missionaries in hostile (to other religions) Japan during the 17th century."
page
47
August 20, 2013
–
28.31%
"The title seems to have come from the repeated motif of the book: "The silence of God." When the Portuguese missionaries are being butchered, where is God? Why is God allowing good people to suffer? Where was God during the Holocaust, as another example?"
page
62
August 23, 2013
–
32.88%
"Reading this book feels like being there. The prose is very descriptive and honest (you know that he is not pulling strings on you). I am in this part when the narrator turns out to be unreliable when after telling the hardships that the missionaries are experiencing, he is now saying that there were successful ones before who were welcomed and treated well by the Japanese. Surprise!"
page
72
August 26, 2013
–
55.25%
"Anyone could be attracted by the beautiful and the charming. But could such attraction be called love? True love was to accept humanity when wasted like rags and tatters. (p. 116)"
page
121
September 2, 2013
–
91.78%
"Done reading. One of the unforgettable reads I had so far this year. Can leave all the images this book put in my head. I have to read a lighter book soon!"
page
201
September 2, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-3 of 3 (3 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Mekki
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Aug 17, 2013 08:55PM

reply
|
flag


The only reason why I did not give it a full 5 stars was Endo's tendency to repeat himself. Some of those were, I guess, intentional but some just annoyed me a bit.