ŷ

🌸 Tana 🌸's Reviews > The Queen of Nothing

The Queen of Nothing by Holly Black
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
40310867
's review

liked it
bookshelves: read-2019, released-2019, read-ebook-owned

08/12/2019

Okay after much debating, I've decided to lower my rating to a high 3 stars. I'm leaving my original thoughts right after finishing this up, but I can't leave this a 5 stars. This is why you don't write a review immediately after you finish a book kids

HUGE spoilers below!!



1) I loved the relationship that blossomed and got steady between Cardan and Jude. What I didn't like was that Taryn got forgiven so easily by Jude. Your sister, who made your life hell for some faerie dick and betrayed you multiple times for said dick, comes to your door and says sorry and you're all good? Just because she killed Locke? nah.

2) Locke is one of the main bad guys in the other books, just to get killed off in between book 2 and 3. Just like that he's gone.

3) the pacing was way too fast, which is to be expected from a book that is only 300 pages. Everything was resolved so quickly! the battle wasn't even a page long so to speak. No deaths, no repercussions at all for anyone.

4) Madoc gets away too easily for all that he's done. He tried to take over the throne and planned to murder the whole royal family, influenced his daughter and son, and he basically gets away with all of it. Jude just sends him away, WITH Oak. Who says he won't influence the boy to gain what he wants again?

5) you're telling me that Madoc and Oriana, who raised both girls can't see the difference between them? In none of the other books anyone mistaked them (except for Cardan, but he was hella drunk) for the other. And now the ones that raised them can't see the difference? it doesn't make sense at all

19/11/2019

I can't believe this series is over!!!! Did I read this in the span of a couple of hours the moment it dropped on my kindle? You bet your ass I did.

"mock me all you like. Whatever I imagined then, now it is I who would beg and grovel for a kind word from your lips."His eyes are black with desire."By you, I am forever undone."

This was everything I hoped for and more! I didn't think that 300 pages would be enough, and to be fair I could have used around 300 more, but that didn't hinder my enjoyment. This whole series is written so damn well. I saw some people say that the politics were a bit less, but I didn't really see it like that tbh. After all this whole book is still about who is in power.

(view spoiler)

02/04/2019

what do you mean I have to wait almost a year for this???

Also, I hope the page count changes because 300 pages is not enough
33 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Queen of Nothing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 19, 2019 – Started Reading
November 19, 2019 – Shelved
November 19, 2019 –
page 100
31.15% "This is going by too fast, I need more pages"
November 19, 2019 –
page 210
65.42% "WHAT IN THE ACTUAL FUCK JUST HAPPENED"
November 19, 2019 – Shelved as: read-2019
November 19, 2019 – Finished Reading
November 20, 2019 – Shelved as: released-2019
March 7, 2021 – Shelved as: read-ebook-owned

Comments Showing 1-6 of 6 (6 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

MischaS_ thank you!!! Love point 4! I thought that I was the only one who realised how stupid that punishment was. Jude spend so much time keeping Oak away from Madoc and now she sends Madoc and he has like unlimited access to him?
That's like, he'll influence him and he can get him to revoke his banishment once Oak is the High King. Not really good thinking on Jude's part. But then again, there were so many laps of judgment.

Plus if it's the same Madoc as from book one and two there is no way he's going to take that lying down... Okay, unless he's the good guy who can accept when he lost as he appeared in book 3. 🤦‍♀�


🌸 Tana 🌸 MischaS_ wrote: "thank you!!! Love point 4! I thought that I was the only one who realised how stupid that punishment was. Jude spend so much time keeping Oak away from Madoc and now she sends Madoc and he has like..."

Yes I agree! it just felt like all Jude's judgement fled from her brain... none of it made sense, she was so cunning she could trick faeries, what happened???


MischaS_ Tana △⃒� ⚯� wrote: "MischaS_ wrote: "thank you!!! Love point 4! I thought that I was the only one who realised how stupid that punishment was. Jude spend so much time keeping Oak away from Madoc and now she sends Mado..."

Same here! What happened?! No scheming, no tricking and everyone were just sooo nice.
Even Madoc, just stops fighting? 🤦‍♀️Nope.


Aoife - Bookish_Babbling Hard agree to all of this, wish I could have been as succinct when i wrote my wafflefest in much the same state as you did lolz...but i maxxed out the character count allowed by GR 🫣


🌸 Tana 🌸 Aoife - Bookish_Babbling wrote: "Hard agree to all of this, wish I could have been as succinct when i wrote my wafflefest in much the same state as you did lolz...but i maxxed out the character count allowed by GR 🫣"

haha that's amazing! I don't think I ever ran out of characters on goodreads before, even when ranting about a book


Aoife - Bookish_Babbling It was my first and so far only time - although that is not to say that in general my reviews aren't massively wordy in and of themselves 🙈🤗


back to top