ŷ

Sallar's Reviews > Prisoner: My 544 Days in an Iranian Prison—Solitary Confinement, a Sham Trial, High-Stakes Diplomacy, and the Extraordinary Efforts It Took to Get Me Out

Prisoner by Jason Rezaian
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
10643629
's review

did not like it

Update: I’ve a had a few months to sleep on this and I thought it’s more fair if I reduce my rating to 1 star.

I feel like a total asshole for giving this book a bad review. But let me explain.

I’m an Iranian and I deeply hate the Iranian government and how they treat people. They are unjust, brutal and terrifying at best and I would never ever ask someone to go and visit Iran while the current regime exists. I’ve left Iran 5 years ago and so far I’ve heard of many of my friends being imprisoned like Jason for things they have not done. I’m sorry that Jason went through that and I think I can understand the terror and anger he must have felt and still does to this day.

But I need to talk about Jason himself in this book because several things bothered me. I listened to the audiobook and he himself was the narrator. This was not a good idea because now I know that I haven’t imagined his “tone�.

His sexist and racist remakes, the constant profanity and smugness, being proud of weird “American� things like McDonalds and private jets, the name dropping, making fun of people’s accents, attire and looks, thinking that he’s above everyone and everything because he’s an American citizen, “commanding� his elderly mother constantly to “do more�, and many other small instances of his douchebaggery in this book really put me off.

The “ugly� city that he saw from the plane when leaving Iran, was the same city that made him famous (before being imprisoned that is), the same city he was bragging about living in like a king in the beginning of the book.

I really wish that he had thought a bit more about the words he chose when writing this book. I mean I understand that he’s angry and he wants the world to know what he’s been through, but this is not the way.
22 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Prisoner.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 21, 2019 – Started Reading
November 21, 2019 – Shelved
November 26, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali Afghah What you explained is like cleaning your dirty laundry with dirt! But one thing I should point out is that you can be an a-hole and also getting unjustly imprisoned. I should read the book to get closer to what you're implying.


Sallar Ali wrote: "What you explained is like cleaning your dirty laundry with dirt! But one thing I should point out is that you can be an a-hole and also getting unjustly imprisoned. I should read the book to get c..."
Yes, like I explained at the beginning, I'm not questioning his imprisonment or the pain he has gone through. I'm just pointing out that Jason as a person, is a douchebag. So the 1 star is solely based on his personality and the writing style. If he was not a douchebag, the book would get 5 stars from me.


message 3: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali Afghah I think your rating should reflect the quality of the book, not the author; even if it’s biographical and the person in the biography is the worst person in the world, if the writing and storytelling is good, that should be the rating factor. But this is all my opinion. You can have yours.


Sallar That’s the thing. The writing and storytelling is not good. And my rating reflects that.


message 5: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali Afghah One unrelated question. I see that you've read the book in 5 days. How many hours you put aside for reading? I'm struggling with my 20mins daily habit.


Sallar I listen to audiobooks so it’s easier to listen while I walk my dog. Written text makes me dizzy


message 7: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali Afghah Got it ... thanks for the tip 👌🏼


Virginia I don’t know what perspective you had when you read it but it sure didn’t come across like that to me! I am Iranian and I did not think that one bit


Sallar So the misogyny wasn't obvious?


back to top