ŷ

Ilana (illi69)'s Reviews > Me

Me by Elton John
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59371159
Admittedly, I’m not the ideal reader for this book. I like a few songs of Elton John’s, have childhood memories of him in the 70s as an outrageous performer dressed in garish clothes & accessories who played surprisingly mellow piano tunes for all that. That’s was pretty much the only impression he’d left me with since.

His fame grew & grew; tabloid stories about is he or is he not bisexual, or is he gay; notorious drug & alcohol abuse; close friendships with Gianni Versace and Lady Di, both ending tragically. Even I tuned in for her funerals & his performance of a rewritten “Candle In The Wind� in her honour, at which I shed a tear. I was a twelve year old still starry-eyed girl when her royal wedding was celebrated with all that pompous circumstance, and her horrific death was shocking to everyone.

I cannot decide whether the title of this autobiography, “Me� is an exercise in humility or complete narcissism. I suspect he couldn’t either, so left it for the rest of the world to figure out. In his one and only autobiography, Elton John gives a linear narrative of his life, from growing up as Reginald Kenneth Dwight, a boy obsessed with music raised by parents who were ill-suited for each other and constantly fighting, a father with whom the only common ground was football which became a lifelong passion for the singer. He describes being naive and unsophisticated as a young man, who had no sexual curiosity or drive, until he suddenly found his libido at 21.

Finding his footing as a performer, he eventually changed his name, became a flamboyant artist and dresser, and a wildly promiscuous coke & booze fiend. He spells out that he had no wish to gloss over any of those “ugly� bits in telling of his life story, partly because he eventually found himself at a self-described revolting low which he knew he had to recover from, or die. That, and also because he was aiming for authenticity in his life as man now more than 30 years free of substance abuse.

Having found sobriety after incredible excesses which he talks about without glossing over embarrassing details � in a way I recognize, because so freeing in their revelation, as someone who doesn't hide from my mistakes and great failings either�, he’s been dedicated to helping many others in need of rehabilitation. Well known figures, a few he named (Eminem stuck in my mind) and people whose privacy he is safeguarding. One of his most laudable contributions has been to his AIDS foundation, which he started after the death of some of his closest friends. Notably Freddy Mercury, who could have been saved in the year following his passing with life extending drug treatments.

Much of the book is dedicated to his musical career, his relationships with songwriters and musicians, his album recordings and singles, his countless years on the road touring the world, details about meeting and working with other superstars. He discusses his “five big loves� (according to this article ) including Linda Woodrow, the woman he was engaged to marry, but especially David Furnish, his longtime partner whom he married in 2014. Then, fatherhood coming in his 60s and how a gay couple managed to achieve such a thing (hint: lots of money, surrogacy), waxes lyrical about the transformative powers of parenthood, etc.

Ok. Fine. Here’s the thing: I don’t care about famous people. I’m curious about their lives because they get to mix with all sorts of people and have influenced pop culture and mark eras and are part of the zeitgeist and so on. On the whole, they’re rarely people I would want to spend any time with, given the opportunity. The massive egos, the insecurity stoking those egos, and the narcissism needed to achieve that level of fame tend to make for unpleasant & often abusive individuals. Not always. However, Elton John doesn't seem to be an exception. By and large, megastars tend to be narcissistic users (redundant but making a point). He speaks about this aspect of himself too. Elton John has done a lot of therapy to overcome his addictions and rein in his mercurial temperament, but self-awareness doesn’t change anything much when a strong temper refuses to be tamed.

I’m put off by his superficiality which he expresses with a garish facade I find unpleasant and vulgar. His obsession with Versace’s bold, in your face regalia, the kinds of clothes only worn by a certain of people who expects to be the centre of attention at all times, is excessively annoying to me. Case in point: Versace is quoted as saying "I don't believe in good taste,". It was said "Armani dresses the wife, Versace dresses the mistress." As it happens, the only designer piece I own is an Armani dress, because I love beautiful & elegant design and abhor bad taste and men who take on mistresses dolled up like expensive whores (we’re supposed to call them “sex workers in 2021 because “sex work is valid & empowering�).

Towards the end, he describes how fulfilling he finds his role as a parent, but you somehow don’t hear much about the children. There was a boy in an orphanage who initially sparked that burning desire to becomes father. But what I gleaned was that his primary goal was fulfilling HIS need when the urge for family struck him as a sexagenarian. True enough, his partner had wanted children too and all parents follow their own needs & biological imperative for having children, but it seemed all of a piece with a pattern of egoism which I doesn’t translate into actual love. That is my subjective perception as the daughter of a narcissistic parent who put her needs above mine & told me she wanted a baby and an ally all in one.

Finally, what tilted the balance to a negative rating and overall impression was a not an inconsequential detail. Not all famous people choose to read the audiobook edition of their autobiographies. We are led to believe these are their own words, when most turn to professional authors who don’t receive credit & remain in the shadows. Narrating the opening and closing chapters exclusively while leaving the rest to a professional narrator wouldn't be unusual. But this book is titled Me , and in it, there are a lot of words and sentences and paragraphs and whole chapters to convince us/himself that since his sobriety, he became a much simpler, humbler version of Elton John, the Superstar. He wants to convince us fatherhood has made him a simpler man who enjoys being a parent able to go to a Pizza Express with his kids and be treated like an ordinary person; to talk with moms at school events about things having nothing to do with his music, such as school uniforms. All that just made me shake my head and say, Okay, sure thing Reggie, gotcha.

Originally gave this three stars because it was full of interesting tidbits, but I think I’ll downgrade to 2.5 � “Good in parts but...� Ultimately, I can’t stand the guy. The very least he could’ve done is narrated his own fuxking book.
49 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Me.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 24, 2019 – Started Reading
November 24, 2019 – Shelved
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: 20th-century
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: library-book
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: culture
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: biography-memoir
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: audiobooks
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: 21st-century
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: lgb_etc
November 24, 2019 – Shelved as: music
November 24, 2019 –
71.0%
November 26, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro I'm a huge fan of Sir Elton and his music, but I also appreciate your candid review, Ilana.


Ilana (illi69) Sorry Kevin. That’s me. I don’t set out to be hurtful, and I did reign it in a bit because I know he is much beloved and I do have a certain amount of respect for the man, but nobody is more than just another human being to me. And I can only ever call it the way I see it. Which is why I’m not rich nor successful. 😉


message 3: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Ilana wrote: "Sorry Kevin. That’s me. I don’t set out to be hurtful, and I did reign it in a bit because I know he is much beloved ..."

Hey, I don't mind at all, Ilana!
It would be a boring world if we all liked the same things.
Besides, I'm sometimes critical of authors whom other people worship. It's all good. : )


message 5: by Emma (new)

Emma Ilana, what a great review. I will probably borrow this from the library rather than buy it myself. I’m fascinated by people’s lives (and that means any ones, not just those who are famous) but not a huge fan of him. And it’s made me laugh he couldn’t even be arsed to read his own audio book! 🤣


Ilana (illi69) Thank you Emma! I don’t write proper reviews often enough these days, but I’m happy with this one. I got it from the library as well, and don’t feel like I’ve wasted my time, as I was genuinely curious. I too am interested people’s lives and stories... from all walks of life, and he has been part of all our lives for so many decades now. I was born in 1969, so his music has been in the soundtrack of my entire life, along with countless others, but of course he is a hall of famer.

I may change my mind about my rating again... or not. I’m not that interested in the music industry and egomaniacs do get under my skin. I’ll be curious to know what you make of it. I’ve no doubt this book will remain on top seller lists for a long to come, considering he has hundreds of millions of fans around the world.


message 7: by Tatevik (new)

Tatevik Nice review, Ilana! I like his songs, but you perfectly wrote exactly why I don't read famous people's memoirs that much. I think I read only 2-3.


message 8: by Federico (last edited Nov 28, 2019 01:48PM) (new)

Federico DN Awesome review Ilana! I like many of his songs but care little for him and possibly nothing at all after reading your review. Sounds like the type who would think he is a simple person because now eats pizza while at the same time not registering at all he is holding a piece with a diamond engraved golden fork. Oh well, one less book I have to worry about :p


Terence M - [Quot libros, quam breve tempus!] Federico DN said "Awesome review Ilana! I like many of his songs but care little for him and possibly nothing at all after reading your review." An excellent comment, Federico, to which I need add nothing (except that I really don't know/like/listen to his songs)!


message 10: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Fab review! I’m the same, he was just not on my radar growing up ... however I recently watched Rocketman and was quite impressed. It was actually quite moving at times . Have you seen it? 💕


message 11: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen Love your review. I am not a big fan of memoirs as they tend to 'bend history'. And Elton John IS a huge narcissist. He just happens to be a great entertainer too.


Ilana (illi69) Tatevik, I’d have to tally up how many famous people’s books I’ve read. Not very many, but some. A few I recommend: “Born à Crime� by Trevor Noah is definitely worth the detour, but then he isn’t exactly a vapid Hollywood romantic lead and is known for his intelligence to begin with, and his is a book I will definitely revisit. Alan Cumming’s “Not My Father’s Son� is so very touching, and his accent makes the audiobook an extra treat, besides which I enjoyed him as a narrator before picking it up. Tina Fey’s “Bossy Pants� is good for laughs if you like her kind of thing. I tried other SNL alumni and they didn’t do it for me though. To each their own. “Just Kids� by Patti Smith�. And Michelle Obama’s “Becoming�... I was really happy to make time for all those. All presumably people with incredibly busy lives, yet who somehow made time to lend us their voices for the complete duration of their memoirs. Imagine that. 😮


Ilana (illi69) Federico, Thanks, I’m glad you enjoyed my review, however I feel badly I’ve convinced you not to read the book. Every reader has such a completely subjective experience and is bound to read a different book from the next reader. You may notice aspects of it I barely noticed for instance.

Rarely do I pan a book to discourage others from reading it, with the notable exception of Heather Morris’s disgusting Holocaust porn she’s raking in big money for by reinventing history and making stories that have zero historical value on the backs of millions of Jews who were exterminated like vermin. She has no claims whatsoever to this history and the fact she’s published a SECOND book on this theme, and that the first book was originally written as a screenplay, shows she had her eye on monetizing Holocaust stories from the beginning. I despise the woman and despise the fact her books are so popular and people are learning about the Holocaust via these schmaltzy totally shitty barely realistic trashy novels. The second of which the person who told her the story tried to stop her from publishing it when he saw what she did with it. Because it was SO FAR REMOVED FROM THE TRUTH AND IT WAS AN INSULT TO CILKA’S MEMORY.

Did I get on my soap box again? And completely out of context? That would be because I would happily bring that soulless bitch to a jury of the dead victims and see what they’d make of her. May she burn in hell. 🤬

Next to her, Elton John literally is an angel. He’s helping find cures for AIDS or at least funding development for medicines to extend life till they find actual cures. THAT’S something worthwhile. Being an entertainer and bringing people joy, is worthwhile. Regardless of whether or not I like how he dresses or how many tantrums he throws. At least he’s not insulting the memory of millions of victims of genocide to make a name and buy a big house and boat. Or whatever the fuck.


message 14: by Tatevik (new)

Tatevik Ilana wrote: "Tatevik, I’d have to tally up how many famous people’s books I’ve read. Not very many, but some. A few I recommend: “Born à Crime� by Trevor Noah is definitely worth the detour, but then he isn’t e..."

Yeah, it's fascinating! Recently I've ordered 2 memoirs of Beverly Cleary, I will read these first as they arrive. I keep seeing some of the books you mentioned in my timeline. I wanted to read Obama's book, as I admire her a lot, I just need to find the book. My favorite from what I read is still Hawking's wife's memoir of their lives.


Ilana (illi69) Hi Sandra, I have not seen Rocketman. Guess I’ll get it from iTunes. I’m sure it’s a great show.


Ilana (illi69) Kathleen, it does seem to go hand in hand somehow, the capacity to entertain on that scale and extreme narcissism. It isn’t helped by the fact that their entourages usually accede to their every whims to stay in their good favours. I suspect even a modest person with the best of intentions must be transformed by all that fawning and attention.


Mark  Porton A very good review Ilana and your thoughts are pretty much in line with mine. His music was a part of my youth but I've found more reason to dislike him as time has passed (I like his music BTW). His abusive behaviour recently topped off by events at a concert in Australia where he verbally abused two security guards - apparently he again had issue with those paid small sums (in comparison) to ensure his safety. Yes he's a precious narcissist with a temper.


message 18: by Federico (last edited Dec 04, 2019 05:24AM) (new)

Federico DN Ilana wrote: "Federico, Thanks, I’m glad you enjoyed my review, however I feel badly I’ve convinced you not to read the book. Every reader has such a completely subjective experience and is bound to read a diffe..."

I wasn't going to read his book Ilana. you just gave me more reasons not to, but I wasn't going to anyway, even if I hadn't read your review lol! You know like you I don't really dig famous people, the massive egos, the conflicting personalities, the outrageous excesses, the image they sell in the media... so I'm always distrustful when I hear about famous individuals like Elton donating large amounts of money to charity or foundations they themselves created. Although worthwhile overall yes, in general most of the times rather than an act of kindness I can only see it as an attempt to wash away their sins and life of excesses, for their own sake or something to do for the eye of the public. For me it would be like seeing your Heather Morris donating millions to charity. Would she do it because she actually believes in it or would she do it to try convince people she has actually some redeeming qualities despite all the evil she's done? It's charity and some people will benefit from it, fine, good if that helps you sleep better at night Heather, but for me that wouldn't score points regarding her persona. Same with Elton I guess. Funding research for a disease he himself suffers and nearly died from. Humility or narcissism? I wish it was some other disease he donates to, then maybe I could see it differently. That's why I generally root for those few famous ones that are actually a good role model, human as they are, and donate millions anyway, because, they don't really have to. They donate to causes they are not even related to and cannot remotely benefit from. Sometimes you even hear about their wild donations after their death because at the time they wanted it to remain anonymous, and after their passing some close friend or relative finally reveals the secret. Or maybe that's just the image they want to sell to the world and they have some ulterior motive, who the fuck knows; but at least I cannot find a fault in them. Anyway, our dear Elton, exceptional entertainer, granted, and I'll never forget many of his wonderful songs. I reserve my doubts regarding the funding research part though. I don't think I'll ever read his memoir but I'll definitely watch his Rocketman movie sometime soon. And I'm positive I'll love it, like so many biographical movies :D


Brittany I appreciated your review, though I'm a huge fan of both Elton John and the more recent 'Rocketman.' I just wanted to say, in case it hadn't been said already, the man who reads the audio book is Taron Egerton. Egerton is the actor who portrayed Elton John and Elton asked he read it for it proved too emotional for him to do the whole thing. Just a new tidbit of information I wanted to pass along!


Ilana (illi69) Brittany: I know who Taron Egerton is and look forward to seeing the movie. Your comment doesn’t change my opinion one way or another. In fact, it only serves to confirm my views.


Ilana (illi69) Lisa: isn’t that the way with so many performers? We can love their work, but not their personalities. The same goes for many authors too obviously. Creative people are known for being difficult to get along with. I should know. I’m not successful nor on my way there, but I know how to offend better than how to befriend people! Lol


Julie Pederick Hi Ilana,
I appreciate your review which is extremely well written, but I'm not exactly sure why you would read an autobiography or listen to one of a man or his stage persona you do not like?
Most people certainly wouldn't bother reading a book by a person / author they don't like or a book they find distasteful or uninteresting. Its a lot of time you cannot get back.

I think you may have missed a part of the ending where he stated "I am not retiring, I am only giving up a life on the road, to concentrate more so on my aids foundation and my family and would like to have as normal a life as a person as myself can have." Or words to that affect.
As you will know he has already stated that he's been doing the school run, taking the children out shopping, and to the movies and doing the ordinary things parents do with their children. You complain that he doesn't talk too much about the children, but not many stars do talk publicly about their children or allow many photographs of them out publicly.
If you were famous, would you want your children's faces & details plastered all over the pages of the world for some sick psychopath to begin stalking like has occurred to other stars children or selves.
As Elton also stated earlier in the book. He woke up on morning to find a woman sitting on the end of his bed. Now a man of his means and money would have the ultimate insecurity, but this woman still got in.
There is a reason celebrities protect their children @ all cost & they should always be protected at all costs.
Obviously at their age children can not give consent for photographs & publicity & know the consequences of it till they are old enough to understand it & did not ask for the life of their parents.
Many children of celebrities have asked parents not to post pictures of them on social media and to ask the paparazzi not to photograph them (once they are of an age to understand).

At first, I must say I totally agree with you. I was a bit disappointed. Elton did not narrate the story himself. Only choosing to do the two parts at the beginning and the two at the end.
But once the meat of the story began,
personally I found that I preferred the narration of Taron Egerton, perhaps as we have so recently heard his voice as Elton's in the biopic Rocketman.

I love that through your reviews you are encouraging others to read the book even though you weren't that thrilled with it. I think that's an awesome attitude. As it's very true, not everyone thinks and feels the same.
Some like me will love it while others will despise it.

Wow, I have not heard of this horrid
woman Heather Morris disgusting book, raking in money from such a horrific time in the history of the world or of the Jewish people & its culture.
What a despicable human being!
That will be 2 books I completely boycott.
I had a strange fascinated on that war, (in high school), on the war efforts of those who opposed the Nazi's, the Jewish culture, those who took great risk hiding the Jews away & the resistance & a little of the holocaust itself. Both fiction & non fiction.
Although I can not read it today as it's too distressing, I don't like watching the news.
I wonder who Elton would be today If he could start again, come from a loving home, with caring parents,
not be followed around by an entourage of 'Yes Men', & always have blow up his nose or booze in his system?

Ilana, Elton asked Taron to read the book as it was much too distressing to record it.
Just imagine having to tell a microphone of billions about how some of ur nearest & dearest does & ur feelings on the subject.
I know I couldn't would you be able too at his age, when you become even more sentimental?
It would be 1 thing expressing your view & experiences to a ghost writer, & saying it once as the writer Alexis would have a dictaphone or recording device, but reading it over & over making mistakes as you would from emotions being dredged up, that you'd rather forget or leave unsaid (we all would needing re-take after re-take I'm sure if it was us narrating.)
Elton is a lyricist not an author nor narrator he only writes the music, not the words.

I enjoyed your opinion even though I thought quite differently rating it as the best Autobiography I've read all year, but meant within the last year.


Sandra Just wanted to say I love this review. Although I ultimately rated this book higher, (basically for the entertainment factor) I agree with your assessment of Elton John both as an artist and as an individual. You put into words what was nagging in the back of my mind as I read. It's almost like the superficial persona of "Elton John" took over the human being that was born Reginald Dwight. It probably happens a lot to famous people. They start to believe their own press. Kudos.


Ilana (illi69) Thanks Sandra, just saw your comment. 🙂


back to top