ŷ

Raul's Reviews > Silence

Silence by Shūsaku Endō
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
43664238
's review

really liked it

Had it not been for the reviews I had seen from my friends whose tastes and opinions I respect, I probably would not have read this book. Reason being that I hesitate to read religious and atheist books because of the preaching, a condescending tone that is normally vehicle for the rant that boils down to: we are in the right, they are in the wrong and these couple of hundreds of pages will be dedicated to proving my point. And given the short description that accompanied the story I thought that the book would somehow be one of those books, and how wrong I was, and how glad am I that there were reviews that encouraged me to read this book.

It is the first half of the seventeenth century, Christianity has been outlawed in Japan and clergy members and Christians found practicing are tortured, forced to apostatize and killed. Sebastião Rodrigues, a young Jesuit priest journeys to Japan in this age to find out what happened to his mentor Ferreira, who had also been a missionary in Japan for many years, whom he looked up to and admired and still cannot believe the reports concerning his apostatizing.

To provide some historical context, Western powers had already begun their exploits around the world by the period this book is set in. By the 1640s the Americas, Africa, and Asia had all in some way or other already been colonized and occupied, with slavery booming during this period. Japan, which was under an emperor no doubt, must have felt threatened by the Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch and other European powers� interest in Asia. Not to mention the wars the Portuguese and Spanish had been fighting in Asia against Muslims, and their racist and religious disdain for Asians being non-white and non-Christian. And to add to all this, the suspicion that the Christian faith was making the citizenry less loyal to the emperor and state, so Japan cut itself off from the outside world in 1641 and only dealt with foreigners from an artificial island off Nagasaki - an isolation that would last two centuries.

Back to the book, the Portuguese missionaries who had at first enjoyed a great relationship with the government and the lords find themselves in a fix; the relationship turns sour and the persecution of Christians begins. In comes Rodrigues, an enthusiastic priest, filled with ideals as he begins his quest.

Shusaku Endo is an incredible writer. His prose is magnificent, and his ability to describe the inner struggle of the priest as he faces torture and his faith is shaken, and to draw quite a portrait of the time and place was just remarkable. Silence here, the silence of God as cruelty happens is explored.
We journey with Rodrigues as he hides from the authorities, as he communes with Japanese peasants, as he suffers personal losses and loses the romanticized ideals he had on life and faith. Such unforgettable characters Endo built with the treacherous Kichinjiro and the priests, Rodrigues himself, Garpe and Ferreira as well as the Japanese Christians facing persecution and the persecuting Japanese officials.

I appreciate the honesty that the writer gives us with this story, honesty that is rare with books concerning faith or the lack thereof. Even though Shusaku Endo himself was a Catholic, there is no condescending here, just wonderful writing, excellently told.
59 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Silence.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 4, 2019 – Started Reading
December 4, 2019 – Shelved
December 11, 2019 –
page 140
52.43%
December 15, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Kathleen I've been anxiously awaiting your review of this one, Raul, and you did a beautiful job bringing out what makes this special.


Raul Kathleen wrote: "I've been anxiously awaiting your review of this one, Raul, and you did a beautiful job bringing out what makes this special."

Thank you so much Kathleen!


message 3: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi An outstanding review, Raul!


Raul Candi wrote: "An outstanding review, Raul!"

Thank you, Candi!


message 5: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Chaikin This was has been on my shelf awhile, quietly calling. Terrific review!


Richard (on hiatus) Sounds very good .......... an excellent review Raul!


Petra Wonderful review, Raul.


Raul Daniel wrote: "This was has been on my shelf awhile, quietly calling. Terrific review!"

Thank you Daniel! I hope you read it and share your thoughts.


Raul Richard wrote: "Sounds very good .......... an excellent review Raul!"

Thank you, Richard!


message 10: by Raul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raul Petra wrote: "Wonderful review, Raul."

Thank you, Petra!


message 11: by PattyMacDotComma (new)

PattyMacDotComma I certainly thank your friends for their reviews that encouraged you to read this and write this terrific review! I appreciate the historical context, about which I knew nothing. Religion is such a touchy subject, but I welcome the day that people don't have to hide to escape harm for their beliefs.


message 12: by Raul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raul PattyMacDotComma wrote: "I certainly thank your friends for their reviews that encouraged you to read this and write this terrific review! I appreciate the historical context, about which I knew nothing. Religion is such a..."

Thank you Patty! I too feel religion and beliefs to be very touchy, and just like you I do believe everyone should have the right to practice their beliefs unharmed just as those beliefs themselves shouldn't be used in anyway to harm anyone, completely agree with you.


message 13: by Ilse (new)

Ilse A very fine review, Raul! I've been on the fence on this one, for the same reason that you hesitated to read it, and for fear of graphic torture scenes - your appreciation of Endo's writing as magnificent prose might be the little push I needed to read the novel.


message 14: by Raul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raul Ilse wrote: "A very fine review, Raul! I've been on the fence on this one, for the same reason that you hesitated to read it, and for fear of graphic torture scenes - your appreciation of Endo's writing as magn..."

Thank you, Ilse! The strange thing is that the torture scenes weren't as graphic as I imagined they would be, Endo didn't dwell on detail as much as I had feared he would. Hope it works out for you when you read it.


message 15: by á (new)

á The expression of your thoughts into written words, Raul, is simply wonderful! I have this same problem with people who want to prove their point of view when it comes to religion and some other issues. I have this book on my bookshelf but haven't read it yet, might read it soon after this great review of yours!


message 16: by Raul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raul á wrote: "The expression of your thoughts into written words, Raul, is simply wonderful! I have this same problem with people who want to prove their point of view when it comes to religion and some other is..."

Thank you á. It's always annoying when a thought can't be expressed without considering nuance or with disdain for a whole group of people. I would love to read your thoughts on the book whenever you get to read it.


message 17: by Beth (new) - added it

Beth Splendid review Raul. This goes on the list.


message 18: by Raul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Raul Beth wrote: "Splendid review Raul. This goes on the list."

Thank you Beth! I would love to read your thoughts on it when you get to it.


back to top