ŷ

Sara's Reviews > Lonesome Dove

Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5512657
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: adventure, american, american-classics, american-west, favorites, historical-fiction, literary-fiction, more-than-5-stars, pulitzer-prize-winners, western, 2021-aty-challenge
Read 3 times. Last read June 10, 2021 to June 14, 2021.

In a momentary lapse of self-control, I picked up my copy of Lonesome Dove and got lost once more in the wonder that is Gus McCrae and Woodrow Call and all the assorted characters that people their world. If anyone ever asked me if I had been to Montana, I would have to say “yes�, and every step of land between the Milk River and Lonesome Dove, Texas. Never has a story felt more real, been more packed with personalities, more genuine in its depiction of place, or more perfectly told.

Even the characters you do not admire, you sadly understand. When McMurtry says of Elmira Johnson:

She wanted July and Joe to be gone, suddenly, so she would not have to deal with them every day. Their needs were modest enough, but she no longer wanted to face them. She had reached a point where doing anything for anyone was a strain. It was like heavy work, it was so hard.

you momentarily understand what drives her. She is living a life she does not want in being a wife and mother, and the attempt to do that is a burden she can no longer carry. It doesn’t matter that her life is not a bad life, what matters is that it is not, any longer, “her� life.

In fact, this book might mostly be about people seeking, often to their own detriment, the lives they have lost. Each of them has an ideal in their head that they are chasing: Call has Montana; Gus has Clara; Lorie has San Francisco; Ellie has Dee Boot; Clara has the idea of a son, all yearnings based on losses they have already experienced.

The book is peppered with wit and humor, and with wisdom. Even in its tragic moments, Gus is able to infuse both of those elements into the situation. He gives advice in such a folksy, off-hand, manner, but the truth lying beneath his observations is never lost on the reader.

Life in San Francisco is still just life. If you want one thing too much it’s likely to be a disappointment. The healthy way is to learn to like the everyday things, like soft beds and buttermilk--and feisty gentlemen.

This is the fastest 900 page novel you will ever read. It never slows or hits patches that you want to speed through. You feel the elements in the descriptions of the weather, the weight of the losses, the constant danger of just living in this place and time; but you never want it to stop. You want to travel beyond the next river, scrape off the mud, and then cross another plain or find another grassland. You want to sleep in the saddle because you are exhausted and then share a plate of Bol’s beans or Po Campo’s fried grasshoppers.

If there was ever a versatile writer, it was Larry McMurtry. This is far from being the only magnificent novel he produced, but it is far and away his best. It is iconic and unparalleled in its scope and its accomplishment. If you like character driven novels of epic proportions, but you’re thinking you don’t like “westerns�, don’t miss this remarkable book. It is a masterpiece that happens to be set in the West and deals with so much more than a simple review, like this one, can ever express.
86 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Lonesome Dove.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
Finished Reading
December 21, 2019 – Shelved
June 10, 2021 – Started Reading
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: adventure
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: american
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: american-classics
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: american-west
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: favorites
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: literary-fiction
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: more-than-5-stars
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: pulitzer-prize-winners
June 14, 2021 – Shelved as: western
June 14, 2021 – Finished Reading
June 16, 2021 – Shelved as: 2021-aty-challenge

Comments Showing 1-50 of 55 (55 new)


Cheri So happy to see your five stars for this one, Sara!


Sara Yes! One of the best books ever. I keep trying to tell friends who pass that this is so, so much more than a "western".


Janet I am really looking forward to reading it this year.


Sara I read it long before joining GR, so never wrote a review. It is time I read it again. Would be well worth spending the time again. I read all four books the first time around, but this one can stand on its own and is by far the best of the four.


message 5: by Don (new) - rated it 5 stars

Don Dunham It reads great the second time.


Sara Swaroop wrote: "Thank you, Sara!"

😊


Sara Don wrote: "It reads great the second time."

Maybe even better because you would catch small details that you would be sure to miss in the first read.


message 8: by Marialyce (new)

Marialyce This is another book that has been on my TBR for ages. 2020 the year I finally read it!


Sara Marialyce wrote: "This is another book that has been on my TBR for ages. 2020 the year I finally read it!"

You will be glad to have read it, Marialyce. One of those books that transcends its genre. Masterfully written.


message 10: by Anne (new)

Anne There is an "I love Lonesome Dove" party going on at GR . 😀🎈🎊🍷 🎉


message 11: by Michelle (new) - added it

Michelle Curie Had this on my list for ages, but your review served as a great reminder that I DEFINITELY need to get onto this.


Diane Barnes This review is just perfect. In the final discussion thread on the Trail, a comment is made that McMurtry said in an interview that he based Call and Gus on Don Quixote and Sancho Ponza. It puts another dimension on this wonderful book. Anne is right, it's a Lonesome Dove party and everyone is invited.


Candi Your first paragraph alone perfectly describes what makes this book so extraordinary, Sara! It is like McMurtry took you each step of the way with these wonderful characters by your side :) :) If life weren't so chaotic, I would have made this journey again this month. I'll make it there another day for sure!


message 14: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "There is an "I love Lonesome Dove" party going on at GR . 😀🎈🎊🍷 🎉"

There is indeed a party, Anne. I think the loss of McMurtry made everyone who had read it want to do so again and everyone who hadn't read it yet want to know what they were missing. I was planning to decline the invitation, but I just couldn't. Gus kept saying in my head, "Darlin' you only live once and then you will be bones like the rest of us."


message 15: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Michelle wrote: "Had this on my list for ages, but your review served as a great reminder that I DEFINITELY need to get onto this."

Please do, Michelle. It is one of those reads you will never forget and never, ever regret.


message 16: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Diane wrote: "This review is just perfect. In the final discussion thread on the Trail, a comment is made that McMurtry said in an interview that he based Call and Gus on Don Quixote and Sancho Ponza. It puts an..."

It does put another dimension on the book, which is a beautiful piece of work if there weren't a single antecedent to draw upon. Also, I know of few works where the film version and printed version mesh so beautifully. I could never read this book without hearing Jones and Duvall speaking the lines of dialogue.


message 17: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Candi wrote: "Your first paragraph alone perfectly describes what makes this book so extraordinary, Sara! It is like McMurtry took you each step of the way with these wonderful characters by your side :) :) If l..."

I had no business taking the time to read this when there are so many other pressing things (including other book commitments) that should have had priority. But, every now and then I like to just read what I want to read--hang the "ought to", mop the floor later.


message 18: by Shankar (new)

Shankar This is great incentive to start ( has been on my shelf gathering dust ) �. Fastest 900 page novel �. Here I come


message 19: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Shankar wrote: "This is great incentive to start ( has been on my shelf gathering dust ) �. Fastest 900 page novel �. Here I come"

Yahoo! Come back and tell me you LOVED it, Shankar.


message 20: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue K H Thank you for this gorgeous review of a perfect book, Sara. No one can capture it all, which is why everyone needs to read it! Have you read the others in the series?


message 21: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara I did, Sue, when I originally read this one. None of the others lived up to this, in my memory, but I was happy to read them all. This book is so complete in itself and you are so right, no one can begin to capture it all.

The reason the film worked so well is that it was done as a mini-series. What part of this book could you leave out to make it into a 3-hour movie? Every word and every character matter.


Peggy Great review, Sara!! I truly loved this novel � maybe my all time favorite. I laughed, I cried and wanted it never to end! 900 pages, no problem, each page is a labor of love ❤️


message 23: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thanks, Peggy. My feeling precisely.


Antoinette Wonderful review, Sara! I am currently reading this very book, and I do feel the love for this book. I find it amazing that so many people are reading it right now.


Lori  Keeton Sara, I agree with Diane that this review is just perfect! I loved your paragraph about people seeking and hadn't thought about it in that way, but you are absolutely right! Even Newt had his adulthood he was seeking. I'm certainly glad you made the time to fit in this read with us as we celebrate an honored writer!


message 26: by Sue (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sue K H Sara wrote: "I did, Sue, when I originally read this one. None of the others lived up to this, in my memory, but I was happy to read them all. This book is so complete in itself and you are so right, no one can..."

I love when books are done as a series. I loved the mini-series too but even it couldn't do it justice.


message 27: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Antoinette wrote: "Wonderful review, Sara! I am currently reading this very book, and I do feel the love for this book. I find it amazing that so many people are reading it right now."

Thanks so much, Antoinette. It is kind of sad that it is the death of an author that often pushes us to read his work. I'm glad to see this book getting a revival. It deserves to be read by everyone!


message 28: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Lori wrote: "Sara, I agree with Diane that this review is just perfect! I loved your paragraph about people seeking and hadn't thought about it in that way, but you are absolutely right! Even Newt had his adult..."

Newt was also seeking his father. And, so many of them are chasing dreams that have no possibility of coming true, because even if they get what they are seeking, it will not be what they think it is. July chasing Ellie. What could be more useless?


message 29: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Sue wrote: "Sara wrote: "I did, Sue, when I originally read this one. None of the others lived up to this, in my memory, but I was happy to read them all. This book is so complete in itself and you are so righ..."

They work together for me, Sue, but I must say I will almost never choose a movie over a book. With books you get every nuance the author feels compelled to present, and you get to make your own decision about what it means and what is important. With a movie you get someone else's interpretation of what the novel is meant to mean.


message 30: by Curt (new)

Curt Locklear I had a copy and lost it. I need to read it. Thanks for the reminder.


message 31: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara You definitely don't want to miss this, Curtis. I had the entire series in my possession at one time, but let them go when I moved and down-sized. I hate buying books twice, but some books are worth it, and this is one.


message 32: by Vishakha (new) - added it

Vishakha A magical review, Sara. This has been resting on the TBR mountain for a long time, I need to get to it soon.


message 33: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thank you, Vishakha. Do dig it out from under and read it. I promise it is better than at least 90% of the books on the list.


message 34: by Matt (new) - rated it 5 stars

Matt I totally agree with your statement of the fastest 900 pages you will read because it is. I was never bored when I read it. Your review makes me want to pick it back up sooner than later!


message 35: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara One of those books that really reads as well the second time around, also. Go for it, Matt.


message 36: by Jim (new)

Jim Puskas What a terrific review, Sara! You almost convince me to read this despite my utter horror of anything having to do with the "American West" and all that stuff about taming it with six-guns and rawhide and "grit"!


message 37: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara That is exactly what this is NOT, Jim. No taming of the west with guns. This is a book that reaches far outside its setting to the depth of its characters, and it is rich in human sadness and struggle. Not a John Wayne character in sight.


message 38: by Jim (new)

Jim Puskas Thanks, Sara. I will have a look at it (although my "to read" list is already outrageously long ....


message 39: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro I loved the TV series, back in the day, and I also loved your review, Sara!


message 40: by Veronique (new) - added it

Veronique Wonderful review, Sara! This novel was on my radar but that’s it. Seems I’m going to have to get a copy :O)


message 41: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Kevin wrote: "I loved the TV series, back in the day, and I also loved your review, Sara!"

One book where having seen the series enhances the reading of the book. McMurtry wrote the screenplay, so it is very true to the book, and you have that mental image of those perfectly cast actors as you read.


message 42: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Veronique wrote: "Wonderful review, Sara! This novel was on my radar but that’s it. Seems I’m going to have to get a copy :O)"

Go on and part with your money, Veronique. You will be glad you did.


message 43: by Kelly's Korner (new)

Kelly's Korner This is one of my favorite books! I've read it 3 times!


message 44: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen I just love it when a book forces you to put everything else aside and read it! You do McMurtry proud in this wonderful review, Sara. I have seen the mini-series multiple times, but know I need to read this ... soon.


message 45: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Kelly (The Introverted Reader) wrote: "This is one of my favorite books! I've read it 3 times!"

Me too, Kelly, which is a pretty big deal since it is so long.


message 46: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Kathleen wrote: "I just love it when a book forces you to put everything else aside and read it! You do McMurtry proud in this wonderful review, Sara. I have seen the mini-series multiple times, but know I need to ..."

Thanks so much, Kathleen. It is a marvelous book, that isn't above calling your name until you cave in to it.


Therese Sara, this was a favorite of mine, and I really enjoyed the insights you brought out in your review, especially about people seeking out the lives they had lost.


message 48: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Thank you, Therese. It is hard to read this novel and not count it as a favorite. Some people don't, but then I kind of worry about them.


Linda One of my favorite books of all time ! And add how these characters bore into my heart. You took me back there with this exquisite review. Thanks for the gift.


message 50: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara I love to revisit it in my head from time to time. Glad this served that purpose for you. Great stuff!


« previous 1
back to top