ŷ

J.C.'s Reviews > The Good Soldier Svejk

The Good Soldier Svejk by Jaroslav Hašek
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
52123967
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: european

“Listen, Švejk, are you really God’s prize oaf?�
“Humbly report, sir,� Švejk answered solemnly. “I am!�

The good soldier Švejk repeats this answer, in one form or another, quite a lot over the course of 892 pages of being frequently grilled by various authorities under the Austro-Hungarian Empire in World War One. You, the reader, will be entirely at liberty to ascertain the truth of the matter!

This was a re-read for me after many years. I remember as a young person being utterly amazed at it, as I’d never come across war satire of this kind before. I found the book less comic this time, and also a touch tedious as it went on, as Švejk (of whom the author admits he is very fond) relates innumerable, ever more far-fetched, stories, to illustrate a particular aspect of human behaviour, while generally sitting in one of a long succession of prisons, military transports, or mental asylums. I am still amazed, though, that Hašek could, seemingly effortlessly, come out with tale upon entertaining tale of unfortunate innocents at the mercy of the civil or military administration, or cunning malefactors who come justly to a sticky end, or unhinged military officials sabotaging their own war . . . having said all that, I attribute any intermittent tediousness I found in the narration to the novel being already almost a hundred years old. At the time of writing, Hašek’s work would have been innovatory, revolutionary, shocking beyond anything we might experience from it today, in our age of enlightened cynicism about “war and war’s alarms� (WB Yeats), where we are accustomed to more sophisticated satire. I found myself thinking that it was just as well the book was published posthumously or Hašek might have found himself treated just as his hero was.

This book contains no grandiose criticism but relies on incontestable and concrete detail. Of necessity, it’s earthy stuff. As the author points out in the epilogue to Part 1,”Behind the Lines�,
“Life is no finishing school for young ladies.�
Part Two is entitled, “At the Front�, and the language and the incidents are scatological and often bawdy. Hašek defends himself thus:
“It was once said, and very rightly, that a man who is well brought-up may read anything. The only people who boggle at what is perfectly natural are those who are the worst swine and the finest experts in filth. In their utterly contemptible pseudo-morality they ignore the contents and madly attack individual words . . . beneath this camouflage these drawing-room lions indulge in the worst vices and excesses.�
Hašek described conditions for the soldiers and the inefficiency of the army command from personal experience serving on the Eastern Front, although he died without writing his intended third volume, “in Captivity� which would also have reflected his actual experience (of being a prisoner of war of the Russians). Thanks to Ian’s review of “The Snows of Yesteryear� and Beata’s of “Wołyń zdradzony� (“Volhynia betrayed� according to Google Translate), I have more of an idea of the region of Galicia through which Švejk passes as Part Two ends.
I woke one morning from a Švejk-related dream (no, really!) wondering how I could sum up this novel in the style of Hašek. Just how easy was it to make up tales where Švejk’s point is couched in a ton or so of irrelevant anecdotal detail? I found that in a few minutes I wrote about 500 words of my own Švejk tale (don’t worry, I won’t include it all here!) but the image I had was of a man who, wandering through the halls of the city treasury, came upon ancient, dusty chests, which no one had ever opened or been remotely interested in. This man opened them, and found that they were full of human truths, accumulated over centuries. Perhaps the events they described had not actually taken place but their import was true. The man read them and realised their value to humanity. The man heaped these truths upon himself as if they were coats of ermine, and went out into the street, accosting all whom he met with wise words from the papers in the chests. Eventually he was brought before the city authorities. They listened carefully to his tales of truth hidden away in the cellars of the Treasury. Then they conferred briefly with each other, nodding their sage heads, and had the man thrown into the river as a danger to society.

Just be grateful you were spared the full version!
21 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Good Soldier Svejk.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
January 4, 2020 – Shelved
January 4, 2020 – Shelved as: european
January 4, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Ian (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ian You got through it very quickly!

It would have been revolutionary at the time, as you say.


Beata I have always admired Svejk for staying sane and keeping the distance in the times when insanity surrounded him. Your remarks are perfect, Jeanne, and now, when I happen to read a chapter or two, I never smile .. Is it only because I know the plot? I don't think so ...


message 3: by Elliot (new) - added it

Elliot This is a book I would like to read eventually. Thanks for the helpful review.

In a book I read recently about the formation of Czechoslovakia, Dreams of a Great Small Nation: The Mutinous Army that Threatened a Revolution, Destroyed an Empire, Founded a Republic, and Remade the Map of Europe, the author mentioned that Hašek wrote propaganda both for and against the Czecho-Slovak Legion while they were both in Russia during the Great War. I imagine that the intended third volume would have been pretty interesting, even if it was overkill.


J.C. Thanks, Elliot, for the imformation about Hašek - I agree with you that the unwritten third volume would have been interesting! Without having the knowledge you give my thoughts were that the book would have had to change in tone, as things got darker and less amenable to comic satire.


J.C. Beata wrote: "I have always admired Svejk for staying sane and keeping the distance in the times when insanity surrounded him. Your remarks are perfect, Jeanne, and now, when I happen to read a chapter or two, I..."

Yes, I know just what you mean, Beata, and thank you for the kind comment.


J.C. Ian wrote: "You got through it very quickly!

It would have been revolutionary at the time, as you say."


Yes, I took advantage of two weeks' holiday from work to read at every possible opportunity (which meant getting up later most mornings!). I did get hooked on Svejk!


message 7: by Théo d'Or (new)

Théo d'Or " It was one said, and very rightly, that a man who is well brought-up may read anything. "

Very true. Thank you for reminding me this author, who, in addition to Sven Hassel, delighted my childhood :))


J.C. Thédore, your remark was very apposite. I have just skipped over part of a chapter in "Talking Heads" (more on that when I review it) but after your reminding me of the quotation from Hašek I will go back to it! I don't know Sven Hassel but I hope to read some of your reviews over the next wee while.


P.E. Thanks for the dream digest, Jeanne, I found it very much in keeping with the gist of Švejk's story :)


TBV (on hiatus) Jeanne, your review is a dream...


message 11: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. Neat, TBV! Thank you.


message 12: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. Thank you, Gary, for the 'like'.


message 13: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Fine review, Jeanne, and perfectly topped off by the summary of your dream. Isn't it amazing the dreams books inspire? I would have read the complete dream story if you'd included it...


message 14: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. Thank you, Fionnuala, especially as you have experienced novel-related dreams! I probably didn't keep the scribbled story - in case plagiarism reared its head!
(Oh, and you are also a poet - I've just read your "Pale Fire Review"!)
/review/show...


message 15: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse This has been on my mind to read since reading Schnitzler's 'Lieutenant Gustl', Jeanne - your rendition of it sounds very promising. Your observation on what might have been his ordeal seems spot-on, at that time what he had written might have offended some powerful institutions. I am on the same page on your complete dream story as Fionnuala, and now wonder if reading on the absurdity of war brings it own strange dreams. Reading on the fall of Berlin at the moment, last night I dreamt about providing the troops with ice creams cones..


message 16: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. That's your kind nature showing through, Ilse! Perhaps soldiers do not live by bread alone . . . which is why they loved Vera Lynn!
Thank you for your kind comments. I am intending to read "Lieutenant Gustl" after your fine review on it -
/review/show...


message 17: by J.C. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. Thanks for the 'like', Boadicea!


message 18: by John (new)

John Pendrey I won’t even try to catch up with you. I am very happy with your own story. I should reread but the message I take is that our own treasures are special to us.


message 19: by J.C. (last edited Jan 28, 2022 02:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

J.C. Thank you, John, I was thinking more about what you said the other day about 'treasures'. They're increasingly valuable as I get increasingly forgetful!
If your treasures are anything like the story of the Aadelar that you participated in, you can offload some more of them onto me if you like!!!


back to top