Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > Surfacing

Surfacing by Margaret Atwood
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: novels

In The Evil Dead these kids go and stay in a remote cabin out in the woods and they release evil spirits that want to kill them etc. In Cabin Fever these kids go and stay in a remote cabin out in the woods and catch a flesh eating disease and die and go mad, etc. In The Cabin in the Woods these kids go and stay in a remote cabin way out in the woods where a zombie army tries to kills them etc. Now these are movies but in Surfacing, which is a book, these kids go and stay in a remote cabin out in the woods but the big difference is there are no zombies and flesh eating bugs and evil spirits at all all though are they. It is a profound question.

The couples go fishing and they catch something that I thought was a symbol, but I did not know what it was a symbol of.

The prottergonist does not have a name. This surprises me. It may be no one noticed but you will think that somebody should of read this book before it was printed and pointed this out. So I will have to describe the prottergonist as The Prot as it is easier.

The prot’s father has disappeared and that is why they go to the remote cabin. They think he had gone feral . The situation could be like Man Thing, which is a manga I have read, but it is not, as the Prot’s father does not became a Man Thing. I was thinking that if the father did become a Man Thing he would be waiting in the woods and catch them and rip them up to make more Man Things, but this does not happen.

There is not much action at all. There is no fighting, no gun play, no tree masking, no aliens. For instance, in The Kurosawi Corpse Delivery Service which is a manga I have read there is mutilation, embalming and martial arts fighting, it is an exciting story. But in Surfacing there isn’t any of that. The Prot spends a lot of time looking for somethig, either the missing father or something else. If you ask me, I think it was excitement she was looking for.

I do not recommend this novel and I have to give it a low score. There are better books about kids staying in remote cabins and anyway Cabin Fever is way better, e.g. when the main guy’s foot comes off.
52 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Surfacing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 16, 2020 – Started Reading
January 16, 2020 – Shelved
January 19, 2020 – Shelved as: novels
January 19, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by J (new)

J A beautiful contrast to all the po-faced and terribly worthy reviews about this book. (A proper comment would have been written in the style of the review, but I have been distracted by my foot falling off in the midst of laughing too hard.)


Paul Bryant thanks J! I think I may get in a little trouble here...


message 3: by Anette (new)

Anette Margrethe Basso Funny :) you Even almost made me want to read it


Cecily As usual, you've found a different angle, which is quite refreshing, even though I doubt it's what Atwood intended, and I enjoyed it as it was. But hey, that's what's fun with GR.


Paul Bryant I think I was possessed by the spirit of the kid who reviewed Gulliver's Travels..... you may remember that one�.


Cecily I do. It's right up there with the kid who reviewed Oliver Twist...


Paul Bryant yeah, he just kind of takes over from time to time. Very unpredictable.


Rebecca Alcazaze Lovely! I never compared this to Cabin Fever or ED myself but I know I’d have much preferred the novel if it had a few more pustules, violent vines and vomit scenes.
What you said about the symbolism hit the nail on the head for me too.

Got me thinking about all the cabin horrors now Paul! Good times.


Mark  Porton Great review Paul, I'm a bit relieved - I felt the same, I thought it was dreadful


back to top