ŷ

Candi's Reviews > A Perfect Spy

A Perfect Spy by John Le Carré
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: espionage, thriller

"Life is duty... It’s just a question of establishing which creditor is asking loudest. Life is paying. Life is seeing people right if it kills you."

I’ve been reading John le Carré’s espionage novels like I would that little bag of my favorite dark chocolates that I hide in the bottom drawer of my refrigerator. Not one right after the other, because honestly, there are other treats I like to indulge in as well. There are the Reese’s peanut butter cups and the Trader Joe’s roasted pistachio toffee (dark chocolate as well, naturally.) But I like to make a good thing last, savor it a while, before dipping my hand back into the bag for another best of the best. In terms of books, rather than chocolate, I have to say that I don’t recall reading an author’s work in such relatively quick succession as I have since childhood when I devoured one mystery novel after another. Despite the fact I won’t share my favorite stash of candy, I have been more than happy to share the le Carré journey with a fabulous little group of women that have the same joy in reading these over the past year or more. The adventure has been that much more rewarding as a result.

It has always been a debate rather nature versus nurture shapes us more as a person. In the case of Magnus Pym, I think it would be safe to say that both contributed a significant piece. This is not so much an espionage thriller, though it is that too, but a reflection on a man’s life and how he was shaped for the role he plays. Magnus has been dubbed the perfect spy. His childhood was one of deceit and lies, yet he yearned for love and always aimed to please. He could just as easily have been the perfect actor. He managed to create and portray the character he felt each person wanted him to be.

"Magnus is a great imitator, even when he doesn’t know it. Really I sometimes think he is entirely put together from bits of other people, poor fellow."

My heart broke for the young Magnus Pym. The elder Pym was more of an enigma to me. By book’s end, I felt little sympathy for him any longer. He was groomed from an early age to work in the spy business. He was good at it. His talents did not go unnoticed. I believe his fate was sealed in one moment in time.

"In a single Christmas, God had dished him up two saints. The one was on the run and couldn’t walk, the other was a handsome English warlord who served sherry on Boxing Day and had never had a doubt in his life. Both admired him, both loved his jokes and his voices, both were clamouring to occupy the empty spaces of his heart. In return he was giving to each man the character he seemed to be in search of."

If you’ve ever read le Carré, you’ll know that his books are not bursting with action. The spy world is not the glamorous, fast-paced one that we see depicted in most films. Rather, what draws me to his work is the fine writing, the sharp analyses of the inner workings of the agent’s mind, and the intricate dynamics between the various characters. Yes, some action-filled scenes are appreciated. In A Perfect Spy, much of what happens is relayed to the reader after the fact. These are the musings of a hunted man on the run as he writes his own book about his past and what drove him to do the things he did. As a result, I felt a bit more distanced from the man himself. Much like I would feel being stuck in the back row of the theater. I understand what is going on, but I don’t feel like a part of the drama myself. Of course, I’m unfairly comparing this one to my last le Carré, The Little Drummer Girl, which so completely absorbed me that I could not let it go for a number of weeks after finishing. The brilliant prose is still here, but the emotional pull was wanting. Don’t get me wrong though, even one of my least favorites by this best-loved author still ranks higher than most of what is out there right now!

"Love is whatever you can still betray... Betrayal can only happen if you love."
173 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read A Perfect Spy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 22, 2020 – Shelved
January 22, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
January 22, 2020 – Shelved as: espionage
January 22, 2020 – Shelved as: thriller
March 3, 2020 – Started Reading
March 20, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)


message 1: by Barbara K (new) - added it

Barbara K Candi, you inspired me to re-read all of le Carre, starting from the beginning. I just updated my TBR list with some recent Kindle sale acquisitions and was delighted to see the first two Smiley's among them. I'm such an impulse buyer when it comes to books - I'd forgotten I even had these! Great fun ahead.


Candi Barbara wrote: "Candi, you inspired me to re-read all of le Carre, starting from the beginning. I just updated my TBR list with some recent Kindle sale acquisitions and was delighted to see the first two Smiley's ..."

Oh, how wonderful, Barbara! I have a lot of 'surprises' on my kindle as well, so I can relate :D


Sara As always, you have encapsulated the essence of this book in your review. I agree that Le Carre keeps us at arm's link from the adult Pym, while we feel we are breathing along with Charlie. Truly loving this journey!!!!


message 4: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ Such a compelling case for trying Le Carre, Candi! Terrific and exuberant review!


message 5: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Candi, your review is a delight to read. I won't ask you to share any of your stash in the fridge, but now I know where it is,,,,, Your enthusiasm is infectious. Would love to get to read this book asap.


Beata Stellar review, Candi :)) I appreciate JlC precisely for static plot and his focus on what a spy's life is like .. Thank you & stay safe! :)


Richard (on hiatus) A fine review Candi ......... this was actually one of my favourite le Carré’s. It seems to touch on so many of the themes in his books. I knew that when Magnus arrives in Devon (my home county) for his exile I would love this novel!
Strangely, I found the distant, older Magnus a really moving protagonist ........ although it was many years ago when I read it - maybe I should re read this along with his others :)


Candi Sara wrote: "As always, you have encapsulated the essence of this book in your review. I agree that Le Carre keeps us at arm's link from the adult Pym, while we feel we are breathing along with Charlie. Truly l..."

Sara, it's really a pleasure to read these books. Your keen insights keep me motivated and add so much to the experience. You know, I think I had a bit of a girl crush on Charlie! I wanted to be her! Well, I wanted to have even just a portion of her spunk and bravery ;)


Candi Jenna wrote: "Such a compelling case for trying Le Carre, Candi! Terrific and exuberant review!"

Thanks so much, Jenna! I'm crossing my fingers that if you decide to try le Carre someday, you will love him too. I would perhaps start with something other than this, only because I think you have to understand his world a bit before diving into this one :)


Candi Anne wrote: "Candi, your review is a delight to read. I won't ask you to share any of your stash in the fridge, but now I know where it is,,,,, Your enthusiasm is infectious. Would love to get to read this book..."

Thanks a bunch, Anne! I'm aware I gave away a big secret with the location of that stash ;D :D I just might consider sharing if any of my friends like you happen to travel so many miles to come say hi! Enjoy your le Carre journey should you decide to embark on one :)


TBV (on hiatus) Candi, I'm really enjoying your le Carre journey. I have read most of his novels, and it's enjoyable to revisit them with you. Now I need some chocolate!


Candi Beata wrote: "Stellar review, Candi :)) I appreciate JlC precisely for static plot and his focus on what a spy's life is like .. Thank you & stay safe! :)"

Many thanks, Beata! I love how cerebral his books are. In fact, the timing of this one left me at a bit of a disadvantage perhaps. I've not been as focused as I would like to be. Take care of yourself!


Candi Richard wrote: "A fine review Candi ......... this was actually one of my favourite le Carré’s. It seems to touch on so many of the themes in his books. I knew that when Magnus arrives in Devon (my home county) fo..."

Much appreciated, Richard! I actually really liked my little jaunt across Europe with Magnus. It's always fun when a character ends up in a familiar locale too :) I think this could have been a 5 star book for me, except it was maybe too soon after my favorite of his thus far. And also if this damn virus wasn't in my head so much!


Candi TBV wrote: "Candi, I'm really enjoying your le Carre journey. I have read most of his novels, and it's enjoyable to revisit them with you. Now I need some chocolate!"

I'm pleased to have you along on the journey, TBV! For you, I will bring along some chocolate the next time around, rather than hoard it ;) I hope you are well :)


message 15: by JanB (new)

JanB Literary mysteries are my default. And now I want to devour a le Carre novel while eating chocolate, preferable from TJ’s.
Marvelous review Candi!


Candi JanB wrote: "Literary mysteries are my default. And now I want to devour a le Carre novel while eating chocolate, preferable from TJ’s.
Marvelous review Candi!"


A well-written literary mystery is a special treat, Jan! And, the perfect combination of le Carre and chocolate is just what the doctor recommends right now. Thanks a bunch, Jan!


message 17: by Angela M (new)

Angela M I haven’t read LeCarre, but coincidentally as I was reading your review, I was eating one of those little dark chocolate bars from Trader Joe’s!


Candi Angela M wrote: "I haven’t read LeCarre, but coincidentally as I was reading your review, I was eating one of those little dark chocolate bars from Trader Joe’s!"

How funny, Angela! What is it about their chocolate that makes it so yummy?!!


message 19: by Pedro (new)

Pedro Candi, as you know I don't have a lot of free time at the moment and am now struggling to catch up with friends reviews or even write my own. Sorry I'm late to your espionage party. This is a great review, and once again you reminded me and that maybe I should re-read the only LeCarre novel I've read so far and see what I would think of it now. Thank you.


Candi Pedro wrote: "Candi, as you know I don't have a lot of free time at the moment and am now struggling to catch up with friends reviews or even write my own. Sorry I'm late to your espionage party. This is a great..."

Pedro, I know they've got you running ragged. You're welcome to the party anytime. I'm impressed you have the stamina to even attend at all at this point ;D It's very kind of you to stop by :)


message 21: by Tsung (new)

Tsung Nice review Candi! Now I'm tempted by le Carre and Reese's.


Candi Tsung wrote: "Nice review Candi! Now I'm tempted by le Carre and Reese's."

Thank you, Tsung! Such a delightful combination :)


message 23: by Sumit (new)

Sumit RK Superb review, Candi!


Candi Sumit wrote: "Superb review, Candi!"

Thanks so much, Sumit! :)


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

Very fine review, Candi!


Candi J.K. wrote: "Very fine review, Candi!"

Many thanks, J.K.!


message 27: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna Beautiful review, Candi. I am a big le Carre fan and am loving my way through his works. And now I know that they will be even better with Reese’s peanut butter cups. Thanks for the smile!


message 28: by Julie (new)

Julie G Hmm. Comparing these books to private caches of chocolate is pretty powerful, Candi.


Left Coast Justin Candi, this one also landed on my 'Tier 2' list. Apparently its his most autobiographical, which simply means he writes invented characters better than writing about himself. Well, what would you expect?

I hope, when your bag of chocolates is empty, you're able to pick a favorite. I'd be really interested in learning which one was best, for you.


Candi Lorna wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. I am a big le Carre fan and am loving my way through his works. And now I know that they will be even better with Reese’s peanut butter cups. Thanks for the smile!"

Thanks very much, Lorna! His novels are becoming like an addiction for me. I can't go for long without one in my hands. Enjoy your next le Carre and the Reese's!! :)


Candi Julie wrote: "Hmm. Comparing these books to private caches of chocolate is pretty powerful, Candi."

Julie, I made the mistake of keeping my most recent chocolate supply in full view in my living room. My son cleaned me out before he headed back to college for the semester :D He stayed away from my le Carre novels, however.


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Candi, this one also landed on my 'Tier 2' list. Apparently its his most autobiographical, which simply means he writes invented characters better than writing about himself. Well, what would you e..."

Yes, that's a really interesting and valid point, Justin! I guess if we all could write, we'd likely do the same. You never want to reveal too much, do you?!

I'm going to have a difficult time selecting a favorite. It just might be The Little Drummer Girl though. I loved The Constant Gardener which I recently finished though too. Hmmm.... Plenty more to go yet!


message 33: by Julie (new)

Julie G Candi! How could you make that mistake?
(I remember once that my mother revealed her hidden supply of Diet Coke and we went nuts drinking it. That was my house of origin--we were so deprived of anything that contained sugar, when we discovered Diet Coke, we thought it was manna from Heaven!)


Candi Julie, perhaps I had a hidden wish for Andrew to make an appearance now and then in the living room ;) After all, it gave me a few moments to grasp some time with him - a bit of a lure perhaps!

Diet Coke is not something I ever felt drawn to - but I can see the magic if it was previously withheld from you all!


message 35: by Barbara K (new) - added it

Barbara K Candi wrote: "I'm going to have a difficult time selecting a favorite. It just might be The Little Drummer Girl though. I loved The Constant Gardener which I recently finished though too. Hmmm.... Plenty more to go yet!..."

As you know, Candi, your review of this book started me on my quest to re-read all the Smiley novels last year, a most satisfying experience. I plan to start working through his other novels this year, beginning with Constant Gardener next month. That's one I haven't read previously (though I've seen the movie), and I'm very much looking forward to it.


Candi I'm very glad that I prompted you on that re-reading adventure, Barbara! It's always fun to share a favorite author. I can't wait to hear what you think of The Constant Gardener. Of course, the book has a lot more substance to it, although I enjoyed the movie :)


message 37: by Ebba Simone (new)

Ebba Simone Fun review. You have made my evening nicer. I like a lot how you compare his espionage novels to pieces of chocolate. One needs to portion them, not consume one right after the other.


Candi Ebba Simone wrote: "Fun review. You have made my evening nicer. I like a lot how you compare his espionage novels to pieces of chocolate. One needs to portion them, not consume one right after the other."

Thanks so much, Ebba! I'm such a huge le Carre fan, and will be disappointed when I've run out of his novels. I won't be able to replace them like I can the bag of chocolates when it's empty!


message 39: by (new) - rated it 5 stars

… I went back an reread everything in chronological order � it was so satisfying. A master chocolatier indeed� m


message 40: by (new) - rated it 5 stars

… Candi: I wrote this down while listening to JLC and thought of when I saw your “Constant Gardner� comment above related to th movie. Thgt you’d appreciate this:

“The job of the movie--as far as I’m concerned, the novelist-- is to take the minimum intention of the novel and illustrate it with the maximum of freedom-- in movie language, in movie grammar. There’s hardly a line left, there’s hardly a scene intact in this movie that comes from my novel. Yet, I don’t know of a better translation from a novel to film.�
--John LeCarré on The Constant Gardner


Candi Mark wrote: "I went back an reread everything in chronological order � it was so satisfying. A master chocolatier indeed� m"

Mark, I think I'll do exactly that someday when I'm due for a re-read :) :)


Candi Mark wrote: "Candi: I wrote this down while listening to JLC and thought of when I saw your “Constant Gardner� comment above related to th movie. Thgt you’d appreciate this:

“The job of the movie--as far as I..."


Oh how interesting, Mark! The film was thoroughly enjoyable, no doubt about that. I'm glad le Carre was pleased with it :)


message 43: by Ebba Simone (new)

Ebba Simone Candi, oh, I understand. How many of his novels have you read? He was a very nice man. I saw an interview with him on French television. He responded in French.


Candi Ebba Simone wrote: "Candi, oh, I understand. How many of his novels have you read? He was a very nice man. I saw an interview with him on French television. He responded in French."

So far I've read 9 of his novels, Ebba. I watched an interview with him once before, and I agree - he was a gentleman :) :)


message 45: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna Candi, I love your review and I love the analogy of holding le Carre's beautiful books out as a very fine chocolate, indeed. I need to return to one of my favorite espionage novelists soon.


Candi Lorna wrote: "Candi, I love your review and I love the analogy of holding le Carre's beautiful books out as a very fine chocolate, indeed. I need to return to one of my favorite espionage novelists soon."

Thanks a bunch, Lorna! It's sad to know now that we will eventually run out of that box of chocolates. But le Carre's books are worth a reread once I've exhausted his list. And the movies are a lot of fun as well!


message 47: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna Candi, I totally agree. And don't forget his memoirs and there are some good biographies as well. If you haven't read The Pigeon Tunnel: Stories from My Life, it is delightful. I loved the book.


Candi Lorna wrote: "Candi, I totally agree. And don't forget his memoirs and there are some good biographies as well. If you haven't read The Pigeon Tunnel: Stories from My Life, it is delightful. I lo..."

I own that memoir, Lorna! I'm really looking forward to it! :)


message 49: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna That is wonderful, Candi. I am sure that you will love it.


Candi Antoine wrote: "Of course there the spy stories - always intriguing - but in fact what JLC writes about is humain despair. His heroes - or should we say antiheroes - Leamas, Pym, Jim Prideaux or Edward Avon, make ..."

It sounds like we agree on all the merits of JLC's writing, Antoine! If these were simply spy stories, I'd not be quite so invested in reading them. But there is so much depth to the writing and characters that I find it irresistible :)


« previous 1
back to top