ŷ

Nataliya's Reviews > Emergency Skin

Emergency Skin by N.K. Jemisin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2020-reads, hugo-nebula-nominees-and-winners, shorts

“Can’t start a revolution with the enemy shouting in your head, after all.�
It’s a story told by that little nagging voice inside your head - the one that you can spend your whole life trying to get rid of. You know - one that is an amalgam of the small-minded, closed-off and judgmental influences that are everywhere; the crotchety old guy telling those kids to get off his lawn.
“We left because it would’ve cost too much to fix the world. Cheaper to build a new one.�
Here that voice is an AI built into a head of a soldier - a slave - from a distant off-Earth colony that returns to the now certainly ravaged by the natural cataclysms and populated with devolved species planet in search of a precious cargo needed to keep the new world going. A long time ago the Founders left what they thought was a doomed planet - and surely without them, without the elite, the place *had* to go to hell, right?
“There were just too many people, and too many of those were unfit, infirm, too old, or too young. Even the physically ideal ones were slow thinkers, timid spirits. There was not enough collective innovation or strength of will between them to solve the problems Tellus faced, and so we did the only merciful thing we could: we left them behind.
Of course that was mercy. Do you think your ancestors wanted to leave billions of people to starve and suffocate and drown? It was simply that our new home could support only a few.�
But once the soldier slave lands on Earth, the disconnect between what you are taught to believe is and should be true and the actual truth begins its subversive work.
”It is the guiding principle of our society. Rights belong only to those who earn them. When you complete this mission, for your bravery you will have proven yourself deserving of life, health, beauty, sex, privacy, bodily autonomy � every possible luxury. Only a few can have everything, don’t you see?�
The point is simple: Once we start questioning the presumed truths, we learn to think. Once we actually think, we can be free.
“We realized it was impossible to protect any one place if the place next door was drowning or on fire. We realized the old boundaries weren’t meant to keep the undesirable out, but to hoard resources within. And the hoarders were the core of the problem.�
No, the story is *not* subtle. Yes, it exaggerates - but does so cleverly and with a good dose of humor and slight absurdity. It’s much simpler than Jemisin’s usual fare - and yet still feels so well-done and effective and galvanizing.
� For all these centuries, the Founders told us that the Earth died because of greed. That was true, but they lied about whose greed was to blame.�
Clever. Quite clever. Loved it!

—ĔĔĔĔĔĔĔ�
The Forward Collection, in the order read:

‘Emergency Skin� by N.K. Jemisin: Lovely. 5 stars.
‘Randomize� by Andy Weir: Meh. 2 stars.
‘The Last Conversation� by Paul Tremblay: Eerie. 4 stars.
‘You Have Arrived at Your Destination� by Amor Towles: Perfectly adequate. 3 stars.
‘Summer Frost� by Blake Crouch: Very intelligent (artificially?). 4.5 stars.
‘Ark� by Veronica Roth: Underwhelming melancholy. 2.5 stars.

—ĔĔĔĔĔ�

My Hugo and Nebula Awards Reading Project 2020: /review/show...
87 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Emergency Skin.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 12, 2020 – Shelved
March 13, 2020 – Started Reading
March 13, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Celia (new)

Celia What about the majority of oppressive regimes that are not even white? (Here’s looking at you, the-entire-African-continent-minus-a-shaky-SA.)


Nataliya Celia wrote: "What about the majority of oppressive regimes that are not even white? (Here’s looking at you, the-entire-African-continent-minus-a-shaky-SA.)"

What about it?
This story is not only about racism. It’s about the ‘haves� and the ‘have-nots� and the divide about those who are feel entitled to their status over everyone else.


[Name Redacted] To be fair, a lot of Jemisin’s work IS about racism...


Nataliya [Name Redacted] wrote: "To be fair, a lot of Jemisin’s work IS about racism..."

It absolutely is.
This story though does not seem to be solely about that.


message 5: by Eric (new)

Eric McLaughlin I don't mind a story about racism when it is about the story. However this one is really heavy handed unapologetic socialist propaganda and that to me is boring and lazy. In short form story telling perhaps she didn't get the opportunity for nuance but that is no excuse, I normally love her writing but this one annoyed the hell out of me. And I normally vote green party.


Nataliya People have always toyed with an idea of utopia. She proposes to get there via a socialist route. Won’t happen just as it won’t happen under capitalism - that’s human nature. Yet interesting to contemplate because against all hope I wish that someday humanity gets there.


message 7: by Cecily (new)

Cecily "Once we start questioning the presumed truths, we learn to think. Once we actually think, we can be free."

An important message. Thanks for a good review.


Nataliya You are welcome! Thanks for the kind words.


Nataliya ❥Kandake wrote: "Yep. Definitely reading this, thanks for the review."

You’re welcome, I hope you will like it. It’s quite a clever story.


back to top