ŷ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > Crime and Punishment

Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: novels, russian-lit

Well, what’s a global pandemic for if you don’t read the stuff you think you really ought to have read by now. Although I hope this strange circumstance will not result in me referring to Fyodor Dostoyevsky as The Corona Guy.

Those yet to read this towering inferno of literature may wish to know what’s in the nearly 700 pages, so here is a scientific analysis :

WHAT HAPPENS IN CRIME AND PUNISHMENT

Long conversations between people who could talk the hind legs off a donkey: .....................53%
People going mad and running about wildly or quietly chewing the wallpaper in their tiny room : .........11%
People being in debt :.................. 41.7%
People being unsteady on their legs due to vast consumption of vodka :.................... 51%
People being ill (physical) :.................... 34%
People being ill (mental) :...�...�...�...…�37%
People contemplating suicide :...……………�19%
People enjoying a pleasant stroll in the countryside : .....0%
People having a friendly chat over a cup of coffee :... 0.03%
Men figuring they can force a poor woman to marry them :.....…�...…………�. 36%
Women being terrified :...�...…………�..……………�. 39%
Horses being beaten :...…………�...�..…�...�...…�...…�... 2%
Nothing exciting happening :...…�...…�...………�.. 0%

This all adds up to more than 100%. That is because C&P is a very excessive novel. It has more than 100% inside it.

INTERVIEW WITH F DOSTOYEVSKY, 18 March 1867

FD : You see, in my books...the numbers all go to eleven. Look...right across the board.

V. M Vorshynsky: Ahh...oh, I see....

FD : All other novelists, they only go up to 10. But I go up to 11.

V. M Vorshynsky:: Does that mean you have more emotion in your books ?

FD: Well, it's one whole notch more, isn't it? It's not ten. You see, most...most novelists, you know, they don’t know eleven exists. I get my characters all the way to ten with their emotional situations, and then...push over the cliff. See?

V. M Vorshynsky: Put it up to eleven.

FD: Eleven. Exactly. One louder.

And it’s really true. If they are not about to jump into a river, they are going to fall in love with a prostitute, or they are going to get roaring drunk because they have fallen in love with a prostitute and will later jump into a river.

CAN WE GET SLIGHTLY MORE SERIOUS PLEASE

C&P surprised me. It was like a Dardenne Brothers movie with the camera tight up to Raskolnikov nearly the whole time, and the action shown in detail almost hour by hour over a couple of weeks. Yes it’s a whole lot about th psychological disintegration of this arrogant twerp who thinks he might be some kind of extraordinary person destined to improve the human race by sheer power of his brainwaves & so therefore is justified in bashing in the head of some horrible old woman pawnbroker to steal her money and kickstart his wonderful career. And bash in the brains of her sister who unfortunately comes in the door at the wrong moment. Bad timing.

But it seemed to me that at least half of C&P was all about the horrible powerlessness of women and how they are forced into marriages which are no more than licenced prostitution. An antidote to Jane Austen, indeed.

And it was about how the arrogant twerp murderer can also be a guy who perceives this injustice and wants to revolutionise society. And to do that he starts by bashing in the brains of two women.
So you see this is a psychological minefield we are in.

Like Macbeth and An American Tragedy by Dreiser the murder is contemplated beforehand, then committed, then acts like acid on the mind of its perpetrator, and the reader is along for the excruciating ride.

Thre are hundreds of connections that trigger like flashing synapses as you go through this big ass book� Freud, Leopold and Loeb, the philosophy of the Nazi Party, Camus, Beckett�

I do admit that there are probably three windbags too many in C&P and I could think of snipping a chapter here and a chapter there to get the whole thing down to a tight 500 pages of ranting and caterwauling. But all in all, this novel rides all over you like an out of control ox cart & will leave you gasping and discombobulated.

Conclusion : excellent pandemic reading
604 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Crime and Punishment.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 8, 2020 – Started Reading
April 8, 2020 – Shelved
April 15, 2020 – Shelved as: novels
April 15, 2020 – Finished Reading
May 6, 2021 – Shelved as: russian-lit

Comments Showing 1-50 of 72 (72 new)


message 1: by Reading_ (new) - added it

Reading_ Tamishly Totally agree to that


Violet wells Fabulous review, Paul.


message 3: by Harry (new)

Harry Can we have the percentages displayed as a Venn diagram, please? Data is beautiful.


message 4: by Robert (new) - added it

Robert


message 5: by Lulufrances (new)

Lulufrances Lol literally thought about finally reading this one this morning as I brushed
my teeth. Here we go (maybe), Corona Guy et moi


message 6: by Nat (new)

Nat K 5🌟 review. Brilliant. You nearly make me want to re-attempt reading it. Not sure self-isolation will continue long enough though.


Paul Bryant haha thanks everyone...! It's never too late for Dosto!


Dusan Since I've read CP (brilliant review, btw) and quite enjoy a stroll in the countryside, I might go with Chekhov instead.


message 9: by Lealea ❤️ (new)

Lealea ❤️ I was given this book by a colleague when I went I embarked on maternity leave (wtf? ) 13 years ago ... I still haven’t finished it. I’ve restarted it many times but I think I need to let it go. It’s definitely not the book. It’s me. Fantastic review!


message 10: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Thanks for the review. This is one of those novels on my non-existing "to read list", and I will read it a fast as I can get my hands on it. And do I detect a reference to the wonderful movie Spinal Tap here/


message 11: by Rose (new) - rated it 2 stars

Rose Thanks for the laugh this morning. I started C&P but put it down and forgot to where I left it.


message 12: by Paula (new)

Paula Ludwigson Great review. I still have horrid memories of reading this book in high school. I feel vindicated after your review. Thanks for making my day 50 years later


message 13: by Jackie (new)

Jackie L Spot-on & brilliant review! Really enjoyed it.


message 14: by Jackie (new)

Jackie L Lealea ❤️ wrote: "I was given this book by a colleague when I went I embarked on maternity leave (wtf? ) 13 years ago ... I still haven’t finished it. I’ve restarted it many times but I think I need to let it go. It..."
Why or why would anyone recommend this book for a new mom on maternity leave?!??! Couldn't be anyone who ever had a baby.


Steve Great review, as always. Years ago, I had given up reading novels and reading anything for fun while in grad school. I stopped thinking about anything else. Crime & Punishment is what reignited my love of reading again. It reminded me what great literature can do and how much I needed quality fiction as part of my daily life. I'm due for a re-read and a quarantine seems like the perfect time to do it.


Betsy Fantastic review, as always. This was a centrepiece of inspiring and influential literature I read as a teenager - and it continues to impact me to this day.


message 17: by Richard (new)

Richard Levine Hmm. Never thought of C&P as the antidote to Jane Austen - nor Dostoevsky as the Nigel Tufnel of his day - but now that you mention it. . .


Linda ~ they got the mustard out! ~ Shouldn't "nothing exciting happens" be 100%? 😂 I love your scientific analysis.


message 19: by carol. (new)

carol. Except for the horses part, I feel like you could have just summed up "What Happens During a Covid Pandemic" in the U.S.


Margaret I’m laughing as I’m getting through brothers karamozov on audiobook as I clean and dust and organize like some sort of manic phase during the pandemic. I know it’s all crazy, but somewhat satisfying in a way I don’t understand and can’t explain. Yes I read C&P as a ver young person. I didn’t get it. I kept thinking. “Just get over it already!�


message 21: by David (new)

David Szatkowski Awesome review.


message 22: by Lady R (new) - added it

Lady R Awesome review damn you! I’m now definitely going to have to read it :-)


message 23: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thank you all....


Niraj Read a brilliant review once that said the main idea in Crime and Punishment is the word 'and' in between the other two words in the title. My favourite novel of all time. Lots of talking though. Especially of beer and soup!


message 25: by Ruth (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ruth First read C&P at about the age of 13. Read it again when I was in my 40s. Amazing how much more tedious it got as it aged.


Betsy As it aged or as you aged? ;)


message 27: by P.E. (new) - rated it 5 stars

P.E. Now that's some superb review you have here, Paul! ;)


message 28: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thank you PE!


message 29: by Нестор (new)

Нестор Your review is so good that I am thinking of re-reading the book.


message 30: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant wow, that you very much...


message 31: by Elizabeth (new) - added it

Elizabeth I felt personally affronted that I never got to read C&P like all my AP Lit friends did in high school (though I actually have myself to blame for taking AP Lang). Then I kept procrastinating every time I looked at it sitting innocuously on my bookshelf (because, well, 700 pages), but now I REALLY want to read it after your review. Terrific review :P


message 32: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thanks Elizabeth... I sure hope you like it...


message 33: by Sara (new)

Sara Brilliant as always :)


Karen Armo Read this when I was at Uni. I think I held my breath for the whole book. Great review!


message 35: by Mazza (new)

Mazza 5 stars to you,
For this stunning review.
Cos when you’re under attack,
C&P? None more black.


message 36: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thank you Sara, Karen and Mazza... !


message 37: by Ian (new) - added it

Ian "Marvin" Graye Did it make you want to say, I can't breathe.


message 38: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant we saw the crime, we're waiting for the punishment


message 39: by Jack (new) - added it

Jack I thought Brothers K turned things up to 11 haha. I may need a break first, but I definitely look forward to reading this. Great review!


message 40: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thank Jack - I now have Brothers K and wow, that is a 1000 page whopper. They had too much time in Russia back then.


message 41: by P.E. (new) - rated it 5 stars

P.E. It was their series, issued periodically, back in the day ;)


message 42: by Jack (new) - added it

Jack Hey Paul, I know some of the editions are pretty hefty, but I would say there is only 650-700 pages of actual story. The rest are intro, footnotes, info about the edition and translators, etc.

Like I'm sure was the case with C&P, 2-3 parts slogged a bit, but once you get into the rhythm of narrative and dialogue it was very enjoyable.


message 43: by Paul (last edited Jun 01, 2020 09:01AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant I hope so!


Donald Powell Great review! This is one of my favorite books.


message 45: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thanks Donald


Klaartje Thank you for your review. It reminds me that there are books I need to revisit.
Reading this book, still somewhere in my 20s, it really broad Home a notion of the dangers of narcissistic feelings of entitlement.
A Far more common human feeling than one would like to admit.


message 47: by Lara (new) - added it

Lara Your review is so good I think I’ll just read it instead of book!


message 48: by Gail (new) - rated it 4 stars

Gail Sider I never read GR reviews, Paul, but you had me at pandemic. I put off pulling C&P off my shelf because it seemed like more work than I had stamina for. But with my library closed and my options limited and the world falling apart, this seemed like just the right time to put myself through some rigor. I’m only 83 pages in (spoiler ok) and I’m already recommending it to everyone I know. Essential reading, as is your review. Thank you.


message 49: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant many thanks Klaartje, Lara and Gail....


message 50: by Moriah (new) - added it

Moriah Hey Paul. Tried to get through it after the first 1/3 of the book. Eventually stopped because it felt like nothing was happening. Just endless pointless conversations and walking around.


« previous 1
back to top