ŷ

Mark Porton's Reviews > Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18643650
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 5-stars, historical-fiction

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe by Fannie Flagg is a book I arrived at knowing little about, written by an author I know nothing about. So, it was a major surprise when I was blown out of the water by this experience.

The story involves a little railroad town in Alabama called Whistle Stop and centres around a Cafe of the same name operated by partners Idgie Threadgoode and Ruth Jamison. There’s a whole crew of characters we get to know, in fact, initially I found it difficult to keep track of who was who, but after a while I really got to know these people. They came alive for me, each one of them, the good, bad and the ugly.

The author jumps from the 1920s to the 1980s and back again and everywhere in between, the chapters are usually named after places such as the The Rose Terrace Nursing Home or after local bulletins like The Weems Weekly (Whistle Stop Alabama’s Weekly Bulletin),. The reader is taken backwards and forwards, from character to character and drama to drama � and one experiences every bump, laugh and tear � it is GOLD!!

My favourite character was Evelyn, this forlorn woman really grew on me. She is connected to the story by visiting her Mother-in-Law at the Rose Terrace Nursing Home and there she meets one of the old Threadgoode ladies. A wonderful relationship develops � but for me, it’s Evelyn’s journey that sparked my interest. Her relationship with old Ninny Threadgoode quickly blossomed into a wonderful thing:

When she woke this morning, Evelyn realised that she was actually looking forward to going to the nursing home. Sitting there all these weeks listening to stories about the café and Whistle Stop had become more of a reality than her own life�..

Ninny could talk underwater with a mouth full of marbles, this � as we all know � can be a little wearing, but it seemed to me this is exactly what Evelyn needed. It was a joy to see their friendship grow. The last section of this book was one of the most moving things I have read in recent times. I read it slowly.

Crazy, wayward, boozy Idgie was another fascinating character � her love for Ruth was absolute. Her path was no easier than Evelyn’s. But she was equally lovable. I would have liked to have sat down and had a pint of best bitter with Idgie, it’d be a riot:

The Dill Pickle Club……was really just a bunch of Idgie’s ragtag friends that would get together. About all they did was drink whiskey and make up lies (we call it Bullshit in Australia). They’d look you right in the eye and tell you a lie when the truth would have served them better

But Idgie had a MASSIVE heart � always looking out for the downtrodden. So kind-hearted, but a handful to be sure.

You could say this is a character piece but it’s much more than that � it also catapults us right back to a time and place most of us have never experienced. We are taken from the time Whistle Top was a buzzing little railroad town in the �20s to the sad days, decades after the railroads closed and the Town turned into a shadow of its former self.

It was also fascinating to learn more about ‘the other� Birmingham. Birmingham is my hometown in the UK, we are called “Brummies�. The US version call themselves “Birminghamians�!! You know our Brummie accent in the UK is often voted the UK’s worst accent. I wonder if the Birminghamian accent suffers the same sad fate?

I’ve come away from this book with lots of questions - such as “what is Birmingham and Alabama like?� or “What do Fried Green Tomatoes taste like?� (BTW at the back of the book there are recipes), a great book sparks your interest in things I reckon. I’ve also collected a wonderful bunch of characters I will remember for a long time. Evelyn and Idgie in particular.

One word of caution though, this story isn’t all ‘Beer and Skittles�, there are certainly elements of racism, violence and domestic violence that come through � making this story all the more realistic.

5 Fried Green Tomatoes for me, with a side of Fried Okra and Lima Beans!

5 Stars
131 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 8, 2020 – Shelved
May 8, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
June 18, 2020 – Started Reading
June 24, 2020 – Finished Reading
June 25, 2020 – Shelved as: 5-stars
June 25, 2020 – Shelved as: historical-fiction

Comments Showing 1-50 of 62 (62 new)


message 1: by Nat (new)

Nat K Beat review Mark, it really made me smile. Gold for sure 🌟


Mark  Porton Thanks Nat, I certainly smiled a lot when reading this one :))


Diane Barnes I need to re-read this one. Love your review.


Melanie I read this so long ago but your review reminds me of how great a book it is. Wonderful review! Thanks!


Mark  Porton Cheers Diane, I reckon I'll re-read this again one day too!


Mark  Porton Thanks very much Melanie, yes a great book it was - such a rich story :)


message 7: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Your review is a delight to read, Mark! I love when a book really succeeds in connecting you to its characters. I'll be sure to read this one :)


Julie G Mark,
I'm so tickled. When I read and reviewed this book earlier this year, I wondered how male readers and non-Americans would respond to this read, and you've answered both questions for me. I am almost enchanted to know what a connection you made to this story, and, FYI, Evelyn is my favorite, too.

I loved this, from your review, by the way:

Ninny could talk underwater with a mouth full of marbles, this � as well know � can be a little wearing, but it seemed to me this is exactly what Evelyn needed.


Mark  Porton Candi wrote: "Your review is a delight to read, Mark! I love when a book really succeeds in connecting you to its characters. I'll be sure to read this one :)"

You must Candi!! Reckon you'll love it - thanks again, I'll look out for your review :-))


Mark  Porton Julie wrote: "Mark,
I'm so tickled. When I read and reviewed this book earlier this year, I wondered how male readers and non-Americans would respond to this read, and you've answered both questions for me. I am..."


Well this Antipodean, Non-Female loved it Julie - was terrific, reminded me of the way my favourite author Strout tells a story, but Flagg tells it a bit lighter (if that makes sense), I'll have to read another from this author before long :-)) ......and yes, all Evelyn needed was a good chat, and she certainly got a whole lot more than that!!


preoccupiedbybooks Great review Mark! Y'know I've never read this, but loved the film when I was younger, so I should give it a go! Also, I live in Solihull so hi! My husband grew up in Acocks Green and Hall green, and my inlaws are from Sparkbrook back in the day, small world, but I don't even notice the brummie accent anymore! I'm originally from Swindon :)


Mark  Porton preoccupiedbybooks wrote: "Great review Mark! Y'know I've never read this, but loved the film when I was younger, so I should give it a go! Also, I live in Solihull so hi! My husband grew up in Acocks Green and Hall green, a..."

Wow, it is a small world! Thanks for that - some of my family are from Solihull and Acocks Green, I went to school in Bromsgrove and was raised in Aston, Rednall and Rubery - came out to OZ om 1972 (yep that long ago hahaha). I've always wondered what Birmingham Alabama would be like, it sounds like an interesting city - might have to go one day, and teach them what a real Brummie accent is!! But yes this is a wonderful book :-)) (Villa or Blues?)


message 13: by Pedro (new)

Pedro Awesome review, Mark. I’ve added this one to The Pile yesterday after reading Julie’s wonderful review. So glad to see your five stars... ;)


preoccupiedbybooks Villa in this house Mark! It's not looking good for them though...


message 15: by S.A. (new)

S.A. Krishnan Loved the review!


message 16: by Karen J (new)

Karen J Mark excellent review, I have watched the movie a few times and really enjoyed it. Thanks to you “Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe� has now become a must read. 💕📚


Mark  Porton @pedro you're a Strout fan from memory my friend, I reckon you will love this one buddy :))


Mark  Porton @preoccupiedbybooks Blues family here, even tho I am a MASSIVE Leeds United fan #MOT


Mark  Porton @S.A. Krishnan - thx so much :)


Mark  Porton @karen.J. Thanks so much, I'll have to check out the movie....but yes its a great read!!


Petra nearly in Melbourne That was a proper review, unlike my piece of fluff, and a good one. Thank you.


Mark  Porton Petra-X wrote: "That was a proper review, unlike my piece of fluff, and a good one. Thank you."

Thanks Petra, you gave it 5 stars!!!


☆~ܳٳܳ Great review! One of my favorite books and the movie is even better!


Mark  Porton Thanks so much Autumn, yes one of my favourites for the year for sure! Gotta watch the movie too :)


Richard (on hiatus) Wonderful review Mark ......... read this years ago and loved it :)


Petra nearly in Melbourne Mark wrote: "Thanks Petra, you gave it 5 stars!!!"

How could I give it less when it had been so useful to me? I rated the book, just not the contents!


Mark  Porton Richard wrote: "Wonderful review Mark ......... read this years ago and loved it :)"

Thanks Richard, yes it's a great book for sure :)


Mark  Porton Petra-X wrote: "Mark wrote: "Thanks Petra, you gave it 5 stars!!!"

How could I give it less when it had been so useful to me? I rated the book, just not the contents!"


Well you did find the book very useful - all 80 copies - I'll give you that!!


message 29: by Morgan (last edited Jun 29, 2020 05:40AM) (new)

Morgan Loved your review. It was made into a wonderful movie in 1991 with Kathy Bates. Fannie Flagg can be seen on Game Show channel in "Match Game" from the 1970's. She was a very funny lady!


Beata Terrific review, Mark :)) I read it years ago and remember crying, crying, crying non-stop :)) The film Morgan mentions is truly wonderful :)) Take care!


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) I hope you've seen the film which follows the book closely. Stars Kathy Bates, Jessica Tandy and many others and was nominated for 2 Oscars


Mark  Porton Morgan, Beata and Jonathan I think I saw it many, many years ago - I'll check it out again. Was Bates, Evelyn?


message 33: by Morgan (new)

Morgan Mark wrote: "Morgan, Beata and Jonathan I think I saw it many, many years ago - I'll check it out again. Was Bates, Evelyn?"

Yes.


Mark  Porton Swaroop wrote: "Mark,
A brilliant review - thank you, for sharing your insightful thoughts!"


Just saw this comment of your Swaroop, thanks again for checking out my reviews and for your kind comments - this is a very good book!


message 35: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Enthusiastic review. It sounds like a book I'd enjoy, too bad my library doesn't have it on its shelves. :-(


message 36: by Laysee (last edited Jun 28, 2021 03:28AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Laysee This is a delicious review, Mark. You certainly struck gold with this book with its characterization and flavor of an old railroad town. I have this on my to-read list and hope to meet the characters you mentioned. I happen to like okra and will be happy to place an order, too.


message 37: by Shainlock (new) - added it

Shainlock This review is gold, too! It made me happy!


message 38: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Fantastic review, Mark. I don't know when I'll be able to read this book. I want the movie adaptation to leave my brain, but it won't. I saw the movie many years ago and still remember it well. What an amazing cast. If you haven't checked out the movie you might want to do so.


Mark  Porton Bianca wrote: "Enthusiastic review. It sounds like a book I'd enjoy, too bad my library doesn't have it on its shelves. :-("

Ohh - that's a shame Bianca, lets hope you can stumble across this wonderful book another way - it really was magic!!


Mark  Porton Laysee wrote: "This is a delicious review, Mark. You certainly struck gold with this book with its characterization and flavor of an old railroad town. I have this on my to-read list and hope to meet the characte..."

Make that the same for me Laysee and a flat white coffee on soy (I bet they wouldn't have soy!!) - thanks for checking this review out it was such a good book. I just had to refresh my mind and re-read it - and now I really remember how good it was. I hope you find it and I need to read your review when you do :))


Mark  Porton Shaina wrote: "This review is gold, too! It made me happy!"

Hahaha - and that's always a good thing hey Shaina? Thanks so much - I hope you enjoy this one as much as I did!


Mark  Porton Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Fantastic review, Mark. I don't know when I'll be able to read this book. I want the movie adaptation to leave my brain, but it won't. I saw the movie many years ago and still remember it well. Wha..."

Ahhhhh the movie!!! That's right Anne, there's a movie, I'll have to look for it. It would have to be really good to match the book though - I hope you read this at some stage, because it is so good - and Evelyn is such a wonderful character, amongst a cast of stars!! I've just added the sequel too (The Wonder Boy at Whistle Stop) - so I need to get onto that quick smart - thanks again :))


message 43: by Anne (new) - added it

Anne Get onto it quick smart to stop mourning LD. The movie is excellent! You'll have to tell me how it compares to the book.


Missy LeBlanc Ivey I really enjoyed this book too. It’s slow and meandering, drawing you in…much the way “Snow Falling on Cedars� did. My favorite kind of novels, when they are well written.


Mark  Porton Anne (On semi-hiatus) wrote: "Get onto it quick smart to stop mourning LD. The movie is excellent! You'll have to tell me how it compares to the book."

I just saw this Annie - I'm glad I did as it's reminded me to check out the movie! I do like the way you bossed me in your opening sentence - bahahaha - sometimes I do need to be told 😂😬🎈


Mark  Porton Missy wrote: "I really enjoyed this book too. It’s slow and meandering, drawing you in…much the way “Snow Falling on Cedars� did. My favorite kind of novels, when they are well written."

I agree totally Missy - it was slow and meandering, what a wonderful description of this one - as with Snow Falling on Cedars, thanks again!


message 47: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa I enjoyed seeing this review pop up this morning. This was such a delightful read. And who could not cheer for Evelyn?


Mark  Porton Lisa wrote: "I enjoyed seeing this review pop up this morning. This was such a delightful read. And who could not cheer for Evelyn?"

Oh I know Lisa, such a great character - thanks so much for your very kind comment!! I had better get cracking on my review of Howards End - I'll make sure not to read your though before I do :))


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Terrific review Mark


message 50: by Sarah (last edited Dec 03, 2022 06:08PM) (new)

Sarah Oh, Mark, I love this book as much as you do! Actually, I've visited this cafe, which is - oddly enough - in Juliette, Georgia, as opposed to Alabama. It was used for the film version of the book, and it serves large crowds to this day.

You better believe their fried green tomatoes are good enough to make you wanna' slap yo' momma!

description


« previous 1
back to top