ŷ

Nataliya's Reviews > The Ten Thousand Doors of January

The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2020-reads, hugo-nebula-nominees-and-winners

“You see, doors are many things: fissures and cracks, ways between, mysteries and borders. But more than anything else, doors are change. When things slip through them, no matter how small or brief, change trails them like porpoises following a ship’s wake.�
This is a story about the desire for unknown, the longing for change. It is a story of the dangers of complacency, blind obedience, unquestioning submission to those who proclaim they are the strong ones. This is a story of the need to take action, to rise above what has been determined for you and do what you have to do regardless of the obstacles in your path. It is a story of growing up while holding on to curiosity and adventure which do not need to give way to propriety and stuffiness. It’s a story of family and abandonment. It is a story of how it feels to be the “other�, “an in-between sort of thing.�

This is also a story about the power of words.
“If one follows the stories, one will nearly always find a doorway buried at their roots.�



“Worlds were never meant to be prisons, locked and suffocating and safe. Worlds were supposed to be great rambling houses with all the windows thrown open and the wind and summer rain rushing through them, with magic passages in their closets and secret treasure chests in their attics. […]
I was so very tired of locked doors.�
There are doors in the world � or Doors, really � that appear in the places where boundaries between worlds are thin and that can take you through to places that are different and strange. They allow for things unusual and new to flow between worlds, changing status quo, bringing fresh beginning with them.

But those Doors are closing now. Or rather, someone has been closing them.

In 1901, January Scaller is seven. An “oddly colored� reddish-skinned girl, she is a ward of Cornelius Locke, a rich man, a no-nonsense member of an archaeological society and her father’s employer. January has no mother, and her father is always away on Ms. Locke’s archaeological expeditions, returning from time to time with a wealth of strange things that go straight in Mr. Locke’s vast collections. January is lonely, and resentful of her mostly absent father, and works really hard to earn approval and love from the replacement father figure, her guardian Mr. Locke who buys her things and takes her on long travels � and in return expects her to grow into a respectable young lady with certainly no penchants for imaginary things and wanderlust.

But then, at age seven, January walks through a blue Door standing in an empty field and sees a different world - one full of smell of ocean and blue water, one that calls to her. And eventually she notes that writing some things down when she really believes them makes them happen. But that is certainly nonsense, and no proper young ladies should be given to such flights of fancy.
“There was no room, it turned out, for little girls who wandered off the edge of the map and told the truth about the mad, impossible things they found there.�
Then, at the age of seventeen, January runs afoul of those in power who view her either as a nuisance or an irritation to be swatted away. Those who look at her and see a weak colored girl of no consequence � unless she has something that they want. And January, sheltered and naive, raised to be quiet and pliable and proper, has a rude and abrupt awakening.
“The truth is that the powerful come for the weak, whenever and wherever they like. Always have, always will.�

This book made me quite angry at times � angry at blatant power imbalances, at the injustice, at imperialism and prejudice - and at January herself � at her questionable choices and desperate desire to cling to normalcy, as abnormal as that normalcy can be. (view spoiler) And anger is often what fuels change. And change, while not always good or bad, is what fuels and sustains life, even if it is inconvenient to the ones happy with status quo.
“The will to be polite, to maintain civility and normalcy, is fearfully strong. I wonder sometimes how much evil is permitted to run unchecked simply because it would be rude to interrupt it.�

It is a well-written book, full of wondrous and magical things and told in a crisp well-crafted prose, with excellent plot and well-crafted characters, and enough worldbuilding to sustain sequels (although in this world of never-ending series I’m very happy with stand-alone novels). Its magical yet grounded, charming yet tough. It allows for a bit of moral ambiguity in the characters, with no one (view spoiler) coming out of this smelling like roses. For a debut especially, it’s very strong; it reads as though written by a seasoned author, which bodes quite well for Harrow’s future works. Those Hugo and Nebula nominations are well-earned.
“I hope you will find the cracks in the world and wedge them wider, so the light of other suns shines through; I hope you will keep the world unruly, messy, full of strange magics; I hope you will run through every open Door and tell stories when you return.�
4.5 stars keys to all the locked Doors.
—ĔĔĔĔĔ�

My Hugo and Nebula Awards Reading Project 2020: /review/show...
148 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Ten Thousand Doors of January.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 16, 2020 – Shelved
May 21, 2020 – Started Reading
May 21, 2020 –
17.0% "“If one follows the stories, one will nearly always find a doorway buried at their roots.�"
May 25, 2020 –
21.0% "Ok, this book is really good. Really good.
“You see, doors are many things: fissures and cracks, ways between, mysteries and borders. But more than anything else, doors are change.3 When things slip through them, no matter how small or brief, change trails them like porpoises following a ship’s wake.�"
May 25, 2020 –
44.0% "January, you idiot, just *think* for a moment. And then act. Please."
May 25, 2020 –
45.0% "“The truth is that the powerful come for the weak, whenever and wherever they like. Always have, always will.�"
May 25, 2020 –
75.0% "I was abruptly, entirely sick of it—of secrets and lies and almost-truths, things I half knew and half suspected, patched-together stories that were never told in order from beginning to end. It seemed to be an unspoken agreement in the world that young girls without money or means were simply too insignificant to be told everything. Even my own father had waited until the very last moment to tell me his whole truth."
May 25, 2020 –
76.0% "There are moments when January is too stupid to live.
This was one of those moments."
May 25, 2020 –
88.0% "Ah, the villain speech..."
May 25, 2020 –
91.0% "“I think I even caught a glimpse of love when I turned back to look at his face—or at least a possessive, conditional, desire-to-own—but it was quickly subsumed beneath his towering fury. There is nothing quite like the anger of someone very powerful who has been thwarted by someone who was supposed to be weak.�"
May 25, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by carol. (new) - added it

carol. Oh, I'll definitely be interested in your thoughts on this one. Are you furloughed? Lol! You reading again!


Nataliya carol. wrote: "Oh, I'll definitely be interested in your thoughts on this one. Are you furloughed? Lol! You reading again!"

No, I still work but clinic was slow and we had days of virtual appointments from home, so suddenly there was all that time to read at lunch (instead of catching up on charting all the time). It is slowly going back to normal though. I have 3 days off this week (before Covid I was supposed to have a mini-vacation) so now I’m just hanging out at home for a few days with endless time on my hands.

I’m next in line for the e-book of this one in the library (finally!). I anticipate it in a few days.


message 3: by carol. (new) - added it

carol. Our library has been spotty about resuming service. They decided to do curbside, but were originally not taking transfers from other libraries, so it was only what was in-house. Ugh.

Things are still slow here, but starting to ramp up. I went in for an antibody test (negative, too bad) and the building was strangely quiet, even though it was one of the 'consolidated' locations. On the other hand, the hospital had 330/450 beds full, so that's improving.

I was supposed to have a big vaca pre-covid too! It's kind of seemed like the longest staycation ever.


Nataliya carol. wrote: "Our library has been spotty about resuming service. They decided to do curbside, but were originally not taking transfers from other libraries, so it was only what was in-house. Ugh.

Things are s..."


Our library is completely closed for the physical books. It’s ebooks or nothing. Their collection is pretty decent though, so I’m very happy about that.

Things are very slowly starting to resume here as well. Waiting cautiously now to see when that inevitable second wave hits, and how bad it’s going to be.


message 5: by carol. (new) - added it

carol. Well, I just read an interesting article in Propublica about the differences between SF and NYC management, and death rates, and comparing responses. Something tells me that you might be in a better position than the east coast, or L.A.. I've been trying to learn more about the herd immunity piece, and I think that concept is a bust, because we'd have to get people with antibiodies to 50% of the population--and you know how good we've done with influenza. Sigh. Gonna have to ride this one out. I'm in a dark place tonight.


Nataliya I just read that article. We did have a decent and relatively early response to Covid here. Bay Area counties reacted quickly (our Santa Clara county was an early hot spot), and our governor Gavin Newton is an intelligent person who was not afraid to be decisive. But I’m really worried to see what reopening does and what the toll of it will be.
As for immunity, vaccine is my only hope.


message 7: by carol. (last edited May 19, 2020 07:15AM) (new) - added it

carol. description


I couldn't help it. :)


Nataliya Love it!


Jennifer A lovely and thorough review! I loved this one. It might be my favorite portal fantasy, and Alix Harrow is now on my short list of authors whom I'd read anything by.


Nataliya Jennifer wrote: "A lovely and thorough review! I loved this one. It might be my favorite portal fantasy, and Alix Harrow is now on my short list of authors whom I'd read anything by."

Thank you, Jennifer! I love the idea of portal fantasy (although I was not aware until today that such a term existed). Alix Harrow definitely writes like a seasoned writer, and it’s a pleasure to devote a few days to a well-written book.


Jennifer Nataliya wrote: "Thank you, Jennifer! I love the idea of portal fantasy (although I was not aware until today that such a term existed)."

I think I came across the term first in Seanan McGuire's Wayward Children series? My favorite thing about that series is its characterizations of different fantasy portal worlds (a grid with nonsense to logic on one axis, wickedness to virtue on the other. I find Alix Harrow's writing and story more satisfying on the whole.

Just saw that you're a fellow San Jose citizen. Hello! Lockdown is getting pretty old in this heatwave with no theaters, libraries, or bookshops open. Maybe it's time to read a portal fantasy that takes place in some frozen ice world...


Nataliya Jennifer wrote: "Maybe it's time to read a portal fantasy that takes place in some frozen ice world..."

With you in Campbell, we are practically neighbors.
Yeah, on a day like today it’s too hot to do anything. This may be the time to reread The Left Hand of Darkness for the delight of the frozen world. Or Kim Stanley Robinson’s Antarctica.
Of course, I managed to get a cold (hopefully just a cold!) on the hottest day of the year - just my luck. Grrrrrr.....


Tracy Nataliya what a wonderful review. It definitely expanded on my inarticulate “wow� and as always is thoughtful and well written.


Nataliya Tracy wrote: "Nataliya what a wonderful review. It definitely expanded on my inarticulate “wow� and as always is thoughtful and well written."

Thank you, Tracy! It was an easy book to praise.


message 15: by Tadiana ✩Night Owl� (last edited May 26, 2020 08:10PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Here’s a short story portal fantasy that I really loved a few years ago, Probably Still the Chosen One:

You’ve probably read “A Witch’s Guide to Escape: A Practical Compendium of Portal Fantasies� (also by Alix Harrow), but if not definitely do!


message 16: by Book2Dragon (new) - added it

Book2Dragon Great review. Love the quotes--a good writer.


Nataliya Book2Dragon wrote: "Great review. Love the quotes--a good writer."

Thanks. And yes, Harrow has all the chops to be a great writer, and it’s just her debut.


message 18: by Nataliya (last edited May 26, 2020 08:27PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nataliya Tadiana ✩Night Owl� wrote: "Here’s a short story portal fantasy that I really loved a few years ago, Probably Still the Chosen One: "

Probably Still the Chosen One � That is a lovely story! Thanks for the link, Tadiana. I loved it.


message 19: by carol. (last edited May 27, 2020 08:38AM) (new) - added it

carol. Nataliya wrote: " I love the idea of portal fantasy (although I was not aware until today that such a term existed). .."

Huuuuuge genre, especially in the 80s when I grew up. I feel like that's what most fantasy was (except 'pure' other-world) until the UF came along. Terry Brook's Landover series; The Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe series, Pamela Dean's The Secret Country, Phantom Tollbooth, Zelanzy's Amber series, Guy Gavriel Kay's Finover (all of which are/were on my shelves).. you get the idea. You are in the boring, regular world, you do something special (gate/house/path/etc) and find yourself in fantasyland.


message 20: by Tadiana ✩Night Owl� (last edited May 27, 2020 08:55AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Whew, Carol, I'd forgotten how pervasive the portal theme is in fantasy! It's really everywhere you look, if you think about it. Seanan McGuire's Wayward Children, Sherwood Smith's whole Sartorias-deles canon, His Dark Materials trilogy by Philip Pullman, V.E. Schwab's A Darker Shade of Magic ...

What was that anti-Narnia portal fantasy that was nominated for the Nebula award a year or so ago? Now I'm going to have to go dig to figure it out because it's bugging me.

ETA: "This is Not a Wardrobe Door" - It wasn't my favorite of the nominees (too heavy-handed in its social messaging), but worth a read.


Nataliya carol. wrote: "Nataliya wrote: " I love the idea of portal fantasy (although I was not aware until today that such a term existed). .."

Huuuuuge genre, especially in the 80s when I grew up. I feel like that's wh..."


Apparently I see it was popular enough to warrant an actual term to describe it.
I immediately think of Gaiman’s Neverwhere though: I mean, he actually named the character Door.


Nataliya Tadiana ✩Night Owl� wrote: "ETA: "This is Not a Wardrobe Door" - ... It wasn't my favorite of the nominees, but worth a read."

I guess (almost) everyone loves the idea of opening a door and stepping out of mundane into fantastical. Tadiana, thanks for another story link! I’ll read it now.


Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ Nataliya wrote: "I guess (almost) everyone loves the idea of opening a door and stepping out of mundane into fantastical."

*raises hand*


message 24: by carol. (new) - added it

carol. Right? There was a serious ton of older children's books, and then the fantasy books that were along those lines. Landover was a lawyer that somehow fell into a fantasy kingdom. There were a lot like that, but most never got hugely popular. A fun idea though, right? Go into an interesting bookstore, a mysterious door, there you go.


Nataliya carol. wrote: "Right? There was a serious ton of older children's books, and then the fantasy books that were along those lines. Landover was a lawyer that somehow fell into a fantasy kingdom. There were a lot li..."

I knew there were many reasons for all those hours spent in bookstores and libraries!


message 26: by carol. (new) - added it

carol. :)


message 27: by Tadiana ✩Night Owl� (last edited May 27, 2020 11:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tadiana ✩Night Owl☽ I suggest a pact: if any of us ever finds a portal, we let the others know. :) It's gotta be to a good place, though. I don't think the Moors* are for me.

*from Down Among the Sticks and Bones


Nataliya Tadiana ✩Night Owl� wrote: "I suggest a pact: if any of us ever finds a portal, we let the others know. :) It's gotta be to a good place, though. I don't think the Moors* are for me.

*from [book:Down Among the Sticks and Bon..."


Agreed. Virtual handshake makes a binding promise. Good portals only.
Now ‘scuse me as I go and open every single door (cupboards included) in my place. You never know...


Fiona Knight There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either :) Maybe a nice endless library somewhere?


Nataliya Fiona wrote: "There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either :) Maybe a nice endless library somewhere?"

Alright, you can join the pact. A nice endless library would definitely be a perfect world at the end of any portal.
Now, I’m not familiar with John Wick, but from a quick trip to Wikipedia it seems that it’s not the kind of portal fantasy I’d ever want to end up in.


Fiona Knight Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either :) Maybe a nice endless library somewhere?"

Al..."


Woo!
Leah Schnelback gave a pretty convincing argument here:
As for endless library, I'd agree, particularly if it's the "contains all books, written or not, ever conceived" type.


Nataliya Fiona wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either :) Maybe a nice endless librar..."

That indeed is a convincing (although at times a bit far-fetched) argument. I may have to watch that movie with this article in mind.


Fiona Knight Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either :) Maybe a nice ..."

Not sure how much the wiki includes, but if you prefer not to wander in unwarned - (view spoiler). Not usually a fan of giving bits away but that's something that might affect whether or not you wanted to watch it, so thought it's worth the risk.


Nataliya Fiona wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "Nataliya wrote: "Fiona wrote: "There's even arguments for John Wick being a portal fantasy! I'm definitely down for the pact, but probably not the moors for me either..."

I saw that bit on Wikipedia, so I’ll be prepared. Thanks for the warning though, sounds like a very tough scene.


message 35: by Kerry (new)

Kerry John Wick movie was supposed to be called Scorn. Keanu could not remember that name and kept calling it John Wick. So they changed the name.


message 36: by Cecily (new) - added it

Cecily I loved "A Witch's Guide to Escape", but friends' reviews of this have been a bit more mixed. Your emphasis on "the power of words" suggests I should try this. Excellent review.


Nataliya Cecily wrote: "I loved "A Witch's Guide to Escape", but friends' reviews of this have been a bit more mixed. Your emphasis on "the power of words" suggests I should try this. Excellent review."

‘A Witch’s Guide to Escape� was one of a few genuinely perfect short stories. This book is certainly nowhere near this level of perfection, but it’s quite decent. It did t click with me right away - but by the end it found the way to my heart.


message 38: by Sofia (new) - added it

Sofia I'm so excited to read this😆


Nataliya Sofia wrote: "I'm so excited to read this😆"

It’s a lovely book. I hope you’ll like it.


Ashley I'm smacking myself in the forehead right now, because only after reading your review am I getting the connection between the story and Locke's name . . . oyyyy, self.


Nataliya Ashley wrote: "I'm smacking myself in the forehead right now, because only after reading your review am I getting the connection between the story and Locke's name . . . oyyyy, self."

I have moments like this all the time! I was super-proud of myself for spotting that 😁


back to top