Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Trish's Reviews > Troy

Troy by Stephen Fry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3461034
's review

it was amazing

Greek mythology - few things are as epic as the stories of Herakles� deeds, Odysseus� wits, or Achilles� prowess. And here, we get one of THE most famous tales: the rise and fall of Troy.



Troy, the jewel of the Aegean Sea. Ruled by Priam, defended by Hector, but ultimately doomed by Paris. In this book, Stephen Fry once again proves his talent in not only knowing every detail of the source material but of also cunningly choosing what is interesting and important and what would be too repetitive or killing the reader with boredom (anyone having read The Iliad will know what I mean).

We follow different stories that explain how Troy came to be ruled by Priam (in fact, how Priam came to his name) - and who would have thought that Herakles had a lot to do with that?! - and are introduced to everyone who will become important in the actual battle for Troy.

Naturally, the book tells of the most famous bits, such as Paris� judgement with the apple or the abduction of Helen. However, Fry also makes sure to include lesser known facts such as the Nubians and Amazons coming to help Troy at one point or that Troy wasn’t destroyed once but twice (the first time by Herakles).
And, of course, no Greek myth would be complete without a host of idiot gods meddling and making even more of a mess of things.
Thus, there is heroism, naivité, stupidity, cowardice, cunning, strength, cruelty, arrogance and every other possible vice and virtue imaginable.

It was honestly refreshing to have the story somewhat streamlined without that diminishing the intricate tapestry this great epic tale weaves or its colorfulness. The author’s dry humor only added to the enjoyment (yes, I have both the hardcover and audiobook that is narrated by Fry himself).

I was gnashing my teeth whenever Paris was in the picture, I despaired at Priam wrongfully meaning so well with everyone (even the ones who didn’t deserve it), I wanted to punch Agamemnon from dusk ’til dawn, slap Helen until she got her senses back, and teach a number of these „grown men� some manners.
Moreover, my heart was bleeding for Andromache, Cassandra, Breseis and what must have been done to the survivors after the trick with the horse had been played and the city had been taken. Yes, the author is kind of glossing the worst of it over, but so many others have done it before him, too, so I can’t fault him for that - it’s the curse of a vivid imagination that everything inside me cramps up nevertheless because we all know how terrible humans can be and have been to one another.

It’s the mark of a wonderful story as well as an equally wonderful way of telling said wonderful story if you know exactly what will happen and yet find yourself at the edge of your seat when re-reading it. This is exactly what happened to me here.

Now all that’s left for me to do is hoping that Stephen Fry will also write his summary of the Odyssey!
115 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Troy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 19, 2020 – Shelved
May 19, 2020 – Shelved as: to-read
February 9, 2021 – Started Reading
February 9, 2021 –
1.0% "Here we FINALLY go again!


And yes, once again, I have both the hardcover (sadly not fitting with the other two *exasperated sigh*) AND the audiobook narrated by Fry himself. *swoons*"
February 9, 2021 –
3.0% "The first time Troy was destroyed had to do with a wall being built by the gods but the king refusing payment.

Why is it that citizens always have to suffer for their leaders' follies? Oh, and of course the king's favorite daughter had to be sacrificed to placate the gods.

"
February 9, 2021 –
16.0% "Paris' judgement, the beginning of the end - because neither King Priam and his wife, nor their subject were able to kill him as a babe.
"
February 9, 2021 –
27.0% "We had the lottery for Helen's hand in marriage and the oath every suitor gave that basically is what started the whole mess with Troy (kind of like what "forced" everyone into WW1).

We also had the birth of Achilles and how his mother, Thetis, yearned to have an immortal child.

"
February 9, 2021 –
30.0% "


Can we take a moment to talk about just how disgusting Apollo's way of cursing Cassandra was (spitting in her mouth)?"
February 10, 2021 –
45.0% "Helen of Sparta Troy



Was she abducted? Did she fall in love with Paris and leave her husband? Was she manipulated/forced by Aphrodite? Why did the Trojans take her son Pleisthenes but not her daughter Hermione (and why is the boy never mentioned again)?"
February 10, 2021 –
50.0% "The grande invasion force



There are, of course, inconsistencies in the Iliad (years skipped, people's ages thus not adding up) but suffice it to say that the Greeks couldn't breach Troy's walls for ages. *lol*"
February 10, 2021 –
55.0% "The reason Achilles (briefly) walked away from potential glory and the Trojan War


Though Achilles wasn't really much better than Agamemnon. There are lots of romantic takes on Achilles' and Briseis' "relationship" but I bet it was just to let him appear in a better light."
February 10, 2021 –
57.0% "I always despair when we get to the duel between Paris and Menelaos and how Troy was ALMOST saved. But nooo, these great Greek heroes had to be utter assholes (not to mention the infuriating meddling of certain goddesses) and all went to hell. *buries face in hands*

Interesting that Helen now hates Paris and how he treats her. Don't get me wrong, I'm right there with her, but it makes you wonder (see my 6th update)."
February 10, 2021 –
60.0% "In addition to Herakles, there was another physically impressive warrior: Ajax the Great (yes, there were two and yes, the other one was called the Lesser).


Ajax and Hector had an incredibly intense duel (usually forgotten because of THE duel that comes later), which deserves mentioning."
February 10, 2021 –
65.0% "There goes Patroclus


And thus Achilles rejoins the war - with fateful consequences."
February 10, 2021 –
70.0% "Ladies and gentlemen: the main bloodshed, THE duel immortalized in the Iliad



(After a lot of other people were slaughtered and even a river god was fought.)"
February 10, 2021 –
73.0% "


No words needed.
A great change in the world regardless of his character flaws (nicely put, Mr. Fry)."
February 10, 2021 –
80.0% "

The beginning of the end. :(

My only consolation is the death of Paris (yes, I always despised the little prick)."
February 10, 2021 –
85.0% "

"
February 10, 2021 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Bradley I'm glad you thought the same about the book! Very well-written. Here's to Odyssey next!


Trish Hear hear, we can only hope! :)


message 3: by Candace (new) - added it

Candace Sounds wonderful! Love Greek mythology!


message 4: by Gary (last edited Feb 10, 2021 08:36PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gary K Bibliophile Great review Trish! I like the pics you posted for this as well. You and I are both Stephen Fry fans of course. He could do a book covering the history of chartered accountancy (sorry Mr Anchovy) and you and I would love it!


Trish He could read me his bloody grocery list and I'd sigh dreamily and ask for more. *lol*


Trish HOLY SHIT! I JUST FOUND OUT! Fry is indeed writing/publishing his version of the Odyssey, just like I had hoped!!! /book/show/5...


Cathy I‘m enjoying Mythos, so I might get this one as well. As we are on the topic of Troy, have you read Ilium? Brad gave it four stars and after much deliberation I ended up giving it five stars�

Plus this makes me want to rewatch the movie. I adore Brad Pitt as Achilles�


message 8: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Wonderful review, Fry is brilliant!


Trish Cathy wrote: "I‘m enjoying Mythos, so I might get this one as well. As we are on the topic of Troy, have you read Ilium? Brad gave it four stars and after much deliberation I ended up giving it fiv..."

Nope. Haven't read the book and the movie was so bad, I'm still unsure what to think about Brad as Archilles. *lol*


Trish Mark wrote: "Wonderful review, Fry is brilliant!"

Thanks - and yes, he is!


back to top