Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Madeline's Reviews > A Storm of Swords

A Storm of Swords by George R.R. Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
111921
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fantasy

PREVIOUSLY, ON A SONG OF ICE AND FIRE: A ton of dudes came up out of the woodwork to fight over a stupid crown, lots of people died, lots of people killed lots of people, there was consensual sex and a lot more rape, some hookers and mercenaries, and life continued to be utterly terrible for anyone with the last name Stark. Also there are fucking dragons and ice-zombie-monsters, don't forget about those! It only gets more fun from here, boys and girls.

So with that in mind, lets check in with our narrators this time around and see what they've been up to. They are:

Arya Stark: God, I love this little girl. She goes full badass here, teaming up with The Hound and traveling the country with him like some crazy mashup of Pulp Fiction and Paper Moon. More than anyone else, I want Arya to make it to the end of this story, because she is so, so cool. Severely damaged and with zero chance of living a normal life after all the shit she's been through, obviously, but in Westeros you take what you can get.

Catelyn Stark: Yes, this bitch is still getting to narrate chapters, and no, she will never be held accountable for the fact that 75% of all the shit that's happening in this book is all her fault. Early in the book, she decides to release Jaime Lannister and get Brienne to take him across the country and exchange him for Arya and Sansa (how many ways can this go wrong? I counted five, see if you can guess more!). Again - she helped her own son's most valuable prisoner escape, and set him loose with one woman to guard him. If anyone else had pulled that shit, their head would be rotting on a stake within five seconds, but because it's Catelyn Stark, all the men do is send her to her room to think about what she's done. And then they keep inviting her to council meetings, because that's certainly never backfired before! (view spoiler)

Jaime Lannister: Finally, one of the Big Bads gets his own chapter! Unfortunately, it's not as fun as it could have been. Sure, every now and then he'll be like, "Man I sure miss having sex with my sister" or "I absolutely do not regret pushing that kid out the window in Book One, that was awesome", but for the most part Jaime actually experiences some personal growth and maybe becomes a better person. But apparently Cersei gets her own chapters in the next book, so I've already started making popcorn for that crazy cunt sideshow.

Bran Stark: You're a warg, we get it. I don't care.

Sansa Stark: Oh honey. You know the expression "falling from the frying pan into the fire"? Sansa does more than that in this book. She falls from the frying pan into the fire, and then falls again into an even worse fire that's much more likely to rape her. At this point, I almost want Sansa to die, just so she'd be put out of her misery - judging by what's happened to her so far, I don't see any way this series can end well for her. Also it'd be nice if she could stop inadvertently causing death and destruction.

Tyrion Lannister: Oh Tyrion, how I love you. You are clever and sarcastic and funny, seem to have a shred of human decency, and are pretty much the only good person in the series. Just a piece of advice though: stop falling in love with prostitutes. Seriously, man. Otherwise, keep doing what you're doing.

Davos Seaworth: Yeah, he's still around. His only purpose is to give us an idea of what Stannis is up to, but it basically boils down to this: "Stannis is a deluded motherfucker, and Melisandre is a crazy bitch who's going to kill everyone." Got it, moving on.

Samwell Tarly: When I got to his first chapter and realized that he was going to be a narrator in this book, I literally groaned aloud.

Jon Snow: He's getting better, guys. After spending two books whining about how unworthy he is, he finally gets to be cool and go undercover with the wildings, and is sort of a badass by the end of the book. His undercover work, I should mention, involves sleeping with a wilding girl named Ygritte, and if there's one character who can be counted on to turn hot wilding sex into an excuse for another woe-is-me fest, it's Jon Snow. I mean, for Christ's sake, dude, you're a fifteen year old boy who's getting laid on a regular basis! Forget about your vows, you should be ! Get over yourself and lighten the hell up, (view spoiler)

Daenerys: So, all that stuff I mentioned up there? It's all important and takes up the majority of the book, but here's the thing: none of it matters, because Daenerys fucking Stormborn has dragons and an army, and she is coming to destroy everything. And I cannot wait.

A final word: If there's one thing I've taken away from this book, it's that you should never go to a wedding in Westeros. Seriously, don't do it. There are three weddings in this book, and all of them end horribly. Stay home and send a nice card instead.
98 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read A Storm of Swords.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 28, 2012 – Started Reading
May 28, 2012 – Shelved
May 28, 2012 –
page 65
5.52% "Catelyn Stark decides it's a good idea to release Jaime and get him traded for Arya and Sansa. She could not be doing a worse job of this if she were actively trying to ruin everything forever."
May 29, 2012 –
page 150
12.74% "I'm working on a Game of Thrones sitcom spinoff where Jaime and Brienne have to share an apartment. Constant bickering gives way to sexual tension, and then in the season finale they wake up in the same bed after a night of drinking. Both scream, cut to black, "To be continued next season!""
May 29, 2012 –
page 250
21.24% "Good news, everyone! Jon Snow may have finally gotten laid. Does this mean he'll stop being the most boring character in the book? God, I hope so."
May 31, 2012 –
page 440
37.38% "Poor Arya. She's basically trapped in her own version of Planes, Trains, and Automobiles, but because this is Westeros and everything is terrible, it's Running, Dying Horses, and Forced Marches. And also there's Rapists."
June 1, 2012 – Finished Reading
June 3, 2012 –
page 575
48.85% "Daenarys is becoming a delightful contradiction. With her insane lust to conquer coupled with her habit of freeing slaves wherever she goes, she's like the unholy love child of a Bond villain and Mother Teresa. I'm kind of in love with her."
June 4, 2012 –
page 629
53.44% ""What have I done? Catelyn thought wearily...First I anger Edmure, and now Robb, but all I have done is speak the truth. Are men so fragile they cannot bear to hear it?" Catelyn Stark is totally that bitch in middle school who told you that your hair looked terrible and then acted all offended when you got mad at her and said, "What? I'm just being honest" like she was doing you a favor."
June 6, 2012 –
page 843
71.62% ""Hello, my name is Sansa Stark and I'm thirteen years old. My hobbies include crying over my murdered family, having my innocence ripped to shreds on a daily basis, and stumbling blindly into the clutches of every villain in the series. You will never hate anything as much as George RR Martin apparently hates me.""
June 8, 2012 –
page 1050
89.21% "God DAMN. Arya Stark is the tyranny of evil men, and she has NO INTEREST in trying to be the shepherd. And you will know her name is THE LORD, when she lays her vengeance upon you."
June 9, 2012 –
page 1110
94.31% "Man, living in Westeros sucks. You can't even build a goddamn snow fort without it leading to someone's murder. (yes, the construction of a snow castle did create a chain of events that led to murder. And yes, the snow castle was built by Sansa Stark, because who else?)"
June 14, 2012 – Shelved as: fantasy

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Nikoline (new)

Nikoline oh boy... your last comment! xD


message 2: by Misty (new)

Misty Grove I love this review! Hilarious!


Becky Best review ever. This was my favorite in the series so far. I havent moved on to 4 yet.

(view spoiler)


Madeline (since all of this is just unfounded fan theories I'm not sure if it's technically a spoiler, but I'll hide it just in case)
(view spoiler)


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Awesome review! It's been a long time since I read this, but you've just reminded me why I loved it. :D


Michael She falls from the frying pan into the fire, and then falls again into an even worse fire that's much more likely to rape her.

Yes. Poor Sansa has been getting shat upon since early in A Game of Thrones, and there's no sign that the shit is going to stop pouring down any time soon.

All of your reviews for this series have been hilarious! I'm also not sure about the Rhaegar-Lyanna theory....I would expect Jon to look different from the other kids in this case. I could see Robert being the baby daddy, though.


message 7: by Madeline (last edited Jul 02, 2012 10:07AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Madeline But with Lyanna as the mom, Jon would still have the Stark coloring and such, right? Catelyn has a line early in the first book about how Jon looks like Ned, but he could easily have gotten those looks from Ned's sister.


Becky (view spoiler)


Madeline Also there's that line in A Feast for Crows (I quote it in one of my status updates) about Rhaegar and "the wolf girl," who I assume is Lyanna.

But then again, it could all be misdirection and Jon's mother was really Wyla all along (or however her name is spelled) and Martin's just been fucking with us.


message 10: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Sharpe In Game of Thrones, Ned tells Arya how she looks like Lyanna, and it's mentioned several times that Arya and Jon look a lot alike. So I think that Lyanna is definitely Jon's mother.


message 11: by Nora (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nora I love this review! I especially appreciated the I just had sex link...thanks for that one.


Lindsey, Corrie, Not to be rude or to rain on your parade or anything, but it is discussed between Robert and Ned that Ned had a relationship with a whore named Wylla in the first book as well as the second episode of the TV series. Therefore, Jon could be the child of Ned and this whore and still have the Stark colouring. It also shows that Ned does have honour, but not enough to keep him away from the brothels.


Madeline You weren't being rude! That's the great thing about unfounded fan theories - there are no wrong answers.

For my part, I go along with the commonly-accepted conspiracy theory that Wylla is merely a red herring - Ned may have actually had an affair with her, but he never fathered Jon Snow with her. Martin spends the entirety of Book One proving that Ned Stark is the only honorable person in the entire series (and that sense of honor is what gets him killed), so it makes no sense that he would cheat on Catelyn and then force her to raise his kid. Meanwhile, Martin throws in cryptic references to Lyanna Stark's dying words to Ned ("Promise me") and hints that she and Rhaegar may have actually been in love. Going off the theory that Jon's parents were Lyanna and Rhaegar, it makes perfect sense that Ned would agree to create a story about an affair with a girl no one really knew and raise his sister's child as his own - Ned loved Lyanna, so even though he hated the Targaryans he would want to save his sister's child; also Ned Stark understood how much danger a Targaryan heir would be in (he saw how the other Targaryan's were murdered after the siege at King's Landing) and would want to protect baby Jon Snow from that. Plus, this is Westeros - there's no shame in having an affair with some girl you met during war, so all the secrecy surrounding Jon Snow's mom suggests that she was someone important. And lost Targaryan heirs are always popping out of the woodwork in these books (there's Aemon at the Wall, and I don't know if you've read Book Five yet but we meet another one there) so it's not unreasonable that Jon would be one.

Also there's that prophecy, "The dragon has three heads" which people believe refers to three Targaryan heirs. Dany is one, Jon Snow is another, and some people have suggested that Tyrion is the third.


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

Tyrion the only character with 'human decency', really? He's a disgusting misogynist for a start, like when he was super pissed Sansa the 12-year-old girl didn't want him, yeah such a nice guy!!! Writing Melisandre of as nothing but a crazy bitch? Um, ok. Melisandre is an interesting character, with lots of hidden layers. She's the only one genuienly trying to save all those ungrateful lords from the white walkers without any ulterior motive.


Madeline He's a disgusting misogynist for a start, like when he was super pissed Sansa the 12-year-old girl didn't want him, yeah such a nice guy!!!

No arguments there. The thing is, when I wrote this review I was in the middle of binge-reading the series and had yet to come up for air, so at that point I still viewed Tyrion the way George RR Martin views Tyrion (pretty sure Martin, like many ASOIAF fans I have a problem with, excuses Tyrion's problematic behavior with "well his daddy never loved him and he's a dwarf so his life has been sooooo hard, guys, and you should be nicer to him!"). With the benefit of hindsight, I can now saw that I'm significantly less enamored of him (not that I was super into him to start - note I said he has "a shred of human decency"). He has a lot of issues that the majority of the fans refuse to acknowledge, and you're absolutely right to point them out.

We differ on Melisandre, however. I agree that she's an interesting character, but she's also a religious zealot who assassinated a guy with dark magic, burned people alive, and wanted to sacrifice a baby. So yeah, I think she's a crazy bitch. And frankly I think it's a little premature to insist that "she's the only one genuinely trying to save all those ungrateful lords from the white walkers without any ulterior motives." So far we've had only one chapter from her point of view, and the series is far from over - whatever her end game is, it's still very unclear.


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

Okay, so I'll agree she's crazy. But she's a deluded crazy. My point is she genuinely thinks she's doing what prophecies have scripted and what her belief says is right etc. Which isn't much of an excuse but I really think she thinks she's helping the cause or whatever, if that makes sense.


RJ - Slayer of Trolls The first paragraph of your review made me think of the upcoming Presidential primaries. Only with less dragons.


Farhana best review!! "If there's one thing I've taken away from this book, it's that you should never go to a wedding in Westeros. Seriously, don't do it. There are three weddings in this book, and all of them end horribly. Stay home and send a nice card instead." LOL


back to top