ŷ

Brian's Reviews > Bel Canto

Bel Canto by Ann Patchett
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
51395417
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction

“To think that God heard his name from so many voices.� (4.5 stars)

The ending of “Bel Canto� left me in a bit of a daze for a few minutes. The novel cast a spell so strong, that when the jarring reality of life springs up at the conclusion you can’t help but be a little disoriented.
This is a novel that has been on my radar for years, but I am just now picking it up.
This story, told by an omniscient narrator, follows a hostage situation in the vice presidential palace of an unnamed South American country. The hostages include a world famous opera soprano, and many business and political leaders from various countries. The point of view also considers the guerrillas who take the hostages.
I have never read an Ann Patchett novel before. I will pick her up again! She has a simplicity and lovely finesse with language. I was caught up in the story, but also in the words she used to weave it. With a precise prose that brimmed with clarity Patchett created characters that, even if only a few lines of the text were devoted to them, came across as real people.
I feel like opera gets a lot of negative attention from readers of this text. And opera is important to many of the characters in the book. However, I feel the bigger point is what opera represents to many of the characters in the text. It is a source of life and inspiration. Something that gives joy and generates much power and strong feelings. That is something different for every person alive, and when you realize that you put opera in its proper context in this book, and you can place the love that characters feel for that art in its proper context, and thus appreciate it, and its potency as used in “Bel Canto�.
So many enchanting moments in this book. So many small pleasures. I loved the world it created. I loved the people in that world. So many characters whose small joys I felt as my own. I loved their truth, their pain, and humanity.

“Bel Canto� is something else!
76 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Bel Canto.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 9, 2020 – Started Reading
June 9, 2020 – Shelved
June 15, 2020 – Finished Reading
January 1, 2022 – Shelved as: fiction

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Connie  G Great review! The movie is wonderful too.


Brian Thank you Connie. I am still debating about seeing the film. Don't want to cloud my memory of the read.

Connie wrote: "Great review! The movie is wonderful too."


message 3: by Debbie (new) - added it

Debbie W. Very moving review! Thank you!


Brian Thank you Debbie. Appreciate that! This book unexpectedly got to me.

Debbie wrote: "Very moving review! Thank you!"


Barb H Excellent review, Brian. It was good to see that you reacted as I had when reading this. I have read most of Patchett's books and have continued to feel that this was unsurpassed- her very best!


Chris I thought this was a wonderful surprise of a novel also! And kinda sorta based on a true event. I loved the relationships that developed between strangers.


Brian Thanks Barbara. I liked it so much I am a little nervous about picking up another of hers. I read "Lonesome Dove' before I read any other McMurtry. Nothing else of his has come close. Worried this could be the same.

Barbara H wrote: "Excellent review, Brian. It was good to see that you reacted as I had when reading this. I have read most of Patchett's books and have continued to feel that this was unsurpassed- her very best!"


message 8: by Brian (last edited Jun 25, 2020 08:16AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Brian Well said Chris. The relationships that developed are the heart of the book. Wish I had addressed that now.

Chris wrote: "I thought this was a wonderful surprise of a novel also! And kinda sorta based on a true event. I loved the relationships that developed between strangers."


Barb H Brian wrote: "Thanks Barbara. I liked it so much I am a little nervous about picking up another of hers. I read "Lonesome Dove' before I read any other McMurtry. Nothing else of his has come close. Worried this ..."

You may not feel as I have about her other books. They are generally well received, but I feel they are no match for this one!


Brian True. I do intend to pick her up again. Fingers crossed.

Barbara H wrote: "Brian wrote: "Thanks Barbara. I liked it so much I am a little nervous about picking up another of hers. I read "Lonesome Dove' before I read any other McMurtry. Nothing else of his has come close...."


Barb H Although others probably would not agree with me, of all of her other books I have read I did enjoy The Magician's Assistant .


Lorna Brian, a beautiful review. I have read a lot of Ann Patchett’s books but “Bel Canto� is still my favorite!


Brian Barbara-
That was the one that looked most interesting to me. Your review confirmed it. I will check it out.

Barbara H wrote: "Although others probably would not agree with me, of all of her other books I have read I did enjoy The Magician's Assistant ."


Brian Thank you Lorna. I am going to check out "The Magician's Assistant" of hers next.

Lorna wrote: "Brian, a beautiful review. I have read a lot of Ann Patchett’s books but “Bel Canto� is still my favorite!"


Shawn I really enjoyed her book “Commonwealth�


SlowRain Well said! A very nice review of a beautiful book. I've only read one other novel by Ann Patchett, but I'm under the impression this is her only good one. I can definitely steer you away from State of Wonder. Watch the Sean Connery movie Medicine Man instead.


Brian I'll look it up Shawn. Thanks for the rec.

Shawn wrote: "I really enjoyed her book “Commonwealth�"


Brian Thank you! And I appreciate the heads up about "State of Wonder".
And I had not heard of "Medicine Man". I will look it up.

SlowRain wrote: "Well said! A very nice review of a beautiful book. I've only read one other novel by Ann Patchett, but I'm under the impression this is her only good one. I can definitely steer you away from State..."


Barb H I suppose that I am being repetitious, but neither Commonwealth, nor State of Wonder , despite rave reviews could hold a candle to BC.


Barb H Brian wrote: "Barbara-
That was the one that looked most interesting to me. Your review confirmed it. I will check it out.

Brian, I do hope that you enjoy it.



Barbara I think you have pushed me to read this again!


Brian Cool. Did you like it the first time?

Barbara wrote: "I think you have pushed me to read this again!"


Bianca I concur with what you've written in your excellent review.


Brian Appreciate that! Thanks Bianca!

Bianca wrote: "I concur with what you've written in your excellent review."


Barbara Brian wrote: "Cool. Did you like it the first time?

Barbara wrote: "I think you have pushed me to read this again!""


I gave it 4 stars. I read it before a trip to Lima, Peru. I'm working on reading the Women's Prize backlist and this is one that won several years ago.


Brian Ahh, I see. Well, I hope the reread holds up to the initial impression.

Barbara wrote: "Brian wrote: "Cool. Did you like it the first time?

Barbara wrote: "I think you have pushed me to read this again!""

I gave it 4 stars. I read it before a trip to Lima, Peru. I'm working on readi..."



message 27: by Dan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dan Witte I’ve really enjoyed all of her books, and I don’t think reading “Bel Canto� would render her other works diminished by comparison. “The Magician’s Assistant� is almost a masterpiece, in my opinion, and “Commonwealth� is brilliant.


message 28: by Brian (last edited Aug 13, 2020 03:41PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Brian Thanks for those thoughts Dan. A lot of people are raving about "The Magician's Assistant" so I think that is the next one of hers I am going to tackle. "Almost a masterpiece" is high praise. Looking forward to it!

Dan wrote: "I’ve really enjoyed all of her books, and I don’t think reading “Bel Canto� would render her other works diminished by comparison. “The Magician’s Assistant� is almost a masterpiece, in my opinion,..."


Barbara Loved this and all of Patchett's books.


Brian I'm finding lots of people do Barbara. I really liked this one a lot, but its the only of hers I have read thus far.

Barbara wrote: "Loved this and all of Patchett's books."


back to top