Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Laysee's Reviews > Abigail

Abigail by Magda Szabó
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4863523
's review

really liked it

Abigail by Magda Szabo was published in Hungarian in 1970 and translated into English by Len Rix only in 2020. If only translation of her oeuvre can be speeded up! Readers who have read The Door will likely agree with me.

Abigail is a coming of age story set in Hungary during World War Two between September 1943 and March 1944. Gina (Georgina Vitay), a 14-year-old motherless girl, is suddenly uprooted from her privileged, upper social class life in Budapest, and sent to a very strict religious boarding school, Bishop Matula Academy, in Arkod located on the Eastern border of Hungary. Gina’s father, a General in the Hungarian army, is unable to tell her his reasons for first packing her governess back home to France and then banishing Gina to the boondocks, away from adoring relatives and a dashing Lieutenant admirer whom he and the governess both dislike. Gina and the General share a loving and close father-daughter relationship; thus their leave-taking was heartbreaking to read.

Although well known as the first institution of pedagogic excellence for female students in Hungary, Matula is an oppressive, no-nonsense fortress, where every student is made to dress alike, fill all waking hours with studies and meaningful work, obey every rule or risk punishment and even expulsion. However, the girls cope by inventing their own traditions, trading private jokes, and having their own fun. Unsurprisingly, being the bright, headstrong, and impetuous teenager that she is, Gina gets into trouble right from the beginning. Her gravest transgression is to bust a long-standing tradition, which makes her public enemy number one among the fifth level girls. Oh, the girls� brand of relational aggression toward Gina is vicious. As in The Door and Iza’s Ballad, Szabo’s writing in Abigail revealed a wealth of psychological insight into female relationships � the ties that bind are as strong as the destructive potential that resides in misplaced expectations and lapses in the language of love.

How will Gina survive missing her father and the prolonged ostracism of her schoolmates? Much more is at stake for Gina than her young mind can comprehend. Yet, there is apparently hope for all Matula girls in despair. In the school compound is Abigail, a neoclassical stone sculpture of a woman holding a ground stone pitcher. The girls hail Abigail as a miracle worker, an angel who comes to the rescue of any student who unburdens her cares to her. Of course, Gina regards this claim with total contempt. Will she need Abigail’s help? Is Abigail a figment of the imagination? If she is real, who is she? Unraveling the mystery of Abigail quickens the pulse of this story.

Abigail sets a teenage girl’s petty fights against the menace and danger of WW2 where death and annihilation are stark realities. Szabo told a gripping story that had me holding my breath in several places. I read this with my heart in my mouth as the suspense built up, gathered momentum, and did not let up until the very last word. I needed to know if Gina would find deliverance from the problems she has created for herself as well as from enemies more fearsome than her rejecting schoolmates.

Readers who enjoy stories about boarding schools and the eccentricities that take place behind their closed doors as well as stories that unravel the love-hate relationship between students and their teachers are likely to love this novel. If I had read this when I was younger, I would have appreciated it more. Nonetheless, this is no shallow boarding school tale and well worth the time.

That the impending destruction is hidden from the understanding of school-aged teens wrapped up in their own dreams lent this story its poignancy. Hitler’s advances rocked the carefree world of a group of adolescent girls. For them, the implications of a world war seem remote given their more immediate preoccupation with peer relationships, fantasy about romance and marriage, including matchmaking their teachers. All this minutiae of day-to-day life is dwarfed by the realities of war, which hit home personally for some of them. The lives of the girls in Matula, Gina’s especially, are irrevocably changed.

Read Abigail. Much awaits the reader within the fortified walls of the Bishop Matula Academy.

I had the joy and privilege of reading this book with the Obscure Group. This erudite group offered much insight into the history of Hungary in WW2, background to Szabo's life, the meanings of Hungarian names, character and plot development. I learned so much from them. Special thanks to Ken Craft who led this motley crew for his tiptop organization of our discussion schedules.
50 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Abigail.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 6, 2020 – Started Reading
May 10, 2020 – Finished Reading
June 16, 2020 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tamoghna (new) - added it

Tamoghna Biswas Fascinating review, Laysee. I hadn't heard of this one beforehand but it does sound a very interesting read. Adding it to TBR list!!


Antoinette Splendid review, Laysee! I have never read this author, but after your review, I am very interested in doing so. Thanks, Laysee!


Laysee Tamoghna wrote: "Fascinating review, Laysee. I hadn't heard of this one beforehand but it does sound a very interesting read. Adding it to TBR list!!"

Thank you, Tamoghna. I'll be very interested in what a male adolescent thinks of this book. Truly. Glad you added.


Laysee Antoinette wrote: "Splendid review, Laysee! I have never read this author, but after your review, I am very interested in doing so. Thanks, Laysee!"

You're welcome, Antoinette, and thank you! Szabo was a talented Hungarian writer. This is one of her earlier novels and quite a page turner. However, her masterpiece is The Door, which was also her last work. That is a must-read. :-)


Sandra L L. Excellent review. I enjoyed the page-turning chapters although at times the details seemed to be necessary only to keep the reader waiting and in suspense to discover Abigail’s true identity. I’m curious as to why you awarded only four stars.


Richard (on hiatus) Sounds a powerful and unusual WW2 novel ....... a wonderful review Laysee :)


Candi A superb review, Laysee! Great insights into this one, in the land of adolescent girls! I found it to be quite suspenseful by the last section and wouldn't hesitate to recommend this either. I think I'll land on the 4 stars like you did, once I gather all my thoughts together :)


Diane Barnes A fine review, Laysee. I agree that The Door is her masterpiece, although I suppose I should read her other works before making that statement. I thoroughly enjoyed this one.


message 9: by Pedro (new)

Pedro An excellent review, Laysee. I’ve added this one to The Pile already. ;)


message 10: by Neale (new) - added it

Neale Wonderful review. :-)


message 11: by BookMonkey (new) - added it

BookMonkey Terrific review, Laysee. I have been tempted by NYRB editions of Szabo novels at the bookstore many times over the past few years, and your review of this one will prompt me to finally buy one.


Laysee Sandra wrote: "Excellent review. I enjoyed the page-turning chapters although at times the details seemed to be necessary only to keep the reader waiting and in suspense to discover Abigail’s true identity. I’m curious as to why you awarded only four stars."

Thank you, Sandra. It was so good reading your insights in the Obscure Group discussion. Why four stars? Good question. I guessed I rated this with The Door as a benchmark of a five-star read. by comparison, Abigail seems to me lighter in terms of its psychological and emotional intensity. I found the ending to be a bit abrupt. (view spoiler)In part 2, I was beginning to get a bit fatigued from all the adolescent antics. A younger me would have rated this higher, I believe. I suppose all this led to a 4-star rating.


Laysee Richard wrote: "Sounds a powerful and unusual WW2 novel ....... a wonderful review Laysee :)"

Thank you, Richard. This is indeed a rather unusual WW2 novel as the war was seen through the eyes of the young who lived through it.


message 14: by Laysee (last edited Jun 17, 2020 12:24AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Laysee Candi wrote: "A superb review, Laysee! Great insights into this one, in the land of adolescent girls! I found it to be quite suspenseful by the last section and wouldn't hesitate to recommend this either. I think I'll land on the 4 stars like you did, once I gather all my thoughts together :)

Thank you, Candi. I agree that it is taut with suspense and therefore, engaging. I can't wait to read your review of Abigail.


Laysee Diane wrote: "A fine review, Laysee. I agree that The Door is her masterpiece, although I suppose I should read her other works before making that statement. I thoroughly enjoyed this one."

Thank you, Diane. Glad you thoroughly enjoyed this one. I shall check out your review soon. The other book I have read by Szabo is Iza's Ballad. It is a good read, too, but not as powerful as The Door.


Laysee Pedro wrote: "An excellent review, Laysee. I’ve added this one to The Pile already. ;)"

Oh how wonderful, Pedro! I hope you will enjoy meeting Magda Szabo and, of course, Abigail. Thank you for stopping by to read and comment on my review.


Laysee Collin wrote: "Wonderful review. :-)"

Thank you, Collin. I learned quite a bit about Hungary in WW2. I re-learned the spiteful venom of which girls are capable. Yikes. :-)


Laysee BookMonkey wrote: "Terrific review, Laysee. I have been tempted by NYRB editions of Szabo novels at the bookstore many times over the past few years, and your review of this one will prompt me to finally buy one."

Oh, thank you, BM. I think you will like meeting Magda Szabo. I very highly recommend The Door. This, too, is good.


message 19: by Tuti (new)

Tuti wonderful review, Laysee!


Laysee Tuti wrote: "wonderful review, Laysee!"

Thank you, Tuti. Abigail is a good story to read.


message 21: by JimZ (new) - rated it 4 stars

JimZ Great review Laysee!!


Laysee JimZ wrote: "Great review Laysee!!"

Thank you, Jim. Now for Katalin Street. :-)


message 23: by Jeannie (new)

Jeannie Nice review, Laysee!


Laysee Jeannie wrote: "Nice review, Laysee!"

Thank you, Jeannie, for reading and commenting.


message 25: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav What a superb analysis, Laysee. I have this one and The Door on my TBR but has not read Szabo yet, will try to amend it as soon as I could.


message 26: by Cheri (new) - added it

Cheri As always, Laysee, a lovely and insightful review. I haven't read anything by Szabo yet, but will add this one, and if I haven't already added The Door, will add that one, as well.


Laysee Gaurav wrote: "What a superb analysis, Laysee. I have this one and The Door on my TBR but has not read Szabo yet, will try to amend it as soon as I could."

Thank you, Gaurav. You're all set for some very satisfying reading. Fantastic! I hope you will enjoy these two Szabo books. So far only four have been translated.


Laysee Cheri wrote: "As always, Laysee, a lovely and insightful review. I haven't read anything by Szabo yet, but will add this one, and if I haven't already added The Door, will add that one, as well."

Cheri, as always, you're unfailingly supportive and kind. Abigail and The Door are both very well written. Enjoy them.


message 29: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara Terrific review, Laysee. I was so sorry to have missed this read with the group. Looked like you had a marvelous discussion and everyone has written such awesome reviews. It is on my short-list now to become acquainted with Szabo.


Laysee Sara wrote: "Terrific review, Laysee. I was so sorry to have missed this read with the group. Looked like you had a marvelous discussion and everyone has written such awesome reviews. It is on my short-list now to become acquainted with Szabo."

Thank you, Sara. I'm sorry, too, that you did not manage to read with us this time. I'd have loved to hear your thoughts on this book. The Obscure Reading Group is stimulating literary company and you'll fit right in. Do join us for the next read later in the year. I'm glad you have Szabo on your short list. Bravo! I'll keep my eyes peeled for your review when you get to Abigail.


message 31: by Ken (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ken Not sure how I initially missed this, Laysee, but glad the link drew me in. Let's just say you know how to put the "thorough" in the review, what with the nice mix of summary and suspense and analysis. You captured a lot of my thoughts exactly!


message 32: by Jim (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jim Puskas Great review! I've got the book on order and I'm trying to track down the rest of Szabó's works in English translation (regrettably, my ability to read Hungarian is far too limited).


message 33: by Angela M (new)

Angela M Terrific review,Laysee. The Door has been on my list for a while!


Laysee Ken wrote: "Not sure how I initially missed this, Laysee, but glad the link drew me in. Let's just say you know how to put the "thorough" in the review, what with the nice mix of summary and suspense and analysis. You captured a lot of my thoughts exactly!"

Thank you, Ken. Most kind. Yes, we do have a meeting of minds on Abigail. I like your idea of the Obscure Reading Group members sharing their reviews in Part III's discussion. That way we can have a nice closure to our thoughts on Abigail.


Laysee Jim wrote: "Great review! I've got the book on order and I'm trying to track down the rest of Szabó's works in English translation (regrettably, my ability to read Hungarian is far too limited)."

Thank you, Jim. Fantastic that you have Abigail waiting in the wings. There are so far only four of her work translated into English. (My ability to read Hungarian is non-existent. You're better off. Hahaha!)


Laysee Angela M wrote: "Terrific review,Laysee. The Door has been on my list for a while!"

Thank you. Angela. I found The Door very intense. Abigail is probably a better choice of a Szabo book for now. Hope you'll take to her writing.


back to top