Anne's Reviews > The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby
by
by

So this was a weird little story about people with too much money.
The main characters just kind of flopped around drinking cocktails, smoking, and complaining about the heat. When they weren't cheating on their spouses, that is.
The gist is that this guy Nick, who is the only person with normal human emotions in the entire book, is recounting his special summer with The Great Gatsby.

Gatsby is this ultra-mysterious man with gobs of money who likes to throw lavish wingdings. Everyone who is anyone shows up to drink his booze, eat his food, and party till they puke.
BUT! He has a secret and he needs Nick's help.
He's in love. <--with Nick's cousin, Daisy
Daisy, however, is married to a douchebag named Tom, who is cheating on her with a floozy named Myrtle, who is married to a wimp named George, who wants to buy one of Tom's cars.
It's the great circle of life.

Gatsby was...? I don't know.
Part of me felt sorry for him because he pulled himself up by his bootstraps and made a shitload of money just to win over the woman he loved. Sure he did it illegally, but how the fuck else are you supposed to make a shitload of money? Not by believing that anyone can be anything in America, that's for damn sure.
The other part of me thought he was an idiot who just wanted what he couldn't have. If Daisy threw him over for a guy with money, then that right there should tell you something.
Move on, dumbass.

Daisy was...? Kind of a dick, obviously. Of course she 100% deserved Tom. How Gatsby didn't see it coming is something that boggles the mind. <--we've all known a Gatsby, though, right? Unwilling to face the fact that his crush is a bitch on roids.

Myrtle was...?
Well, that shit was just funny. She didn't deserve to be road pancake, but if it had to happen to someone, at least it wasn't her dog.

Jordan was...? A golfer, a bit of a klepto, and Nick's quasi-love interest. You never get the feeling they're really dating-dating. <--more like they're both killing time? She was somewhat of a non-character for me.

Tom was...? An entitled, smarmy buffoon. But apparently, that's a good look on some people, because everything seems to come up roses for him.

At the end of the day, I'm not really sure why this is considered a must-read.
It's basically just a slice of asshole life. The very wealthy, very bored, and very cliqueish don't necessarily interest me and this story really wasn't an exception. I think it has the same appeal as those reality shows that follow rich housewives, or television series about wealthy a-holes doing shit like murdering their business rivals on yachts. Like, somehow I'm supposed to think, "Oh, look! Their lives aren't perfect, either!" but all I really end up thinking is, "You miserable fuckers can't think of anything better to do on a yacht?", because I sure as hell could come up with something a bit more fun than that.

The best thing about The Great Gatsby was the length. I loved that it didn't drag on and on and on. There weren't a lot of words wasted on unnecessary side plots that didn't go anywhere or descriptions of scenery that didn't matter. I appreciated that quite a bit.

Oh, the version I listened to had a bunch of letters written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Some of them were interesting, but oh my god, the guy sounded like such a snobby cunt when he was talking about how worthless and low-brow other authors of his day were. This didn't really matter to the story, but it was sort of a pathetic note to end the book on. And maybe the intent of putting those letters out there wasn't to make him look bad? Maybe I'm supposed to think he's right and that he and his pal Hemmingway were a step above everyone else? True literary champions!
If I'm honest about it, I'm exactly the sort of peasant reader that enjoys the more unpretentious novels, so to hear one author bashing another one for being too easily digested by the sweaty masses doesn't give me the warm fuzzies.

Then again, these were the guy's private thoughts, so it's not really any of my business. Plus, I can be a real twat when I'm venting to someone close to me, so who am I to judge?
This one won't go down as a favorite but it is another beloved classic that I can check off of my list.

As far as the audiobook goes? I think Tim Robbins is a good reader, but this is my 2nd book read by him and he's not my favorite. He has this tendency to lower his voice and whisper sometimes. Thing is, my hearing is SHIT, so I end up either having to go back and relisten or just kind of miss a few words. I'm not blaming Robbins, just my eardrums. I'll probably try to avoid books by him in the future, but not because he sucks.
Tim Robbins - Narrator
Publisher: HarperCollins
Edition: Unabridged
Awards:
Audie Award Nominee
Best Audiobooks
Listen Up Award
The main characters just kind of flopped around drinking cocktails, smoking, and complaining about the heat. When they weren't cheating on their spouses, that is.

The gist is that this guy Nick, who is the only person with normal human emotions in the entire book, is recounting his special summer with The Great Gatsby.

Gatsby is this ultra-mysterious man with gobs of money who likes to throw lavish wingdings. Everyone who is anyone shows up to drink his booze, eat his food, and party till they puke.
BUT! He has a secret and he needs Nick's help.
He's in love. <--with Nick's cousin, Daisy
Daisy, however, is married to a douchebag named Tom, who is cheating on her with a floozy named Myrtle, who is married to a wimp named George, who wants to buy one of Tom's cars.
It's the great circle of life.

Gatsby was...? I don't know.
Part of me felt sorry for him because he pulled himself up by his bootstraps and made a shitload of money just to win over the woman he loved. Sure he did it illegally, but how the fuck else are you supposed to make a shitload of money? Not by believing that anyone can be anything in America, that's for damn sure.
The other part of me thought he was an idiot who just wanted what he couldn't have. If Daisy threw him over for a guy with money, then that right there should tell you something.
Move on, dumbass.

Daisy was...? Kind of a dick, obviously. Of course she 100% deserved Tom. How Gatsby didn't see it coming is something that boggles the mind. <--we've all known a Gatsby, though, right? Unwilling to face the fact that his crush is a bitch on roids.

Myrtle was...?
Well, that shit was just funny. She didn't deserve to be road pancake, but if it had to happen to someone, at least it wasn't her dog.

Jordan was...? A golfer, a bit of a klepto, and Nick's quasi-love interest. You never get the feeling they're really dating-dating. <--more like they're both killing time? She was somewhat of a non-character for me.

Tom was...? An entitled, smarmy buffoon. But apparently, that's a good look on some people, because everything seems to come up roses for him.

At the end of the day, I'm not really sure why this is considered a must-read.
It's basically just a slice of asshole life. The very wealthy, very bored, and very cliqueish don't necessarily interest me and this story really wasn't an exception. I think it has the same appeal as those reality shows that follow rich housewives, or television series about wealthy a-holes doing shit like murdering their business rivals on yachts. Like, somehow I'm supposed to think, "Oh, look! Their lives aren't perfect, either!" but all I really end up thinking is, "You miserable fuckers can't think of anything better to do on a yacht?", because I sure as hell could come up with something a bit more fun than that.

The best thing about The Great Gatsby was the length. I loved that it didn't drag on and on and on. There weren't a lot of words wasted on unnecessary side plots that didn't go anywhere or descriptions of scenery that didn't matter. I appreciated that quite a bit.

Oh, the version I listened to had a bunch of letters written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Some of them were interesting, but oh my god, the guy sounded like such a snobby cunt when he was talking about how worthless and low-brow other authors of his day were. This didn't really matter to the story, but it was sort of a pathetic note to end the book on. And maybe the intent of putting those letters out there wasn't to make him look bad? Maybe I'm supposed to think he's right and that he and his pal Hemmingway were a step above everyone else? True literary champions!
If I'm honest about it, I'm exactly the sort of peasant reader that enjoys the more unpretentious novels, so to hear one author bashing another one for being too easily digested by the sweaty masses doesn't give me the warm fuzzies.

Then again, these were the guy's private thoughts, so it's not really any of my business. Plus, I can be a real twat when I'm venting to someone close to me, so who am I to judge?

This one won't go down as a favorite but it is another beloved classic that I can check off of my list.

As far as the audiobook goes? I think Tim Robbins is a good reader, but this is my 2nd book read by him and he's not my favorite. He has this tendency to lower his voice and whisper sometimes. Thing is, my hearing is SHIT, so I end up either having to go back and relisten or just kind of miss a few words. I'm not blaming Robbins, just my eardrums. I'll probably try to avoid books by him in the future, but not because he sucks.
Tim Robbins - Narrator
Publisher: HarperCollins
Edition: Unabridged
Awards:
Audie Award Nominee
Best Audiobooks
Listen Up Award
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Great Gatsby.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
June 25, 2020
–
Started Reading
June 25, 2020
– Shelved
July 9, 2020
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 74 (74 new)
message 1:
by
Boadicea
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Jul 09, 2020 07:41AM

reply
|
flag


Your review was spot on, and I have been giggling around the house, muttering, "true literary champions," to myself. My husband thinks I might be losing it.


*high-five from SC*
Yeah, I know exactly what you're talking about. I was excited when I didn't have to use an ice cube tray anymore. We've arrived, dahling! lol
I had zero sympathy for any of the characters. They were boring and gross.

I wanna watch the one with Redford...*sigh*

I read this three years ago, and I can see why this is considered a classic, love is suposse to be a universal thing, although most of the characters seems to begin and end with that love.
Julio Cortázar said something similar of Fitzgerald in his novel Rayuela and declare that if you don't understand it, you are dumb. Well I felt pretty stupid when I read it twice, although in different order, like he suggested.

The book is about assholes making Asshole Soup. The end.


I think it's about somebody actually following all that advice about "follow your heart" "live your dreams" and "IT'S CHAMPAGNE O'CLOCK!" and all the things you get on little signs in little British gift shops or pasted in cursive against a sunset background on Instagram and where that sugar advice will really get you if you take it literally...

That, my friend, is an EXCELLENT shelf!

God. YES. If I 'followed my heart' and 'lived my dreams' every day I'd be a smelly hobo with an STD.

The characters were, like you said, "very wealthy, very bored, and very cliqueish", in other words, not very likeable nor relatable.
I am glad I read it though.

“So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.�
Jennifer, if have to be borne back ceaselessly into the past, I hope there's another pile of your grandma's trashy romance novels waiting for me.

The characters were, like you said, "very wealthy, very bored, and very cliqueish", in other words, not very l..."
I'm really glad I read it, too. I hate feeling like I missed out on something.

Now that would have spiced things up. lol


Also after reading these comments I kinda this was about Harley Quinn. Her killing and beating the shit out of these characters would probably entertain me more than anything that has happened in the book so far.

I see the layers, but you could say the same of almost any book or tv show about the bored rich. I think it does a good job showing a slice of life for that era's uber-wealthy & the futility of trying to fit in if you weren't born into those circles. I just didn't find the subject matter or characters compelling or interesting. They didn't do anything. But a lot of people have been and always will be fascinated with the lifestyles of people like this, so there will always be a market for this sort of story. I'm not saying people shouldn't read it, just that it wasn't my jam.

Also aft..."
You're too young, but this reminds me of a more boring version of Dynasty or Dallas. lol

The Redford version is better. At least it was the last time I saw it in HS English.
FYI, there are two competing graphic novel versions of Gatsby coming out.


The Redford version is better. At least it was the last time I saw it in HS English.
FYI, there are two competing graphic novel versions..."
Seriously? They've got a comic?

Interesting. How did you come to that conclusion?


Great review.

Ohmygod, yes! Keep Romeo & Juliet on the roster. They need to know how that shit turns out. lol
Robert Redford was in your town? *sigh*

I wish they would add in some actual good books along with the classics, too. You know, so the love of reading books doesn't die out?
I think I'm stopping with this one, Al. If this is the best, I probably won't really love whatever comes next. Well, I take that back - I think there's maybe one other one that I might read...someday.

Some of the stuff I read in HS English I really enjoyed. The Once and Future King by TH White, William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway, To Kill a Mockingbird, etc.


I’ve heard of that but never bothered watching it. I just don’t like these “rich people do whatever rich people shit� stories very much. Same reason I never bothered watching Downton Abbey and lost interest in Upstairs, Downstairs. Yeah I’m sure there’s some good shit in that category but it just seems like a more artistic, not quite as stupid version of those dumb “I’m rich as fuck so watch me do something dumb with my friends for attention!� YouTube channels IMO. Same for all those popular rap songs about flexing and shit (though there are a few I like if they have a good enough sound).
Anne wrote: "Al wrote: "This was required reading in high school. But I was a small town teenager. What experience do I have that relates with Gatsby? I hate that aspect of high school literature. Of course it ..."
I mean everyone has different tastes though. There’s some classics I like, some that I think are rubbish and I’m pretty sure anyone could say that if they’ve read enough (and/or don’t just jerk themselves off to “I’M SMART BECAUSE CLASSICS�).

There are definitely classics that hold up. To Kill a Mockingbird was one that all of my kids loved, as well.

I agree. I love to read about interesting characters that are nothing like myself. I mean, I couldn't relate to Dexter but I liked that book. I guess what I mean isn't that I need to be able to relate, just that I need to be interested, and I find the Gatsby characters as interesting as I find the Kardashians. Obviously, a lot of people enjoy watching the Kardashians and a lot of people love The Great Gatsby, so there is definitely an audience for it.

Ha! I need to watch the movie, I think. Maybe I'll like it more?

Right?!?! I have always given thought to his later books- I mean booze and sex and murder and more booze, but I feel it wouldn't be as interesting as advertised.
Chad's list is good. There are good books. I just think my HS and College lit were so concerned with symbolism. I remember the Eyeglasses in Gatsby. But c'mon- I get if you are talking Animal Farm, but why not focus on other stuff- what makes a good character, how to write good dialogue. I mean, sometimes a cigar is just a cigar, y'know ?

I agree totally. There are many different ways to connect, but I know people who only like something if it has a relatable character.
Not me but to each their own, I guess.

Well said! I sometimes think we put too much energy into breaking some things down. When really, it's just a cigar. lol

Ah, the smell of peen...
Takes me back to the good old days of yore when I was but a young lass.