ŷ

Nataliya's Reviews > Sal and Gabi Break the Universe

Sal and Gabi Break the Universe by Carlos  Hernandez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3672777
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: lodestar-and-andre-norton-awards, 2020-reads

I think 9-year-old me would have loved this book. My 4x older self is much too old and cynical and irritable for it.
“The real way to deal with a bully is to stick a raw chicken in their locker.�
Because you really should read about precocious, quirky, overly energetic and enthusiastic kids when you are their age (and I read it only for completist sake in my Hugo-Nebula nominees reading project this year). As an adult, you get an annoying migraine from this hurricane of preteen precociousness and the desire to hide in a quiet room from all the overly enthusiastic and extra-witty preteen banter. (And if I never hear kids referring to everything as “sandwich this� and “sandwich that�, I’ll die happy.)
“My whole family had had to move out of our house in Connecticut because of all the weird stuff that kept emerging from another universe (PS: Unicorns are real, and they are just as unhousebroken as regular horses), but like I said, it was only that one time.�

Also, the sheer abundance of weird disjointed plotlines all squished together made my head hurt. Magic + parallel universes + possibly evil alternate selves + resurrection of dead mothers + baby brother in NICU + domestic violence + preteen attraction + robot parents + a girl who without proper distractions will grow up to be a terrifying dictator + diabetes + sentient AI... There are certainly more things that escape me now, and they are all stirred into a swirling mix of stuff that I can’t even bother to think about since so many of them being superficial and inconsequential and ultimately lackluster. Honestly, this book should have been half of its length with half of the plotlines (or even fewer) and it would have been more cohesive and more enjoyable.
Do you see the book cover with all the super-bright neon color flashy abundance? That’s *exactly* how this book feels.

Also, despite the interesting title, no universes were harmed in the making of this story. Not even a tiniest bit of the universe is broken. There may be a gentle suggestion that ripping holes in the fabric of universe may eventually be a bad idea, but there is never any danger or urgency or anything that suggests that anything besides a fun and safe kids adventure is at stake.

Plus, can I vote Gabi to be one of the pushiest and the most annoying characters I’ve ever read about? I think she’s supposed to be smart and driven and self-assured, but what I got was the annoyingly disturbing image of a young wannabe dictator in the making.

2 stars from my adult self.

—ĔĔĔĔ�
My Hugo and Nebula Awards Reading Project 2020: /review/show...
56 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Sal and Gabi Break the Universe.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 7, 2020 – Shelved
November 6, 2020 – Started Reading
November 8, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by nastya (new)

nastya As an adult, you get an annoying migraine from this hurricane of preteen precociousness and the desire to hide in a quiet room from all the overly enthusiastic and extra-witty preteen banter.
rofl


Nataliya nastyako wrote: "As an adult, you get an annoying migraine from this hurricane of preteen precociousness and the desire to hide in a quiet room from all the overly enthusiastic and extra-witty preteen banter.
rofl"


So true though. This book certainly made me feel like a grumpy adult.


message 3: by nastya (new)

nastya kids deserve better! but there's always Queen Diana Wynne Jones


Nataliya nastyako wrote: "kids deserve better! but there's always Queen Diana Wynne Jones"

Absolutely! And amazing Frances Hardinge as well.


message 5: by Dylan (new)

Dylan That second quote you included is just painful.


message 6: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth Hahaha, great review, Nataliya, and I can only laugh because you had to trudge your way through a book while not perishing from annoyance!!


Nataliya Dylan wrote: "That second quote you included is just painful."

It’s one of the early examples of my irritation with it. The rest of the book is in the same vein and more.


Nataliya Elizabeth wrote: "Hahaha, great review, Nataliya, and I can only laugh because you had to trudge your way through a book while not perishing from annoyance!!"

Thanks, Elizabeth! I managed to make my way through it. I guess the neon color book cover should have been enough of a warning about its contents - and it would have been if it weren’t for my reading project, since I included “baby Nebulas� with adult Nebulas. Maybe I won’t next year...


message 9: by Cheryl (new) - added it

Cheryl Thank you for this. I didn't realize the cover was turning me off until I got home from the library and tried to pick it up to read.... I will try, but w/ the permission your review implicitly grants, I will readily dnf.


Nataliya Cheryl wrote: "Thank you for this. I didn't realize the cover was turning me off until I got home from the library and tried to pick it up to read.... I will try, but w/ the permission your review implicitly gran..."

You are welcome! Ah, that cover with so many screaming and competing colors � it should come with a seizure warning.


message 11: by rima (new) - rated it 5 stars

rima While you are completely entitled to your own opinion, I would like to point out the Sal and Gabi is a book meant for ages 8-12, according to Amazon and Barnes & Nobles, so when you say that the storyline is full of ‘preteen precociousness,� keep in mind that it was meant for kids.


Nataliya ostrich wrote: "While you are completely entitled to your own opinion, I would like to point out the Sal and Gabi is a book meant for ages 8-12, according to Amazon and Barnes & Nobles, so when you say that the st..."

Well, yeah. I did say that this book is meant for kids of the protagonists� age and that I would have loved it a a kid of that age. It’s just that for adult me that precociousness is a bit too much, but I’m aware I’m well out of the target audience.


message 13: by Mwanamali (new)

Mwanamali It hurt reading all those plot threads. I recently moved and it's full of tweens who seem to run on noise and chaos. I live on the first floor. And telling them to stay quiet only works for three minutes max. Whatever happened to the PlayStation generation? Those kids were mellow... I'm sorry you had to read this. If you skipped some nominees we won't judge you. Honest.


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Wonderful review Nataliya


back to top