ŷ

Beata's Reviews > Hidden Valley Road: Inside the Mind of an American Family

Hidden Valley Road by Robert Kolker
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
47571190
's review

really liked it

This was, I think, my first book tackling one of the most mysterious diseases, schizophrenia. Mr Kolker explains the ways it was treated in the past in a most accessible way, at least I, not belonging to a medical profession, understood most of it, which does not mean I remembered everything as there is a lot of information, including names of the doctors and those of the medicaments.
Mr Kolker took a sad history of one American family, the Galvins, living in Colorado, as the background for his informative non-fiction. Mimi and Don Galvin had twelve children, and six of them, boys, developed schizophrenia as they grew up. These unusual cases, six male siblings suffering from this medical condition, allowed doctors to do research into the reasons behind schizophrenia which provided a better understanding of it.
What made this story sad for me was not only the cases of this terrible disease, but also other forms of abuse and neglect which were hard to read about.
All in all, this is not a book that puts a reader in an upbeat mood, but it is definitely worth the read. It is written clearly and gives a broad picture of ways to define and cure a disease which terrifies us.
PS The Gavins seem to be a big family, but last year I watched some news on a Polish family consisting of 21 children (2018) plus parents.
86 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Hidden Valley Road.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 20, 2020 – Started Reading
August 20, 2020 – Shelved
August 20, 2020 –
87.0%
August 24, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Barbara K (new)

Barbara K I’ve been tempted by this book, Beata. I look forward to learning what you think of it.


Beata I'll be posting my thoughts soon, Barbara :)) It's worth the read despite being rather disturbing ...


message 3: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Great review as always, Beata ;)


message 4: by Orhan (new)

Orhan Pelinkovic Great review, Beata. It must be extremely frightening for parents who are planning children, and who have a family history (at least one of the parents) of this mental disorder, to make the best decisions on how to move forward.


message 5: by Barbara K (new)

Barbara K Another super review, Beata. I will reserve this one for that time when I have less stress in my life and I’m more prepared to absorb the conditions you describe.


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

What a great review, Beata!


message 7: by Jenna (new)

Jenna ❤ ❀  ❤ Terrific review, Beata. And as for the family with 21 children--- what are these people thinking??? Yikes!


message 8: by Judith (new)

Judith E Were there members of the extended family with schizophrenia or psychiatric disorders?


Beata Diane wrote: "Great review as always, Beata ;)"
Diane, thank you :))


Beata Orhan wrote: "Great review, Beata. It must be extremely frightening for parents who are planning children, and who have a family history (at least one of the parents) of this mental disorder, to make the best de..."
Thank you, Orhan :)) I suppose you're right, on the other hand, not everybody knows their family's history well, and some mental disorders may reveal themselves in the subsequent generations, staying hidden ..


Beata Barbara wrote: "Another super review, Beata. I will reserve this one for that time when I have less stress in my life and I’m more prepared to absorb the conditions you describe."
Thank you, Barbara ... Yes, I agree, you must be prepared for this book, but it's really well-written, and the history of the approaches and treatment of schizophrenia is truly interesting.


Beata Dita wrote: "What a great review, Beata!"
Dita, thank you, dear! :))


Beata Jenna wrote: "Terrific review, Beata. And as for the family with 21 children--- what are these people thinking??? Yikes!"
Thank you, Jenna :)) I suppose as a mother I wouldn't be able to give enough attention to all children, love, yes, but what about taking care of individual needs and problems? It's not for me to judge, but if you look at the Gavins, Mimi was unable to notice things going around in her family, not that Don was helpful, he was not, not that interested in heling out, especially in later stages of his marriage. With so many children, you just put everything aside, and focus on bringing up children. I have no brothers or sisters, Jenna, but I have 4 much younger cousins on my Mom's side, and visiting them was fun, but our upbringing was totally different, as you may imagine.


Beata Judith wrote: "Were there members of the extended family with schizophrenia or psychiatric disorders?"
Not that I can recall, Judith. The author and the doctors focused on the immediate family since it was them that gave way to new ideas into how schiozophrenia may be triggered.


Terence M - [Quot libros, quam breve tempus!] A great review, Beata 😊!


message 16: by Orhan (new)

Orhan Pelinkovic You are right, Beata! Good point! Now I know why I hang out with you virtually ;) you're smart and kind :))


Beata @Terence, thank you, My Friend 🤩🙃


Beata @Orhan, ditto 😊 and your avatar is sweet 🙃


message 19: by Annette (new)

Annette Great review Beata. I've seen a lot of reviews for this book. It looks like it's very popular.


Beata Annette, thank you :)) Yes, it's quite widely read, and quite a new publication.


message 21: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Sounds difficult, but compelling. I had a friend whose son was diagnosed with and later committed suicide. There is so much we don't understand.


Beata Thank you, Victoria :)) Such a terrifying disease ...


message 23: by Peter (new)

Peter A wonderful review on a tough subject, Beata. I'm trying to avoid many of these types of books lately but I love reading your thoughts. :):)


Beata Thank you, Peter :)) I know such books are not easy to read ...


*TUDOR^QUEEN* Great, honest review. I kept looking at this one as I love biographies and non-fiction, but it just seemed too "heavy" for me to bear. We have the Duggar family over here who had a show "19 Kids and Counting", but they finally stopped! Now they have a show following their adult and married children called "Counting On" Glad you enjoyed and were able to appreciate this book. :-)


message 26: by Heidi (new)

Heidi Excellent review for a book that sounds fascinating yet very hard to read.


Beata *TUDOR^QUEEN* wrote: "Great, honest review. I kept looking at this one as I love biographies and non-fiction, but it just seemed too "heavy" for me to bear. We have the Duggar family over here who had a show "19 Kids an..."
Thank you, TUDOR QUEEN :)) I think my perspective is a little distorted as I'm the only child. I appreciate all love and care I received from my Parents, and I sometimes believe that you can love all your children, no matter the number, but it's rather a tough task to give them all the care and attention they need .. This was the case with the Galvins, parents unable to 'read' their children and observe their worlds ...


back to top