ŷ

Caroline 's Reviews > Gone Girl

Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3236194
***NO SPOILERS***

“Domestic noir.� Gone Girl, is part of . It really is the perfect descriptor for this twisty--and twisted--mystery-thriller. Gone Girl is breathtakingly good--for many reasons, not least of which because of a twist that’s not only unpredictable but because of its exquisitely perfect timing. To be sure, “unpredictable� is a descriptor that gets tossed around an awful lot whenever mysteries and thrillers are discussed. The difference is, Gone Girl is one that truly lives up to the label.

Gone Girl is as much a character study as an out-and-out thriller. The married couple at the center of the story, Nick and Amy, are as vivid as any real-life Nick and Amy. The narrative unfolds half in Amy’s voice and half in Nick's. This technique not only allows for a full portrait of both characters but draws out suspense very nicely--and Gone Girl is a highly suspenseful story. Particularly impressive is how manipulative Flynn is, asking her reader to feel a variety of ways toward her characters. It’s not often that feelings toward characters change so utterly.

The plot is very tightly organized--strikingly so--and punctuated with dozens of crucial not-so-little details. All the while, Flynn kept manipulating as often as possible. Most notably, in one pivotal moment, the story transforms from a mystery-thriller unfolding in a straightforward manner to an inverted mystery that turns everything on its head.

Flynn clearly dedicated a tremendous amount of time to Gone Girl, not just in the actual crafting, but in research; she presented a forceful depiction of psychopathy, and Gone Girl is chilling and eventually terrifying. In the finer details of psychopathy, however, she slipped up. Most readers may not care about (or probably be aware of) the oversights here, but since Flynn was so meticulous in other respects, it’s peculiar that she wasn’t in this area too.

The story’s conclusion will not please all. It may shock just as much as the various other twists and turns but in a way that will leave many with a very sour taste. Others will admire Flynn's courage in not only foregoing the bow but also the pretty wrapping paper. She chose an ending that rings truest to life and makes the most sense given the characters� stunningly complex circumstances. This is an ending that whispers rather than shouts, but what a whisper it is. The last line is pitch perfect.

Final verdict: A must read, especially for fans of smart psychological thrillers and domestic noir.
27 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Gone Girl.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 26, 2012 – Shelved
October 22, 2012 – Started Reading
October 23, 2012 –
page 11
2.76%
November 4, 2012 –
page 55
13.78% "Enjoying this so far and not finding it slow or boring, as I was expecting to."
November 14, 2012 –
page 103
25.81%
November 24, 2012 –
page 184
46.12%
December 2, 2012 – Finished Reading
December 15, 2012 – Shelved as: adored
November 24, 2014 – Shelved as: she-wrote-it
December 15, 2014 – Shelved as: memorable-characters
February 2, 2015 – Shelved as: mystery
February 2, 2015 – Shelved as: thriller
February 2, 2015 – Shelved as: page-turner
May 25, 2015 – Shelved as: domestic-noir
February 9, 2016 – Shelved as: reading-slump-remedies
August 10, 2018 – Shelved as: edgar-award-winner-or-nominee
August 10, 2018 – Shelved as: womens-prize-nominee
May 7, 2019 – Shelved as: shirley-jackson-award-nominee
October 7, 2021 – Shelved as: favorite-author
November 15, 2023 – Shelved as: top-21st-century-fiction-by-women

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Amanda Love this review!!! I loved the book- I did think the beginning was slow, but I after I got to the middle I appreciated how well planned the book is. The whole first half really sets you up for the rest of the book!


Caroline Thanks. Yes, I really admire how well-organized the story is. I compare it to a book like The Night Circus, which is just ALL over the place, with weak characters, and it's a night-and-day difference. Flynn is far and away a better writer than many I've read of late. I will be reading her other books for sure.


Amanda I read Dark Places and didn't love it nearly as much as Gone Girl, but I think you'll like it!


Caroline Oh, yeah. I know some friends were discussing her other books on my FB page, but I can't remember who specifically, because it was a few. Others were saying they also didn't like Dark Places. I will borrow it from the library; I don't want to waste money if it's not a home run like GG was for me. I bought GG. Thank God I don't feel like I threw away money on it.


Alexandra I liked GG but I felt like there was soooo much misogyny. Nick's I got because of his dad, but Amy's hate and disgust of her own gender was positively masochistic.


Caroline Oh, for sure. (view spoiler)


Leslie Just saw this review now as I was looking at my own review. Very sloppy next to yours. Agree completely about ending. I know many hated it but anything else would have been hated more and seen as wrapped up too neatly by those same people. I thought it was fitting and realistic. Saw other comments about other books. Thoroughly enjoyed Dark Spaces and Sharp Objects. Especially the first one which was the first I read of hers. Neither are as good as Gone Girl because with Gone Girl she dove in deeper to give us more than a glimpse or overview of the characters. But all three have intriguing plots, sharp writing and while not AS GOOD, when comparing it to the other mystery books I have read the last few years, are leaps in bounds ahead. Mysteries are some of my favorite books. It's the true crime, horror side of me. But for the most part it's become so huge and generic with the same 10-20 author dominating the shelves with plots that only slightly differ. (I have enjoyed the Dragon Tattoo or "Millenium" trilogy and am thinking of reading the first in the Tanya French books, "In the Woods," soon. It has good reviews and looks unique and I bought it forever ago.)So Flynn pops out and grabs me, even at her "weakest."


Caroline Leslie wrote: "Just saw this review now as I was looking at my own review. Very sloppy next to yours. Agree completely about ending. I know many hated it but anything else would have been hated more and seen as w..."

Yeah. I was really impressed by, well, not just the story, but Flynn's writing. She just has such a way with words. I've never read work by an author who writes quite the way she does.


Leslie She used to write for Entertainment Weekly the only magazine I've subscribed to for I don't even know how many years. Her reviews and articles were very well done on there as well and I miss her contributions.


Caroline Yes, I saw she had written for EW. I like reading their commentary on each week's "Survivor" episode. :)


message 11: by Dear Faye (new) - added it

Dear Faye Caroline!!! I can't really get the ending. So it just ends like that? Or is there a hidden meaning behind it?? LOL


Caroline Wait. You read it? Did I miss one of your updates? That's how it ends, all right. IMO, Nick's hands are tied, as I said in my review. I couldn't see the story ending any other way. Not that I wouldn't have loved for (view spoiler)

JMO.


message 13: by Dear Faye (new) - added it

Dear Faye Haha I didn't rate it yet, but I finished it earlier today :))


Caroline Oh, yay! I don't know how I missed that you were reading it! :/


message 15: by David (new)

David Katzman always a great review. :-)


Caroline David wrote: "always a great review. :-)"

Thanks, David! :]


ұ𲹰ó Great review,Caroline.
Now i am very curious to read this....


Caroline Gary wrote: "Great review,Caroline.
Now i am very curious to read this...."


Oh, thanks, Gary. I've been meaning for weeks to finish revising this (am more motivated now that the movie hits theaters today)! If you have even the slightest interest in psychological thrillers (well, I know you do because you liked In the Woods), you will like this. It knocked me out of my seat! O.O


ұ𲹰ó Great!!!!I just downloaded it for the weekend...lol
Have you read In Cold Blood by Truman Capone?


message 20: by Caroline (last edited Oct 03, 2014 07:06AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Caroline Gary wrote: "Great!!!!I just downloaded it for the weekend...lol
Have you read In Cold Blood by Truman Capone?"


I haven't, but of course I've heard it's spectacular, and a million other praise-worthy things. I greatly enjoy reading (high-quality) true crime stories. My problem is Capote. I just can't get past what went down between him and Harper Lee, so...In Cold Blood stays off my TBR. :|


ұ𲹰ó It was on my TBR list for years and when i finally read it i was so sorry i waited so long.
Really brilliant!
I will wiki what went on with him and Harper Lee.


Caroline Gary wrote: "It was on my TBR list for years and when i finally read it i was so sorry i waited so long.
Really brilliant!
I will wiki what went on with him and Harper Lee."


See, I'm SURE this is how I'll feel about it if I ever read it. Yes, check out what happened between him and Lee.


ұ𲹰ó oh,this is very interesting.
I will read the biography of Harper Lee...thanks for pointing me in this direction.
Looks fascinating.


Caroline Gary wrote: "oh,this is very interesting.
I will read the biography of Harper Lee...thanks for pointing me in this direction.
Looks fascinating."


You're welcome!


Debbie "DJ" Got your review in my daily digest today...weird!


Caroline Debbie "DJ" wrote: "Got your review in my daily digest today...weird!"

Sorry about that! :[


Debbie "DJ" Enjoyed reading :)


back to top