Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

La Petite Américaine's Reviews > Eat & Run: My Unlikely Journey to Ultramarathon Greatness

Eat & Run by Scott Jurek
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59329
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: auto-bios-etc, sucked

And now a summary of this book.

"I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan. I'm Scott Jurek. I am so great. I'm vegan."

Look. I like Scott Jurek. We all do. He's a great runner and he just seems like a really nice guy. But you'll need the willpower of an ultra marathoner to get through this one...and getting the to last page will probably feel like crossing the finish line in a 100-mile ultra, too.

Here's the thing. I don't really care about a book that's nothing more than an ongoing list of Jurek's trail-running triumphs, broken up by the occasionally interesting vegan recipe. And while I do buy into Jurek's plant-based diet thing, it's really not going to stand between me and my weekly cheeseburger. Though Jerker never gets too douchebaggy about his diet, he does get irritating. I mean, his whole claim that eating cows and chickens is bad because the animals are injected with hormones and antibiotics? Well, dude, you're probably right, but let's not forget that your prized vegetables are doused in pesticides ... unless they're organic, in which case they're fertilized with feces. *Yummay*.

And isn't it just such Western snobbery to refuse food and get all crampy about your diet? I mean, you don't see Kenyan running champion Samuel Wanjiru following a special diet. Oh wait, that's right, he got wasted and fell from a balcony to his death, so he actually doesn't give a fuck about his diet at all. Never mind. The point is, shut the fuck up, eat, and enjoy life.

The parts where the book momentarily borders on interesting are too few and far between. Example? His wife finally up and leaves him (perhaps because our fair Jurek was too busy training, racing, and winning) because she's in love with another man. Now, any non-moron knows who the guy is, but not only does Jurek frustratingly refuse to dish out the dirt, he doesn't even give us an inkling of emotion. Come on, Scottie! Call her a skank! Call her a cheating hooker and tell us how you went out and banged her best friend for revenge! Give us something we can USE for Chrissakes! But alas, no, it's only depression and more running.

Something like a narrative arc follows when Jurek talks about losing his mother and falling out with his best friend, but it's always the running, the running, the running. See, instead of telling us how he feels, we just learn that Jurek's bad mood leads him to lose races that he should have won. The moral of the story? Jurek comes to understand that winning isn't everything. Sigh. Fuck me.

Unlike my other reviews where I rip the book to shreds and take the author down with me, I actually *like* this author and wanted to like this book. It didn't happen. But I don't want my money back. Hey, That's a first.

Sucked. But Scott Jurek doesn't suck. Just hire a ghost writer next time, buddy.
118 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Eat & Run.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
June 15, 2012 – Finished Reading
June 26, 2012 – Shelved
July 26, 2012 – Shelved as: auto-bios-etc
July 26, 2012 – Shelved as: sucked

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by David (new)

David Tolson Great, hilarious and insightul review. Actually I think you went easy on Jurek. Anyway, the real runners are from Kenya and run 25 miles in under 2 hours.


La Petite Américaine Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh!!!! I wish people would stop with that. Come on, Jurek runs up peaks, it's different than a Kenyan running on a track.

In any case, ultra runners don't get to give diet advice. :)


message 4: by Laura (new)

Laura Norton-Cruz I kept wondering while I read "Born To Run" if Scott Jurek's wife was going to get fed up and leave him. Y'know, the going off to 5-day ultra runs with panties and dead animals and pranks every year being that obsessive about food and running. Did he have any insight into that?


La Petite Américaine I'm sure at some point she got sick of cheering him on. I maintain, he could have given us more details, esp. since it was one of the Born to Run cast who captured her attention. Wtf? Way to stay tight-lipped, Scottie. Lame!


message 6: by Laura (new)

Laura Norton-Cruz Serious?! He says that and then doesn't explain who?


message 7: by Kara (new) - rated it 1 star

Kara "Just hire a ghost writer next time, buddy"

The sad thing is he DID have a ghost writer - and still, this was the best they could do.


La Petite Américaine Kara wrote: ""Just hire a ghost writer next time, buddy"

The sad thing is he DID have a ghost writer - and still, this was the best they could do."


Whoa! Geez. What a crappy ghost writer!


message 9: by G. (new)

G. Brown Hmmm, I would have thought reading a memoir from a runner would be nothing short of mindblowing.


Pierre Fortier It's kind of rude. Very aggressive review. Keep it cool, breathe and relax a bit. We are not here for that. We are here to share our thought, not our frustration.


La Petite Américaine How is this review suddenly getting attention anyway? I wrote it in 2012 or something. Is it because I updated it after fixing a typo? Did it show up in a feed somewhere?


La Petite Américaine @Pierre: I always vent my frustrations in my reviews -- you know that. I have lots of positive reviews, too, but no one cares about those.


message 14: by G. (new)

G. Brown La Petite Américaine wrote: "@Pierre: I always vent my frustrations in my reviews -- you know that. I have lots of positive reviews, too, but no one cares about those."

You have just found the secret to getting attention: controversy. But you must learn to harness its great power.


La Petite Américaine Definitely not trying to create controversy. People just get pissed at me when I say that a bad book sucks. Not my fault their taste is warped. O:)


message 16: by G. (new)

G. Brown Haha. Well it should be noted that Jurek hasn't been performing as well ever since you did this review. Coincidence????


message 18: by Kumari (new)

Kumari haha, G. ha ha LPA!
FYI, I got a message that you had an update.

@Pierre: I AM here for that. Speak for yourself.


La Petite Américaine Are you telling me that every time I fix a typo an email gets sent out?? OMFG


message 20: by Carla (new)

Carla You are right! I am fed up with vegan proselytising.
I am vegetarian and I do not bore people with my diet.
This book as vegan fashion, is only a money maker.


Tomas Mikeska he is writing about himself, about his diet choice, about his strengths and weaknesses, I'm not sure what you would expect. It is great book ABOUT HIM ;)


La Petite Américaine Carla wrote: "You are right! I am fed up with vegan proselytising.
I am vegetarian and I do not bore people with my diet.
This book as vegan fashion, is only a money maker."


I went vegan for several months for a health thing, and I do have to say that all of my running pains/injuries disappeared and I had a *ton* of energy -- there clearly is something to going vegan for sure.

The problem isn't the diet -- it's people who get all irritating about it. Shut up and eat, no one else cares. O:-)


La Petite Américaine Tomas wrote: "he is writing about himself, about his diet choice, about his strengths and weaknesses, I'm not sure what you would expect. It is great book ABOUT HIM ;)"

Agreed on all points, except I'd substitute "great" with another adjective. :)


message 24: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex This book is very inspirational to people who like running and want to achieve running related goals. It's not just a money maker. The recipes are actually a very nice addition to the book. I'm not a vegan or a vegetarian and I wanted to try some of the recipes. The book is very informational about how eating healthier can lead you to better running performance.


La Petite Américaine Alex wrote: "This book is very inspirational to people who like running and want to achieve running related goals. It's not just a money maker. The recipes are actually a very nice addition to the book. I'm not..."

Glad you liked it! :)


message 26: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex This book is about vegan running so what did you expect.


La Petite Américaine Alex wrote: "This book is about vegan running so what did you expect."

As a distance trail runner for the last 8.5 years and an avid reader, I expected better -- as you may have noted in my review.


message 28: by Robin (new) - added it

Robin Roseth Agree, lol.


Steinar Sounds like the small American is a bit jealous 🤭


La Petite Américaine Steinar wrote: "Sounds like the small American is a bit jealous 🤭"

Really? Furthest thing I was feeling when I wrote the review. Where does it come off as jealous? Do tell.


Spaceman But did you try his recipe for chocolate adzuki bars?!?


La Petite Américaine Spaceman wrote: "But did you try his recipe for chocolate adzuki bars?!?"

I didn’t try any recipes. Someday maybe.


message 33: by Jens (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jens A. "I read an autobiography by a vegan ultramarathon runner, and was dismayed to find out he talks a lot about veganism and ultrarunning"


La Petite Américaine Jens wrote: ""I read an autobiography by a vegan ultramarathon runner, and was dismayed to find out he talks a lot about veganism and ultrarunning""

I have this odd feeling I’ve been racing *and* reading longer than you have. :)

Try reading the whole review next time.


message 35: by Gregory (new) - added it

Gregory I like you.


La Petite Américaine Gregory wrote: "I like you."
:)


Angelica Holt Did you know that Scott Jurek is a vegan?


message 38: by Morgan (new) - added it

Morgan Hewitt This is such a mean spirited review


message 39: by Morgan (new) - added it

Morgan Hewitt Felt genuinely disappointed with the state of humanity after reading so much negativity and narrow mindedness in this post. It doesn’t have to be all sunshine and rainbows all the time but it also doesn’t have to be tearing people down for sport. I sincerely hope you your life has improved since you wrote this review because nobody in a good place writes something as unpleasant as this


back to top